Gurmail Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab
!"#"
$% & &
'()"*+"$,-*"#(.(
+"$,-*"#'(.(
+"$,-*"#- $ $ $
- ( /&&..
**$ # (#'# +
'$12 // #.
$ $
3
(.*+"$,- /&&..
**$
(#'# +
'$12 // #.
$ $
4% $52* 4(&'# "!
& &-' -("
$52* 4(&'# "!
6'* ".+"$,-
!"!#$%!"&!'() *&
!"!+%!"&!'() ,
-, .
6'* ".+"$,-7& &/
,0
1
!"!#$%!
"&!'()
./
-,
0
2
0
-,
341
!"!+%!"&!
'()
./
00
,0
#5'()
./ *,0 , 0, 1
1
, !
'
! " #$ %&'
( )"
*
%
+,,+,,,$-
+
. " #$ %&'
( )"
*
%
+,,+,,,$-
+
/ " #$ % %&'
( )"
*
%
+,,+,,,$-
+
'6)'((67&
02
, 01
7
07&,
07-,.
078
1
14 0
1
,
0 ., +((7
01
7 4
0 ,
7
* 9 0
.
8&!($!8!%$)#
7&
( / .
0 0
,. &!(!&:!()('
0
0,;
.
2
*
0
0 &, "
3,
1 ,0 <,
/
/, 4
0.,0 , .
7 1 ,
'6)'((62
01
1
0
84.
, / . ,0
7&
,<=>
1 ?7 => @1 0
;
4
.
0 0
,. &!(!&:!()('1
0;
21
%
1 1
((/
/
1
04, / ,
,4 ,
,
01/
,4 1 , 1 )#(
.0 0
1 #(
4
0
1 & .0 0
1 0
+5.0 1
0%)40
, 41
;1
')(0 1
.0 ?
1 1 1
2
0;
/1 4
,0 / => 0
1 4
,0 / =>&
=>"
/1 ; /1 , . 2 ,
/
4 * / =>
66'((6, -,
-,
1
.
0?7 8'' 66'((6
4 ;
.
,
-,
(''(( =>A%@ =>A#@ 7
, ,
, 2
0,
.
,
0,
7
,
<, /1 , ./7&01
02
", 1 ,.
=>A+@ =>"7
<, /2,
2
0 1
1
B2 , , ,4 .
0 0
,. &!(!&:!()('
1 +5.0
, 41 '6)'((61 ,0
2
., 0
)$'((6
1 0 *
0 1 4
2
0 ; 2
0 1
,4
/
0, !
*
341
0, .
1
;
1
/ 0
-,
0 21 1 1
0 341
1
/
1
0
, ;
1 0
341
-,
0 ,
) 8
",0 /
,.
6#) C8" D21 >
1
./
,
%6 , 2
011
, 8'
1
, 7
1/
,
-,
-,
- 341
2
01
>
A
0A'7
0A%7
&
0 A5,4
0A)2
0A+2 ,. A$ !77E, 1
0A#7 E A67
A/
0 A( 1 E, A &, A'
E,A%"
0A5&
0A)7,
) E,A+7&01
0 A >
,
%% ,
,
, 0
,0
,
, A ,
,
/0 ,0 ;
/ , . 1
41 ;
.
0 0
,. &!(!&:!()('1
21
((/ ,
11 , 1
04, !
/
;
/
+((7
1/
, 1
2
, ,4
2
,
,
1 0 ./ ,00
*
0 *
0, .
8
, 1
0
,
0
0
0A'1
0
)$'((#
00
*
. 2
*
0
)$'((#=>A'@
>
1 E, A( 1
)$'((#
')@! 2
0 0
01
/ %(2 .,0
0
, 7
1/
+
./ ,
1
1
1 ./2
*
0 2
,0 .
.
,
') 8" 1
, , !
0 1+
1
+
+
+
+ + 1+ .
*+
1
; ,
1 1 ,
0
/ , 1
. ,
./ /
2 >
2
1
1
!, , /
, 8" = ,
,
0
*
0
)$'((# ;
2
1
B
.
1 / ;
.
.
') 1
)8" , -,
-,
1
$
?7 8''./ 4
1
1 ,
1 1
'#)'((6 0
01
?7 8(1 0
2
!, 341
0;
1
/7
&
0A% 1
"
A%
/21 0
1
0 4,
/
,4 1/7
1/ , 1
=
., 1 .
81 <,
1,
1 .
./ ,
,
, . 0,
FA
8 .
/ /4 / ,
;
,
/ -,
0 341
0 .
21
.
0
, 7 ?
7
/
,
, 8
0 1
, , ;
,
/ ; / .
1 4
./ , -,
0 0
!, 341
0 /
. 0,
/ ;
, 1
0
0
-,
0
?7 8'' 66'((6
4
# 21
1
7
-,
.
/ 8
0
1
1
.
/
0
, . /
.
,.
/1
1
0 !
!"!#$%!"&!'() !"!+%!'()
1 ' ; ,0 ,0
#5'()
8%'$'((&;8((%'(%./ *,0 , 0,
0
0
-,
-,
341
0 !"!#$%!"&!'() ,
) 8" 6#)
0 !"!+%!"&!'() ,
') )8" 6#)
%
-,
-,
341
0 !"!#$%!"&!'()
2
0 !"!+%!"&!'() <,
0 0
5 ; /.
. / 1
<,
/ ?
. , ) /
.
8& &-' -("9 86'* ".+"$,-9 ' ,
' ,
& &
.
A
4
0@
A .
8