← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/5982/2023allowed

Himanshu Narang v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-05-08Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages



     



  

!

 "  #$ 

% &   !  "#$%&'()*+&!'&)$!,!'

'

()")") *&+ , #  ) ()-%." *)))*$) () /&  ." *&+ , #  % &  )0) !'&)$!,!'' -.   %      2

  #.

&  &   "

,   340  ) %$ # 5  #  )6744& &86)9)0606& "

, 79:

; , 306*3<9*3<4*398*340*347 && &.  =

 &

., " *&2 *, %.  >.. 2 5 % ,

 #   2 #, %  & &80)8)0600 ; ?

0=)

5  > 

 &2$, %. % &  )0  &    +     ,  &   )   > + *  >  

 +   # % ,2.

*#..$ + & & $  .+   &% *>,%% #  , %  )   + @  % >  #  2$%$ ,   #

> .&2 #.

?

, &2  #% ,  #  &* 5   &.. 2 5 % ,

 # $2 5

  #/,

  +&  & & &<)0)0607& ,  %% 2 #  ..5(  A$(  #  , &   *,  & &2 #   & ..5(  A$ (  >. & , &  & % ) %,    *.

 &(* %   %  & &83)7)0607  )B  %  .  ?

 .     #  , %.  /  "   &  ,, &A%   , & & 08)0)0607.  >  #" /%.

"  , & & :)7)0607)   *.

 &(*

%, ,.&  % %%  +

& , %  + ..$&    ,, &  %   ,  &    % A,, &       2

  & ,. &

 ,. & ## & , +  &.

 &,  .#  *%   , & &  %  2$.

 &(* %) 2 . # $% +  # 340) ))> .&  >   $@ , & *$2  , $

+ ## , $ & &  &   % + 2  #  #$    >   , & #/, )"

, 706)  5..$ +# , &  *>,% ,2  & #  , % &  #  ## &  &

. & -

% + >   # ## ..

&.$,  & & #,2  + ,2.$ &%

,   #,.%  , > .&2 #.

?

, )  C2.

"%  2  #, ,.&  



   



 B.S.Joshi and

CRM-M-5982-2023 -3others +State of Haryana  / 0-  )12-31-

# .. > &2$  .. ,,  #41.5

/-)

60 / 0- 7 )1 89 / 0-:

  + & .

> % %  + .+ % , & .>)  # * C2.

"%  Gian Singh ;

State of Punjab and another   )12-31-  # & .

>  & . .> &2$ "%  # 5

# State of Haryana ;

Bhajan Lal: )122

) )

<8 # /&  && '

 

       



 

       

            !   

"

 

 #







                 

 $

%&'  

  

   





 (







  "

  

  

     )*+ ,   #

- +

,     

  

(

                  !("

   



 

     

 

  

  (    - "

  

-  

 

   

(     

  

 

(  

.- -

(- 

 

 (     

 

/ 

(

 

 

$  

     

  

($ 

 (- (   

  

   



       



.  0

  



1     

( 

 

  

 .

    

(- *

   ( 

               

  

 2          ( 3  

 (

  

   

 

  

    - 

  (   

     -   -

-

-    



.  

   

    (  

  (-   

(

  





(     

    

 

 



  

  (  -  

 (          

 -

    

    

-



(  





 .



           

 # "

 #

    (

             

  

    

    



 

 

  -  

  

 

    

          (  

#

 



   

   



         

       

 



    

       

               #

-

          

       



+ ,

  

-  

 





 

#



         4 %%.$ .> &2$ C2.

"%  %.

  #/& &  *%% >  +

& , %  ,   #

> .&2

.$2  #% ,  #  &2$.. > &,, %

%$  # 2$5 > .&2  , & # /, * >,%.$  2/ , # .

. , & "

, 340)

   .* #& , &5 .$#.. > 2&%

 &2$/&,.% , & & *

 )6744& &86)9)0606& "

, 79: ; , 306*3<9* 3<4*  398*  340*  347     && &  .   =  

 &    .,  " * &2 *, %&.. 2 5 % ,



#  5 &5   , %  

&.

   $   %  ..  2 & 2$   & , &  # , %  &   , & &2 #  ,  . >)

 &.. > &)  !'&)$!,!'    '(<&   .,@$ B % @ A   &'

 A B 

% 2.

'

 A