High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2909/2010disposed of

Shyam Sunder & ANR v. State Of Haryana

2015-09-09Mr. Justice Satpal9 pages

#$!% & "'

& "

&( ) *+,

( - ./

01 2) )(0

(+ +2+

(( 1 "

)

"# $%! % &% $ (, )

3 . )4*( 250)

$. )4*(

( 2 ) & +6. )4*(

( 34 5 . . 1 % &% '" $ (

0+-

(+ 01

2) +"7+)8) 4$+)+$+2 $+) *0 99(0 72)9 ()) )( ):;) ; 60 -1 (0

(+ 04 -

*4*( ) ) )(2) 992+ + (( 1 +- +)

1 .< )(2(0 2) 992+ + (6)01 +) 2( 1 ( (0

2+0- 2)

*( =:> 9 $ ) + + ) (

2) 992+ + ((61 +- +) + 1 < )(2(0 2) 992+ + (+?(0+ ) 2( 1 ( (0 2+0- 2)

*( /> $ $+ *2(6++ (((0 +(( ((0

*2(??$ *) )@$+ *2(? )(0( +0 6+

( +) (049 ( ")0 8+0).8 +0 6+ 99 )(0 65(0 ) *2((9( (=;=!)1930.$0+ A0 +0 9(

65 ( 90( @. +0 6 ( (

( 0 ) ")0500 1. 280 6 . *09 +0 * (56(0(0 )0)4*( )(0 02+ 61-*5.+0 (*B2(* %+

$A60+0 &+(*( ((0

)( +*(0 ((0 )+ (6+( (90(A0 +0 )%+

*0 ) (0 05(

- ( .

*((-2(@ .(0

++6

+()92(+) +( 1**+( )(0 .(6(0 *290( 0)%+

609 )( +*

(0 *2+()160 +

+60+ ( 6+ )+ 2) C( *-1(50 +) A0 +0 ( )(+ 02 ) *1.0 0(0 (()6+(

(0 ( )(50 +0

+ )1+

*(( )*( *2+ )(0 ( (0

(0 **2+ )60+ +6 ( )(- 0182 )8& 4606 +(+()992)((0 9(

)0 -1 (0 2+ )*)60 90 )(0 ( (0

)(0 ( - 9+* ))(- 94 1( (

= 90(.+0 6 ( (0 ) **)( ( 8 +0 ) * ()9 (0

( (0 ?( )1 (0 -++ (0+ +(( (.# "?$ <6+ 9+( )

(( (?$ 6+ *) )-1$A:

&0 +0 824+(9(0 (.290+( ?$&6+

) 5 * +-9 +6 *4 )(0 ()(5

++ ++4) ?$

(6+ 0(9 )$+ *2(?

6+ )*1 ? )( + (. 29$+ *2(?

6+ ? )-1$A& 2+0')4. )** .

+ (. 29 1(0 )* 9

( ?$D<6+ * 4 )# +* * E-(1

(?$"6+ * 4 ) & 2+0')4 )(0( ++-(1+ ?2++2((0

+(0 *2(?*2)(- 2 )2( (++ *) )-1 )*((0(02+-)(0 *2(?6+ )(04 -

-+*)9-2( 1 +(0(0

(+6 +( 2)0 / 2) **2+ )6+( +( -1(0 * * ((0 4 +(9(.*06+ 2)

*( := $ 09 6+ ) 9+( -(0 (0

**2+ ); $+ *2( ? )+1+6( ++ +( 4

(+ *+ 9+( (0 **2+ ) (0 (0 **2+ ) 60 ) 19 *(9 ( 2( ( (0 ) ) * ) +

*((0 +(( (+2)

*(==$ )(2(

*((0 *) ) (59 ( *+) ( (0 ( *(+ )

@ **2+(* +(0 *+ **2) )(0( *2(0) 4 )(+ *+ - 1) +- )2-(B2-(0(0 **2+ ) -1.(0 *4*( ) ) + ) + ) ( ) -4 99 . (

0+-

) )*2+ (0

(+4 (192 (0(

*)) +( 4 *++ + *09 )9+((0

(+ (++2-(( )(0((0 +721 (0

+(0 *2(? (+0901 -- (0(*+

)+ ?2++2(-1(0

+++0 62)(04

* 4 )1721#2(0 .+ 6+) ( *( )+

(?$" 6+( +() (*( ) 60 (0

(+ 6 ) ( ) . (0 ) ((1 + + (

+(-+0 ) * )**2 +-2+1 * .(+ 0901 -- (0(+2*0*(*2)04 -

* )2(4 #2(0 . -5 -9 + ) ( 04 -

*4 ) (0 * **2 60 + (0 + 4 ( 9)92+ * .+(1(0 *+ +

( )*2+ (0

(+2(0 29 (0($A %+

0+(+2

( )(0 *2(4 +)0+-

* ) 0+( . *4*( (0 **2+ ) + ( +2+(- 2*0+( ++0+-

)?+& )&(+((

(0( ( +(1 *2(? + ( (2+(6(01 0+ 94 *(1 ) 4*(9 4 ++ ( + +2-(( ) (0( (0 + ?

*- ) 1)99(0 # " (+ -- (0((0

*2(?62)(04 +(90(619 ()9

(-2(

)(0 0 4 6-4 .(+ 1 )(0(*4*( )+ + )2 (0

(++2+2+(- )(0

29 )72)9 ()) - (+) )*2+ (0 (( (0 *(1+2-(+ (0((0 +4 60 9)+2* ( *)( 4

* *(1(0

(+4) *)* 1 4 *++ + ) (+.(0 . 1 )(0((0

29 )72)9 ()) - 2 )

04 0 ) )*2+ (0

(+)9

(0290(0 *)6(0(0 +++(*

2+(0 +(0((0 *2(?0+ 94 * .*9 ()*++( (4 +(0 (++(0 2) ) ) **2 (5 * ( -2( @ @# "6+)9 )(0 ?()1(/ (+ )(( )*((0((0 *2(?6+490 6))9 -265( 0 49 6+ +) (0600) * 610 (4 * ( 0 49

02+-) 6+++9+* 1 + (+2( ((0 ((0

((1)) (0 ( +(1-1 (?& ?& )( )+ 2 ( )

*(-1(0 *2(? *)90 +(( (2)

*(>@$60 (+ ( )(0((0 6 (6

++60**+( ))

)0 ?&+)4(((0+ *( 2) C((20+ -

691 ( )(0 # " * (56-2((0

+ * 49 (0 * 1 # " +2*0

*( 6+ )(( )14 *2(99 *1& *() 4

> 1- ((0 )++(0 *2(?

*((0 +9(2 +(0 +))*2 (+(0 + +(0(+0 0+ *++( (1+(2*5(0 ()94 ++?$ . ( +(1- 2(A0 *( )6(0?+& ) &+0 0+*( 9*1+(( )(0(+0 ))(56-2((0

*( (+(0 +))*2 (+ ?

+(0(+0 0)+9 )*2 (+ *)90 +(( (2)

*(>@$

0+*( 9*1) )(0( 2) ))(*(

2 02+. (0 **2+(* + 60 (0 *2(? + ( ( -2 - (*- ) 4 ) ? & )?&60*01*+ 0) -

4 )< )-1(0

*2(

*( ((0 6( ++ %+

. )2-( ++1 0 0+ -

) * )0+( -2((0+6( ++0+ (0 ++)(( )(0( ((0 *2(?@

0) *

)() 0 (0 ) ) 60 (29 (6 -1+ 0) ( 0

.$A%+

- 9) * )0+( *() (*( *2( 4 + (0 ) + ( *( (0 * )-(1 ) (2+(6(0 ++(0 +(( ((0 *2(?

(0+-

0 )-1(0 F- 2(42+ **++) ( ( )

(0((0 **2+ )*- *4*( )(0 + ( +(1 (0 *2(?0 + (+2)(- (2(02)(2+(6(01 ( + 1 (0 *

9 ++ *) (0( *-(+02)- ++( )2 (0 (*+ .(+* (0((0 *2(?6+ 1 )(!)1930)60 +0 6+

)0 )2(1(; +0 0) *

)((0 02+

")05 6+ (29-*5(0 02+ 9(0( ")050)+0( )(0

+(1(0 *2(?) (- * +2+

*((0 92)(0(*+ ")056+0 )+0 62) * ++104 )(0 *2(?049 +0( )(0 B21272+( ) +

+++290(( - *+( (0 *2(?F+*0*( ((0 ( 92 (+

1- *2+ *2(?+ ((0 9 9( -2 * .49 ) +(94 ) 190((+ +2*0 5 +

++)(0((6(02(1+2*0 *)

+299 +(((0 *2(?((0+ *( ++2*

. (9((0 *2 -(1(0

1. ) ) 1 + ( ( ( (0 *2( *+ )2*((0 *2(?+) -- (0 94 *(+)**2+(* + 492) 9 (2(* ?

(2))90(.+0 *(- 2( )99-*5(0 ) + ++( )(0 * +(((0 ) )90(

+ +60(+ (0 *2(?(+ 1 *(

**2+ ) 16 (56(0 ( 0) ?

(9)9+(0 16 )21) ( )(0 2(.

.(0)9( +() (*( ) +((((0

*2(4 + (0 92 (4 (129 ) 6+ (0( -+ + *(4 1 9( + (0 9(+ (0

*2(? 0+*( (+*2+)2( - (0 65

**( +(1(0 *2(?(0(*)+6 2+ )

;

-+ 72 +(0

+(0 *2(?+ )21 ?

) -1 0 ( + ( )*2( ( 9 (0( - 9 (0 ( **2+ ))049+

(0 +0 1 (04 )2*0 ++(* 0++ ?

)(0((0

6+- )049(( ++)- )+0

( + *)(+06(0((0 B2 +(6+-2+1(0290 +2*0+299 +(0+-

2(((0 *2(?

94 6(0 *))(0 (

*(+)**2+(* +(0 +)2-((0((0 *2(0+

4 ) (+ *+ - 1) +- )2-( 9+( -(0 (0

(+ )*2+ (0

(+ 2- ( (2( 1 92) 60(+ + ((9 +) (0 *4*( (0

(+ ((0++(9 . )*2+ (0

(++2-( (0((0

(+ +

049)

) ( +

1 + - ) + 1 ( 42+*4*(+

104 -

*2+()1+* / (+.(02+. 1 )(0( + + ) 2 (0 - )2* ) + (0( )1 2) 9 ) *2+ (0 (( 4 + (0( -(0 (0

(+ (44 )1(0 *+ 104 2) 9

*(2+ /1 +.;(0+))1++>;/

490 ) )*2+ .(+*+) )72+()

) (( )2* 1 + + )2 (0

(+(0 2+0- 2)

*(=:>9 $

( (0( 90( ; 1 +

+ ) 2 (0 2)

*( /> $ +0 (0 + (0 + + ( 2 **2 (1 2( + ) 2) -(0

*(+ +0 + +6 +(0

) + () 2(

1 ( A(0 (0 +) )*( (0 + . (0+

+)+ + ) (&

( - ./ ")*+