High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2635/2011dismissed

Lalit Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2015-03-09Bench- 48 pages

!"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2

!" #$ # % & &

& ' & ( )#* & %

$+ %

& , - (

& '

. !" //0( &

&'( $+1 * *

// ( * *

' & 2 &

3 &

& 2 &

+ $+ & & 2(

' 4 ( '

& #

$+ ( . ( % $+1 * * $+ $+1 5 ( & 3 $+ $+1 $+

(

( & 6 & $+

7%$

" //0 $+ 8$ ( 9

. ( -

( :

( 2

% $+ " //0 3 % & %

!" //0 3 & ' 3 & ;

& 3

( &

& 6 ( & &

& & & 1 $+0 8< - ( 9

. (

( :

( 2

% /" //0 9 * 7%$ & &

3 " 3 '

$ ( & &' ( & &

% 3 % 3 (

! 3

( & & $+ $+1

(

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

: 58,8%%1>#(8$1+$"#08+6"8;8$ "# #>1(#+6# -9 !: %--+8* "8'("8%; 5-'.( )- $- #,$8/.1,"$"8$$"#";*#+-9$"#0%-,#6'$%1758,+-$9-'+(1+$86$"#>8)1+8 8(*1$$#(#8,1.;$5-91+)#%,!%8>##+ 8%)"8,68$#)-%168..;-01+#( $"8$ $"#%# 58, +-$"1+) $- ,'))#,$ $"8$ $"# 866',#( 58, 1+6808/.# -9 0#%9-%*1+),#7'8.86$ "#%#58,+-%#8,-+$-%#&#6$$"##>1(#+6#-9!5"-58,$"# >16$1*-9%80##%$#,$1*-+;58,6-*0.#$#.;,'00-%$#(/;!8+(!

"#*#(168.#>1(#+6#8.,-,'00-%$,$"#>#%,1-+-9$"#0%-,#6'$%17 "#08%#+$,-9!8+(!

"8(6-+>#+#(808+6"8;8$-+ %#0-%$1+)$"#1+61(#+$$-!$58,!5"-"8(-%)8+1@#(808+6"8;8$ #"8(*8(#8+8$$#*0$$-,-%$-'$$"#1,,'#/'$"#6-'.(+-$,'66##("# *8$$#%58,+-$1**#(18$#.;%#0-%$#($-$"#0-.16#8,$"#08%#+$,-9$"# 0%-,#6'$%17"8(*8(#8+8$$#*0$$-91+(8+8*168/.#,-.'$1-+$"%-')"$"# .-68.08+6"8;8$ 3 +$"#+(18+6-+$#7$(#.8;1+.-()1+)$"#91%,$1+9-%*8$1-+ %#0-%$6-*0.81+1+)-9%80#68++-$/#$8<#+,#%1-',+-$#-9"#98*1.;-9 $"#>16$1*1,>#%;*'6",68%#(-9$"#1*086$-9,'6"+8$'%#-9-66'%%#+6# "#8(>#%,#%#86$1-+-9$"#,-61#$;5-'.(8.,-/#1+$"#'00#%*-,$*1+(-9 $"#98*1.;"#9'$'%#-9$"#>16$1*1,8.,-$"#,'/&#6$*8$$#%-9(1,6',,1-+ /;$"#899#6$#(98*1.;+$"#%'%8.,#$'0$"#%#8.1$;1,$"8$,-*#8*168/.# ,-.'$1-+#>#+9-%,'6"8"#1+-',6%1*#1,,-')"$-%8..$"#,#%#8,-+,$"# (#.8;1+.-()1+)$"#91%,$1+9-%*8$1-+%#0-%$1+868,#-9%80#68++-$/# 0-,#(8,8,-.1()%-'+($-,"8<#$"#9-'+(8$1-+-9$"#0%-,#6'$1-+$8+;

%8$#1+*;>1#5$"#(#.8;-9 (8;,1+.-()1+)$"#91%,$1+9-%*8$1-+%#0-%$ "8, /##+ #70.81+#( /; $"# 0%-,#6'$1-+ $"%-')" $"# $#,$1*-+; -9 ! *8%&1$1+)"8%08+6""#%#9-%#$"#68,#-9$"#0%-,#6'$1-+1,+-$8$8.. 899#6$#(/;$"#(#.8;-9 (8;,1+.-()1+)$"#91%,$1+9-%*8$1-+%#0-%$ :

$58,9'%$"#%8%)'#(/;.#8%+#(6-'+,#.800#8%1+)9-%$"# 800#..8+$$"8$$"#%#58,,-*#0%#>1-',#+*1$;/#$5##+$"#98*1.;-9$"# 866',#(8+($"#98*1.;-9$"#>16$1*"#%#9-%#$"#%#58,#>#%;0-,,1/1.1$; -998/%168$1-+-9$"1,68,#('#$-$"#0%#>1-',#+*1$;

-$1>#1,8(-'/.##()#(5#80-+-$1>#68+#1$"#%/#8 ,-'%6#9-%.-()1+)898.,#68,#/;$"#0%-,#6'$1-+08%$;-%9-%8+86$'8. 6-**1,,1-+-96%1*#/;$"#866',#(08%$; '$9-%89.1*,;*-$1>#$"# 98*1.;-9$"#0%-,#6'$%175-'.(+-$"8>#6"-,#+$-,86%1916#$"#%#0'$8$1-+ -9$"#0%-,#6'$%175"-58,:;#8%,-.(,$'(;1+)1+4$",$8+(8%(1+8,6"--. "#%#9-%#8*+-$1+6.1+#($-/';$"#8%)'*#+$$"8$!58,0%-&#6$#(8, 8>16$1*$-5%#8<>#+)#8+6#8)81+,$$"#866',#(-+866-'+$-90%#>1-', *-$1># =

#8%+#(6-'+,#.800#8%1+)9-%$"#800#..8+$5-'.(,'/*1$$"8$ $"#-66'%%#+6#"8(8..#)#(.;$8<#+0.86#/#$5##++--+8+(0* "#>16$1*"8(6"-,#++-$$-1+9-%*"#%08%#+$,5"-5#%#5-%<1+)1+8 91#.(8/-'$<*858;9%-*$"#1%"-',#1**#(18$#.;89$#%$"#-66'%%#+6# 8+(,-1$6%#8$#,8(-'/$-+$"#68,#-9$"#0%-,#6'$1-+1$58,9'%$"#% ,'/*1$$#( ?

! 5"- 58, ,$'(;1+) 1+ 4$" ,$8+(8%( 58, %80#( /; $"# 866',#("#68*#5##01+)8+(+8%%8$#($"##+$1%#-66'%%#+6#$-! 5"-

= 58,1+$"#"-',#!

5-'.("8>#$8<#+,-*#$1*#$-08619;!"#; 5-'.("8>#/##+1+8+'$$#%$%8'*8-+866-'+$-9,'6"'+$-58%(1+61(#+$ 5"16""8(/%-')"$(1,%#0'$#$-$"#98*1.;"#;"8(08$1#+$.;581$#(9-% 8%%1>8.-9$"#1%08%#+$,$-$"#"-',#$-(1,6.-,#$"##+$1%#1+61(#+$$-$"#* 4 "#%#8%#68,#,5"#%#8>16$1*"8(/##+$-;1+)51$"8+1(#8$- "1(#$"#-66'%%#+6#-+866-'+$-9,"8*#/%-')"$1+/;$"#-66'%%#+6# '%$"#%1+$"#1+,$8+$68,#91+($"8$$"#08%#+$,"8(/##+5-%<1+)8$8 91#.(858;9%-*$"#1%"-',#(-+-$91+(8+;8/+-%*8.1$;1+$"#6-+('6$-9 !8+(!

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

#8%+#(6-'+,#.800#8%1+)9-%$"#800#..8+$%#9#%%1+)$-$"# 9-%#+,16,61#+6#%#0-%$5-'.(,'/*1$$"8$$"#%#58,+-1+(168$1-+$"8$$"# 866',#(-%$"#>16$1*,',$81+#(8+;1+&'%;"#%#58,8.,-+-6.'#$"8$$"# (%#,,5-%+/;$"#>16$1*6-+$81+#(8+;,#*#+ "#-66'%%#+6#"8($8<#+0.86#-+?=5"#%#8,$"#

? 58,%#)1,$#%#(-+=!58,,'/&#6$#($-*#(168.#78*1+8$1-+ -+.;89$#% .-+)(8;,-5-+(#%$"#%#58,+->1,1/.#1+&'%;9-'+(-+ "#% /-(;! %8>##+ 8%) "8( ,'/&#6$#( $"#866',#( $- *#(168. #78*1+8$1-+-+.;-+3=89$#%$"#866',#(58,8%%#,$#(8+(/%-')"$ /#9-%#"1*/;$"#0-.16# "#%#1,+-5-+(#%$"8$+->1,1/.#1+&'%;58, 9-'+(-+$"#0#%,-+-9$"#866',#( ! "8( 68$#)-%168..; ,$8$#( /#9-%# !: %--+8*

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

8'+6"#( /;$"#08%#+$,-9$"#0%-,#6'$%17-+$"#"#8(-9$"#866',#(-+== 8/-'$(8;,89$#%$"#-66'%%#+6#8+(=(8;,0%1-%$-%#)1,$%8$1-+-9$"#68,# 5-'.()-$-,"-5$"8$$"#08%#+$,-9$"#0%-,#6'$%178))%1#>#(/;$"#86$-9 $"#866',#(8+($"#981.'%#$-91+(8+8*168/.#,-.'$1-+1+$"#08+6"8;8$ 016<#('08A'8%%#.

+$"#8/->#986$,8+(61%6'*,$8+6#,91+($"8$$"#0%-,#6'$1-+

4 "8,#,$8/.1,"#(/#;-+(%#8,-+8/.#(-'/$$"8$$"#866',#("8>1+)5%-+)9'..; 6-+91+#($"#0%-,#6'$%171+"1,"-',#6-**1$$#(%80#'0-+"#%(-+-$ 91+(8+;1+91%*1$;1+$"#5#..6-+,1(#%#(&'()#*#+$08,,#(/;$"#$%18.

-'%$

#,'.$8+$.; $"# &'()#*#+$ -9 6-+>16$1-+ 8+( $"# -%(#% -9 ,#+$#+6#08,,#(/;$"#$%18. -'%$1,6-+91%*#(8+($"#800#8.1,(1,*1,,#( 8%6"

'.8$1 "#