High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3001/2019dismissed

Luxmi Devi v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

CWP No. 3001-2019 1

! "# $%&' ( )

+ *!%! ,

*- ". *! )

!0".

#1 2* ("

, "3/4.(

* 2* "5%* 2

64 ..6 .(

64 *- 7 / 2*, %* 8/2 34!! !

6 *- * !0".

! 9/ * .0* !8 "3* *.

/*%3/( .

" " "3! "

. "3!

"3".%

. "( * 6%* : ;;;;;;

/ "

*( *!- "(6( '

".* (6( *%".

8 6 -,

"<9: 3/

*'0

".* "!0 "- "$ ".=% !

8 6

7/ *.%".

"/ $ ".=% !

" >< 7 ""%"

. " < '* " ( -

*! 0* * ''

" < ! "

. 8-

*4 "

0!!

!! " ". !

" "* '0

" /

" 0 .?.

. / * " 0*

. "3! =% ". " "/ 0!

. "( 7,

"<9:

CWP No. 3001-2019 2 / "

*( *!-*00 .%0 *%". "

*0*

"<9: 7 ! 0%

* 8- "!

" "/ "@86 ,%0* %* ".

8-6 - "3.7"0* " 06 !*.

* "3

"6 0!

.%".

"<9: / 0 &%* !. !%!!

. ".

*- ".* * "

*0*

"3!

"<9: 4 " / !* *.* !8 "3 "6%. "30 3* 0/ A%.3'

7%6.8 !% ".!

!* 0*.% ./ "8 67#1 B) !"

# $#$" %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

# $#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

)-.-. , ! "/ "("

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! !! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0 "

) %'" ) 0'"

)

'!"

) ' ) 0

, * 1 1 ! "

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!"# %$ ! !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

) "

""" % ! "

! & " ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

" ) ( 52 !

CWP No. 3001-2019 3 "

# " $

! "/ "( " ! 2 % "

3 ! ( ! ! ' "

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! "

! +

7 " )

& # $! "

! +

' "

"/ "

2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& # $4%% ! ""

% ( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! & ) !"

#$ !"

# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :" % )

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

!! )! "

! &" !"' "( ! "/ ( % ""

, !) "! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & ( % " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( ! !" ! "

! &' '

2) ""

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! !"

!" "/ . / &0!

" 7 '

8- 0 & %* " 8 !%''

* C . " 667 "3 '

* * '* 6 - " 0* " 06 ! 6 .7"8- "!

" "/#1

CWP No. 3001-2019 4 : " 66 /!

!7/ "0* !!/ .8

" "

8% *./

""%"

.%".

" ><4 " .

<4 ! " 6 0!

. "3! !

7 66 "% 4/7 *47 / * .

"/ 8

*' "

. %".

0*( ! "! 66 /!

7/ *.%".

" ></ !8

""%"

. 0* * ''

4 0*( ! "! 7%6./ "8

* "3*

. "3!7 66"

"% "*

!4 ! 4

></

. 98: / 7*.B*@%!

. "8

8 / "

"3 !!

<9: ! 8

!-.* !-.7/ /

56 0! "3 "0*

. "3!8 / "3 ! '%!

8 %6 66 . 2

" "3 8-4

0!!

!! "/ .8

"8% '0

7%6. 8 " 6 0!

, ' 6 *6-4 '0

" / ! 8

.8% 0!!

!! "/

"4 7%6.8 " 0! "3#!"

&&#$! 3( $ 9: !

" * =% * . ! *"

.4 "@86 ,%0* %* ".

3* 66- 8!

&0* !! "0 '

"0 !

"<9: . "6%.

" " %* /

! * =% * 8 0*( . !

'%"

.7/ // !8

&06 &

CWP No. 3001-2019 5

* "3 '%"

7%6. '

'%"

! '

".7"

7%6. 8 . !/ *3 86 3

0 -'

". "

!%/ 0 *!"

"" 6 C .* .

%6 "'

5 "3 -'

/ 6 ** "3 !

" 9:4 9:4 < >< '0 * "3 '7 / '

0*( ! "! !

"D > 4 "@86 0 &%* !6 *

"6-"!

""10 -'

" ! '

!0 *!

"< ><( "@86 , / ! %* * 6 *

0 -'

" / ! 8

" .?

. %".

* !

" 9:4

=% * "3 /* - "" 8 0 6 C . * ""10 -'

'%"

! * " %"0 . .% * %!

8- ".7"

* 6 * - %* *4 "@86 , / ! %* 8!

".7"

* / ! 6 * * / 3/ '0

"/ "" 6 '

'%"

9.: / 6

. "3 0*( ! !

"< 8 !

" <9: 4 "@86 ,%0* %* ! 6 *

" * * 0 -'

! 8

8% " .

.46 8 6 - 0 - '%"

6"37 / "

!%8! !

". " .

.*'

A* -/6. "3!* ( -

*! *'* 4'0

"%".

/ 8 ".7"

*! !" .

"*6 "%".

" < ><

*. "3 .

! 8

* . " A%.3'

* / 3/

CWP No. 3001-2019 6 '0

6674 '"

-!/%6."

/ $ ". =% !

" 66

* * "

!%*- * " %* /*

A* -6 "./6. "3!4'

" "3 8-

"- /*

!7 /*

A* - /6. "3!4 / 3/ *'0

"7 66" 66748% "

%".

"< ><7%6.8 "!

: ! * *.! '.

5 "3 0!!

!! "4 "@86 ,%0* %* . 6 *

.* 7 "3 "=% * 0* ? '

'* ".%' 7%6.'

0/-!

60!!

!! "/ !8

"/ 77 / *. ( "36 "./ !"

/6.

0!!

!! "/ !8

"%".

"E ><4 ".( " ,

"" "-. ( "3* 0! "3 9: / 6 '0% "3 3 00 * . ( -

*!8

*. ". ''

4 "- "

* ' *.

!%8! !

"3 ! 8 &6%.

.7/ /'

&6%. "3

* '*.

*4 0* 1*

3 00 * .F-

*! !"

0*( ! "!!

"<9: "" "(5 . 93: / "@86 %* ! %* * 6 *

" ". /

*6 * 8

" / "3 " 7 ! %0/ 6.4 7/ / '

"! 0*

. "3 !

. "6%.

.4 %'8* 0*

"<9: "" "(5 . ( (

** .6 '! 9/: "0 D4 "@86 %* !'

0*( ! " !

"<9: !'

8 "(5 .8-

CWP No. 3001-2019 7 ! 6 ".7"

*!7/7 *.

!!% "

" %".

* !

" < >< "- !%8!

0%*/ *4 /6.

** *7 !

"" "(5 0*( ! "!!

"<9: < !0 0% * /8-

*4!/ ! "0!!

!! "

".'0* !

. "G/

"EG/

" "G/ !* "G 66 "

!%* "3G 62 *6

* 4 /! 6 ". !

* *0*

!!* " "

! ". "0!!

!! "

* . 6 ". / !

. 6 ". 7 =% * . 8- ,

*- ( .

"! .

. ". D !!% . %".

* !

" <

" E $ ". =% !

" 4 ><4 667 . 8- *. .

<* 0%86 0%*0!

6-4*.

60'

".% 6 C

! .

".''

* !

( "3 =% * ". "=% "4 ,

0!!

!! " 66.

!/ ! "

60/-!

60!!

!! " ". "=% " %* !8

. '0

'%"

/%!4 " 0*

. "3! / 0!

. "( 7,

"<9: /

*6 6 . "D><!

5 "36 0! "3 "0*

. "3!7/ / !. !0!

.( .

.EFF .

" 6 8- 0

* !

5 "3 6 0! "3 " 0*

. "3! *. "36-4 0*

"7 ! 6 .8-

*7/ /7 !.

.8- !0".

! ( .

* .

. <E 6 ' 0

* 7

." 3*%".

0!!

!! " ".!

".!

"8-* *. "3

"<>.

. < '0

'%"

CWP No. 3001-2019 8

* !" *.

.7"

* ". "=%

* ! "%"

/* C .0!!

!! " "./%3/!

.*.

"/ "3 .8-

*4/7 * " 06

. "3! .*.

"0 !!

0*( ! "!,

"<9: F

*1"

4 2* "5%* 2

64 6

. ..

6 .(

64 *-

* "3 * ,

*- !%8'

*8 "3 " 0!!

!! " ". "=% " ! ( . '

0!!

!! " ". 7

"8- * *. "3

'/ " <> .

. < ". !

7 ! / . ( *-.

%* *4/ "

".!

"*6 ". " "7 !.%6-

. 47 !'

*4/7

. %* *!%8'

!0 "% *. %!

" ! 7"

* ". "=% !!%/ 0*

!!* "

! *2 *%! -7 "%6

"30!!

!! " ".4 4!/ !"* 3/ !!

"0*

. "3!/ * ! !%8'

! "

"3 !'

. ",

"<9:

%6 66 !0!!

!! " ".!

".!.%6-

86 3

" ,

0 - '0

" !

".! . !/ *3 . 7 /

*'0

"H 0*

!. !' !!

6 E

*/ ( "30 *%!

. "3!8 / "

"30

". * *. "3 * "

"!4 7 " /

"6%.

". !!=% 6-( .8- 0* " 06 !6 ..7"8- "@86 ,%0* %* ".

" ".* 60'

% /* -9!%0* :

CWP No. 3001-2019 9

0* - *

*!6 ' "36 0! "3 "0*

. "3! *( !. !' !!

6 "( 7 667 "3*

!"!#1

:/%3/ 0

* / ! "

!/ "

6 0/-!

0!!

!! " ". "=% "4/7 *4 *'

! "

"( 7 "

*0*

@ 8- "@86 0 & %* " ".* 60'

% /* - 9,%0* : 7/ "@86 %*

3* 66- 6.

7*.0!!

!! "%!

></ !!

" "3

0/-!

60!!

!! "%!

. ",

"<9: / ,

( *"'

=% * .* 7! '

'* ".%'

5 "3 0!!

!! " 7/ / " 0*

!8-* *. "3

'/ "<>.

.<4

'%"

5 "3 0/-!

60!!

!! " 0!!

!! " !

"4 ! 8!6%

( "3 ,

" ".7"

* *

"! 0!!

!! " ".4/ ! !!

*4 ".!%/0!!

!! "

"%* !*/ !8 "."8 6 7"

* ,

, "

0!!

!! " / ! 8

" 8- * *. "3

'/ " <> .

. <4 * 0/-!

0!!

!! " ".!

".!.%6-

"8- ,

/ 06

!/ ! "0/-!

60!!

!! " ". ! /%!4 8-*

660!!

!! "/ !8

.8-/ *4 ! "6- !!

"." !7"

*! "!

6! * 6 ' "3 6 0! "3 0*

. "3!3 !

CWP No. 3001-2019 10 8:!

" !"

.4 ! '0*

/ 3/6 3/

"@86 0 &%* 7/ 6 "

*0*

7*.B0 .@%** "3 ", 1<9: 7*.B.

.@ %!

. "0*( ! , <9: !( *-

3* 66- 8!

*( '

" "3

8 /8-/6. "3

7*. B0 .@. "6%.

". " '%"

.4 86 3

0 - !%6 66 ./

7%6."!

* '%"

J/ !8

&06

'%"

!?7 !'

".7"

7%6.8 . !/ *3 86 3

! !0 !

!0".

'%"

!.%6-

".7"

*! * !%8!

"3 !

" / ! %* ! 8

" .* 7"

7 *.!

A* -

*. '%"

.- 8

" . !8%*!

! %

6 '0

'%"

!4>D4>4E<?14 '%"

!4<4E>4F?1/ !8

. !8%*!

. "

! !4 . ! " * "

.%8

'%"

!.%6-

.4/7

".7"

*!/ ./!

/%!4"

* 8%

" / !* *. D 2* "5%* 2

6 " !

"3 /

! 06

. " 7*

!( 6-"

=% * ".*

0%86 0%*0!

* % 6 C

" 6 ". *

! .

* / ". "=% " !( *-'%/ !!

0%86 0%*0!

06 "" "306 "" "3'

CWP No. 3001-2019 11

3*-06 9<"!: ".'7 .

** . "! .

/ ! 0 *3%'

* . 8- * !0".

". 7 " '06

/ / ! ! " '0*

* 8 5 "' ".7/ 6

6 "37 / * ! "3% "6 0%86 0%*0!

/* -7/ ! " 0!

8% % 6 C

" =% * .4

( "38

. ",

> ! !

6 8( . !%!! " ". " ( 7 6 7 !%''

* C . "0 E".* 60'

% /* -9!%0* :4!0 66-

*/ ( "3* *.

" "/ ".4 0/-!

60!!

!! " ". " =% " / ( "3 8

"4 86 3

" * 0 -'

".!. !/ *3 6!"! .

* "3

". "=% !( *-'%/ !!

0%86 0%*0!

47 "/

/6.

" "!

!%66-. !/ *3 !86 3

"=% 8 / "

"3 !%** "3 "!

"<9: "3!4

0* 0

" '

! . !' !!

". / "!

" ! . !' !!

. ( "3. !' !!

"7*

"4 660 ". "3

"!4 "- 6!'

/ 7*

" !. !' !!

%!=% "-

".!(

. 9 +,G : , 9

$$: ( ".

* /

*!0

5 "3?*

!? /

** 0*