Subhash Chander v. Superintending Canal Officer Ferozepur Canal Circle Ferozepur And Others
!"# &#'()($*
+,, -./0!)0 0!* ,,,,,, #"("($*#1 2#1).) -.3#1(*"#*&(*4 !*!5
%%('#1 $"0#1)
,,,,,, #)3$*&#*") 6 7 ,
- -
1#)#*"
1,
)0$8 9.:!1 90.*4#1;
&<$'!"#
1, !<*##"
-(*40;
-#*($1
.*=!/,
1, 1!"##8 !*&(";
&<$'!"#
'!<#!"$11#)3$*&#*"
, , , -
;
7
, #"("($*#1
-./0!)0 0!* %(5#& (*)"!*"
'(<(5 3#"("($*
1"('5#) ?
$*)"("."($* *&(!;
(*"#1 !5(!;
)##8(*4 !
*!".1# '#1"($1!1( )#""(*4 !)(&# $1 &!"#& ,+,
;
3!))#& 5#!1*#& (<()($*!5 !*!5
%%('#1;
!=!)"0!* ## (<()($*;
#1$B#3.1
)0$1"
6 6;
>0#1#/A >!"#1'$.1)#,
,
%.1"0#1 31!A#1 )#""(*4 !)(&# $1 &!"#& ,,
?;
3!))#& 5#!1*#& -.3#1(*"#*&(*4 !*!5
%%('#1;
#1$B#3.1 !*!5 (1'5#;
#1$B#3.1
)0$1"
6- 6;
>0#1#/A !* !33#!5 %(5#& !4!(*)"
$1 &!"#& ,+,
;
&():())#&,
,
1(#%5A;
7#80 !: )./:(""#& !* !335('!"($* /#%$1# '!*!5 !."0$1("(#) >!"#1'$.1)#;
!55#4#& 0!<# &#:$5()0#& !5$*4>("0 $*# 2(=!A 9.:!1, , !33#!1#& !%$1#)!(& 31$'##&(*4) /#%$1# '!*!5 !."0$1("(#) )./:(""#& $/=#'"($*) )"!"(*4 31!A#1 7#80 !:
#"', %!5)#,
'5!(:) 5!*&
!=/(1 -(*40 $* , , !"
"(:#;
*$ 1.**(*4 $* 5!*& !335('!*") (,#, ;
*!:#5A 7#80 !:
!=3!5,
"
%.1"0#1 '5!(:#& 1#<#*.# 1#'$1&;
"0#1# *$ '$**#'"(*4 "01$.40 5!*& 3#"("($*#1;
"0#1#%$1#;
"0#1# *$ C.#)"($* &#:$5("($* >!"#1'$.1)#,
"
)"!"#& /#%$1# #@#'."(*4 )!5# &##& 0() %!<$.1;
!=/(1 -(*40 0!& #@'0!*4#& 0() 5!*& '$:31()#& #'", ?;
9(5!
;
+ ;
D $* ,+,;
<(&# :."!"($* D;
>("0 0() 3!"#1*!5 .*'5# !=3!5
0#1#(*,
"
)"!"#& >!A "0() #@'0!*4#;
!=/(1 -(*40 0!& 5#%"
3!))!4# 5!*&
!=3!5
;
0$>#<#1;
>0#* 5!*&
!=/(1 -(*40;
"0#*
!=/(1 -(*40 0!& 4(<#* !* !%%(&!<("
0!& #@'0!*4#& 5!*&;
<(&# :."!"($* D;
>("0 0() 3!"#1*!5 .*'5# !=3!5
;
/."
>(55 &#:!*& 0() 5!*& )$5&
, "
!33#!1) 5#!1*#&
.3$* '$*)(!"($* :!""#1 >!"#1'$.1)#;
<(&# $1 &!"#& ,+,
,
,
#(*4 &())!"()%(#&;
31#%#11#& !* !33#!5 !4!(*)"
$1 &!"#& ,+,
/#%$1# 5#!1*#& - ;
0$>#<#1;
)!:# &():())#&;
<(&# $1 &!"#& ,,
?,
, 7#!1*#& '$.*)#5 )./:(") !
%1!.& 35!A#& >("0
'$**(<!*'# >("0 "0() 1#4!1&;
0!& )./:(""#& !
'$:35!(*"
3$5('# $* ,,;
>0#1#.3$*
>#1# ).::$*#& :!""#1 '$:31$:()#&;
>0#1#(* ("
)#""5#& :."!"($* 1#4!1&(*4 #@'0!*4# 5!*&
>(55 /# '!*'#55#& !%"#1 '!*'#55!"($*;
"0#A >(55 4#"
:."!"($* !4!(* #*"#1#& 1#<#*.# 1#'$1& 1#4!1&(*4 #@'0!*4# 5!*& ;
>0#1#(*
>(55 4(<# 8!1!:
5!*& !&=$(*(*4 90!)1!
?
3!))!4# ,
"
"0#1#%$1# '$*"#*&#& <(#> .*"!8(*4 4(<#*
/#%$1# 3$5('#;
0!& !
)"!"#:#*"
1#C.#)"(*4 3$5('# &$#) >!*"
"!8# !*A !'"($* <(#> '$:31$:()#,
)!(& '$:31$:()#
)"!"#& /# )(4*#& 3#"("($*#1;
2(=!A 9.:!1;
"
!''$1&(*45A '$*"#*&#& <(#> '$:31$:()#
;
#*"("5#& 3$(*"
66 3$(*"
66;
>1$*45A /# 1#)"$1#& !."0$1("(#) /#5$>,
, #!1&,
* 31#)#*"
'!)#;
0!& )$.40"
$* 35#!
)!:# >1$*45A &#:$5()0#&
* $"0#1 0!*&;
'5!(:) 0!& 5!*& :#!).1(*4 9!*!5 + !15!
!=/(1 -(*40 %$55$>(*4 :!**#1
!"#
!
# $% !"#&
% !
#
!
# !"#
'(% ") * '
' % !&#
!
# '(% "
+* , ( - & .#&
( , / 0 1( 2*(
3 45'6 , "
'!)# !
'$:31$:()#
!11(<#& !"
/#%$1# 3$5('# )"!"($* !<#1:#*"
1#4!1& %$.*& 3!1!
3#"("($*;
1#!&) !) $ 1( %( ( '% ( , - %( ( *- ( " 7%(( $ ( /+- % ( &&& 2, , ( (
$"% ( , ( % *% (
/+- % *%( $" 2 ( % ((
(8(,(*%(
$"%*, (-% ( ( 7
( 8(, *%(
$"9% , ( ( "% 7$' +(
'(% ", %
$ 1( 7% , ( ' 7 *- (
$"*, ( ( /+- : (((-% ' - 7% , ( 1( '% *-( /+- % $"
%((% - *- (% 2 -,( % - *-( 8( %( 28 ;# 6 , $>#<#1;
>0#* !%$1#:#*"($*#& !<#1:#*"
3!1!
3#"("($* '$*)(#& 5(40"
)#""5#:#*"
;
("
)##* '$:31$:()#
&$#) 1#%5#'"
!*A ).'0 )#""5#:#*"
3!1"(#);
!) '5!(:#&
1#5#<!*"
#@"1!'") '$:31$:()#
1#!& !) 9 *(%( * &&& !
+* <( !+* + 2( &&.&."
* ..
& & ,2 + , ( ,=
"&
(
>( #
1( 3 >( # ( ,,/0 !+ , ( ,< ,>( 1( % ( * (7 ,, %, (7* ,%( ( %'- *( (*7 1( , : ( ( **- -* (%(7 *+( ? %*((- ,6
?
, 0#1#%$1#;
"0#1# *$"0(*4 (*&('!"# !*A )#""5#:#*"
!11(<#& !"
"0#A >$.5& '5!(:
!*A 5!*&;
!=/(1 -(*40,
, 7#!1*#&
>!"#1'$.1)#;
<(&# $1 &!"#& ,+,
$/)#1<(*4 !) 1( ( * <,( ( * 1( ,(@ 2 <* 37 A,, 2*( (7 * 1( ,*(( ( * 4 ( ,( %(( ( * ,(( ,(,( 7 < # 1( '',< '% , " #$ '', 7%
&# '',< , '%
&# 7%
# 7
%((0#BB3C ,% , %( ( -,- % , %(( % , B3( * ( ( ,,%(( , ( 7 (% ,,D('7%(*7 , <&44, ( 9 B3 2 , .2, .
"
( % B#3 ( *- 6 '!*!5 !."0$1("(#) .3$* '$*)(!"($* :!""#1 '!:# '$*'5.)($* "0#(1 ".1* !331$<#& !"
-#1(!5 !88!
-#1(!5 $ 1#4!1&(*4 "!8(*4 >!"#1 !88!
4(<(*4 >!"#1 !"
? )(:(5!15A !88!
-#1(!5 "!8(*4 >!"#1 ? 4(<(*4 >!"#1 !"
? ;
!331$<#& 3$(*"
6 3$(*"
66
)!:# %!55 >("0(* '!"#4$1A &.5A )!*'"($*#& >!"#1'$.1)#, -(*'# %$.*& /# &#:$5()0#& 3$(*"
66 3$(*"
66;
)!:# /# 1#)"$1#&,
,?
<(&#*"5A;
4(<(*4 "!8(*4 3$(*") C.#)"($* %!55 >("0(* !1#!
'$:31()#& #'", ?;
?, * "0() <(#> :!""#1;
%(*& *$ :#1("
(*)"!*"
'(<(5 3#"("($* )!:# !''$1&(*45A &():())#&, ,
#*&(*4 !335('!"($*
);
(% !*A;
)0!55 !5)$ )"!*& '5$)#&,
-
+,,
)=8) 0#"0#1 )3#!8(*4 1#!)$*#&
#)
$ 0#"0#1 1#3$1"!/5# #)
$