← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/614/2006dismissed

Kartar Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

 

     

  



! % ##"

&& '((  )*+ (,       )(

 $ -#.

,/ 

 ( "

&&

 - $"&&.

-.

)*+

00000      && ! % ##"

( &" 

12 345 ,,

.

  ,  4 3 "

#( )(7 $"

+( (  .

 64

($ 8$  8.

#"(, )&"

" ", ;,#.

 "& .

&&#"(

+ <



 "#

&, , /"&&# $ 9"$" *"(,"

)&"

" :,$".

,

( "( (((("

=# 7 $(= 9"$ 7 &"

(   "& ,,

/"

(,.

/", ,,

 , ((, /7 ,7.

( , ,# "#( "( ", 9 7( 7 " ( .

?@ ,& 7 ".

$

,# 2 $

$(

1&"# ##"/,

/"

, ( .

&& ,  & + 



.

9$ , ", #& $"#.

 &"

" + "&,.

(+("/ ( "( ((,, ,"# , &.

(+* "($"# A"(" +,( ("( $" ;,"

"& #"(.

,(" " "

"($"# A"(" +"& +,(

3"

& "((,    39 & $(

  "& # (

"&7 (,  (

(.

 (7 

.

!&," B$" , 2/("#"# "



2C &# ) *" ( $ "&(

)&"

" 9$"& /&&"# -/.

/$"

& +"# 3) <6 +"# ,"/ (+& 

( "#

&, , /"&&# $

 &&"#

="# "

( "& & .

$  D( * ( *" ? $&& $+#$

$ *", 7@

(,

 "# ","# ** $=  +"# 3) 556<

(", /"&&# $@ ("#&&, ( +#$  $&@ +"# A",.

,"( &(,  $ "

&(@ #7 +# (

( , &7"#  (

@ 2 &,

(( , ( #7 +# & ,  ( 

""# (

+, 9, (

"#$ # (

, , ( ( -E, "

  #"(@

, # (

",  ( -E, "

@ $ 2 ( 9"&((

((# $ / $ ).

+ "/"(".

A( "/ (@ (", )  $, ( +

"(@ "/&.

) ,"( &(, ","7

(,.

&&"# $"

(

&,

",  ( $ -E, "

 &(.

$9/.

(,

", )@

 ( , F$"+",

(,@ $ "( ).

2

, , ( #7 +# ,

""# 7 $(=@ 2 = 

#

7 $(= +"# 9"#$,.

""# 7 $(= #7 +#



=#( <4

# (, #7 +#@ #7 +#

""# (", 7 $(=

/, "  &(.

(&, (& ) ((" 88@ $  &.

+&=  & &# 

" ((((".

/",

@ (& ( ", )@ (& (("

$" ,@

,"#&7 (,

 &(.

"# A"(" ,  (@ 2 ( A GF) (" +("( & 12 GF)?

#"(,@ 2 ,

 #$ (" & &

  (".

2 , ,

&#

7 9"((( + 2  D )&"

".

9$ /"",  (  9 (& ((" 88  & +&=  &@ ( (& (("

$" ,@ $ 2 ,(",

7 D = "#$@ 

.

!&," =

7

D = ( , "# + 2&&A #"( ,"# $.

,(", (", D.

9$(

&,#, & =

"#

( "/("#".

 & ( $ & GF ".

;&,$.

)*+ $#$ (+& =$" "/, $

  #"/ GF);.

, 7 $, " 9,@

 &" "/("#" $ &""(.

$&& #"(

, "&,

  "

$&&.

"&  "& ;,#.

(&",

"( ,  ( &", 

$&&



(( /",, , 

< ).

$ ","# "

 "

(.

$#   ,  4   , #"(

(,.

&,, #"&7

&"

, "&

"#

( /", .

F ", $ / $ ).

)H D (, (7 #,(

+,

=# 7 $(=

(((("

$9"(.

("", #,  "/("#"

)H

2A+& (,

.

(, )&"

" ,7.

" A GF).

,, & 12 GF)?.

, ("#( (,"# ( "& ( 2&&A #"( $"#$ ( $#$

(+&

)H5 ) *" 9$

+ 7

.

$,,

 ,

$"

.

(, (7

"& ( .

( "&&7 #,

+,

(((("

)H = 9$ 9="# $ D, (+& )&"

"

9$

7

+ ,(", 2.

9$ $( (" +  , 2.

#"# ( ,, ,, ",/" /", GF)!.

9$" ("",

.

!&,"

2 .

,(",

7

 & +&=  & ,&7 (&, (&( ((" 88 88 (  (& (("( $"



 

.

!&," =

7

D = ( , "#

 + 2&&A #"( ,"# $.

,(", (", D@

.

(  & (&( " (& (("( (+& =$" ( ,(""# $( (("( $ & GF ".

;&,$.

)*+ (+& =$"

,"#&7 # , = "((,

).

,(", (", "

&(

(("( $ & GF ".

;&,$.

)*+ .

$,, / " $"

@ ,"# ",.

7 ", ((((".

"$  ,  &&9, 7+,7 &( , ( )H4 (+& =$"

"  & $ "

&(

(("( $ & GF ".

;&,$.

)*+.

/", ",/" GF):

("", ( &# "

&( ", ((((".

  "# $9"$ &

)H 2  9$ (, D.

)&"

"

,(, #,"#  ,"&, ( )H< $   .

>.

"

.

3=, +#$ #"(" ,   + ) 556< (, (,  ! ( &" ? ,.

9 "&97 ,.

3=, D /, #"("

""

  GF)

,,& ))  #/  )H D( *

 + 9 /

="# ( "&





<

4.

, ( !&," 9$ 2

(" # , " &"=&7  2,".

( $.

,,& ))

&(, /",

>$.

(

,, ,  55 ).

&& "

""#

"  ( ( "# /", #"(

 $"

+ ,", &&#"(

,"# " + &(&7 "/&/,

< "# , /", .

F ",  9"((( ,"&, +&9 H -,/  + ) $7 /"&&# >".

>$("& (, =9( !

$( "( ( ,"(

(", @ +

7( #.

"&(

/ ,

(,.

("# !



",

, $7 ( $"# 9 

(",

(,.

$9/.

$"# /, 7 "/, $ + 





,"# 9"((.

&# ( $ (( &(  $, (

&#  $" /$"

& 2 .

+

,7(.

$7

=9 ! + "/&/, &(

9"(( (, 9" ! &(

/,

 &"

"( $"#$ $""(

H

) !.

9"

&( ,(, ("

"& &"( H.

("# ($

/, &"

"( $"#$ $""( $ /,

+

7  &"

"( GF.

I)( GF

4.

("#  + $ ( &"

"(

H5 - * ,,& D.

) +#$ (

, , " #"( 3 #,"# ,("

7 ("#

7 ,(", D.

)&"

"

.

/", 7 3

/",  35 .

#"( 3 .

7 "

=# <4

#

#7 +#.

#

(&, (& +"# &( 88 88.

$9/.

3

,(",

7 !&," ,(",

7 D =  &( ,(", "

2

(.

7 9"$,9

&=$ #" , "# + #"(  "/7 &"( $#$( ,(",

&#

7  ,

7 ,(",



+$ "(

, D ( "/ #"(( $ #"( +"# #"( 3

E

$ ,("

7



"(

", D /,

7 &/ 7 #"( 3 GFH5? #"( 3

GFH5?

H D( *.

9$

", 

 ",, 9"(( 9$ + #"/  ( + 9 /

(,.

,  9"((

(,.

("# ,( =9

,", $,

( D (, (,",  J

&(( GF) ,( + ("#( GF)G.

)- )D , + ("#( D (, ( / ,,

 $"# # (.

"&

/"

, ( ,

", (

$/ $, &,

(& &&?

(,.

&, 

(& +(",( #"# $#$ ,

2

(.

+$ 9"(((  &7 )H $ / $ ) )H

) *" &&7 (, (7 #,

=# 7 $(=

! % ##"

+ <



 "#

&, , /"&&# $.

7"# #7 +# & ,  (  $ $( )H( (+* , &#$7

((F "" +$&

+ $7 ( = $" #(

&, ($, 7

"& " $

,(, &

/" "#



 #"/

"("

", 3 /"(  "7 +9 $( )H(

$( + &&#,  /,  , $7

"#$ $/ "/&/,

9#&7  ,(, #"( $"

( 

/"

$( ,, ("( 7

 F&" F "" !&," 2

(.

(+ ""# " .

$( ("

"#, , &"& ( ( "# 2," >$.

 ,/( "

 ,9 #"( F "" !&,"

 ( #,( F ""# D( *.

",, 9"((.

 (

, ,,& )) .

+ 9 /

(,.

$.

F ", 9"(( >$"(  (,(

+, ( D( * , 9"(( +$&

(,.

("#  +  ,

( D ,", ("#( /"( ,  ( , 2 &"# ( ("E

39 A(" "(( 9$$ , (

"  ( (.

( D( * H



 ,

(.

#"/"# "( ,+

", + $&&(( (7 (9 $( #"/

 "/"("  



!"# #$%& '

(.

4

 

&

4.

,&"# ("

"& ("" 9$ ",, 9"(( *", 7 ,"# ( , , 9"(( ,7"# *", 7  7

+, &

("# ("#(  , +&= ( 9$ /"(", (" ,=

,"".

+(/,



+&"/,  ( ("#( /"(

 ( ," 9""#

"&

&, ("#, 9"(( +&= ( ("

7 9"(( $&, &"+& ,"( ,,

2

&(.

D( * ,", ("#( /"( ,  ( + $

$( F ", 7 ,  F , ($9 ("#( ,  ( "# $( D( * , &&7 (,, ("#( >$.

,("" H D( * ,( $&

7



5 2



 

"

(.

,"+"&"7 "&?&"

9"(((

(",, +(/, 9$ $ "(  &&#" 7  "7 #"( "&( &(&7 &"

 && $  (

,( #"( &&.

"& "#$&7

&,,  F "" ",, 9"(( ( +"# 9 /

,( "( 7 ,+

( ,&7 (,"# $ & GF " &( ,"( ((, .

$&,"# 9$ &( ( $ & GF ".

9"$" <

$(.

/"

 /"", #,.

(" $ "(  ( ""

/"("  #, "( "(?(,"# ,( (  &7 #",&"( #&

& "& 9="# 3 "

&  >$  "/&7

( +* "(, &,

(& && ("

(

,7(

 (("( $ & GF ".

;&,$.

)*+

( ,+

", + $&&(( (7

 $ # ,/ , &,

(& && 2 $,, / (& ( ",, 9"(( D9/.

# "( &( 9"$

" 2 "#& ;,# '

(

!" # #$%& '

()***+,-  +./-012.

,&"# ( 7 ("".

+(/, 9$ (& "( $,, / ",, 9"(( (.

"( &.

$#$

, (("

" "( /7 +&

/.

(&

 &97( $,, / ",, 9"(( ( 2 $( ( A&7 2

 , &97( ( (& ",, 9"((.

"( ((, " ((((" ,7( #$ "&&

7  $( "( ,("" >$.

+* "( * ,

4 $( &, ,A &"= /", ($9   "#

7  &  &  $, (("( $ & GF ".

;&,$.

)*+ (&( " &7("(.

, 7 $(= /, "(

$# #"(

&("/&7 " "/&7

#,

/"

((, "& "( A" ,"&,.

9&& (,.

,( (

7 "&&#&"7  "" "7 2 "( +(,   "(& /",



 "" &9 >$ "( "&&#&"7  "" "7 $9"$.

"#$ $/

&&, " 9$"& F "("# && *"(,"

"

"&&7.

="# /"9 A"7

+, /,.

( 9,,

 (", $"#$ (", $ "(   , $ ( ( #,

/"

, (  $&, & "( , 9"$

" "( ,"( "((,

,"#&7  &&?

"( ," , (, + $" ;,"

"& #"(.

9"$" 9=

,7.

"&"# &, ;.

9&, "(( 9( ( (  ( (, $"

*"& ,# ""# ( 3 ((7 ""

" (

, " "

 &"  

  

 

  

 !"

#  %&"

#