Bakhshish Singh v. Sachin Kumar And ORS
!" #$% !&
!" #$% !&
!" #$% !&
!" #$% !& % !
% !
% !
% !
!'() *))* !'() *))* !'() *))* !'() *))* "+( "+( "+( "+( *) * *) * *) * *) * ,-( ,-( ,-( ,-( .*) * .*) * .*) * .*) *
$/00102130 ***,,-- 4+ 2015+0 ***!,
6 6 6 6)
11+,7 ***,,-- 4+ $/001021300 ***!,
6 6 6 6
2,0 ***,,-- 4+ 2015+0 ***!,
4
4
4
4 6 6 6 6.
11+,7 ***,,-- 4+ 2,0 ***!,
4
4
4
4 8..
8..
8..
8..
$-9121300 ***,,-- 4+ 2015+0 ***!, -1-
4
4
4
4 6 6 6 66
11+,7 ***,,-- 4+ $-9121300 ***!, ! ( :$;
2*# 2 !"!
5 !#
< ! ( :$;
2*# 2 !"!
5 !#
< ! ( :$;
2*# 2 !"!
5 !#
< ! ( :$;
2*# 2 !"!
5 !#
< "( *1/01- 1-='= >0,,-- 1*=8..6> >,*)1 6) = >,*).1 6. >,*)1 66 *
*41/ 0 +,='= >0,,--+1 6)= 6. 66 >0,+1=8.. 6 *
*;+,1- +,='= *14='= >0,?@1'*
!"!
5 !#
<=#*
!"!
5 !#
<=#*
!"!
5 !#
<=#*
!"!
5 !#
<=#* )* 0 >1 ,,- 0-- A 1 A7 01 1 , ? , A7 0 1 -1 1A+-=21 +/201A 01>>0B1A+-: 113+>01* * ,0>1A1>= .* * )A+.*
,** $7, A0= "+9A= 1 / ,- A? 0 01A13311*"$ )8 01> > 0 B11 +/: +1 2?1> A13 311*"$ 4))C) >0=B0:* 7,3 ? '--13 1 0 11 +/ ? 313 > 0,+ -2-
17?- 41--3 1-= 21 33* <0 07 0$7,=A0=0>0,,111 +/31011+/*!+--7=5+-,5+=2+1 2130= 001 5+ 1 0 ,= ?0 7 0 ,3>011+/+1+-1,-19+1*!= D* = ?310>$-9121303101'> 0* *) %1>> -1 ,11 ? >1- A> 0 1A+- /13 ,1 + > 0 0 > 5+-, 5+= 2+1 2130 001 5+= ?010 ? 1 A7 0 1A+-A7,13,? *) * .* * -1,,-- $/0010 2130= 0+A > 0 5+-, 5+= >1- -1 ,11 * 8 )*) * ) 310?@1'+,7>0=?0= 1 +30 > 0 ? 1,- ,>,*01A+-?+>!*C= =
@ ,1-3?101E8F,+* *) -1,,-- 2, 0= A13 ?1> 1 +30= ,1'-7 > 0 2+1 2130 >1- -1 ,11 * 6 )*) * ) 31 0 ?@1' + ,7 > 0 * 0 1A+- ? + > !* )= =
@,1-3?101E8F,+* * -1,,-- $-91 2130 0= A13 +30= ,1'-7 > 0 001 5+ >1- -1 ,11 * )*) * ) 31 0 ?@1' -3-
+ ,7 > 0 * 0 1A+- ? + > !*))=8 =
@,1-3?101E8F,+* .* ,,-A13*> 0A>1-A70 -1$/0010 2130 /13 1>11 > 0 ? *) * .= , 1 * 8 )*) * )= A7 ?7 > 0>0,1?A701A+-+ >00>5+-,5+=?0=* 6)> 0A >1-A70+,71130--30G++> ,1?A701A+-* * ,,-A13*6> 0A>1-A70 -12,0/131>11>0? *) * .= , 1 * 6 )*) * )= A7 ?7 > 0>0,1?A701A+-+ > 0 0 > 2+1 2130= ?0= * 6.
> 0 A >1- A7 0 + ,7 113 0--3 0 G++>,1?A701A+-* 8* ,,-A13*8..> 0A>1-A70 -1$-91 2130 0 /13 1>11 > 0 ? *) * .=,1 * )*) * )=A7 ?7>0>0,1?A701A+- +>00>0015+=?0=* 66> 0 A >1- A7 0 + ,7 113 0--3 0 G++>,1?
6* 01+1'-'101,,-,11-7- 0 11 > G++ > ,1 ? A7 0 1A+-* *> *> *> *> 6) 6) 6) 6)
,1 ,1 ,1 ,1313 313 313 3130>5+-,5+ 0>5+-,5+ 0>5+-,5+ 0>5+-,5+ C* 0 1A+- ? >--?13 ,1 0 ,,---1$/00102130( 2* 2* 2* 2* * * * *
,1? ,1? ,1? ,1? )*
0-71 !*)=
@ * +-1 !*)=C =
@H!*)=
@I) J * %+1 F !* =
)=C =
K =
@ .*
+-1,-1>B: !*C=) =
@HRs.90,000 X 9J * ;>,7 !*C=) =
@ 8* ;>1+ Rs.50,000/- 6* +- D, Rs.15,000/- C* ;>-'>>1 Rs.15,000/- -,1 -,1 -,1 -,1 Rs.8,90,000/- E8F, E8F, E8F, E8F, + + + + * 011,+A+0>11331303> 0 5+-, 5+= ?010 0 A 1 A7 0 1A+-8 70A1>710,,* -1$/0010 2130 1 0 0+A > 0 * 0 1A+- 0 1 0 0-7 1 > 0 !*)=
@* ) * ; +- > 0 ,,--+ ,7 00,10A?01301* ? 3+ 0 1 ?0 0 1 +7 '1 313 1 > 0 = 0 11+ ?3 1>11 0+-A171/* -5-
))* "=0-+-,130,,-- -1+A1000-710A130-7 A7 0 1A+-= 0?'= 1 ? 0 0 ,1 A0>++,,0'AA70 1A+-* ' 0 ,1 ? + 0 '1- 010-?1*!-1?,-+,011> 0 :A-,D+1-+,7;*'*"7 1-+,7;*'*"7 1-+,7;*'*"7 1-+,7;*'*"7 201 *=
)6)828C
201 *=
)6)828C
201 *=
)6)828C
201 *=
)6)828C L 3 -+,7
3 -+,7
3 -+,7
3 -+,7 ;11'*+!-10+0+! *=
)C)C2)
;11'*+!-10+0+! *=
)C)C2)
;11'*+!-10+0+! *=
)C)C2)
;11'*+!-10+0+! *=
)C)C2) * #7 * '* 0-- *2 - + * #7 * '* 0-- *2 - + * #7 * '* 0-- *2 - + * #7 * '* 0-- *2 - + ,7;*= ) .!! 1'1-8.
,7;*= ) .!! 1'1-8.
,7;*= ) .!! 1'1-8.
,7;*= ) .!! 1'1-8. * ) * 0' 1 0 >1 1 ,+ 0,,A/* )* , 0 '1 313 1 > 0 5+-, 5+= 0 -1 0 -7 -1 +, 01 - =1300?3131'01->,-+/13 0>-?*01A+-0100?1-7 ?3 ?/ ,+ A 13 !*
@ , 7= +0 01!*)=
@,0*01+7 '131301>0* ).* +0 1+= 0 71/ A 11+ ?31>11-',1>11++0 11+ <3 =).C* ,0 -))*) * = 1+ A70 ;A+ 11= "+9A= 0 0-7 11+ ?3 > -6-
+/1-- ?/ 0' A >1D !**6 + >> !*=.
@?**>* )* * )* )* 0 :A- ,D + 1 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 0 0 0 +,
+,
+,
+,00-010A>-71>1= 0 11+ ?3 1>11 A 71/= A+ 0 1=AA-+>1D01>0*A > +7 '1 = + > 3+ ?/ 1 G+1A*$+01=03+?/>13 01>00+-A--70>-17* 0>--?13A'1?A70 :A-,D+( M* 10,1>1>0-100? ,13 0'7 '01- 1'13 -1 ? 13 !*)=
@ , 0* "13 +0 -1 1'13 > 0'7'01-0>11,'>0'1 *0+300?1>>0031--7, < ) 0 0 0+A 201',- ? 13 !*)=
@ , 0= ? 1 -7 0 3+ 0 -7 1>1?>1-*01A+-0>1D00-71 >0A7,1311+?31>1>0/1-- -A+ 1 0 7 )8* A > -7 1>1 0 11+?31>11A71/A+01 A A-+ >1D 0 1 > 0 * A > +7 '1 + > 3+?/ 1 G+1 A * $+ 0 1 0 3+?/>1301>00+-A --7 0 > -17* -7 A+ 0 -1 ? +A- ,+ +7 '1 0? 0 0-7 1>201',-=9+1>7,1>-?1> 11+?3?01-,+1301*01 1 0 - '1 > 0 ?1> > 0 ?0 0 , 0 - 201',- ? 13 + !* )=
, 0*N -7-
)8* <01- -713 +, 0 A'1 1 0 E 0 E 0 E 0 E 0E0 0E0 0E0 0E0 +,
+,
+,
+,=/,131'1?01,>21 6>01 '1=)C6 ?01-/139+11-1> 0,'11>05- ,</:"7>1 <3=)6) >0=05-1<3=0 :A- ,D + 1 +0 2/+
+0 2/+
+0 2/+
+0 2/+ +,
+,
+,
+, 0 - 0 1>01--7,1A111+,7- >0?/105-1<3*01? A71301'B/1--?/:*0A'1 >--?( M)*,,-7130A',01=0D1 +>>11'10?00%=++A-7=? >10 '+1' ?10 '-1 -1* 0 1>1 1+ A7 0 5- , </ <-> + $= 1>7130%01'>-1303'01- A13!311*5;8$6C +0?01,> 201 "/0 0 A ,' * +0= 0 % 0-,1--01+A1,10$>,1- ) +1- 0001*<>1+A00% ?1'01>010*01+10-1 0-10*'* +/05+&' *
)2)C=0,-70-010A>-7 1>1=011+?31>11-3?10+ >3+?/01,--70>-170-- 71/ 1 0 1 > 0 * 01 D= /,13 1 '1? 0 1, > 1 6 > 0 1
'1=)C6 =?/9+11-1>0,'11>0 5-1<3=,1--71 0>?010>1 0>--?13D,1( DDDDD
*20+-$37>05-1<3-1>1 1'O2/1--?/O*!130119+1?100 1>1101>>> )* )* )?010 -8-
20+->05-1<3=,1A1311+ ,7->0?/-1120+-$=11,,0 P1'Q 1 5- 11+ > !* )=8
@ 1 )* ,, + 0 0 >1 0 1>11 1+ 0+ ? A+30 0 1 > 0 1A+- 0
130 +* +- 0= 0 130 + +- A 31R>0+7,1A1311+?3> /1--?/-1/P1'Q=0+=1>1D1301> 0 % !*) =
@* < 0> 1-1 >1D 0 1>0%1--7!*)=8
@,0*N )6* 01 + 1 "91 5+ 0 4* 2,- "91 5+ 0 4* 2,- "91 5+ 0 4* 2,- "91 5+ 0 4* 2,- 0 0 0 0=)8)>
=1 C* C* -A'0 ?0'11A+30A70-1,'0 1>0=11+?3,'-100 1 > 0 1 0+- A 1 1 0 0-7 1>0*0A'1+( M * 01 + 0 - 3 0+30 0 9+3 > 0 1 A0 > 01 + 1 ! - + ,7 ;*4*$5+=
# )8(;?1%S)...8.= ?011?0-001?0'11A+30 A7 0 -1 ,' 0 1 > 0 @ 19+= 1 1 0 11+ ?3 >1D + 0 11+ <3 ?010 0+- A / B,17: 3+113 > ?01- 13 0 1 > 0 * 0 / > '1= " )) ) > 0 9+3 1 ,+ 0A-?( M))* 0 1 1 1 0 ,,11 0 1 ?0 '1 1 A+30 A7 0 -1 ,' 0 1>0@19+=11011+?3>1D + 0 11+ <3 ?010 0+- A / 0 Q,17Q3+113>?01-1301>0,+, >-+-1>0,1A?+0 401-* ) *01=11,1A-0-01--1+1 ?0 +7 '1 1 A+30 = 1 1 0 -9-
11+ ?3 >1D + 0 11+ <3 ?010 - 1 A 0 1 > 0 @19+ 0 0 > 1+ > ,1+- * %+A--7=11+?3>1D+0 11+<3 ,'1+11@3+1-1A0/0 1>0@19+1+0=A+01= 01A+-@+A>110* 1,01A+-@+01?010 7A01300011+?31>1/,131'1? 0'110,1+-*N 8* 0+= 1 '1? > 0 -? -1 ? A7 0 ,D + >--?A71$0>01+=01+1>0'1?
0 > 0 ,+, > 13 0 + > ,1 ,7A-0-1=11+?3,'-10 0 1 > 0 1 0+- A 1 1 0 0-7 1 > 0 * 0 1 0= 1 + ).* *)C 1 0 9+111 > 0 "-1 21= !9,+="+9A=0+=011+?
,01+,,-1 )C* '1? > 0 1 > 0 >1 11 0 11+?31>1A702>"+9A0-'1=0 1 > 0 1 G+1 A !*=.
@ , 0* )* 01A+-0?7>++,,?01- ,+130,703+00? 0 7 > 3 0 1 > 0 0 1 0 1* 0 G+1?0000+-A11+>>++ ,,=?00?0 7>3=0A 1A70 :A-,D+1"7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +,*? 0-01>->,-7,=00+-A11 >) F=1>0?A? 8 700+- -10-
11>8 7*0>--?13A'1?A70
:A-,D+( MC* 0 '7 0* 0 G+1 1-- 1?0000+-A11?003>0 10 7*2-401/1,,,1 7+00A,,'1!0 5+1*#+11-1A/>0>0-7 1 0 * <0 , 1 1 , 9A= 0 1 -?70+00*-7? 0+A+-00?1--A11> 7?1--A +,A-,*<1,01/=00+-A 11>)F1>01A?03> 8 700+-A110>*211--7=1> ->,-7,>1D-7=0110+-A) F A?03> 8 7*0>171/0A >1D 0 0 A 17 1 0 ,,0 A7 0 1A+-0+*N
* '1? > 0 1 > 0 >1 11= >++ ,,E) FA1-+?01--+-1301> 0* )* 0 +-1,-1 0 A 130-7 ,,-1 A7 0 1A+-= 0?'=0,1??'1-0 A?/* * +0=0?/,11+( 2* 2* 2* 2* * * * *
,1? ,1? ,1? ,1? )*
0-71 !*.
@ * +-1 !*)=) =C
@ H!*.
@ I) J * ++,,E) F )= .= @H!*)=) =C
T!*))= C J .* %+1 !*8 = .
@ H!*)= .= K !*8 = .
J *
+-1,-1>B: !*=C=8 @ H!*8 = .
IJ 8* ;>,7 !*=C=8 @ 6* ;>1+ !*.C=
@ C* +- D, !*)C=
@ * ;> !*)C=
@ -11-
-,1 -,1 -,1 -,1 !* !* !* !*8=.
8=.
8=.
8=. =8
8
8
8 @ E E E E6* 6* 6* 6*F, F, F, F, + + + + 6 6 6 6
6.
6.
6.
6.
,1 ,1 ,1 ,13130>2+12130 3130>2+12130 3130>2+12130 3130>2+12130 * 0 1A+- ? >--?13 ,1 0 ,,---12,0( 2* 2* 2* 2* * * * *
,1? ,1? ,1? ,1? )*
0-71 !*)=
@ * +-1 !*)=C =
@ H!*)=
@ I) J * %+1)@.0 !*)==
)=C =
K.=
@ .*
+-1,-1>B):
!* = =
@ HRs.1,35,000 X 15J * ;>,7 !* = =
@ 8* ;>1+ Rs.50,000/- 6* +- D, Rs.15,000/- C* ;>-'>>1 Rs.15,000/- -,1 -,1 -,1 -,1 Rs.21,05,000/- E8F, E8F, E8F, E8F, + + + + .* 011,+A+0>11331303> 0=?0100A1A701A+-. 7 0A1>710,,*-12, 0 0 ?1> 01- > 0 * 0 1A+- 0 100-71>0!*)=
@* * ; +- > 0 ,,--+ ,7 00,10A?01301* ? 3+ 0 1 ?0 0 1 +7 '1 313 1 > 0 = 0 11+ ?3 1>11 0+-A171/* 8* "=0-+-,130,,-- -1+A1000-710A130-7 -12-
A7 0 1A+-= 0?'= 1 ? 0 0 ,1 A0>++,,0'AA70 1A+-* ' 0 ,1 ? + 0 '1- 0?0-?1*!-1?,-+,011 > 0 :A- ,D + "7 201 "7 201 "7 201 "7 201 +,=
+,=
+,=
+,= 3 -
3 -
3 -
3 - +,7;11 +,7;11 +,7;11 +,7;11 +,
+,
+,
+,*#7 *#7 *#7 *#7 +,
+,
+,
+, 6* 0' 1 0 >1 1 ,+ 0,,A/* C* , 0 '1 313 1 > 0 = 0 -1 0' -7 -1 +, 0 - '1 313 0 1 > 0 * 0 1A+- 0 1 00?1-7?3?/,+A13 !*
@ , 7= +0 01 1 !*)=
@ , 0* 0 1 +7 '1 313 0 1>0* * +0 1+= 0 71/ A 11+ ?31>11-',1>11++0 11+ <3 =).C* ,0 -))*) * = 1+ A70 ;A+ 11= "+9A= 0 0-7 11+ ?3 > +/1-- ?/ 0' A >1D !**6 + >> !*=.
@?**>* )* * )* * '1?>01>0>111>1 ,)=)8)6L011+?31>1A702> "+9A0-'1=01>01G+1A !*=.
@,0* -13-
)* 0 >113 > 0 1A+- + 0 ,1 0>++,,A?00?-> ,-7 0 >1D -7* 0 1A+- 0 ?3-7 ,- -1011>0,D+1"7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +,* * 03>0?.
701>01 0101*0 :A-,D+1"7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +,= 0-1,*60+0111A='?0 , ? ->,-7 >1D -7* 0 >--?13 A'1?101( M6* U<1-101/00A3> 1>>30,301>,,-11 , > 0 -3- ,1' ?0 -1 A0-> > 0 ?0 0 , 9A 0 , ?0 1 -> ,-7 >1D -7* $+ ,,-7 0 ,11,- > 1R1 0 >+1 > ,1' -/ > 17 ?+-+113A-1'1+0?
>3+ -17*=0>=311,1'* -03 1,,-1->0,1+'1A-10= 1?+-A+>11G+1A-*0300'0 1A+1- , > ,3* /13 1 11 0 ++-1'>=-7=,3>1=0031317= -1>,1=0031,11D=00+1+ >--? ,1+- , > -1>= *= 11 > . F > 0 A-10 1 > 0 ? >++ ,, ?00?A-?.
711> F?0 0 ? A? 0 3 > .
7 ?+- A A-*N * '1? > 0 1 > 0 >1 11= >++ ,,E FA1-+?01--+-1301> 0* -14-
.* 0 +-1,-1 0 A 130-7 ,,-1 A7 0 1A+-= 0?'=0,1??'1-0 A?/* * +0=0?/,11+( 2* 2* 2* 2* * * * *
,1? ,1? ,1? ,1? )*
0-71 !*.
@ * +-1 !*)=) =C
@ H!*.
@I) J * ++,,E F !*)=.)=
@ H!*)=) =C
@ T!* C=
@J .* %+1)@.0 !*)= =6 @ H!*)=.)=
@ !*= @J *
+-1,-1>B):
!*)=C8= @H!*)= =6 @I)J 8* ;>,7 !*)=C8= @ 6* ;>1+ Rs.1,92,000/- [Rs.48,000/- X 4] C* +- D, Rs.18,000/- * ;> Rs.18,000/- -,1 -,1 -,1 -,1 Rs.18,14,250/- E6*F, E6*F, E6*F, E6*F, + + + + 8..
8..
8..
8..
6 6 6 66
,1 ,1 ,1 ,13130> 3130> 3130> 3130>0015+ 0015+ 0015+ 0015+ 8* 0 1A+- ? >--?13 ,1 0 ,,---1( 2* 2* 2* 2* * * * *
,1? ,1? ,1? ,1? )*
0-71 !*)=
@ * +-1 !*)=C =
@H!*)=
@I) J * %+1)@ !*)= =
@H)=C =
K8 =
@J .*
+-1,-1>B: !*) =C =
@HRs.1,20,000 X 9J * ;>,7 !*) =C =
@ 8* ;>1+ Rs.50,000/- 6* +- D, Rs.15,000/- C* ;>-'>>1 Rs.15,000/- -,1 -,1 -,1 -,1 Rs.11,60,000/- E8F, E8F, E8F, E8F, + + + + 6* 011,+A+0>11331303> 0=?0100A1A701A+-8 7 0A1>710,,*-10 -15-
01- > 0 * 0 1A+- 0 1 0 0-7 1>0!*)=
@* C* ; +- > 0 ,,--+ ,7 00,10A?01301* ? 3+ 0 1 ?0 0 1 +7 '1 313 1 > 0 = 0 11+ ?3 1>11 0+-A171/* * "=0-+-,130,,-- -1+A1000-710A130-7 A7 0 1A+-* ?'= 1 ? 0 0 ,1 A0>++,,0'AA70 1A+-* ' 0 ,1 ? + 0 '1- 0?0-?1*!-1?,-+,011 > 0 :A- ,D + "7 201 "7 201 "7 201 "7 201 +,=
+,=
+,=
+,= 3 -
3 -
3 -
3 - +,7;11 +,7;11 +,7;11 +,7;11 +,
+,
+,
+,*#7 *#7 *#7 *#7* .
* 0' 1 0 >1 1 ,+ 0,,A/* .)* , 0 '1 313 1 > 0 =0-10-7-1+,01-13 00?3131'01->,-+/130>-?*0 1A+- 0 1 0 0 ? 1-7?3 ?/ ,+A13!*
@,7=+001 !*)=
@,0*01+7'1 31301>0* -16-
. * +0 1+= 0 71/ A 11+ ?31>11-',1>11++0 11+ <3 =).C* ,0 -))*) * = 1+ A70 ;A+ 11= "+9A= 0 0-7 11+ ?3 > +/1-- ?/ 0' A >1D !**6 + >> !*=.
@?**>* )* * )* .* '1?>01>0>111>1 ,)=)8)6L011+?31>1A702> "+9A0-'1=01>01G+1A !*=.
@,0* ..* 01A+-0?7>++,,?01- ,+130,703+00? 0 7 > 3 0 1 > 0 0 1 0 1* 0 G+1?0000+-A11+>>++ ,,=?00?0 73=0A 1A70 :A-,D+1"7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +, "7201 +,*? 0-01>->,-7,=00+-A11 >) F1>0?A? 8 700+- 11>8 7* .* '1? > 0 1 > 0 >1 11= >++ ,,E) FA1-+?01--+-1301> 0* .8* 0 +-1,-1 0 A 130-7 ,,-1 A7 0 1A+-= 0?'=0,1??'1-0 A?/* -17-
.6* +0=0?/,11+( 2* 2* 2* 2* * * * *
,1? ,1? ,1? ,1? )*
0-71 !*.
@ * +-1 !*)=) =C
@ H!*.
@ I) J * ++,,E) )= .= @H!*)=) =C
T!*))= C J .* %+1)@ !*C =6 @ H!*)= .= K !*.)=8 J *
+-1,-1>B:
!*6=..=.C @ H!*C =6 IJ 8* ;>,7 !*6=..=.C @ 6* ;>1+ !*)=..=
@ H!*.C=
@ IJ C* +- D, !*)C=
@ * ;> !*)C=
@ -,1 -,1 -,1 -,1 ! ! ! !*= .=.C
*= .=.C
*= .=.C
*= .=.C @ E6*F, E6*F, E6*F, E6*F, + + + + .C* G+-0 >11+1=,,- >1- A0->>0,,--+,7=1*** 6)> L * 6.> L* 66> ,-7--?L ?0 0 ,,- >1- A7 0 -1 A13 * >
L *6 > L *8.. > 0A7 110,1'1,+3?,A701A+- 1>10D11A'* .* "13,,-11 =1>7=0---1,>* *) *) *) *) * * * * !"!
5 !#
<J !"!
5 !#
<J !"!
5 !#
<J !"!
5 !#
<J +-01 # %
# %
# %
# %
<00,/13@( & <00!,A-( & -18-