← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1405/1987dismissed

Sarwan Singh v. Jagir Singh

2016-09-20Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

 

     



  !

"#$$%&'&()$*#$+,$-.  #/0.1   "-2"(&(3/ '&(%$4$%$"'$4!#/-53/6 ' **$77"(#'

8$-'5'

"3&-&(3/#/$-'

 $'*(4$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&-()./'

-$'$(#) - "9"904:%"#$0 -#/$"**$77"(# -5;/:&-&(3/&2"("04:%"#$0 --$'*(4$(# - <&(37"04:%"#$0 --$'*(4$(#'#1 =====  +*,&-(

**$77"(#>*7"&(#&&'"33-&$:$4#/$9543+$(#"(44$%-$$ -$(4$-$4,?#/$62$-**$77"#$5-#02/$-$,?#/$9543+$(#"(44$%-$$ #/$#-&"75-#4$%-$$&(3#/$'5&#'$$;&(3'*$%&&%*$--+"(%$#/$ "3-$$+$(#'#'$774"#$4.. "(4.

 @ ."(4@ A!0/"'

,$$('$#>"'&4$ - "9"90  7$"-($4  %5('$7  -  #/$  "**$77"(#>*7"&(#& '5,+&#'#/"#(.. 0"-&(4$-&(3//"4$(#$-$4&(#"("3-$$+$(## '$772&#/#/$"**$77"(#>*7"&(#&&(-$'*$%#7"(4+$"'5-&(3,&3/"' &'2"/$##"7'"7$%('&4$-"#&(2"'.0B>"3"&('##/$*"?+$(# $"-($'#+($? 0B>"-&(4$-&(3/4&$4"#$-(&($+(#/'#/$ $@$%5#&(#/$"3-$$+$(##'$77"(4#/$*-*$-#?4$:7:$45*("3&- &(3/&(*5-'5"(%$##/$C&774"#$4.  @A!"3&-&(3/

0 "%;(27$43$4#/$*-$:&5'"3-$$+$(##'$77,?*5##&(3$(4-'$+$(#(#/$ "3-$$+$(##'$774"#$4.

"(4"7'-$%$&:$4"'5+0B>/$ #"-3$#4"#$-$@$%5#&("(4-$3&'#-"#&(#/$'"7$4$$42"'&@$4"' 1 2$:$-0,$-$#/$'#&*57"#$44"#$0(1A 0"(#/$-'5+ .0B>2"'*"&40&($''$(%$&("770"'5+ 0B>"'$"-($'#+($?

/"4,$$(*"&4/$"3-$$+$(##'$77/"',$$(*-:$4#/-53/'%-&,$D-" &(3/"(4$:$("##$'#&(32&#($''57'& "+/"4"**$"-$4"'C> 02/ "4+&##$4  #/$  "3-$$+$(#  #  '$77  /$  #-&"7  5-#0  (  #/$  ,"'&'    #/$ "-$+$(#&($4$:&4$(%$04$%-$$4#/$'5&# $5-#/$-'5,+&#'#/"#"($%$''&#?"-'$#'$$;#/$&(95(%#&( "3"&('#"3&-&(3/"'/$2"'#-?&(3#"7&$("#$#/$*-*$-#?"(4"%%-4&(37? (  A

0  '5&#  -  &(95(%#&(  2"'  &7$4  2/&%/  2"'  4$%-$$4  :&4$ 9543+$(#"(44$%-$$4"#$4  /$"**$77"(#>*7"&(#&"%E5&-$4#/$ ;(27$43$#/"#-$'*(4$(#'A# >4$$(4"(#'/"4&('#&#5#$4#/$%&:&7 '5&#"3"&('#"3&-&(3/(.

A ,?'$##&(35*"("3-$$+$(##'$77 4"#$4.. 1"3&-&(3/%(%$4$4#/$'"+$0-$'57#&(3&(#*"''&(3 #/$9543+$(#"(44$%-$$4"#$4.

 (#/$2-&##$('#"#$+$(#0"3&- &(3/4$(&$4#/$$@$%5#&(#/$"3-$$+$(##'$77"(44$$(4"(#'A#

#;5*#/$*7$",("&4$*5-%/"'$-'/$62$-**$77"#$5-#/"' $--($5'7?"(4*$-:$-'$7?/$74#/$$@$%5#&(#/$"3-$$+$(##'$770,5# *$-:$-'$7?"7'((>'5&#$4#/$"**$77"(#>*7"&(#&(#/$3-5(4((> "**$"-"(%$$'5,+&#'#/"#5-%/"-"(<"5-0"##-($?*7"&(#&0/"4*5# &("**$"-"(%$"(4-"#/$-*-:$4#/$%"'$(#/$%-''>$@"+&("#&(0'/$ "('2$-$4#/"#*7"&(#&2"''5$-&(3-+2$";$?$>'&3/#0#/5'0#/$-$2"' (($$4*-:&(3#/$+$4&%"7-$*-#62$-**$77"#$5-#'/574(# /":$$@%$$4$4&#'95-&'4&%#&(&(4&'"3-$$&(32&#/#/$&(4&(3'-$(4$-$4,?

1 #/$#-&"75-#"'#/$"3-$$+$(##'$770+5%/7$''-$"4&($''"(42&77&(3($'' /"4,$$(*-:$40-0#/$'5&#2"'&7$4(1 095'#&:$+(#/'"#$- #/$'#&*57"#$44"#$"(40#/5'05-3$'#/&'5-#-'$##&(3>"'&4$#/$&(4&(3' #/$62$-**$77"#$5-#

$-  %(#-"0  - <&(37"0  7$"-($4  %5('$7  -  -$'*(4$(# '#1"(4 -5;/:&-&(3/&2"("07$"-($4%5('$7--$'*(4$(# '5,+&##/"#((>"**$"-"(%$#/$"**$77"(#>*7"&(#&2"'"#"7"'"77 #/$"%#'2$-$4($,?/&+/$4$$(4"(#'/":$,$$(*-$:$(#$4-+ -"&'&(3#/$'*$%&&%E5$'#&('('5**-##/$&-%(#$(#&(0-$7&$45*(#/$ -"#&4$%&4$(4&%577$45#&(  2.

34&565527 8 9  9- 0  !!  0  

( :8  659   %9 ;< 8  655 +

578% :&7 - 0 !!8=8 0 :$(#/$-2&'$0+"(?

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

$7&$%#%"(,$3-"(#$4-(#/$"('2$-&'&(($3"#&:$0-0"77#/$"%#'0

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

  +*,&

>59 ()./'

,9795:8 @5

 A5@

,979 73"

A5@