← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2474/2025dismissed

Subhash Chander v. Superintending Canal Officer Ferozepur Canal Circle Ferozepur And Others

2025-02-18Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger7 pages



    

 

   

   

!"# &#'()($* 

+,, -./0!)0 0!*&#1 ,,,,,, #"("($*#1 2#1).) -.3#1(*"#*&(*4 !*!5

%%('#1 $"0#1)

,,,,,, #)3$*&#*")     6 7 ,

-  -

 1#)#*"

1,

)0$8 9.:!1 90.*4#1;

&<$'!"#

1, !<*##"

-(*40;

-#*($1

 .*=!/,

1, 1!"##8 !*&(";

&<$'!"#

'!<#!"$11#)3$*&#*"

, , ,  -

;

 7

, #"("($*#1

-./0!)0 0!*&#1 %(5#& (*)"!*"

'(<(5 3#"("($*

1"('5#) ?

 $*)"("."($* *&(!;

(*"#1 !5(!;

)##8(*4 !

*!".1# '#1"($1!1( )#""(*4 !)(&# $1&#1 &!"#& ,+,

 ;

3!))#& 5#!1*#& (<()($*!5 !*!5

%%('#1;

!=!)"0!* ##&#1 (<()($*;

#1$B#3.1

)0$1"

6 6;

>0#1#/A >!"#1'$.1)#,

,

%.1"0#1 31!A#1 )#""(*4 !)(&# $1&#1 &!"#& ,,

?;

3!))#& 5#!1*#& -.3#1(*"#*&(*4 !*!5

%%('#1;

#1$B#3.1 !*!5 (1'5#;

#1$B#3.1

)0$1"

6- 6;

>0#1#/A !* !33#!5 %(5#& !4!(*)"

$1&#1 &!"#& ,+,

 ;

&():())#&,



,

1(#%5A;

7#80 !: )./:(""#& !* !335('!"($* /#%$1# '!*!5 !."0$1("(#) >!"#1'$.1)#;

!55#4#& 0!<# &#:$5()0#& !5$*4>("0 $*# 2(=!A 9.:!1, , !33#!1#& !%$1#)!(& 31$'##&(*4) /#%$1# '!*!5 !."0$1("(#) )./:(""#& $/=#'"($*) )"!"(*4 31!A#1 7#80 !:

#"', %!5)#,

'5!(:) 5!*&

!=/(1 -(*40 $*  , , !"

"(:#;

*$ 1.**(*4 $* 5!*& !335('!*") (,#, ;

*!:#5A 7#80 !:

!=3!5,

"

%.1"0#1 '5!(:#& 1#<#*.# 1#'$1&;

"0#1# *$ '$**#'"(*4 "01$.40 5!*& 3#"("($*#1;

"0#1#%$1#;

"0#1# *$ C.#)"($* &#:$5("($* >!"#1'$.1)#,

"

)"!"#& /#%$1# #@#'."(*4 )!5# &##& 0() %!<$.1;

!=/(1 -(*40 0!& #@'0!*4#& 0() 5!*& '$:31()#& #'", ?;

9(5!

;

+  ;

D $* ,+,;

<(&# :."!"($* D;

>("0 0() 3!"#1*!5 .*'5# !=3!5

0#1#(*,

"

)"!"#& >!A "0() #@'0!*4#;

!=/(1 -(*40 0!& 5#%"

3!))!4# 5!*&

!=3!5

;

0$>#<#1;

>0#* 5!*&

!=/(1 -(*40;

"0#*

!=/(1 -(*40 0!& 4(<#* !* !%%(&!<("

0!& #@'0!*4#& 5!*&;

<(&# :."!"($* D;

>("0 0() 3!"#1*!5 .*'5# !=3!5

;

/."

>(55 &#:!*& 0() 5!*& )$5&



, "

!33#!1) 5#!1*#&

.3$* '$*)(&#1!"($* :!""#1 >!"#1'$.1)#;

<(&# $1&#1 &!"#& ,+,

 ,

,

#(*4 &())!"()%(#&;

31#%#11#& !* !33#!5 !4!(*)"

$1&#1 &!"#& ,+,

  /#%$1# 5#!1*#& - ;

0$>#<#1;

)!:# &():())#&;

<(&# $1&#1 &!"#& ,,

?,

, 7#!1*#& '$.*)#5 )./:(") !

%1!.& 35!A#& >("0

'$**(<!*'# >("0 "0() 1#4!1&;

0!& )./:(""#& !

'$:35!(*"

3$5('# $* ,,;

>0#1#.3$*

>#1# ).::$*#& :!""#1 '$:31$:()#&;

>0#1#(* ("

)#""5#& :."!"($* 1#4!1&(*4 #@'0!*4# 5!*&

>(55 /# '!*'#55#& !%"#1 '!*'#55!"($*;

"0#A >(55 4#"

:."!"($* !4!(* #*"#1#& 1#<#*.# 1#'$1& 1#4!1&(*4 #@'0!*4# 5!*& ;

>0#1#(*

>(55 4(<# 8!1!:

5!*& !&=$(*(*4 90!)1!

?

 3!))!4# ,

"

"0#1#%$1# '$*"#*&#& <(#> .*&#1"!8(*4 4(<#*

/#%$1# 3$5('#;

0!& !

)"!"#:#*"

1#C.#)"(*4 3$5('# &$#) >!*"

"!8# !*A !'"($* <(#> '$:31$:()#,

)!(& '$:31$:()#

 )"!"#& /# )(4*#& 3#"("($*#1;

2(=!A 9.:!1;

"

!''$1&(*45A '$*"#*&#& <(#> '$:31$:()#

;

#*"("5#& 3$(*"

66 3$(*"

66;

>1$*45A /# 1#)"$1#& !."0$1("(#) /#5$>,

, #!1&,



* 31#)#*"

'!)#;

0!& )$.40"

$* 35#!

)!:# >1$*45A &#:$5()0#&

* $"0#1 0!*&;

'5!(:) 0!& 5!*& :#!).1(*4  9!*!5 + !15!

!=/(1 -(*40 %$55$>(*4 :!**#1  

          



  !"#

  !

#  $% !"#&

 % !

#  

!

#    !"#

 '(% ") *         ' 

        

 

'  % !&#

   !

# '(%    "

     +* ,  (  -  & .#&

    (     ,  /  0   1(   2*(

3  45'6 , "

'!)# !

'$:31$:()#

 !11(<#& !"

/#%$1# 3$5('# )"!"($* !<#1:#*"

1#4!1& %$.*& 3!1!

3#"("($*;

1#!&) !) $ 1(  %(  (        '%  (  ,  -  %(  (    *-  (       "   7%((   $ (  /+-        %       (     &&&   2,    ,  (    (

   $"%  ( , (   %      *%  (  

 /+-   % *%(    $" 2 (  %  ((

 (8(,(*%(  

$"%*, (-%   (           (  7  

 ( 8(, *%(  

 

$"9% , (  (   "% 7$'  +(  

   '(% ",  %    

  $   1(    7%  ,  (   '  7  *-  (

   $"*, ( (  /+-  : (((-% '  -      7%  ,  (       1(    '%  *-( /+-  %     $"

%((% - *- (%  2   -,( % - *-(   8( %( 28 ;# 6 , $>#<#1;

>0#* !%$1#:#*"($*#& !<#1:#*"

3!1!

3#"("($* '$*)(&#1#& 5(40"

)#""5#:#*"

;

("

)##* '$:31$:()#

 &$#) 1#%5#'"

!*A ).'0 )#""5#:#*"

3!1"(#);

!) '5!(:#&

1#5#<!*"

#@"1!'") '$:31$:()#

 1#!& !) 9  *(%( *   &&&     !

  +*  <(  !+*  + 2(  &&.&."

 * ..

& &  ,2  + , (   ,= 

"&

  ( 

>( #

1( 3   >( # ( ,,/0  !+ , ( ,<    ,>(  1( % (   *     (7    ,,     %, (7*  ,%( (  %'- *( (*7   1( ,      :   (  (   **- -*  (%(7 *+( ? %*((- ,6

?

, 0#1#%$1#;

"0#1# *$"0(*4 (*&('!"# !*A )#""5#:#*"

!11(<#& !"

"0#A >$.5& '5!(:

!*A 5!*&;

!=/(1 -(*40,

, 7#!1*#&

>!"#1'$.1)#;

<(&# $1&#1 &!"#& ,+,

  $/)#1<(*4 !) 1(  ( *  <,( ( *  1(   ,(@ 2 <* 37   A,,  2*(  (7  *       1(  ,*((  ( *  4 (   ,(  %((  ( * ,(( ,(,(  7 <  # 1( '',<     '% ,  " #$ '', 7% 

&#  '',<   , '% 

&# 7% 

#   7

%((0#BB3C ,% , %( ( -,- %  , %(( %  , B3( * ( (  ,,%((  , (    7 (%  ,,D('7%(*7    ,   <&44,  ( 9 B3 2  , .2, .

"

( %  B#3 ( *-   6 '!*!5 !."0$1("(#) .3$* '$*)(&#1!"($* :!""#1 '!:# '$*'5.)($* "0#(1 ".1* !331$<#& !"

-#1(!5  !88!

-#1(!5 $  1#4!1&(*4 "!8(*4 >!"#1    !88!

4(<(*4 >!"#1 !"

?  )(:(5!15A !88!

-#1(!5  "!8(*4 >!"#1 ?  4(<(*4 >!"#1 !"

? ;

!331$<#& 3$(*"

6 3$(*"

66



)!:# %!55 >("0(* '!"#4$1A &.5A )!*'"($*#& >!"#1'$.1)#, -(*'# %$.*& /# &#:$5()0#& 3$(*"

66 3$(*"

66;

)!:# /# 1#)"$1#&,

,?

<(&#*"5A;

4(<(*4 "!8(*4 3$(*") C.#)"($* %!55 >("0(* !1#!

'$:31()#& #'", ?;

?, * "0() <(#> :!""#1;

 %(*& *$ :#1("

(*)"!*"

'(<(5 3#"("($* )!:# !''$1&(*45A &():())#&, ,

#*&(*4 !335('!"($*

);

(% !*A;

)0!55 !5)$ )"!*& '5$)#&,

 -





+,,

)=8) 0#"0#1 )3#!8(*4 1#!)$*#&

 #)

$ 0#"0#1 1#3$1"!/5#  #)

$