High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1379/1987dismissed

(O&M) Bharpur Singh Etc v. Mukhtiar Singh Etc.

2024-03-11Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj26 pages

!"#$ "%&'&#()*+*+,

)- .

* / *

* 1111

! " # $%&'($%()' # $%))*$%()' ! +"

, - " # $%))*$%()' # $%&'($%()' .... / *

2 * .

! /!

#" , 0 ! ," 0 "

"0 , 0

1!, 2# 0 # #0 0 ,3 # 0 3 * 3 .

* 2 $ ### %(45%()% # 1

# %6& ! , %7' 8 %*

! !

# ,9, ! , ! 3 # #

! ,%7' %* ! , !

# ,

# 3! ! 54%5%(')%6&

! 0! ," !,

," #!# 8!

## , ! ,2 #

0 #

,$ # " 0 ! # ,

474:%('( ;

, # 0 !

0, 3! " 0 #%6& #

! 1

# #!

# %6& #

! "

# 0 ! , !8!< =%))* # %()'" !, 9 > # " !

# ! , 3 ## # /!

! "0! 3!

#!# 3 #%6& # ; #!

# ! ,

# ! , 3! # 54%5%(') #!#

," ! , 0 ## 54$&4 ; 0 # " # !

0 ,"# #

," 574&%('* ! 0# ! !

,3! %'4'%((* #!#

=%5

# #! ,>? , #

# " ! !, 0

#!# ##

," " # 0 !!

/! # , , ! #!

3-7 5'4&%()4 ;

, # "! 3!

#! # 0 0

# 0 , , # $# , ! 3!

# # #!#

,0 ! ,

? 0

# , # " #

! # % @ ! ,3!

# #!#

,A? 5 @

, ! #!

474:%('(A? & @ 1

# A? 7 @

0 # A ?- : @ #

A ?- *

# 2 3

@$% ,B@$58!

,B@$&= , @$7

, < # > ! # 54%5%(') 3%B 474(%('( 35B 1 0 3& # #! , $

!0 2 0! " $# 3

-@$% ,, ,B -@$5 ! ,B -@$& 8+ C <-!

3 > -@$7 ! , ! 5&4:%(4( 3! 0 ! , 3-%B # !

3 8+C 3-5B #

+ ;

3-& 3-7B

! &'5# ; !

"%(5: 3-: # 1!, + !

=4*#%()4 3-* 3-'

# !0 " +! #!0C!,",! !

# 54%5%(') 3%

#! # " !## 0! # ! 0 # ; 0 +! $ " ! # #! ,"

## ,"

,$ #

0 # =%5 # $ ## =& !

# ##

! , =3 0! # ! !

" # !03! 0! #!# ," <! ,>

, 0# 0##

1!, 5445%()4

+ !

! 4'4%%()4 0 ," 8! 2 , ! , !,

0 #

# #! ,#

#!# 8!"2 , , " 1!, 5445%()4 , ## 0

; 0 !0C!," ,! # 3%

0! 0= !0 0 , # !0 ;

, ## " ! 0 0

0 C!," ,

= !0 = !

0 0!, ! !3!

# #

0 #

, 3 6-!

3 "

, ! #! , # 3% !

! 5&4:%(4( < !

" !>

, ! 0 !

, 0 #

# 3! ; #

, , ,3 0#!

# # ; # 3!

# 5&4:%(4(" ,#! &4 !" # 3! %(') #! #

," 3! !0(( #, # !

+ 3-:

! &'5# ; !

"%(5:# 0 $# 0 #! ,2 # 0 $ ## !

3% 5&%5%(') #! 0 !!

,, # " # 0# -

C!," ,!"

0 -

C!," ,!" 1!, 4:45%()'; 0 -

C!,",! ! # #

!##

! 3!

# 3% !

2 # , <@%> #! 0 ! # $ #

# # 0 " ,! # ,

!?7% !5'# ++# ,

# # # 3! 5)4(%()5

#!#

," # /! ! 3 *3.

2 # # - ;1! ## ! ,0 $#

," 2

# , 0 # # , #!

# ; 0 /!

," ! , !

! 0 ,, , ! , 2 $ ##!

#,, ,< #! ,> !8!

##! ,<!, # ! ,>" $ ## ! ,

!, ; ! , 0## &4$74 !" !0 + -! %4'

%4)# ;

" %)'5 2 $# =%"

0 # #! ,"

! #!! !

# !, 0 # ,! # #

# $ !, # ! , 0 # , # !

+ ! &'5 # ; !

" %(5: 0 3! #! $ ##! , 2 #

, < $ =%&'( # %()'> # #! , /!

! " " ! , 0

## &4$74 0 + -; ! ,0

, !

# #!#

, # #

#, ! #! !

# ! #! 0 0 # ! , # " #

# % @ !

0 ## ' " # "

## A? 5 ;#

! =%

" 0 # #! ,A? &

# 2 # 3-% 5)4(%()5" !0 "

! ,0 , ! #

2 +! # !0 C!," ,!

# , , , ,, #" 0# -

C!,",!0 ,+ =%*% %5%4%()7 2 0 +! 2 ,! 0

! #" ,

" ! %(*:

# 2# ,

/! # 5)4(%()5 ## #

, 3 6#

0 0 , 3 !

! #!# #

2 !

0 +! " ## ## ,

, # # 3! #!<

=%&'( # %()'> ! ,

" ,! # ! , 0 , + -"

=%))*#%()' +! # =%&'(#%()'

,,!

< > ;

! , 3! # #! #

%(') # < 3% =%&'( # %()'>

0 3! " 0 ! , 0 # , 0 # # &4$74

# 3! 54%5%(')2 , ! , # 3! #!0 # "

, <

> ;

#! # , " # # # 3! 5)4(%()5"

0# +! "0! , , ! ! ,+!

5%45%()*

0 ,

" !?7% !5'++ 0 0 # ,

# 5)4(%()53! #!#

," # #! # # 54%5%(') 2!

! $ # 0

# #!

# <

> ;

#! ,!

1!, #

#$ %&% %'

)

* D0! +! # 3

# # # # 0 , " ! E 3! 3! # # ,

! 0 0

# !

3! 2 ,! 3!

# # !

! 0 0 ! !" # 54%5%(')" , # 0 3! 0

#! #

" # #! # $ < > #! !0

0 3! # ):# ;

" %)'5

&& # 2 ,

" %(4);

=%&'( #%()'

2 !

0 0! , 0

? "! #! # ,, $ ## =%))*#%()' ,! ): # ; " %)'5

# !

3! !

; " "#! !

0! 0 !

" !! ! 3!

# !

$ # "

!, 0

,#!

! !

! "

0! , !

# ! #! # ! !

! 0 ! # =%))* # %()' !$ < > ;

! ! , 3! 5&4:%(4(" #

, ! # ! ,"

## 3 # 5)4(%()5" 2,#! &4

#5&4:%(4( !" # 5)4(%()5 3! " 3! 0! %4& # , ;

0 !

!0 , ! #! , ! , <

> ;

!, <

, $ 9 # ,>

# 0 ! 3! " "

0 !

! ! %(*:" 0# ! # 3! # !

! , F! "

3 ! !

# 0 0 ,6

, <

> ;

#! !, 0 # 5)4(%()5 0 # %:4%%('(" %44%%('(" 4545%('( %44&%('( 0 #!#! ," "!

! #0 0! < > ;

, , ##

! ,

B $ ##! #! ,2!

# 3!

# # #! #!

00 , ! # 2 !

! 3 0,! # 3!

# # #!# , # #!#

," , 0

" ! 0

" /!

0 # # <> ;

#! #

#5: #, 0# +! ! %(*: #

" !0

3 #,;

# " ! # # "

%(*:" # ! 0 ,

03! %('*"%(') # %()5 < > ;

#! ,! "! , 3

3 6

, 3 " " <@$)>"

74 #3 F

3 2 ! 0 " "

0 , # 3 0!, 0 $# < =%&'( #

%()'>"

,! ,6 #

,#! ,#,;

# 3 !0 ! 00

! , #

0 " 3

/! , ! /!

< > !0

> #! ,!

# # 54%5%(') < 3%>

" !

3! #!0 ;

, ?## ## #

#= "+! " ,

! !

" # !

0! ,

0 0 +! # # # 5&4(%()5

" $# # ! # 2" # " 00!, 3

, # 0 0 <

> ;

,!0 ! ,0## $ !, # $ # < %&'(#%()'>

# 5)4(%()5" " # 0 # 0# +! " !

0 , ! 0

#! ,!

0 $# < =%&'(#%()'>

! , #! , !0

, <# #

," ! , 2 ,B !

0 # 8!>

# 0 3!

#! 0 ! , 574&%('* 3! 0 #!#

! ,

," , # # "4'4'%('* , # !

, # " " 3-7< =%&'($%()'> # " # 0 ," 8! 2 , , ! !,

# "

, < # ,> ; " < ," 8! 2 ,>

0 # 0 #

, # 0

, 0

, ## ;

#! ,! # ,3! 4'4'%('*" 0

# #

0 3! 0!

,574&%('*"

# ,

, 0 ! #

;# # 0 , 3! #!# ," ! !0 !, 0 0

, # !

0 3! "

, 0 #

2#! #

# # ,

0 , !, 0 0

" 0

! %()4" ,

! # 3! #!# , , # 03! #!#

! ,

," !0 /!

# # 0# # ! , ! 3! 54%5%(') # " #! # # 5445%()5" " 3! 0# ,

B+! = 6+ !

!" # 0

0 0 +! 0 3! 2

0 # < $ =%&'( # %()'>

!0 /! #

!5)4(%()5< 3-% =%))*$ %()'># 0 # !, 0 # 3!

# # 3! 0# !0 ;

, ?## " "

# 0 3! 0 , # 0

,;# # 3! 0 ##

0 # "

!0 /! !

6 0 # #! # < $ ="%&'(#%()'>!, 0# ;

,! !, !

0 3!

, !

# #!# %('*B # #!#

%(')B# # 5)4(%()5" 9 , + $ 4(4)%()% 3

" "#

! , # 0# +!

2 !

# $#

3! <! ,>0# +!

! # !3!

# !

# , 0"

# !

! "

# =%&'(#%()' 0!## !

, 0! # #

!## 2 !

0 !##

,0 $ =%))*#%()'" # 3

#!#! ,

0! 0

! 3!

# !

< # > ; ! # , !, !

0 # # 0

! ):# ;

" %)'5

&& # ,

" %(4) #! #! 3!

# !

0!, 0#+! " " !

0! 0

0 ! , # 2 # !

!! , !

# 0 !

# 0 ! 0 ! # $ %))*#%()'

# !

$ # 5)4(%()5=

# 3

0#!

0 $ =%&'(#%()'

0 1!, # D0! +! #

#$ %&% %'

%&+

, !,

1!,

! " "

1!,

# 0

0! 0

##! !

!, !

3 0# +! " " ##

!3!

01 0 $ %))*# %()' 0 6# , 00 +! 0

, 01

, # # 2 3!

# # 54%5%(')

! 0# !0 ;

, ?## "

# !

6 ##

! ! ):# ; "%)'5 !

! #!# /!

" !0 !

3! 5)4(%()5" " # !

< # > 5)4(%()5

" "

# ! !

;

# $ ##"

=%))*#%()' , ! !

! "

!,3 0 0

, < $ ## =%&'( # %()'>

# 0

0 # " " " #

0 0

" 0!3 0# +! " !

0 0 $ ## =%&'(#%()' 0 0

F! "!

# # !

! #

# 0 !

;

" 3! !0 0#%4& #3!

# !

! ," 0! ! # !

3! , #

B0!" #

# ;

0 0 #

%&'(#%()'

! 0, , ## !

!0 ,

, 0

# # 3! 0! #!# ,574&%('*" , # 3! 474:%('( #! #

" # , 3! /!

54%5%(') 0 ! #!#

," #

, # # 3! #! #

# F! " !

# 3! %()%

# , 9 ,+ # 0 # 5)4(%()5 ;

# # #!#

," # 0 3! #! # , # #

%('*

0 3!

, #

03! #!# ,"

=%&'(#%()'

! , # # 3!

# " , # # 3! #!# ," #!#

," " "

# ,# # 54%5%(') #!#

0# !

3! 0# + !

!, 0 0 !

3! 5)4(%()5 2 # 3!

# !

0,!

, ! 3!

# # , 03 ,#! , !

# 3 0 $ =%))* # %()' 0

, ! ## 3 5&4:%(4( # 3! 5)4(%()5 0 ##

, ; # # , 0 $ =%&'( # %()'

!! 0

0 0

; #! #

, # $ =%&'( # %()' 0 !

5)4(%()5" " !

0 ,

!, 0 ! 0 =%))* # %()'" # " #

0 ; 0" !

0 # "! , =%&'(#%()'<

=%))* # %()'> ;

0 , 0

# 0 ! ;

, #!

! , 0

! ! 0

F! " # 6

,0## $%&'($%()' "

# ! , ; !

# ! , < $%))*$%()'>!, 0 2 !

0 +!

- 3-G6 4547%()7" " %54(%()7 2 ! , < $%))*$%()(> ! , 0 3$%B 1!, 5)%4%()5< 3 $5 3$& >

!, =%&'(#%()'

,! # =:5#%()%# 0! 3

! 0

#3!

# 54%5%(() !

# 4%4&%()4 3$*

= %5 # 5'4)%('( ! , !0 " #! # ! + #

%7&*:6$ ,

#! 0

, ! , 0

" !,

# ,

#! ,

" " # 1! # 0 ! ,"

#3 !

# "

# !

, 5)%%%(')2 C 0 ! #

0 0 # ,

#! , 2

#! 3-% 5)4(%()5"

, # ! !0 %4& #, 5)4(%()5"

, !

, ! ! #

3-% 0 , F! "

#-@$%"8!

,-@$5"

=%))*#%()'

## !

%(*: 0# #

0! %5 #, !"

" !# '

," ' # ,

0 0

! 2

, 0

0 , , !

0! !

# 3! # # /!

2 !

,03! ! !

# ; " 0 , 6

# !

!3!

+ 0

! #!#

=%))*#%()' 1!, 5445%()4< 3-: -* =%&'(#%()'>"0 !# 1!, "! ,0 0 #, # !0 /! # 3! 5)4(%()5 F #, , "; +! #

! , , !

$%))*$%()' F #, , " =%&'( # %()'

=%))*#%()'

2 # =%))* # %()'

6 0

! , %7' 8 %*

! !

# , 9, " !

" , 0## ' # 3!

< >" #" < >

# ,- 0 , #

0 # # / *

2+,

$!-$