High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1534/2016allowed

Jasleen Kaur v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2019-08-20Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan11 pages

"#$#%&'(') $*

%+ ,- '''..

** %

/ -$,$

%#% --# -0 1 %!#2 -1 '''

$.%!

3& 453 '

/ 6

! " #

$% &# / 67' %# ! &#'( &) "! !

"! +

,-#

( .#!##

&( -" ! )) " ""! (#, ( ! " # /! ! 0(& -!# !

(,!! 1+

.! ( & & () )" "

) # -" "

23 "( "-) ""

. "(#( & & () )" - 0(& # !- " #

#! "#

.( !&#"! #

#( &

) # "!( !%#" # . " " !&#"!##

() & .#&) "! ! #&& #

" "! " # ! !( #

4% 5' &.#4 ''

6/ 7()

8 - , ' 8 - , ) .

& & )#!

.#!#.,& ,- , 6' &# , ( . # & "!

# &#" !#!5&#!#& #"!, (

& & , ( -!) " " )# "! 20

# .# & # ! - ( ,!5

) &" -9# # !- ! )& ". -! , ) - , ' , ) " 4&& 9""!4% 5'#

(! .## # " -! , #! (! #!# " !,&.#!##

. !-& # &# # " ) # ,& -#.! .#!#." ( !-& )! !)

)!5%#4&&9""! ' . # ,( . -9.&#) #! !(,! ! !) &) ( ".#!# . ) "

&)!# .

.! ! # .## ,&) :%;: #).5 %# )&

&) "! , . ! ! (<. # "(.# 4 '' " 5& (< . ! # (&# 6 / 7()" & "#=4 " #

#&( ##! ) #) ">4924% 5'#"#! - "! ,

.""!

# ?()) @A #(<@A

.#!#. ,-#) # ! # (&#6/ 7()" & "#=4 #" #=4,&

/ 1 *

@A.! " #

#" 8 &( ##?()) 2! -)) @A #! ) "# =4/ 1 *

&8 " #

# #( &( # )

-"&# !() #(<. &&

# ) #?()) @A #). ! .#!#.! # ! ,-4269),&# ")5& )

#=4.& ! ( " #

# " ! A) ">4924% 5'

.### ( B4# - ?()) "! -

=8" ) (<.#!#4# -" =44 #(<@A#,

.#!##- "=4.## ""! "#) ),-4),&##& "=44 ! !#=4(), ) @A#, C (- ."

,-#! 494 ! !# -#=4(),"

,- ! 49 #! D " #

# #( &( # ! #4&&9""!#) "# ) #! A) # #?()) ##) #=4(), #! #! - ""! " )#

(,"( % ,(#&()

! ( " #

# ( #'( &) "6 :, () (

'( &) "# ( !"#$%& '() * & + ,),)& -

" #

#A&( ## (&# ) #=4#.##

# ! - . ! & " . - ! , , '

, ) # !# "#

.! (! ,- "# -! , # . "# -! , #, A) . #" #!

"! E F "

#!.#!# #!# "") ,! (! ,- - ! , #,! "(!#.,&A) ( (, &# "#

! A)(!#.#,

!<( 4#&

! ( " #

# ! !( *&.& - ,),)& .##

# &&(# -! , .)5#! (,"( # ##) ) .) .5/& 0" 1 ,),)& - " #

#"(#&( # !.# !( ! "#!.& #"! # !# "#

.! (! ,- -! , # 5& " # 4924 % 5 ' ! ! ( , & * * & ,),)& (,)#" )!#&#,& "(! .##

!# " # !!( ! (!

# ) - "

! "#!<( ,"

. #,! "# ) #!!( !<( ) .5,-6 :, () ( , *234

))7

" #

#A&( ##

#( "!," # (.# ! &# )( ! ##.!5 (" )## ( ( ! &#, ( 1

&.# "# &#, (C##%#5( #-.5 ! #." -) ! #!4"(# # ! ""! " ) ! !

# ! #.)5&# !

- #

& ! 5&# # ! !

&# ! " )! ) ! &#,- "#

) -(7 # .#& !#& "

2" )#) 6 . " C## %#5(. ,-# ! # &

. #! " #

#"(#&( ##

# () ( ! # - # - "!

#! # !

" )# !

&#4#&

#" # ) " 0> , . 7() #

(),

* *

! !

&# " #

"(#(,) #0>

6 &# / 9""! C " # #) , (),11++1 1#) "(7 # 2 .7()

#. #!

"## @A0 3 "# .@A0 ( ) ! = )@A0 0>; / 9""! # #!

! ") , (),11

+ 1**1+ 1 1 1**1+

1 + 11 1**1+ 1 & .# " .

! !( ): ! " )" # " ) *

!"! ( ! "#@ !! !( ) ! " ) ) , (), 1**1+

. (

4!#& ! !

&#3) , (),1**1+ 1 1 .( 4!#& ! / ) ) , (),1**1 + 1 . ( 4! %!#!

# .

# "

(), . ( # ) " 4 # ! 1

# &# %# . # !" ! - " # !( ) ! " ) "#) , (), ()@A0 ! ( " #

# #( (,) # ) , (),11

+.( ,-#

# "& "#=4 %#

(! 0>+C##%#5( # .# . 5,-# ! &.##

%#.# ##& #. ,-# !"5&() "

2" )#"# 0> 6( 8 ! #)&"

##!

(),

.! " )) , (),11++1 1, (

# !

. ) & & !#& 0- !

&# #" ,!5! " ) # ""! #! ) .(7 # .# # # (5 . - . & # ! )) # !#& %# . (! ! # ! - " # ) &

@A#,0 *

* " #

#"(#(,) ## (# , # "! ! - #& (

# #

# ! # ) , (), 11

+."!( #)

& ) , # (), " ! ""! " !

! / ) (7 # .# 5&# !#&!

& &!#& ! ) " #

,-# ( ! ) ,-#

" & # !

" # ) , (), !

( &# "#

" # " *

! ( "(# (,) # .# #

)

! # # # ,

) , (), 11

+ ,-

# !( " - - # !

#" # (

. # !

!&# ! ! ! #!

.#!#. ,-A)&#" "!. " #

# #( &( # ! # ! " &#!

#!"!

- ###,

# (), .(&#)

#,! "! #),-# !( #. !! " # ( " ) ##

#" ##.

(), # ,- !( .# &

+ 4 -

&" #$%

#&( ##?()) @A # "#=4(), .&! "& "=46 . #! (

(##(<@A

.#!#. )( ( -# (!#=4(),) " $% &##"(#&( # ! "!#!! - #" #) - "! "#! <( ,"

. " $% &##"(#&( # # (#&# - !

!!# "! "#

##" ##.

) , (), 11

+ "#& " # (&# !

4" )# " #"

.& EF # #=4 # !- (!

.# .!-&,&#&##

! (! !#.#!# &) ")!5.! 4! "492>% 5'## !# "#

. ! (! # (&# - ! , .# . A) !( .%#" . "#'( &) "6 :, () ( & *8 .& .

,8 .&

# !( # "

. # ! ( E,F %# !( # " "

. # ! ( !, ( ! E F "#!.#!# #! "

!# "") ,! (! ,- -! , %# (&##492>4% 5'# ## !# "#

. ! (! ,-8 - , ) # . #

..A) (#.&(,-#(, !

!( ,- )5& )

#" #

2!!( . (, &# ! A) (!# .. " *&.&8 .& /& 8 .& E!F 4# ! )#! A) "492>4% 5 '##).#(<@A . # ! # ! -. -""!

! -)) @A# . (<. # ! ( . ! # ! # )) ,- #69 -#" #=4.& %#" ) & #! ) "=4 @A ! -)) .#!#. & ," (! , (! -492>4 % 5'

#! A) # ) #"!%#" . "#'( &) "6 :, () (

8 .&

#! "# !( ,! ) (,"( F 4" ## &,-# (" ! &# "! !& &#!

- #& ( ##

#" ##.

) , (),11

+ ( ( "#)

,-# ( ! ) ,-#

# . ##

#!"!

- # ! ###,

) , (),11

+ #<( " &# !

") , (), "# ! ""! 22( 7 # ! %# !( " - - #

! #).

.#!# "! %#" (!#! #. " #

!###,

) , (),11

+,-!

.##. & # ! #

# ## ()," ).#!## .!&!

, && # "" ! ""! !

( &

(), " ! !

" ).##

! !

- # - "! .#& ! ) &,-#

" (7 # & &!#& "

# (&# (,<( - # ) "#

. " ( # ! EF %#

# ! "0>+C##%#5( .# # *

#. 5,-# !-" )# ! )) !! )) .##

. & )6"(# #& # ! "5& ) ) (" )#"# #) # .

!( #/0! E"F %#!

"#" ) , (), .#!## , ,- "!. C " #

# .##

# # ! # !

" ) # ! ""! .#!# ) - # . # # . (&# , & ! ) &,-" (7 # .#& ! ) "!#&

. # !( /0! E&F %#" 4" ## "! ! ,-#

) (, & &#" ) ! # !( #

" ! %#" . "#, !( #

. '( &) " ! ! *

! +

,-# ( #,- %#

!<( "#!#&") &#

2(-, , !#&

!! & - '(') 8 / 69