← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/86/2017dismissed

Ajay Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana

2023-03-23Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari16 pages

 

   



  "##

   

$$%% &'   

$ 



 

$$%% &'   

$      

 

       (



') ))* "  ! $$%% #



! $$%%

+

#

 

, -

-#)'* "  ! $$%% +

#

 

($ (.) ))* /* 01

 

 -# 3 ) "#4# % $$% #

"44

#"

* '$

-#  + 

5

6* % # # % -# 7'8* 0#* )' 3 ) "#4# % $$% 4 3% !

"44

#"

3# )

9)'8) #4$'8 #"

'$* % # # % -# 7'8

#"

#" #

$"

!! "

 $'

#)3% '

 -" #

 (* '

 -" #

(  :# ) -" #

;

(*

'

 -" #

  (  :# ) -" #

;

(

* % # # % -# 7'8

#"

"<'# % '$

$"

!! $'

#)3% '

 -" #



(

* )'8)

$   "#  :

;

* % #% 7'8 #4$ '$

#"  !   "

>  " #

 ( %% #"  )%% '

8 #8' #4$# 4

!

$# ) 1 ")

$14



5 !# ")

!'% )!

#"

)%% !' ) '

8 #4$% #4$# 4

! ) 4 ) ")

>  " #

(  :# ) " #

;

( %% #"  )%% '

8 #8' #4$# 4

! %#!

$14



5 !# ")

!'% )!

#"

)%% !' ) '

8 #4$% #4$# 4

! #= 4 ) ")

>  " #

  (  :# ) " #

;

( %% #"  )%% '

8 #8' #4$# 4

!

$# 1 ")

$14



5 ") !#

!'% )!

#"

)%% !' ) '

8 #4$% #4$# 4

! 4 ")

9)  " :  '

"' %1

0:* $# $

"' 1 #"  '#  #8 # *

#% "* :

4 -" #

   (   )   !!

#4$ '3 #  #4$# 4

%% #"  '$ 3"4 88# #"

#" # 3# 3"4 88# <'

):# )  " '$* 3"4 #4$ '$

") )4* )' )1 %  # '  )8#

$$% '$ 3! '

 



#!

!"  "

- ?4@# -# 8) "#

%$) #"

48 !!"

4 ) 

9'%# 4

& (.) 

4 (.) 5 &#%%8 (' )# ) "# @'#



<'%

4# 

/ % 0$# % 0#

"#$ !4 #

- ?4@# % 8:# )  ) $%#" !!#"#% ##  / % 0$# % 0#

)1 "%%"  ,

'<< " 

"  #"% @' 4 ) ) 3

! + 7# % 0$# % 0# :) @' & (.) :

3

9)!  - ?4@# "#

!4 #

@' 4 ) 4# 

 )$# %* 0#

9)!  )1 ")  0$# %* 0# :) "  ) "% $ #

'

!# ! 4.#

4 :)#% & (.) @' 4 $%#" $ 1

8 "

!!"

3'

$ - @1 %# )% 

- * @1 ?'4 

8)3#* ) #* #   %:

-:

+  )#.)'* +  

) )* )$ 

)%%* # #%%8 (' )# 

$% :# ) #

. !"#3% $#

9)1 "4 ) :# ) "  %%1

7

0# ! ) $ )#4 # *

)1    3 # )4 :# ) % )* - @1* @1* ) #

-: "' @'#

)'%

") '

"%

+

#  )# % )

$

+ 

)$ -# 8) 8 )4 !# 3:

) # # .#%% '

"% 4 ) "')# "

A)

)1 # )'

"1 ! )%$*

%% $ !% :1 $

0# '

"% -)# ?'4 4#  )4

/ % 0$# %* 0# :)#") '

"% 4 ) : ! 7# % 0$# %* 0#

<' : ! .#

"1 " #

8# "'%$# 

3#

& (.) $

" : 8# 

(%#" -  #

+ '

'

 " #

*  *

(

 #8 #

: "# '

- ?4@#

'#  #8 #

:  

4 ) @' =$#

!! '

 " #

( : 

!  "4$% #

 #8 #

 ) ''% !4%# # ")%%

: $ % #% '

  



-# ! !! " : ="%'#%1 #3% ' -# )' # "44# %   

* % 7'#"#% 8#    %* 0#* "44#  !" #% 3! ' -#



 9) $"' #

=4#

:# 

'3<' %1* $'3%#"

$"'  "% $"' #

#

!  "%' $"' #

"* % #% 7'8 :

$"# 8 '

 -" #

 (  :)# * $%

" "*

"%#4 !% #4$%#" #

! "* % ! "'

% =4# ! :# 

    

 

   



9) % "'

% $$# ! #" $$%% * ) )4 %1 8'*

" #8 3%  #!#" # $'$  "'% :#  ""' "* :) $" #%1  $$ :#  3= (A

(A

4.# '34## % "'

% ! #" $$%% '34# * )'8) (A *

=4#  # # ")#!* 4. $.# 8 3'

(A 3# $

% 8:# ) )#4

"#4 # 

0:* 1 )1 '34# #

#  #!#" #

(A

"=4#  #

%* ) ""$ *

$#'

:)#") B=

#8

4  ) 

=#

9)!* "'

% ! #" $$%% 8' '% %1*  #!#" #

@' 1 :#  :)  $$ :#  3= (A % #  "# : )# *

3'

:# )

!' ) <'

!!" * $'$ 

 1:#  ""'

3"4  <'

"#4 

 )  3"4 "4$% %1  88

     ;

 ) % -   "'

%* ) #8'%1  3! ' * #4$'8 #"

#" # :%% <'

):# )  %#! #4$# 4 3"4 #4$ '$

#" $$%% * :%% 4# * 4 $% . '$

: )1 $$#% # 84 ")8

C  #8 !  '34## '$  3! ' % "'

% ! #"  $$%% @" 

C# %1

"% # =4#  # # ")#!

(A * :)

@' 1:#  ""' "*  $%$3%1 '

!%* <'

 #3' #

"#4#  1 % %%

0:*  #3' #

(A

=4#  # # ")#!*

"#4#  1 % $$%% *

"#4  )'8) :  4$  ) #  !!#""1* )'8) ! "'

% '3@" # )#4

=" # "=4#  #

* )'8)

# "=4#  #

3'

% <'

4# #4%%1 #4$# 8*

5* #8# $#'%1

:# #

0:*  .

!" '4 !  ")# 8*  ) ""'#

"=4#  #

(A & (.)*  "4$% %1 '

:)%4* "4$% %1 "%#$ !!" * #!

1*

4# #4% #4$4  #8# (A $#'%1 "

:# #

 



     

 



 

 

 

  



         

 

 

    

  

     

 



 



 



  

 ! 



    

"

    



#$

 

%$

 

&  "

  

 







        

 $'

$( #$)* 

  ++ 



  

, 

        

+

   

   



+

       



  "

 + + 

+ 

-    

 + 

     

+

 

 

 





      

./ 0)

  

 "

  +  

+   

+   

  1 

+



  

 +

    

       

+  

 



 

  "

 +  







 

   

  

 , 



  

+      

+

 

 +



 

        

"

  



    

 $'

$( #$)* 

  

  

 

+ 



 + 

 !   

 

 +

 



  +     

 +      

 "

    

   

+ 

  )$  # %

$ #

")# 8 (A

"=4#  #  43#%#D*

! # $.# 8*  "= ' *  '"

!%%:# ! "E  ! "# #%3#%# 1

"#4 # E 3 )#

 "# ' "#4 :$ ""'* )' $" #%1

$

@' 1:#  (A *

$

"E "

# # #%3#%# 1 "#4 )#"%

"#4 #  "%%1 $.

9) 4.# 8 ! "* '

# "'%$ 1 $.# 8 (A *

"=4#  #

)1 #  %1 3'

=$#

! "# "#4#  1 $ #"#$ #

"#4 

 



 

(A



- $  #:% '"  =4#  #

31 @' 1 :#  (A *

)' '% #

3#

31* !  @'#

9) , @'#" #4 #8 B= (

) 3  +  4    ! /    5  674 7 +8 -   +

41 0     

9 4 :

;)/$

% 0 <0   + 7/ ; +    =   + 9) ! :

$

,* ) * @' 1:#  "# @'#

$

3'

"#4 # *

)'8)

'% 3#

$

9)!* B= (

'$$ 

! 

"#3% 1:#  ""'

<'

"#4 

 

                   

'# "'  #8 # 3# C*  #8 # !!#" ) $'

$%#" 4

'# "' #" * ) # 4 3# $'

$%#" 4

#8  ' #"%' :)#") B= ( #8

9) B= ( 3 #4 ! 

  

   



 

 +

       

   +

  

    + 

   >

   

"

 , 0 - 0  9

<0 

 +     



  + + 9

      

  ? 



 + 

 +9 <0 9  

   +

    

      9 

  + 

 +    

, 0 

 +      +  

 

 +? 



   +)# )(

      @<0 +           +  A   

    

  + "

    +  



+  , 0 

  

+    

+  "

  )% )(  

 

 



  +

 ! A7B#7#C#'



 

  



  + 

"



 +   

, 0











    

"

 

 

, 0 



 

  

 

   +





  



 



  

, 0 





 

   

 

"

+ +

  

 

 



  

 



  

- 



 

  





 

 

 

  



   

, 0 

  

 



 

   

  

  

    



  

 3       



 

       

   

  



  

 





     +



" 

+    

+

+



9 

  

  +

  

 

 

3  





  

  



     + 

 +





<7DAE  

<7D. & 

0093F)( )( 1 F A   ! )#)% 009<7D. 

  %#'

009<7D. E2

# #8  ' #"%'

) # 4* % )

%1 ! 8'#% * 3'

) #"% "

' "'# 8 "1 "$# )#"%

B= (*  #8 # !!#" $%" )## 8*

"%# )4* 4 3# ="%'#%1 .

:

)#4

-#

$''

)!

)'8)

"1 44 B= (* "' "1 "$# )#"%*

9)' # #1 #8 #8 44* )

3

3% # ) 3%1  #8  ' ""'

B= ( *

 ) 3

3% $ $$#   #%

* # )

3

3% 3# ! )

8#3% # 3'

'88 # "# # ) #  

9)'* # #1 " # 1 #8 :

44

'# "'  #8 # 3# C*  #8 # !!#" ) $'

$%#" 4

'# "' #" * -: 3# $'

$%#" 4

#8  ' #"%' :)#") B= ( ;

#8

9) B= ( ;

3 #4 ! 



   

  

+

     

     +

  

    

! +     >

   

 "

, 0 - 0  9

<0 

+     



  + + 9        

  ? 



 +

 +9 <0 9 

   +

    



 + 

 +   

, 0 

 +    

+  

 

 +? 



    +)# )(

     @<0 +           + 

  

   

 

+ "

    +   

+   , 0 

  

+    

+  "

 )% )(   



 



 +

 ! A7B#7#C#'  



 

   

  +

"



 +  

, 0













    

"

 

 

, 0 



 



 

  +





 



 



 

, 0  





 

  

 

"

+ +

 

 

 



  





  

- 



 



  





 

  



 

  



   

, 0 

   

 



 

  

   

  

    



  

 3     



 

 



 

   

  





"

    

+   

  

    " 

+    

+

+

  

9 

  

  

 

 

3  





 

<7DAE  

<7D. & 

0093F)( )(

 1 F A   ! )#)% 009<7D. 

  %#'

009<7D. E2 # #8  ' #"%'

-:* % )

%1 ! 8'#% * 3'

) #"% "

' "'# 8 "1 B= (*  #8 # !!#" $%" )## 8*

"%# # * 4 3# ="%'#%1 .

:

)#4

-#

$''

)!

)'8)

"1 44 B= (* "' "1

9)' # #1 #8 #8 44* )

3

3% # ) 3%1  #8  ' ""'

B= ( ;*

 ) 3

3% $ $$#   #%

* # )

3

3% 3# ! )

8#3% # 3'

'88 # "# # ) #  

9)'* # #1 " # 1 #8 :

44

'# "'  #8 # 3# C*  #8 # !!#" ) $'

$%#" 4

'# "' #" * )% 4 %# - @1 3# $'

$%#" 4

#8  ' #"%' :)#") B= (

#8

9) B= (

3 #4 ! 



   

  "# 

+

     



   +

  

    +    >

   

"

, 0 - 0  9

<0 

 +     



  + + 9

         ? 



 + 

 +9 <0 9  

   +

      9 

 

 + 

 +   

, 0 

 +    

+  

 

 +? 



    +)# )(

     @<0 +           + 

  

   

 

+ "

    +   

+   , 0 

  

+    

+  "

 )% )(     

 



 +

 ! A7B#7#C#'  



 

   

  +

"



 +  

, 0













    

"

 

 

, 0 



 

  

 

  +





  



 



 

, 0 





 

  

  

"

+ +  

 





  





 

- 



 



        

 

    

        

 

      

  



   

, 0  

   

 



 

   

  

  

    



  

 3     





 

      

   

  



  

 



" 

+   

 

  

 

 

3 







  



    

+ 

 +

 

<7DAE

 

<7D. & 

0093F)( )( 1 F A   ! )#)% 009<7D. 

  %#'

009<7D. E2



;

# #8  ' #"%'

)% 4 %# - @1* % )

%1 ! 8'#% * 3'

) #"% "

' "'# 8 "1 B= (6*  #8 # !!#" $%" )## 8*

"%# # * 4 3# ="%'#%1 .

:

)#4

-#

$''

)!

)'8)

"1 44 B= (6* "' "1

9)' # #1 #8 #8 44* )

3

3% # ) 3%1  #8  ' ""'

B= (

 ) 3

3% $ $$#   #%

* # )

3

3% 3# ! )

8#3% # 3'

'88 # "# # ) #  

9)'* # #1 " # 1 #8 :

44

'# "'  #8 # 3# C*  #8 # !!#" ) $'

$%#" 4

'# "' #" * @1 ?'4 3# $'

$%#" 4

#8  ' #"%' :)#") B= (

#8

9) B= (

3 #4 ! 



   

$"#%   

 +

             

    &

 +

  

    + 

   >

   

"

 , 0 - 0  9

<0 

 +     



  + + 9

       

    ?





 +

 +9 <0 9  

    + "

   

     +  

 +     

, 0 

 +    

+  

 

 +? 



    +)# )( 



+          

  +  

  

+ 

 3

 +     

   



 "

  /)% )( 

       +  

  



 , 0 

 



G  +





G  

, 0 

  

 G   + 

+ "

   

+    +     



 3  





  <7DAE

&



<7D. & 

0093F)( )( 1 F A   ! )#)% 009<7D. 

  %#'

009<7D. E2 # #8  ' #"%'

@1 ?'4* % )

%1 ! 8'#% * 3'

) #"% "

' "'# 8 "1 "  %%1 B= ( *  #8 # !!#" $%" )## 8*

"%# # * 4 3# ="%'#%1 .

:

)#4

-#

$''

)!

)'8)

"1 44 B= ( * "' "1 "  %%1

9)' # #1 #8 #8 44* )

3

3% # ) 3%1  #8  ' ""'

B= (

 ) 3

3% $ $$#   #%

* # )

3

3% 3# ! )

8#3% # 3'

'88 # "# # ) #  

9)'* # #1 " # 1 #8 :

44

   

!

9) $ 4 4 '$

31 " 4 ) : '" 

(A

(A ) $

 )* ' )#

 B= (

%  ' $1 '$

31 " 4 )

0:* 4#" %8% =4#  #

$

" 4 ) : '" 

(A

* ) ) $

"'  ) " 4 )* : :# )".

)4)8*

4 4 @'# "#3

%% @'# : "%

4 4

: "% '!!#"#

"'  )

# 1 "' %#!

9) %

4 4 @'#

 #" (A

31 " ! 

)       





         + 

    



  

% 

 

+   





  /     

9       

 

B

)'8)* "#4#  1 :$

!! :

):

# ) (A  (A '# "' )# 4.#  #!#" # * 3! % #% 7'8

0:* 1 # !" '4 

%  "

!!#""1 $

44 '$

 

% "%#$ "'%$ 1 !!"

:%%  "'% ""'

<'

"#4  (A

@' 1:# 

   

9) "%'#

:

3* ) * # "8 %1 $

#"%' *

<'

):# ) "1 44*  "4$# '

$!

<'

# % "#4#  1 %# .

* # $

44*  "3 * ! "* ) 3

$% .* '$ "<'#" "#4#  1 ")# 8 (A *

"=4#  #

9)'* ' "= 4.

!#4 "%'#

 $"' #

) 3

3% !#4%1 $ ")8 8#

 

9)# ' !# 

4# $$%* '") 3 ) $$% #4#

!

$$%%

3#%* )'$

)1  ! ):# ) .

"' 1 )'8) % #% 7'8 ! ):# ) :# "44# % : 8#

 $$ 1* #!

1* % :# )

"" :# ) %:* 3'

%1 !  =$#1 $# %#4#  #

! !#%#

$$%

" 

:

! ):# )

( # 4#"%% ' $$%#" # * #!

1* * #$

 

 

!

  "#$#"$"#     !

%&'()&     &(%&(*)+(,-./01*(,)2/(3 ()12 &(%&(**(+2*%,4'( ()12