High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/857/2014dismissed

Vishal Kumar v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-04-2511 pages

!"!

#$% &

'()!*+ ,,(( &+ -.!/0'+

" #$ %%%% #$ % %$%$$ .+ + &

'(!/($1 +',,(

,,(( $%$$ & ,,((3&

'()!*+

""+ 1'/!"* # ,

04'(+ (-

5!"$ -"+!+'6'-'- "'+ , $/ )!++ , 7$

+*+ , 5""

( -'* '+- "'+ , '10 '

'+" +' ,!

'0(!+- 7$$ 9.

'+/ )!+' 0

+' ,!

'0(!+- 79. !+" *,+

*+( $0

$,4 $:

!('+!+"+ "+!

*,+

*+;*'

< $',,(

,,(( = (1,,("

01 /!"*# '6 ( .+ ; * ' * >6 .?

:',,(

'()!*+ "'!'@!, +049 , +'

+- "'.?77 &

'( )!*+ ' ' ; +

-!* @$ -"+!+$ +!

"'*

','((+$-"+!+ A' *,( '

'+;+ ' + ',0! , * 7 -'+(4'++$' *,( B '+"'!'@!,('

','

*+ (0+ "+"

+ .

# ?' ' *,( B '+ +!+ ((0!% , * $+

;+* + '+'

* <;1+$' ++ 4 (4 !( A' *,( *=; '*+ "7 ' '

'+B 04; (4 "+' ( * + A' *+ ( ; ( ! (4 " + ' 04 A'

*,( (";

'A+ *D( -!='1'+ ' ' , + , '

+* A'4 ; *+=

+"!( +! ' = ' *,( B '+ &

'( )!*+ ''

'+B *0 (,' ## ;

, = <

'+'0*!++04 *!=;

,+ 04'+( "'

* D1 "A+ *D(+'04 "'!'@!,$' *,( ,+ ("+,+

+ , E9>6 .?7:

; +"

+!+- 7 79.'0

*>6 .?

:*04'

*,( 9 , +'

+- "'(";

''+,(

(

+ '' ,,+,++!"'

,(>6 .?#: 98!

+,+ >6 .?7:; ,+,+ -* ,= )!*+ ""+;( >6 .?: / + - "' >6 .?7:> ;+ +!+-

+ . A'04; 04 '* 0 "'!' @!, 0( *+ = - "'$ .'"+,'+; ((' ,+= ",'"+,'

' ,(

!++ ;(( '04 A'04;

'+!"' < 0( -* - "' + !

" , *+*1 ,,(

>6 .?7: 0( =*+ (0+ " .

# //

1+(4 "+'04; =

1 **>6 .?#:

A',+ (' (' ' $!(4 (;

' (' +; '1+ 04< 0(-*- "'; = ,

04 , +'

+- "'1 **>6 .?#: ,+'. +*,+>6 .?7:$' !

'; ,'46 ! *+*'+( " ;+ +8! >6 .?7:E; *1 0+ ' - +

(

+$ ( < , ($ -"+!+ + (+ "' !

'"'!'@!, .?7$+ ) +,( - "'1 + *>6 .?7:

, 'B + "

+ !1+

!(+ 0+ ((

!++ "' *'+( "B ,+',+ 1+

$'+ -' - "'$

+ *$ / )!+

'+/ )!+

' +"!

(0+>6!

,(!

((+-//)!*+ .?& )!*+ *.? & )!*+$.?

'1"''!

-//)!*+>6!

,( !

((+ + , *;+= & )!*+;

"" 1+ ;

'-//)!*+;''

'+/ )!+

$-'- "'+ , $/ )!++ , 7$

+*+ , ++ 1 -//)!*+B '!

(('*

''4'= (( "'!'@!,;' 04'0!7 9 ; +1( ' "'!' @!, (( '+/ )!+ 7 0! , * "0!'1 (0 4 (4+ 6!(1!+ '+/ )!+ ="'!'@!,

* '+ '!

;'+ / )!+ ; 1 (0( + ' 0 6!(1!+ +*/ )!+$'; =,404'

,+ ?'' "'!'@!,+!

$'; +

0(40+!"' '0+*'+/ B '!

04 '+/ )!+$ -' - "'$

+ * / )!+ "'!'@!,; '04'

04'+( "

* 9 ++

, ' 04$ '+/ )!+ (,'

((4 ((

+*+ , 5""

(

-'* '+- "'+ ,

+*5""

,!' 04'*+ (' 0!* "' 7 '+;'04+'* +

+ 0!+4 A' !+- 79.; (- 9.;

.!+ !'01

( !+0+-//)!*+ & )!*+$'01*,+ (";

' 5""

(

-'* '+- "' ;+*

+ *$/ )!+$'+/ )!+-'- "';+++ '0

+ +* , 5""

( -'* '+ - "' ; ++ # <;1+$ & )!*+ .? -// )!*+ .?

'1 !,,+',+ 1+

A'4'1 "+

((4 ''

' +"!

( 0+'* 7 ' ' ;

'1 *= " 4

*+=04& )!*++= 04-//)!*+ 0+',(

+"+ ;+ +8! >6 .?7:@; *10+'

A+ ,+

+$-"+!++1+ 4 "';+ '

,' *+ (+ 1+' , 9; !0+"

+ ' *&

'()!*+3 *,( A' (( *0 ( ## ;'

! '*& = @!,.?$ '+ ' ;+ !"' A'01 *0 ( !*0+ ; (("(4 !

04 ' '!"' ; 1+ 04 ' ,(

!'+ (( *0 (

%7 #

%7 '*'+/ )!+;+ ( 0 9; !'' "'!'@!, '+/ )!+$;'; !

"(,'##

%7'(= ''+'

'((:+,+!+- 7+ . ; ,+,+ *,( 1 " !0* 0+'!+ 7 '+"!+- 7$$ 9.; +* "

(('

# A',+ 6* *4 ;

,+1 .?$& )!*+ *.?$-// )!*+ !,,+',+ '' ;

'46+/!

(

'0*044 '

0+'* & )!*+ ''1+*

**+=0+',(

-//)!*+ '' '* **+= 0+',(

.?7$+ ) +,( - "'' ,+1'' 8! ; !

04 ,'46 ! '+( " 0 (,' ## 04& = )!*+ .?0!

04"'!'@!,; + 1+ A'

(( '

* " *+ ( 1 ,!'* A'4,( ( *,(

<;1+$;

; 6* D++ (!+,,+

'1 +

'+/ )!+ + '

'0(!+- 79.;'

( "((' '+

'+/ )!+ ;

,+ *+ (4'"+!''+; 1 ' 0 " ;

''+'+!"''

*0 (,' < $ ""+ 104' (+ $',,(

*,( ' ,,+ ''

!+ D+ !

(+',,(

1'*(4+"! ' '+

*,(1 + +

(('

A' '.?$& )!*+.?$-//)!*+'1

!,,+',+ + +*'1+

4 ',+ '+ (!+* ,,+,+

'+/ )!+$'0

' *1 (

A'*

(1 ++1( '"'!'@!,; '04'+( "

* A' (( ',' !

04' ' '+/ )!++1(' *,(

4(('

-'- "'

3+ ,

''!

0'+/ )!+ '+/ )!+ ' 0

04 ' (+ + ( !+ + '

'0(!+- 79. 9

0(' '+/ )!+( !('1 ** '*!++"'!'

@!, A'++$ ' (+ + ( !+ ' "+

(4 ++

,+4''

*,!"/!"*0

'6 (' A'4 '!(0

+' ,!

'0( !+- 7$ 9.,!

+ "(4 ?'1'+(+ !

(+',,(

'1 +!((4"'+!"''+ +;

A' ,+

!* ( 1 9

( ,

' + "

!* ( 1 $ ' !+ *!

, 1+4 ! !

,,+ ' 1

'!( 0 + + (4

!* +,+104+ 0(!0!(4+* "

*,( ' !++ "(4 , " ' "!

( '

$';1+$ +" 1+=',( ,+ 9 ' ,+ $

,! ' (( '

;+*

+'(("6+/!

(

*+= 04'+/ )!+$

+*$-' - "'/ )!+0+& )!*+.?-//)!*+ .?7 ,3 5""

( -'* '+- "'

; * '0

6+/!

(

04'

9',+ 0'-//)!*+& )!*+ '1 ' 4 '

!+ 4 6+ /!

(

0+'* A'4'1 !,,+',+ 1+

4*+ >6+/!

(

;=, 1 ' 01 ;;

'"+ + ! A' <B0(-!,+*!+

( !**+

"'1 +41(! +( 0 46+/!

(

0 +1 !+

A' 6+/!

(

;= 1 04

( 9' 06* 04' !+;

'"++

+ ! F

9 '!(0*1(!+ (4 '!(0+!'!(F

9 '!(

, + F

1 6+/!

(

"++ + 4 1 +41(!$

!,,+04 '

!+'+ ++0+04 '+,+ 1 F 1 E+ 6+/!

(

0 ' 0

$ '!( !+ +* 4 *+ (

'+ *,+00 -!

' *

((4' 0,+1( =4 '+

+ ;

'(; 9'

$'+

1 + +,+ +* ' 01 6+ /!

(

;

'' **

' + ' 0*04(+ !

(+',,(

!"" ' ' (( 0;*0 (,'0 "!

04' "'!' @!, ## ' *0 ( ,' !*0+

%7$#

%7+1(''+; 0;' '+/ )!+ ;(( 0;'+/ )!+ '+

,+ 9

,!''*0 (,'

# ## (("0!

04 ; 1++ 1+ .?$& = @!,' '' *0 (; !

04'

'+; !

!((4;

* .?7$9 , +'

- "'$' 1 " "

$' ,

((4* ' ,+'*0 (,'+ +$'+; + *0 ( 0;/ )!+$'+/ )!+-'- "' *, ';','!*0+ ##

%7#

%7 '!"' '*'+/ )!+;+0 "!

04'+/ )!+'+'!

0-'- "' 0(

'+* '1 + + 9'0 4 ,

1 1 ,+1'

*,(

4 ' **

$-' - "' 0

+ ' ,!

'0( !+ - 7$ 9.$*+(40 !

''!

0 '+/ )!+ ;'

+ ,+ !*,

!*, A' ,+ ' ,+1 "

044 + 0(!0 A'(++ (!+' + "'(4'(''

1 + + 0(

' ' **

8! 04+ A'+

" '

+ ;

' ' ' +* +

!* ( 1 ,+ !*, 0 +; ' '+/ )!+ !('1*!++"'!'@!,'+ ;

, '

04 ;(( 9;

!*0!,' ,+ '1,+1'+ ;+ 1(4

1(1 '*!++"'!'@!, ;(('

, (

04 A'+

1 + +,+1'

*,(

4'01 + ' **

* - * (+(4$'+

*+ ' '(+ !

(+ ',,(

' '+/ )!+' 0

$(('

'!('10

(";

' '+

* (+ 1 "

'* A'(++ (!+' + "'(4'(' '1 + + ,+1' *,(

' **

' *!++"'!'

@!, 9

+ ' ,

$';1+$ +" 1+=' ,( ,+ 9

!*0!,',+ ,+1 04+ 0(!0"

,+ 9 + "

!* (1 $' ' 1 ' 0 *,( 1+4*+ ( "'+ '4,'

0!'"!

9',+ $'

!* = !*!( 1(4+* ' *,( ' (

,0( (!

'"!

9 0'(''1 + +, '+ '4,'

0!'"!

(+ D+ !

(+',,((

!0(, ! 4 (("( 4$,+1+

4+ +* 4 ' *,!"/!"*$;'

;++ ++ 04'

!+'6' ( ('

'!(0 "'(4 ++;

'! (!(

!0 ($ "1

'; '1 0 "+ + 1+(= + ' /!"* ( !+ +* ,+1+

4 + (("( 4 - *,(4 0 !

'+1 ;*40,

0( 0"+!++1+

/!"* ( A'<B0(-!,+*!+ '(')'*+(', '-(.+(', /.0121 %-'-. 23'0'-

% 4 ;'

( + "'0

,( ' ,

((4'(' ('+

!0(,+ !*, 1!+'

A' ,+ !*, + + $ + +* +"'04 (04'+ (!+

+ "(4$(1,,(

(+ '40 +1

;

(( '140+ ";' 1+4,,($;'

'*40:' 0 (04'

'+/ )!+ A'*+ '' 0 6* (48!+ %%%'0,!

$51'566!

2*7. 2*7.

!"!

#$% +

?''+ ,= ":+ G : ?''++,+0( G :