High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/937/2017dismissed

Nirmal Singh v. State Of Haryana

2019-04-11Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan17 pages

# $%

"#$% &'()*"+,-./* #0.123#"$# &'()*"+,-./*1&**,33.&4#& & ' ( ) * +

' , -

"* *

' , -

"*/ 0 *

. "

' 1 * *

2# $%

' * ) * !

#0.123#"$#5

!"#$$ % "& '%% '$( '&!

! * ! " ! * # $% ! * 4 + %& !"'%% '$'& !""

'!""

!" '"

& & '"

) * & !

& (+ $ '&!

"!'$

, !-

./0$ 1 &"& ! 0& '

'!"2 !'!

$ & !*3'

!''

'&'"-'

&*!, !' 44 *(+ '%% $$'!"&'$,!

*, '''!

'$'% +# & 0'&

#"'!

"& &" !0 % !'($ !

&, 0"!45* *

& '

#", 0"! 467 +# & 0!10"

!" !0 '

, 0"!4567 !

& & & %&! !"&'% & "& + '& '!

"%'+'! *9'!

! '

$"%'+ !" ! *" &" & !

& %$ %&! !"&'% & " ! '+ , 0"! 67 !

& & & %&! !"&'% & /!" , 0"! 67 !

& $ %&! !"'!

"%'+'! *9 '!

! '

$"%'+ !"! *" &" & !

& %$ %&! !"&'% & "#!" 0' " %& 0 "! (' ! " "'" !" '"

: ./ 70%$'!'!";' 1"'" '"#0$ & !

+# & '1!

&'0& $'!

&0 $"1'"! < & ('!

! '0& $'!

!"#%'&"'( "=+ '&('0>'!

& '!!

='0& $'!

#''$$ (+"! &'$,!

1$$'

$'( "59:

!"('0>'!

!"& '& '01$ "#'% !

( "# !" %'&" &'$,!

"& ""'> % !" $'!

*# 1 &* 0 $ !"

"" & "'!0 '

(+ &'!

" &1$$'

& &'$,!

'$ "(&!

& ('!

, ''#"'!

#''>!

&" " "" % ! $1 & "' &'$,!

, ''#'!"

'1!

'!+$1 '!

' 0"!#" &'!

&0$ & !' #'!& $'"!

#"" & &$*!' $+*?

@'"' ! : *#"'!!" !"""'> % !" $'!

*&'$,!

'$!

#"0%'!!*!' $+* % '!

, '' ('!

" 0%$'!'!" !" & & '"

7 *# ! #'$+!

!'0"!" & '!

&0$ & !# & $ %!

!'!" &0"*(+0$(!

1 &" #'$$ , ' ''!

0%'!!'(& %"$+%0> & % , #' 1 !( '"!

< &0$" # & "&! &'$,!

%&!>$ > & ! ! &'!

, ' '$"& #"" '"0"0>(+'+!

"'" #$$" '0'$ !" & &( 0!

& $ !'$ $'!

% '

"$ & , &' '$'& 6!'("'!" '" & !" %" ! &"'" !"*./ 7* &'$A6*./ 7*#'& " & , '

( +#' !"& %"&" /'!'"! 6!1 " '"!#'0%$ "

0'$$'!#'% "

%'" &0%$ "!

'$$" 0 '$&'$" %& 0 "! /'!

( &#"! ! %%&" " 0' "'" !"" '00 # & '$& 0&

&, 0"!

& 7 + /'!

" !#"! !" & !0 +# & 0!10"

!" !0 *'!"0 & !'(1 < !0 *" %& !"'%% '$ @ '&!

0 ! $ '%% '&!

! ( '$ " '%% $$'!" 1 !"$+'&

"'"" %& 0 "!''$ "%&1 "0' @ '&!

0 ! $'%% '&!

&" ,"'" 1 !"$+'&

"'"" %& 0 "!' %&1 "0' ( +!

& '!'($ ("'!

%%&"

!"'!

& &" $ '&!

"&'$ &"

2 '1 '& $ '&!

0 ! $&" %'&" '!

! "&

!"'!

& 0& 1 &+0'& $$+

&6'-" *78 &

&6 0 - * *: 2 * '3; < *= * *78 &1

&6> : ,*

@* + :#, + '3 ) :#, ' 0*& *

< + ) * # * 3 % ! ) *#

:#, *78 &* :+ 3-3!< :#, * 3+ ;:+ :#, - 3 - * 238* 3 2-**3- 3 * A 3 B**78 &;

: 28 * +3

A B

@ % ! + 3>2

< + : 28 *

< +3! +392! % + ! ! + < +!

&6?

@*< + "= + &):*0

+3 +

>>C 3 "

!*78 &) : 28 *

@ % +3 + >>C3 " +!3

&69# )*#'0

@* :#,

A78 &/B3 < *78 &/D 0 * # - ,

3 "

- 78 &'

% * *78 &'D < ,*78 &*+ + 3-3!<

% * 078 &E * +3*78 &ED

! 78 &

&6 , 3! * &F !8 < *'/* & *78 &E* " + % ' " * *78 &E* " + @

&6 , '

* # * ; ' *&):'7*0 * 3! *78 &< * 3 +

+ 3!8 *

D@ * 3 * ! 3 *

!3- 3 *

D@3- *3- * * !

3 2 *78 &G

* + 4 3 % "+ 2 % 33

: 3+ "! +3 @+- 3+ "! +!

&6@

@3 @

* < *+ + 3- * " +! -

% +

3 < + +-

% - 3A78 'EDB*3 A78 'ED B*A78 'ED@B* 38A78 'ED B*!*78 &;

+ 3!

&3& 28 - >

"3 <

@* 2

- + < + + ! 3 !- +

*# "* 0* -

3! % !+ %

+ % ' < % - !

2* 23!+

&6> :#,

@* < +

0 *# 3 +

0 *#

* &* - *78 &D* * *78 & < 3-

% *

*78 &/*3 #'0*# * " < : 28 * " 4 < 5

% ; /3!* ! *' 3 * 78 &;;

*- + 8 32 A3 B*8 32 A34

8! 3- B 8 32@A3 B 9

% - 3! " +

@* ) 0 , ) *=

@> '

@+ 9 &'9 @&' - H, 03*25* < *# :

+* " - 3 !* - 3 * * + # + 3 +

6 , ) * ) 0 *3 !*+

)

@ &'

:+ + +

@ ?

: 28 * +

- ++ I + I

@* + 3 E !* + I3! " + 9 @& '

@ 9 @ & '

* - - * 3- & '

: 28 * " + ! )!- 03*= +* + 3 D@!* ! "+ 0 : &3 *# 3 + " + 3 ;3!* + - +- ! , ) * -

@ 78 * -

6@&0 +/3 # - +

@* !+

-' 2 >

! % !+ -, : & '

& '

+ ! % !+ &*= *

+ !3+ & '

& '

: 28 * + 3!

! % 3+ ,+ # 3 2@ - 6 -, +3 ! # E @

@*;:+ (- @5?:&0 % !?25 &*=

@* !+ 3 & '

% ! & '

: + 3!

: 28 * !+ !

! & '

& '

6>/

+782 # E

@* + ! 3!

-' +

! % ! & '

& '

6? /

@* * + % 3+

< E !* ++-

+ + 3 * + *" <

% !+ < +3

+ * * " %--+ ++- 2 > < + J

: 28 * %

65 '

) * *& - +

+ 3 + !

& ++

+ @

69,+ * 7G 6@D 78 6@DH 78 6@D

7 + 3!

6 ( ) + 'E#*= 8

:+ D 3 " B+ !E AE B+ ( A B + " * ! 4 *

3 +

6 >

+8 3!

8 * 3 @C 3! 3A " B

) *+ + ! #*= *+ &):*

+- &):*0 * @

> @

% "* 3 0%$'!'!";' 1!0 0 ' '

$ $'!

"'00

&'$,!

'( "59:!"('0>&" '" 00 && !0 01$ "#'% !

( "# !" %'&" 00 &'$,!

"& ""'> % !" $'!

< 0 $ !" !'"" %" 00 , ' '#''$'>!

&"" "" % ! $1 & "'00

&'$,!

< #'!"'1!

'!+$1 '!

' 0"!#"'$+ ! : *#"'!!" !"!""'> % !" $'! *'00

&'$,!

'$!

#"'00 % '!

, '' !" & " " 0%$'!'!"'" 7 *(+0$(!

" #'$$ ""'"" * #' $+!

!'0"!" & < &0$ & !# & '$$ %!

!'!" &0" 00 , '''!

0'00 0'

" &'!

'1 ( '"!

00 &'$,!

%&!>$ > & ! ! &'!

& ('!

, ''$"& #"" '"0"0> 00 % '

"$ & "'" !"./ 7" 0 ' #'& 0&

&6> : ,

@* + :#, + '3 !

E * ! ) *#

:#, A78 &B "< A B % + 3-3!

&6> :#,

@* < 0 *# 3 +

0 *#

* &* - *78 &D* * < + % + 3-3!

*78 &/*3 #'0*# * + A78 &B< @@

&69# )*#'0*

A78 &/B*3! :#, 3 < * *78 &/D - ,0

3 "* A78 &B< :+ 3-3!< * +3*78 &ED @

&6 "3 <

@ - + < + +! 3 ! 8 + *# "

A78 &B< * + +3! :#, * + 3!

+ @>

2 * + 4 3 % "+ 2 % 33 3+ "! + 3 @+- 3+ "! +! @?

&6? *< + &):* 0

@ : 2 8 * !

@ % +3 + >>C3 "

&6 , 3! * &F * !8 < *'/A78 &B % + 3! ' * *78 &E* " +

) % 3- 3!

% ! "'> !" %$ ''$("'>!

%%&"&" "'" !"2"25 2 '1 '$& '

+ 0 " & !0 1 !0 00& !

" 6 *

@ + 3* + I3! " + 9 @& '

@ 6 , )

) 0 * +

@ &'

+* 28 * + 6

+ - * +-

! , ) * -

@ 8 *

- : 28 * " * +* 4 ,$'&$+*'00 &'$,!

''$"'> !" %$ ''$( (+"'"!

"'" #'!"%& !"'"" %$'0 00 && !0 % &6@ &0 + *

@* !+ -, : & '

& '

:+ 3!

+* 28 *

!+ % + ! & '

% 3 3! + @& '

+ + 3!

4 %$ ''$(' ($

# '%! 6!0' " '00

'$"%&1 " %$ ''$(*%& !0 '"" %"0'!!"( & $ "

6!& &"%&1 %$ ''$(*" &@& %<!B($ " , %& &"

,) *'1 $ "'"

!0 " %& 0 "! ! 0'& !

" ( & !*"!0 ( !"!

" '00 *#'

%"" %$ ''$(*"%&1 "#"'($ " 0 &"'!"+ '" /0$

" %($"+%& !0 '"" %$'0 00 && !0 &@& %'1 $ ' !

&8 C 2 "( '&!!

"'"'!'$(!"'! /0 %"!

% 0'$& ! &'$ !1'

!" 6!

'!7 !'$ & '!+" &$'# 6"!$+'& $ 1 !0 & 0 ! !

5 , 0"! " .1 !0 0" "'" '0" #0 '& !0!" !"#"" '0"! '& & $ 1'!" 6$$ "&'"!

' 1 ! !

&" %&1!#&"& %&

!" 0!" /"8 D E "!# " &0""

'0& '"'$0 ""'

!'0 &"'! '" F" '0""'"!"'" '" *#''"@'& & $ 1'!" D @'"!#& '$( '!D $ # & D'!

"'"#&

&0!1 ! !0 # !'!'00 "'> & 0 & "'

!0 $! "'"# !" 00 && !0 ">%$'0 #' '&'#'+&" %$'0 00 && !0 "'"" /"& $+ %&('($ "'" # $ '1 %'&"0%'"

!" 0& 6" '('0$'#"'"!'0&!'$0' *!#0" '00 '$$

"'1 !$0"

%+0'$! &+"'!" &% &!* " ( & !!" %& 0 "!"%&1 "'"" '00

#'%& !"'"" 0 ! '!

'%'&"0%'"

!" 0& ( & !# $ !"( $ !

(+" & '0""'"" '00 ''

" !0 '$( %$ '" '00 ! 00' !

( 0! & !$+# !" ( & !'( ! 0'&

(+" %& 0 "!'"'0"&$+

"!0 " %& 0 "! ! 0'& !

" ( & !

"!0 ( !"!" '00 *#'

%"" %$ ''$(* "%&1 "#"'($ " 0 &"'!"+'" /0$

" %($"+%& !0 '"" %$'0 00 && !0 2 !

" %& !0 " '00 '"" 0 ! 00 && !0 ' ( ! "'($ '"'0"&$+(+" %& 0 "!"&

& $'($ 1 !0 * !&'$$+ " 0 &" # $ ( $# " ( $ 1 '!+ 0 !" & 1 !0 " " 0" "'" #' $ # & # ! " 00 && !0 '%% !

" " 1 !0 '

(+" '00 0'E '$"+'!

0'"'!

'& "'"" 0 &"'+ !" &"'! & '!'($

(" & '& !

%& !0 '" " 0 ! # ! " 00 && !0 ">%$'0 *" '00 # $ *! ("*( !""$ "" ( ! ""'"& '!'($ (" A&"'"

% &% *"# $ ( ' !

%&%"!"( $' #!

: "'"*! 00&0 "'!0 *" ( & !!" '00 &'" & '1+ 6" $$#* " & & * "'" "&0" %& & E & & "'($!

" %$ ''$( &"' ( &1 ! '&$ &00'!1

'"7'!

+1 ,"'" ; 7 5F ,"'" ''&'"&' 1 '&! &' G'!

'&'7%$ H

"'" !" 6? / *

@* ++- + + 3 * + *" < ! 4 3 : ++! : 28 * % /

! +8 3!6

* 3 @C

3! 3 " B %

3 +*+ +3 >* 3 * * + 3! " # $%

3 +

# $% * '

"$ ;''!'!

'00 &'$,!

%&!>$ > & ! !

&'!

, ''$"& #"" '"0"0>*#0& $"

! & '" "'" !" ./ 7 & 0&

(+ : # , A78 &B3!&69# )*#' 0*

"'" !"./ 7;''!!0 0 '

$+ 0&&(&'"

(+ 0'$ 1 !0 %& 0 "!'%&1 " 0' '

'!"" '%% $$'!"( +!

& '!'($ (" & !00'!& "!" & & #"" # $$& '!

!"'!

& && 0&

(+" $ '&!

"&'$ &" 00& !

$+*" '%% '$'& A" B #

A # B # - D =D 3 =D