Kulwant Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"#
!$%&%"'(
)* *
( + , * - - -
! "
# ! ! "
$ ! ! " % & '''' - - .
* / 0
( # ! "&&)*&&+ , - .
" # , " % / 0 1 "
2
#34#+2 "% & 2
"
$ & "# 1!
$ &!
( 2$
2 53 5+ &5/1
2 (
2 # "2 # 2 (
2 #
2 # "
" " /067 !"
2 2
# "
" " ( 2 2 ". 2 "
# 2
#+
# 53 5+ &5/3 ( 58 &5/8 2 # " ( 9-
" 01)-,#
" 05167-, " 01)-, ( 2
# " 2 """ 9- &5&5 ! ! " "" #2 "2 , 0/ 5:
&5&/ " % & #
# 22# " - "
" )
!" /83) -234%&&%"'& 4 5!
0! /'!5 $"2'&!0
#"/ 1!
7! % %"'!/ - ##2 # " # "
" )
!" /83) 2 # " . "
2 #
# " "
# # # 2.
2 "2#"
"2 "2
)
#
"
"#6 #2
2 2 2# "
#2
# #2 2 # " "
.
" 2 9-
" 01)-,# "#
" 05167-, ( 2
# " " 05167 -, "" #2 # ,
2 # # "2 ( " #2 "
$ ;"2 " 2
$ <
.
! ,"
- $ 2 ,
"
!=6+ #2
" > " "
"2
.
#
2 2 #2 % & 2 62
%
.
,
"# #
#"
+#
# ,
"2 .
#2 % & ):
# 2 6 # +5 !2 2 6 2 2 &#
?# 2 "# 2
# 2 2 2 2 2 2 % & ""
#
#2 2"
""
2 6
2 "
2 "
" 2
2 >
"
2 6 2 3 2 # . "
!= 60
=" # % &
.
"
2 #2 .
" "
=" 2
% & #2
"# ""
!= 60
""
2 " ( "
@ 2 A# 2,
#2
#, 2 ##
" "
." "2"
2
2" #2 # A# 2, "
.
"
" #@" ""2 #" 2" " "
#
#2 " "
#
# " "
# 2 62 ): "
" " " "
# "2 "
> # " " #"
66
# #2 @ 2
2 "
#"2
" 2 #"
# = " 2 "
"
"
,2 #"
- " "
# 2 62 2 "
8
2 #2
> 2
#
# " 2
@ #" 2
6 " "
#
2 #
""
"2" ( " @ 2A# 2, !
# $%&
'()
# # ,
" " # #@"# "
2 22 2 2 ! #,= " "2
2 ( 2 #
" #>
" " 2 "
"2 2 ""
" ,
@ " ( "
@ 2#2 "
22 " #, #
" .
22 # "
9
@ 2 A# 2 , # !
*+,
,B% 15&&5&/ "
/1 5+ &5&& A# 2, @ 2 !
"
# $%&
# = " "2
- # !
*+,
# #, "2 @ "
,="
@ " " 2 @ " " # "
"
- 22 #, "
"" #
( @ " ="
# , "
" > #= " " 2 " >
#""2 " ="
@ " ,> ( 2#@"
#, 2 "
2 " #
## # " % 8/ @ 2 " 6
!
" ! !
! ! " -234%&&%"'& 4 5!
0! /'!5 $"2'&!0
#"/ 1!
- !
( ! ! " "2 "
" 9-
" "" "2,0/ 5:
&5&/ -234%&&%"'& 4 5!
0! /'!5 $"2'&!0
#"/ /!&7"'5!'
"*
( "% & 2
62
#2 2 # # , "" 2 "
2
" 2# ""
"2" " / ( "#2
2 #
" 2 != 60
:
="#
" #
2
"
, " " " # #". & !
#, "2 2 # # # A# 2 , # " " "
% &
2 62 " " " # , 2 # "
"2 ,@ " "
9-
" 05167-,"" # " "2,@ " # % & ""
% &
# " "# 9-
#"2
"#" " #
( # "
, "
,
B ,22
D D " , "
,
!" &55)
53 5& &5&& != 63 ,
B ,22 "
# # % & # ,
B,22 ,
B,22 @ " ""
"
" " # "
, "2 @ " ( "" "
#2 2
">" "
22 #2 % & # "
"##
2 " #
2 2 " "
,7 ; .
"2# "2 !2 2 % & ? 2 2 2
2 "
@ "2
" "2#2 #
"
2
#2 # .
" ""
"2" " 2 0
% &# 22
! 2 # " % &
" " @ 2 A# 2 , - # * . # $
& # * - # $ '((/ ,+-
01 - 2 ( )' " "
" 2" #
6 ""
"2""
"'&%5!/ %"'
"# /;24!' &
- "
#
+ % & 2 62
2
+ 2 # "" " # % & #2 #,
" 2 # " 2 # " " "2" " """#"
" ( # " 2 " 2 # 2 " "
""
#CB"
2" E
22 2 " (
@".2
6 2 ""
#
" ""
"2" "## "2 2 2 # # #
"
# , 2
"2 ( 2 2 " "
"
" 2 "
.
" "
2 2 "
"2" #" #
.
" (
"
" " # #"2 2
" " 2 " "
" "
#
2 " ! " )
!" /83) "
"#22 2 "2"
- # " /0
#2" ( ="
@ " # , , > "
" ""
(
"
< 2#". /0 ,
)
2 . #@" "# . 2 (
" "# A# 2, 3+
4 5 '((' ' 6 ( #"2 , , "
"
. ""
" # # 2 " #
" "
# " 2 " 2
"
" ( A# 2,
!
"
# $%&
+ # !
*+ ,
# "" " "2" "
" - " #
@".22 2 " ""
"2" - "
% & 2 62 2
( " " " 2
% &
2 2 ( "% & #2 ""22
" 2 " 2
#2
#.
# 2 #% & 2 22# F" #
2 2 " )
!" /83)# # A# 2, @ 2 #2 2 22# #
"
"
#2
$ ;"2 " .
! 2 - "#2 ."
? " % & #@"
##
!=60
# 2
2 % &# ".
2
"" " "" ( " #
# # "2 2 #" 2 ( " 2 #"% & " % & "# ="
! "&&) , - .
#, 2 # "% & #
# A# 2 , !
"
# $% &
6 ( @ 2 " 6 # $ % ! & ' (
2
# " % & 9-
# "" # "2 % &
" # "" "
2 #
" 22 / # 2 "#2 " # " 9- ;
2 " " 2 "# 2 2 "
( 2 # "% & ""# ( 2
#
2 " #,
B,22
D D " ," ,
!" &55)
" " #
2# 2 # !
8
, ,
B,22 @ " 2"
, """ #
" "% &"#
@ " 2 2 2 " # "
, " . @ "
, ="
! " &&) , - (
2# # ( 2
# " % & "" #2
#2
""
" #2 " /06! !" "" 2 #
2
# . # " % & "
!=6& 2 ""
= 2
# # " /067 !" "
" 2 ! " 2 # "
2 #
"" 2 "" # ( 22 "
#
9
!2 #
+ (
,
% & 2
. 2 # " ,
#" "#
"
! 2" 2 " ,
2" # 22 2""
"
6"2 " " % & ): # # +5 " # " " "
( "% & @ 2 A# 2 , - # * . # $
& # * - # $
,+-
01 -
@ 2 #2 " - - # * . # $
& # * - # $
( "
" "
" 18:6!-, " 9- " 01)-,
" 05167 -, # " "" # "2 , # # " % & # # , - ,+ -
01 -
22# #
"
" 18:6! -, " 9- #"22# "" # " "" # # "2, ( > " # "
"2" # #
92 " 2 "# "
, .
2# 2 2
" 2 ( " " "2" "
,
+ ## ,> " "
% & # #% & &3 &5&&& 55
,
9 2 % & #
" =
: " 2
( " " "2 % &
# 2
-"2 "
> # # " #
, ( - 2"
"
:
.
2 "
2 # " """
)* *
- -
)
.
G*% #
G*%