High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1628/2019dismissed

Ramandeep Singh Gill v. Gurpinderdeep Kaur Gill

2019-03-07Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill6 pages

"#$%&%

'"(

)* "+, %%-%%)) .." / 0!1! 10) "(

)210 .. -%%

3# 453 % * 2*2 3 453 % * **55

"# 30%%3%31"6.7(8

.."%

, "!" )) . ! ( 0 ( + "! , ( ( %% )!!

( 8 . 1(+ ;* 8 !

"< => 0 ! "+ , ) 0!

!0 1(+ 1"( 10( "!"(@0(!7A7*0 31B!0*, 97?, 9: " )).

0 ( !' !! "+ ,

10( "!"(@0(!7 ;

0 !, 0 D, 4< ..",1!9"(

07 ,! 9

" ..

( "( ,

(( !' !!

0?"

0 .610 !( "% ! ) 1. ) " ! ( ) ( " , ')1+"

07 , ( !)1 ! 0 +0( "+ ,

0(1+,

)0 !7"'

.:7 +"9 0210 ..7+ 9 1&:

0!%",

9: , ..",1!9"(7 0

( " )).

0( !' !!.

! () "7 " 0. 7 +0 1"(!7, 0

"+ ? , ' "

07 ,! 9

! ( "+ " "(7 ! "

'9 07 $ % % " 9

! ()). "%,1!71"( "; <

10!*0 31B!0*, 97,("

610 !( " 0:"(

" 0 ", 1! (:)). "%, "!0 +0(!, 0 . 610 !( " ?! B " , 0! "!"

7 "9

!!1 !?

(7, "

7 ,( 0 !

( , "% ?! 0 8 ( , " )). " 0 +0( "+ ,

0 ! .0 (:) "( "+ ", "0

1! 10;"(< "( , ..",1!9"(7 ,0 1+, , ! .7 ,( .0 (: 1!

()) 0"

", ! ()0

( "+!"(%

" ()) 0"

(, !0 ).:78 00 "+, ",!) " 7,

" ! ).

!1 "+ ! B " 9

" )) .. 00 8 !

". 10"( ".:!1, 10" " 0 " !1, ""(,

!B ", 8 0: 0! "!"

%@, .

.: "+1) "* "

7 ?!! , , ! ( )0 8 !

"! ! )1. , , )). " ? , +10( "!, )!,..9 '( E !0 ,8 "+ 610 !( " , ). ?, !%F ?! ! ( , ! , )). " ! ) 0'"

*0 31B!0*, 97, 0( "0:).

, .(?

1.(9 ,). !

"(, 10*0 31B!0 *, 97 ,! , " " 0 " "( 0: ,

%?! 0! (,

;&< " , ) " 1"( 0 * " C

7 , .." ,1!9"(,(.

0.:).

( (,,

,(B 0 , .( +"9 0 210 .. "( ! ., .: "( ? , 1 , >)0 !! 0 ').

.." ,1!9"(%?! 0! (, " 0 08 . "(7 96 " 0 !0 G1 0 (7?, ," ".:9 9 "

? ,,

9 ,, )0 "!"(? , 1!1,)0

!!7 > / !""

9 9 "

(% (0 . 1078 ( 0 ')1+"

(, "7 ?, .

? "+ , )).

"( 9:( !' !! "+,

9: , ..",1!9"(7 ,!

1"( , * "

8 ( !

" ?, )).

0 " 9 (% , ! ( * " ! )1. ! , )). " !? ,0 +10( "!, )

07 !,.. 9 '( !0 ,8 "+ 610 !( " " , ). ?, !% ", 9! !

' 0 . "0

0(7 ?! 9!

,, ' "

0, .( !0 ! ( "+ ""(? ,, "

H708" 100') "7 "0 5 &"( "(!'

?!, ", '

" % % &%%9:, ..",1!9"(%, 8" >0! ' ')1+"

1.(0 (!1"( 0# E-%% , '

) "7 ,

) 0 ?! 0 ! ( "+ H7 08" 10 0') "7 "0 5 & "("(?!"

0 ! ( "+? , ", 0 .

10! *0 31B!0 *, 9% ? , ! ,8

" ('

;H< 0 ", ""(7,

G1 0 '

0' "+

!!1 " , ! !) "(B "+

8 ( %" !

","(7, , .( !0 ! ( "+9 :

"(, 0 .610 !(

, ! 10"( !0 ! ( "+ " "(% " *,B1". / 0!1! 6 !, ;

I<7 ;C< ; 8 .< 7 "49.

1"69 "( 0:" +, 10 ,! , .( , , 0 .

10 ! ?, , .(0

0( "0 .: 0 % " , !

7 , 0 ?! ! ( "+ ? , , 0 '

0 ? , " , 0 .

,1"6,1"1

6!," " 6!,"% "49.

10, .(, 10+(,0 "0:"?

1.(,8 " ( " "8 ?

* ;<

10( "!"(@0(!7% "49.

0, .(,, @ 0

, .(0 1.(.!

" ?0(!, B "+

8 ?, "! (

0 08 .. "+ ' ?, :

0( "0 .: 0

( "+! ?

.( 9 B " " 10 "610 !(

?, ,, :0 %", !

" ,"(7 , 0 ?, (: ,! 9

1+, ! 0( "0 .: 0 ! ( "+ ? , , 0 '

0 " "(%8 "9

"( 7, 0 ?! 0 ! ( "+ ? , , " 3 +7 ' 0"., '

"%!!1,7, ! 10 ,! "

0 . 610 !( " 0: , " ) " ! ) * " ;<

10( "!"(@0(!7---F .)) 0 "+

.."!19' ! , , ')1+"

0 )!!

( 0 . 10 ! ) ".: ..

" , ,

,( B " , 0 "( ? , 1 , >)0 !! ').

..",1!9"(% 5 .

0 !19' ! , ' , 8 0'

"! '( 9: , )0 ! 9

0 . 107 !

!9. !, ( , ,

;C<

7,( (? ,'. ( " " " "!, "+ , .( ' ,

10! *0 31B,!0 *, 97 ?!"

"1'9 "1) )0

(0 . 10 ), 0)).

0( !' !!.

9:, ..",1!9"(1"(

% @ "(":'

0 ", 0+1'

"!0 !

(9: .

.."% * " ;<

7 ?, , ! 0 8"

(61(

)0 ")0

( "+!70 (!!1"( 0# E% ;< )). " !? ,0 +10( "!, )

) 0!

07 !,.. 9 '( !0 10 ,8 "+ " ", ). ?, ' "

!% ;<"(;&<>> >> >>F ,1!7 1. )

" !

! ( " ""

? ,,

! ()0 8 !

"!7 ?

1.(!"(

!9. !, (,, ' "

07?, ,!9

"(' (.:0 ! ( "+ " "( ! "

'9 07 $ % % )0 0

..",1!9"(% , 0( "0: ).

' "

0 !D"(4"("

*0 31B!0*, 9% 10*0 31B!0*, 97? ..,8 610 !( " 0 ""(0:, )0 ")0

( "+!% ' 0"9

0"+.

..% ! ) !"( B " 9: ,

0 . 107, ..",1!9"(7,!.0 (:1!

(, !)0

10! "0 7?, " ", )). "!

B "+

' "

07 !) "( "+%, ! (8 0!

",!"

"0 0 ..",1!9"(% ,1!7 " 10 ) "

"7 61( ,! 9

" 1!

( 0 +,!

.." ,1!9"( . ' "+ ,

0 , .(% "

7 , )) ..",1!9"(7,!)) 0 (9

10! "0 "(7"(, !(

"( "+, 1! (:)0

( "+! (, "!"

7 , ' "! "

, "+ ( . (1)

",, ..",1!9"(?

1.(9 . 9 0: + , !0 +,!9

! ( 10"(% "8 ?

9 7?

"(":'

0 ", ")) .%, !7 0( "+.:7( !' !!

!"# "

!$$# %

$%&% (! @, 0*) B "+J

(# !J @,

09.

# !J