High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/595/2006dismissed

Surinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2020-02-18Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"# $%&%!'()*++ ,-%'# -%'./ 0+11 22 3 -&,& !" ,'4 0+ &1!'# '

( 67

+ ++

!"#$% &$' )

* +*'+ !,-!+

. //// ++ 8+ %%+"+ 0'& %"

. " $ 1+"0! !2'$# " +"0)"

" 3

%$# %"'

)&$ '$&&%+"% $3 4 " 56 "# "$"$&' #"

'2 %" +"

'# - $%!'

' '$ 9 -# # 46 0$$+ )( $)&$2$ "$(

$& !

7 " "& + $& ) ( ) $& & ! $ &+' +"0$ 0$$+

)( $)&$')$' 56 0$$+ )( $)&$ 9)$' $''%2$""$+%$%+ :' %%+"%$# %;+ 0'!2'$

.&$'

$+!( '

' . %%("!' )(+0"

+"0)$&%$# % "$"$&%( "

" "'. %<+ "$&'%'

0& )"

) & "!'& %$&'% '

+.6(%$$$( 0'!6%'

0$ %$!+ + ' & &"$ '6# %76 '

"% #" =:&$) $ % $!- "".

2 '0 "$ ") $$&+ 0'

+" >$( ! "

0 '?+ 0''

".&"$ >$( ! ?$5

4!'6# %

% #" =:&$)$ %$! @ ! $'&&%'

"+ 0''

"+%%+)."$' + !'&$' $02 $'($ %$&&

2$ >$( ! !2''% )

%$ %$)(

-+.

0' $ $& 1 0'! " $&

0 "

0 '!, % 2$8 02 ' + # %! 2'$ '

) ) " $ ' ($ % " '

4!' $02 ''

.$'+ "%$+ '+( " 0''

"0$$- "".

$2 %$% $2 '$)"$) 2$8?' &'% )$#

0* )0 '''

..+ 22

.+$($&#

0* )0 '''

&$0

%$# %&$0$ 0$' #

0?'%$)(

2 02 '+( 0'!2' + 0'2 $)"

% &$)')? .$+ 3 ()! % . 00 $A$6*

. 0" #.+ 0'$$& 0'!8$2$' %$)(

! ' . $0" $ . #

0 % ) &$) " ""( 8$2 0'& %'

+ 0'%$+ ""

+ $&. 0+%8.'

!+ %%+"+%8'

+ 0'!+ + 0'& $'.$$&'%

"' && $'$ "! '($%!'% #")+ (

+ $'

($ % +"

0$'

& )! 0' 8 ! & .$2%? &') '

(+ 0'(" '% ?' %$)(

"'+( 0" %$# % ")$#"

+ +"$ >$( !- "".

&$)2'8(

# 2 '

$+ %$"

$! ' 2 &" $ >$( !

!'$2#!+ 0'+%%+)."$' + +&&".

) ' " >$( ! :'%$)(

) 0$ ) $"'

+ $ % +"'" '$&+ 0'.

)$)(

-+.

0''

" 0"'

) B9:'6# % ((""'

"$)B97 . $2+%' ) "+< $'$ % $ !

'$+0'$ . *+ "( 0'!$'.

$&2'

%'&$) C62 %$"".>C +

0'&$'$&&%+"% $3 4 56 :'6# %% "$+ <+($%"

0 '0 "$+ + " '$&+ 0'(( ($ 0 ">+.) " 2 <+$ ! >$( !

'$+0'66# 0'&$0 0($)$)9 $%$"+%"

$ '" " .$"$&+ " 0$ ' "&+ "$ & ($)$) 9 $! 66 # 0' '

"" $# %$( $& ($)$)($ "% $'$&"% "$'6# %!

2'$$$8' ) $($ %($ $:'6# % "$+($ (% "(( "$+0' ( $&'( %$&

"B91> &"'( %$&0 &$)'($!%$#"

'$ $ "( % "$$8'

$($ $# " D+ ))$ %'

0 ' ($ % $! ' 6# 0 % "($ "'% ($(2 '> %%+" + " 0' 2 ($"+%" .&$ ' 6# %.* 0'$

4 "'2 &$)

" &&+ '

00$+"$& $'

)))$ 0 "2 (( "!2'

%'2 0". %%+" ".

'2 :' %%+"'

"($"+%"'

+ % $02 ' 0 $% "'

" %%.&$'6#

%! 2'

%' 2 8 $ ($ $ # " ( %$# ))$,+ 0'%$+$& # $!'6# % %$"" ) $& 2 ! $$8 $ ($ $ # $+ "$%+) "$%$)( $$& # "$'&$)

' %%+"2 (( " "& " '$+$& """

$ '

&1+"

( $ $& %'

' $+ $& "

$ '

&1+"

! !'+(( "%$( $& "$%+) "+($ '%'

$' %%+"&$&%$ ($# ""+"% 5:'& 0'

'$&&%+" % $3 4 6 9% + #

. .$+$& $! "

$ '

&1+"

! %$)) "'% $ '$+$& " $1+"0!

% ($&% '$+! " $1+"0!

$.# 0'

( & %'

0&$$&&%+"% $ 4 66!3 4 " 562 "

% $"

%%+"!'2

0'" %%$"

0 !$2'

%'!'( ""$0+ "%

,+ 0'%$+$& # "%!'($%+ $9 "

) #2 ("

. $2 E'+( 0'($# ""'2 %%$+$& ' ""($ %$$ %2 ''($%+ $$ E -+.

0'%$)(

$($# ""'$%+ # $$&' "+(($ 0'($%+ $$$)

(% E3 ,@ 1

! 2'$ '

" (&$)" '($)$) 9 $$'" ".$"$&+ >$(

4"($" 0 "($# 0%$($&($)$)($

B9!( %$

0 )'$2 0' $& + B97 B97 > "'

&%$"+% 0'($)$)9 $!

""$#"+ %'"" ".$"! ".

0%$

. $0 0 $& ' "% " " ($ % ( ( "+ 0" . '

0( 0$ $'($ %$&&

>&+' "'

' +$&" ' %%$"

)2 "+$'

)$'

0 "'$%8"+$ )+ ( + !2'

%'2 )$) + "+&& $ +" ' $"

%$+$& +>0 #'($.

. )'

(".2 + "" ' ('$( %$" ".2 " ' "($)$)2 4'$+ E4 ''*+) ! 8!,:

%!$0 "($"

" %%. 0A$3 4

2 +" ' ) $& + " 0' $ $& 0'! " $& #

0@ .

:' +8 !, %C "8$.,:

!C "8$ 2 #

&$" 0$&%$$7% &$) 4+($ 5

3>($#"

%$($&" %% B9C E (*+) "'

$ 3

4!''

)%'

" + % . 0 0 $ A$6*

$ % $ ! "&$+"'

0!. 8!% +%'!

'$ 0'2 2$8 0%$"

$!'$2#'2 "$ '.$ ") "" $&$$&$&'% &$) $2 .$8 >($#"'

($ B9- E 1 0 0'! 8!,:

%! "($"

(' %$"% . 00 $A$6*

$$"

&" & #$+$&$'

0'$$&, '

0'! " A "0 '!, % E56$$( 0'!2'$'

"% "$+' # $

"($" 0 "($# 0# $+"$%+) ''

'($%+ $# "%0$%$% +"" )$&' %%+"2 %$""+"% $33 ! 2'

%' ' % 0% %+) %

)2(+$'

).+'" "' 0 $%$"

$% "'

".& #$ #" ' %$& $'

"-+.

0'>&+' "'

'2 $" ' % <+ $ " $

4 ' )

" ( '

2$8'$( '

02' ( %':

) "

0'!B9 %'2 $( %$% $2 '(

$& %$$&

0' ,+ 0'

"&%# "%!' %%+"9 "2$

5 ,E

*+) "'

'2 ($" '

)

>$( !- "".

(%$"!'( + 0'

$$&1 0'! "$&#

0 "

0 '2 .$+0' ' '$( .1 2 0'$$&-+.

9 0'! "$&#

0 "

0 '> " " 0 +$&,'

) 0'$+< ,E :

) 0'! ( %'$&#

0@ .

%%+" + 02$8'$($&, )$ &(

4!' 2$

0'!2'$2 $

. '

'$+?

0')'

) 2$8'$($& %%+"+ " .$+

():'2 &+' "'

" '2$8'$($&

%%+"+ 0'&$ .$+ ) + "'

+ 0'

"$% ?'($ % (('""' %%+"$'9"

(% (%$&

"& #$ #"'

) &' 0+)! "

$+%$# %" %"' %%+" ) $" .$#!2'

%' &'

) 00 #"

"''

& "'( 6'

#' " "%$+ &$' ; %%+" %$# %! " ,(+ "#$% - &$ ' $& +

. "0$ 0'$+0''%$" $''2 E'+( "E -+.

0'($# ""'$%+ # $$&' "+(($ 0' ($%+ $ $ $ )

(% '$+0' ' 2 %$ 9 " 0'$.'

&$&' %%+".+'+%8$' 0+

" %$+ " $ . '

" $ )

($ &2 ) $ %$ % $ "#

$ ' )"$$0$$'$$$&

F %'$ .$+"$$%%+"+$"

&&% ($2$& (%( $!$.# " $$&#$&# $+($ $ $"+$ ($&))$"+$( 0$& )%:'& % $ . $ 0' $& '

&& ($ '

# 0$ #

. ))$ $$&'# .% + 2 ((" &2 ( %0 "

0') +"

"$$0$$(+ <+ $) 8 $# '

" +'&+ :' ) $ #

$ %$ % $ '0$$'$2'

'2 '

#"($"

+ "+'&+ ) + 8+$"2 2'$"($

( $ 8) 6& "(% '($$&.$''2 $.

8 "($.

. %%$+0 #..$'$&')$.2$'$&

% E'+( "E -+.

0''

0 $ ' #2$+ "'

#.' ($$$%'

%+ %+ ( #$ #' %%+" & %

' " #$+$& % $ #$+'

'($ ($ . &$" '$&'

"" .$+0'$.$$8 (+ '"+ . ''

)( 0$'

"' %+ %+ (

#$ #$) $%($ '

( %2 '$+ ')$ $ :')"

# "%%$$.$ '$%+ # "%:'

# '

.%$"+%" &

)(

:'6# %'

"$ $$ #$ #' %%+"

2$0 !%'

)& $$"($

)$ %+'

%$# % $ :'$+0'' %%+"'

". "&$'$&&%+" % $ 3 4 6 $& %+ ( . '$) " .+ '

$+ $

%$% + $$&'

"2 &%'

2 % $&" '$& + 0'$ %%$+$& ' "0 0" 2 $

$&%+ ( . '$) " 6%$)$+'

' %%+"2 " 0'% $

(+.

%2 "

"# ) '$2 0% + $$'2 "$ 0&$' #$&'$'%$))+$'$ ">&

"$ 9% % "% + $9(%"$'

)2'

" 0' ($' (+.

%2 ".'

+%'2$0&+ " 0% +"' %% " 2'

%'+ 0'! $%($'

& :'$+0' "%$+ &$' '

%$""'

' "'

" 8( % 3 ()2''2 "

8 $($ . $'" #$&'#'

% !'&$ " $&'

%%+" $&+ .

'" +''

%$ 2 '$+ ) 6'C6

&!'%$)(

%%+"2 %<+

"2 ''

%'. $0$ #

0 .:'&$!'%$+ "$ . "$+.2 '0 "$ " $&' %%+". 0" #$&' $&&"

0 % :' " '

" 8 ( % .+$( $& #

0 * )0 '''

+%'($&( % $) 2 "$

&%% ." 2'

2 "

8 '

) %'

%%+" (% )" 'C6 "2 %<+

"2 '' %$)(

!'&$'2 $% $& " $( "$ $0' %%+" " "&$)' 2 @ "%$+ &$' &+'%$""'

. " ($ 0') $'($ % )+%''

" 8( %$

4!2' C62 $"0"$' 9 "

4 " ' " ) 8 ' ($%+ $ $ "$+.&+ :'

%$ 2 '$+ ) , $ $ +&& $% "$+. ') "2 '0 "$+'&+ $& '($%+ $$+ %%$)( ".$'% %+) %

8(# $+ ) .2 '( $$) )$ # &$ &

)( $A$'

0$&'

$ ' 0"$($#" &' %% "'

" 8( % # 0 )"+ 02 $!

$.# $+ '& %$%$&%$)(

.$'$&'# % )+ 0'2 $)$#'

)$'$( $ $($# " ))"

"$'

)$ #'

& ''

)+ "" "0$ $'($ %$ $"0($0 "

0' ":'%$"+%$&' %$)(

.<+ + 2 &'$(

$$& + 0'!2'''

"+%%+)."$' + "'($ %'

. &$)" 2' ' ($ % ( % )! %$)(

2'$ 2 ( ''$( '

"0$'

)%$"":'+' $ +9(

"" ($ 0') $'($ % :'( 8.' %%+""$$)( + . & %$:'# "% ""+%" "&%.' %%+"&

$ + " '($%+ $% :'($%+ $'

"+%%&+ ($#" %'

0&$' $&&%+"% $ 5 "3 46

' %%+".$"

"$2$& $ . "$+.:'

$+2 + " %'

+%'%$% + $:'%$# % $$&' %%+"&$+%'$&&%"$ $% &$ &% :' " %$+ &$ ' '

( " '

%$&' %%+";%$# %."+%"8( # 2'& % ' & $&&"! ($$) "$ . "2 $&'

6$)( & '

' %%+". ' "0 0 " 0$&'% '

"% +"" '$& ) "" 0"($:'$ "

($# 0$.8

00$+"&$' $'

) #'

% " #" #'$ "

"# ) '$2 0% + $$' "!$% 0&$ & "%+ $&'$'%$))+$' $ " "+%'($& )'

#$." 2 ' $'2 '2$+ ".)$ %$&% + "+$$ " " %% " 6'

!$ %% .'$2$' %%+";%$# %:' <+ 0 " "% " 6# 2$&' .$#!6& "$ 0

$ & ) '

+"0) ( " . '

$+! 0 " ' %$# % $ %( !'$ +(' " "' &$+"$.2 '$+ ) "

) " %%$"

0 + 0'; %%+" "$.$.

0 "$ ).'

$+2'

+("

%> .

% " '

&1+"

! "

%"$ + 2 $ 0'

) "$ $) 8'

)+"0$')

0% ++

)*++ -%4 E''( 07 $"

G7A$ E''($ . G7A$