Karnail Singh @ Noni v. State Of Punjab
-1-
!" "
#$% &'()'* +,
-.
/
00 11)$2
3 '4(4
5 40#$" $2
% 6 .
3
7
!"##
"
"$"% & '( 3
7
.
## (#"!"" ' % !""! ) )#
(*+ #, "-"
, (" .) / )0 " !12(" ).)3 4 )0 "3! "5" *"# ( 03." " -" 6"(* ## ( !" %%
!!! "3! 5!"( ! #
!7.!# %6 *#"%
-2- " ""! " "" %#" %!"#"!"*"
#*!!
8
) * )3 )02-'6 "#!! 6# ,2-"6 "% 6#" *7!(%
#!! (" 7"!"% 7"6 -"76" 9:7; 9*6"'
8);
6*!"%%""!9:7; ( < ;" ## " 6 %(7 "%"*!"% !9:7 ; # #"* 6 6 %"* =
# !!"6#!!6#!! ##" => "* % ;" "#" "
2 %%#"
6 %!"%9:7; !"% !
=> "* % % !% 6 '(* !!"##"* !!" *;" %
#%!#
% ( !"6 6 " 6 ! %"*(" -0,)/ 2 =!!"##" ! " " #" ! "6 ( # ?6" "# ! !!" # 6 % 1 6 #"#" 6 6 (* 6
%( %"7 (* 2 =!!" " ! ;"
-3- 6 6 " " " 6 !" "% #"7 %# %6 "" 6"## #* ##"
6 %# ! "% 6"
#"#7#"@"%# %%(7 4366 # # (A6#"#7 #" !!" ( %##" # (A#"6 (" %#"
- %#!
A 6 #"#" #"* 6 "% 6
!" %6 ! %"* !" 7 " #" 6 %# %"* -0 , )/ 6" 7 # #
""*%%A -66 (*6
=#"
"!
)8 6 "" 6 6 7 ##
""*%%A , (*6
%( %"7(* 2 =!!" " >A 5 ( 6!"%12A 586 " "(*2%# " A 6 #"#" #6""%" @"" %%A 16 #"#" (*6
%( %"7(* % !6
6""" = " "# !!"#" 6
" #" %# %"* #"
"% (!"2 7?=-" 6"!! !"% 6
!!A
("%#"
"#" !# % %#
% 2 7?=# "#" %# %"*#"
"% !
-4-
)8 6 ?, + (" !!" "" %!?= #"#" #"#" " .B ! 5 # A & 6 "
% ! 5 A &8 2% ( "" ! 6 ! " "%' ! ;" -"%%%A ?
=A* )0 )0 !!"7"#" %#
!"% ?, + " #" % 6 (!"2> " 2> " 6" #" % #",!+ " !!"# %##" " #" ' %7 , ",%#A-""%
%# %# 6" # 6 ?, + (" 2"*6 #"#"A +""#
(*,! + " A +8!""#!"#"!,% A%"%#! 6 #"#" #" =##"!## # ! % "> " ")B,"
,6" ##% !"! 4 !""" % ! !" ! ## 6 " " 3! "5" C *"# ( 6# *%"
-5- .
#" (!" " , " #" !"A%!66
< 2 7 9 ) 2-' 9) ?,+ (" 9 ,,% 94 .
;"# 9. / 2" 9/ / !" "!#" % ! ## 6 "" " ,"
, 6"(* "% %" 6 # % ## # ?6" ! 6
6 A%(*## ! %6 B
#" 6" " (* " , " !" " " (%
##6 !"%%
!!! "3 ! 503. ( ?#" ## 3 "6 "#" (!!##
?
/BB )).@ ( 34/ 0.. 6 %
, "(!! ## " ##"(7 6 "" 6 (
, " 0 2 (" (*" ## (! *%#!" "
-6- , " ##"! "*" "" !! 2 "6 " " !#" ( " % ", " ""*67 (* 2 # 6
( A% (* #" 6 ! 2 " A# * ! / * %# 1
(""* 2 ! """, " " %"*#" ! 5(%# 6 " " , " 7 " " #6
('%" A%! # 6
6 %7 ! #" (! ?! "" " ""( 6 (
% ! *
%# !"%A%(*#"! A* %# (%#"6 ! "" " % "*( "*"#""
* (# 1 """ "" "6(*", "*%" !!"!"% ""##"! ( (!" ", " *%" "# (" % "(" 1 """, " #!* %#"
( ""#""6
-7- %#"! :%" ? # ( * "(*, "
2"" ##"!"" # #" " % ##6 #" ## %# ' % ) = " ! " % (!!"#" ##, """ "<
!
"##$$" % &
'
(
'
!
) *
+
, - ' .
.
" #
$ " $
!%+
-8-
+
/
, - .
0 12 (
(0 +
/
!
+
+
4 5
& '
((!
%! )*+ , - 6 7
+
+
+
+ 8
'
+
+ 8 '
+
+
+
+ +
+
0 + '
(,
-. ,$/ + +
+
'
+
+
-9-
+
+ /
0 "&& /
1 "2 (,, !(!
+
+ +
'
9
+ +
+
+ +
(
.
( ( +
:3
./ 6 ; #$$<=3.3<. =%
12
+
/
9 4 "
$ 3 "2 (!4 + + +
+
.
+
+
+
+
+
-10- + +
'
+
+
+ (
9 #$0
+
(
% ##
'
'
+
+
+
+
'
'
'
#/ , - '.
'" (
5
'
2 '
## / +
'
&
+ '
/ +
-11- #)
+
#:*#$$" >' *#$$"
%
!
'
'
'
5%
54 , - , .
0?+ $ + + ?
9 (
0 0 6+ 7
5%
0 5%%+
*
0?
+
#* 0
* & '
,%
'(5+
#
>'
*$
,! +
.
>'
+
*$
-12- #0
7
@ , #$$" <*= 3.3 <. = :)+ 6 , - , .
: 0?
(
+
0? #% 0
+
(
% "
.
>'
#50
+ '6
!(&'5
'
>'
'
.
>'
/ +
#:
2
$
+>' 6 8
03
8
7 ".)#)%, ,
-13-
@ !
>'
#" 7 < &#=
'
A
3 < &%=+
67 < &#=
$
/ +
% )$ 7
'
$
B *:$ , '
>' # (
>' )
>' *
3 < &%= C,! ( &=
+
),.
< &)= >' B
..
3 < &*=(
.
>'
>' D
5%E
-14- )#! , - .
'
,
45
'
+
+
(+
+
) *
'
(
+
+
(.
$ & ',
% , - , .
'
4
4 12 !
+
+
+
#
) 6F
+
'
+
+
)/ & 4
4
* !
+ +
+
(
-15-
G
+
( )) 0 1 6 '"
,
4+!, - ,
*$
, (
(+
( '
(+
+
(
+ 0 + '
!
%%5
, - ,
) *6F
%
+
+ +
(
, - .
- "
* 0 8%
+
+
+
+
-16-
(
, - '.
4.
4
' H 12 &
( # / ' 4
4
'
'
( )/ (
4
4
*/ 4
4
8
)*0
'
%
( , - ' .
4
4
4
4
' (
4
' !
-17-
(
)
*
)B
+,
B $$
7 < &#=
7". )#)% B < &= B @ + A + )#$$5 ,
>' &C / +
2 ", " " # ! A% ! # 6
( " 6 #6
6 '( A%(6" %7#" (! ", "! "" 6"##"
" 6#"6 %!# (!", "#" ((%(" !""'! !!6
6"% 7"" " !"!"*%" ##"" %
-18- A%!#6
*%# %!" # 6 !! ! # 6
( ' ""* "
: "%* ( ! (( 7 %*!!!6
"%
(* "! % 41 ""6"" % !* %#1 ((*", "*
%#1 6"6 %# ( %#" 6 " * " !"% " ! *
"*#" 7#* %#6 !!#" . 1 """" %"" %# !%"*#" ! 5 ((*" , "" >A 56 (* !!"! ( ! 6 12 ( " " #" " > !!" #!*##" 6 "! %"*(" -0,)/ ?"?
# %"( #
6 ##" ! " " #" ! " 9)2-'# (!"" , " ##" " #" ! "6 ( #2 " 9/ 6
""* ""("
-19-
% ! 2 -' "" %# ! %"* #" !.! /1 """" #
!"( ((*", "#
(#* #
( ( " 6#"
#6"""" > B, !"## ((# * !"%* "6 ( ", " "" % " (*## (##""#"
# ' %! ) )#
(*+ #, "-"
, (" . ) / )0 " ! 12 (" ).)3 4 )0 "3! "5" *"# ( 03. " " -" ( ! 6 ## " ( %
3 "> !> %! !" ## ## " (! ! " "! (6"(*", " ! ! *"
6" ####"* "#"! *! *"4% (!" 6
#(* , " "" )B ) )) 2 (% ""* 6
%%"7#*")0 #"! "*B*"
# ## !* !#"""%"!" ! "" #" *"!#" (*## *""%!! " *
-20-
. %
0
?D( #"%, " 6"#"# ", " %"! !" "" %*(%' %!?D( #"%, "%" !
' )9
,5
44 " A"! ' % "#" "(6< -& .
(
( +
& + +
/
0
+
*5 .
%/
&
.
.
+
(
&
+
5
2 + +
+
<#=
#)+
<#=
#*:+
)#
)%$ )%
-21- .
.
+
/
(
G
(
:
+
'
"&
8
/ .
&
8
'+
+
$6
.
6 &7I<""*=#..##$J+ .
1 4
-
K
4 @ ;
3
I<""%= % .. #*J+ 6
-22- .
< =+
9
#
K
@
! I<#$$%=#.. )"J+ .
1 E5 / +
H +
8
/
/ +
L M
0 ?
. 14
4/ +
+
'7 +
+
/
+ +
+
+
+
-23-
.
(
/ I<""= ) .. *5J+ .
'
''' :6 A@
4 @ 4 4 , @
, 4 1 4
4 4 / 4 4
4 4
/
/
4 4
G
A
C
6
+
+
+
8
A
+
-24-
+
2 +
(
4 I> J /
1 4 +
G
' +
+
4 " B 3 3 9 > . K
+
4 4 1
+
+
(
!
+
+
'
<4
4=+
<4 2
4=
2
-25-
0 '
1 N
N,
+
N& -
'
+ '
+
NA +
+
K -
+
'
+
<, +
+
- L
M
<0
+""5==4 #$ , K
+ 1 &
2
+ +
+
# >
2 2
+
8 2
+
).
-26- * 3
- .
)
;#!" #"# % !! > " 6 ( " "*" 7# (
)
('!# % *# ( "(!!"
* 9"##"! " #
(*!%#"%"!"%( "#"
!6
% ! ## " "" * )) 2 ! #" "" #"" "%" > *!(*##
! "* "(* ## "!"%* 6(*##(* *" !!!##%! 6 #"# "#" ( "
!! % " %
) , > *!*%#"#"*#"" * " ! " ##" " #"
# " * "!"%" "6(*", "" (" ! ' %! ) ) #
(* + # , " -" !!"% ?6"""! ) ) %!
6" ## " #" "*
-27- "(*% ?6" ""! % # %! "! % !!
8
)4
#" # "*0)'21* )11#8 "
#* ! ""( ? , " " ,%% !" !"%
"* &'()'* +,
3
7
')9 )'#')
7: 2: '
40 );!$<=' )4#$ "
%
4=#
7: 2: '
' 0#'2)&1
%
4=#