← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6614/2023allowed

D v. State Of Haryana

2024-04-16Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel9 pages

       



 

 





!"# $% &#'()($*

++

 

        

  

,- + . . -

    !"#$%  

 &"##  ''''' . -/ +

0!1

 2 

(       

 %    $ ) 

*

  *  %     

 %+  " 

 %   

 )   " *!%  !

 ,%   %  

   #,  +-

 &  % 



 %   

  %

.      *    %  -/0 11 ) % .23 $ 3 %415% 1 6#%"27.8   *    % * (9 2: ./72272."

%

* %  /:;42646 91% ;% 1 ( , <%#%" 27.2"% /2/87;9146 % % 8/"

 %   46 2 </7..272/") )

 + =  

  

  

    





  !  

   "#  $% &   '

# '" ( ( )   

 &*+, -    -$ - 

.

"

" *

    

 /.$ *" 

  

 .     

     0  1  #  $  

  

   %$. *

 

- &*+    ( 

     -( 

  &*+

  )

 2        -$-    )3    ' 

 4 4 #

 



(& 2

 5 (6 7

3    )      

  

-$ - 89+1&-*-+-) (, -$$   $-$ - 

.*---

-1---1-#  $ (   --:),;<      

   % 5 ( 

       )3   =(   (   3 >>>>     

    "( (    )  (   < >>>> 



)   

3 

 

  " 

   4 

 3

  

         

 >>>>  

 

   "-  (      # (  

$    ''

    )  )  <2 

       "      

  9

 )?    )

 

(   )? -(    2

   

  2     

 9

  

 ''      

  4 3)    ( "

  2       

   #)2;



32     

 -(                    (  

    

   5 ( 

 

   3 

 5 () 

  3-     



  :



   2

   )2    -  (       2 

 ( 

3 5 (

 

  0   ) $      2  9

-(   

.-$- $      @A<# 3 B    

( (, 

 

 

    

 2   

 

   3    -   

     @  CD) ;(5 (

( 

 (     3  @  

      

        3    3

  3

   



2   

 

 

 2 -(    ( 

  2     )  



  

   ()  ( 

 3  

  2 



-(     )3

   

   (      ) 

   

           3  (       

  

 

(



 -(   

   3   

-  (       2 

   (

 

( 3-  (   

$ 

3  

2     @ 

  0 3    )3  ) 

   (   



 ( (  

 (  3  (

-(   

 ( 2

       

2 

 

     

   

-  (       

3   

- - $

2  @  5 (  

2 ( 3 3    

 

)

)-(   

  3#  

 

  

# ) 

   

      3

 



 

  #    - (           3  (  )     3    

     3

         2

   2

 2

         )

 2

 2

     (3

 2-(      2 

   ( 

3

 ( 2  )   2 (        (

-(    ( *B ) ( 

)  )3''  2

 

  (      

3-(        

  

  

)3  (         2      

 B2    )    (       2 (    

    (   

)    

)     

   

 -  (       

B 2 )



     3   0 

       )  

 

 

 *   

       

   

(   (-3  2 (( 

(     -   )   )         3  3

 

   1F1 @                   )?     0

             4( 0

 

  D &-*-+-    

)

.*

. 11 #  $  (   )3 <  - # 

    ;(CD)  4%5 (

)  )  8 &-*+ &-*-+- (   5 (-7 .-$ -    ( 

  4 4

 4  4G

  (   -<  (  ( 

         

?

-1   



)  4 4

 4  4G       ?



   

      $/-- - 4 4

 4  4G

  )   

     -$-

- G 

    





   

   (    &*+

   

) 3

( ( &*+ - 



 

     

 

   (   

    )

3

 

  -    

     

      *  ( 

 +   

   ) 

  3 ()    



# - G  

        

    *  ( 

+  -* 

     



)( )

#      (

3-*    

   

( 

(     



   

?

 

)       

( )- @  

   -        

          4 4

 4  4G ?

      -&*+ 

(  3  

(      3 $

$-     3    *  ( 

+   

6 7+9AG1&*,HA*+F 9

 ----------

3 )

-3

 

III-,  * ( III-#( -   

 

   

 

   ---- G

 



  II- %  ((       )------    +   + 

 .-# 3   

(

=

) (     ----< -1

0 

  III-, /- + 

 ( ( )  

 )3  ) 

1= C  III

 (         

    ( 

)  

  )

  ) *  2    + -7 

 (     

) (   4 4

 4  4G

    

# - E  

    

 )( )

# 

()   

    B  :  *( 3 ," -   :

  *  ( 

 ! # -   

" G # -", -/.= -*     D   

     

      

 

   (   (       - ) (

 &) 3 -

 (         

  )   1) 

@  



 3

       



  ( 

      ) 3  

   (

(     

 )3 3  )-  

)

)

 



 

3)  )3 

(5 (-*    3        



3

  

  ) 

1  3 

     3) )3 

(5 (    ( -    

 

  3 )

    3 

        (

   

    3 



   

    3 -*   3 

 

      

  ) 

1   

 )3 

(5 (

(  

 (  

(5 (

    

 

   - G 

$-$- - *     

3     





 )           

    ()  

 

 -J / >  %     

      * 

       

         

   $%%

 * > %   &   %  % %  %  %  .87-272-  1 ") %

&% - 9$%    $   $ *% %  8 9

 

  

%     * 

% /7..272/ 5    *       

  $

   %%

      *  9 ) *

 !  

1 

      

  

     %   /77.272-? $)    + K$- #    (  )  

         ( 

6 *" 1 3G )   )





   

   

   " #  $% 0 

 6  "  )

)(

   23

) ( G

  

  32

 L  "  )

)(

    G 30 =  =3=3 ( (L  "  

  

?

 - & :

   ( 

) 4   0 

 :

E  3

  ()  



  )-

**" ( 3=

   )3 

)

 ? 

) G

 

   

  K

?

 -J &     L    G  (  ) 

   (       )) 0      

   = 4

  3 "L :

3)?

   (   

   K

 ?

 J-   

          )

  ) 0  3

  



E  )

 )3 :

 

 =   - ***" :



 ( ))3G ) 



2

 *+  *  ( 

+  " )     

/ $%#    

(      

        3 )   G    

3   G

 

)2(

G 3) - 

3   

        )

 )  0  3 

  2 - *;"  :

     ? 

 )  G

  ) 0 



    

" $%# )

 



)3(        ? 

- ;" #       

(   )   )3  :

 0  



 )

) G

 

)

  3 )  ( *+ -     G  )    0 (   3



-J ; @   )  &  %   .;72272. )  $

 ) %  %    .278272.@./  %  ) 

$*%  ) %  7: $ * ,       

*   * *  )   %   &      * %    

%

  !

%    )      %   $ % @

 % *  %  % 

  * )  !

%# %  %  %.87-272- *%  "     %%         72    70

2   5

  )  * $$    %  @"  %

 

  

 1 "             

) % % % % %  : 9$ )*$"    

) 

*  * 

 

*  *   

%    > %% 13  

 )$"     %     *

 *  %% 13 

"     * *) % 

+ 6 @   

+  * 

6 @    ) $ %" % "   

6 @     *  

    *  $6 @     %   % )  *  4$6 @   



" ")   1  4$ 6 @   

$ 

 %   *   9$

  < %<  %%  %      %  

 %+   * )    

     1 9A

 4$

6 @             B 9% *% %    ) %  *

 * %% 13  

    %  *$ 



)  

 %  % "  %    *   *  $ %%   *   

  0 <%%  .7

  *$ *%   , 



  % 

3 ..  %  %  *% " 

%

 % " "   



. -

 

# .;"272- #?3 C

&   D C * D