High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1495/1987allowed

(O&M) Karam Singh Etc. v. Harnek Singh Etc.

2015-08-19Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

!"##$%&%'()*)&"+,- .!/!0%'*1 2#$#!&#2 "1/)*13 & "1#/& 44#55!'"& 6#/&)& !/'#7%'*1 2#$#!&#2 "1/)*13 & "1#/& #&4'2#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& 81#"1#/ #4/"#/&5$!54!4#/&0!9:#!55;#2"&##"1#<)2*0#'"= , :#/##//#2""1# #4/"#/&/'"= > 81#"1#/"1#<)2*0#'"&1)52:#/#4/"#2%'"1#%*#&"=

/#&#'"( /&17%'*5!+2?$!"#+ /"1#!44#55!'"& /)'%5!/*+2?$!"#+ /"1#/#&4'2#'"& @@@@@ *)+%,'

>A,-

/!9#/ %' "1# !445%$!"%' %& / %045#!2%'* "1# 3 & )71"%!/ %'*1+ !44#55!'" > 1# !445%$!"%' %& &)44/"#2 :9 !' !%2!?%" 55;#2&):<#$""<)&"#B$#4"%'& 0#'2#20#04!/"%#&%&"!7#''/#$/2

1#$1!55#'*#%'"1#4/#&#'" #*)5!/#$'244#!5%&""1#

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

B 1#&!%2/2#/;!&'"!&&!%5#2!'21!2!""!%'#2%'!5%"91# !44#55!'"A45!%'"%&$'"%')#2"/#0!%'%'4&&#&&%'"1#&)%"4/4#/"9 )22#'59+%'"1#9#!/,+.)'21!%'*14)/4/"#2"1!?#0?#2!' !445%$!"%')'2#/#$"%',"1#!&" )'<!:52%'*& '&5%2!"%'

!'2 /#?#'"%' /!*0#'"!"%' $"+ /&1/"D"1#$"E :#/#"1# 22%"%'!5 %/#$"/ # &):0%"& "1!" ' '"%$# "1# !/#0#'"%'#2 4/$##2%'*&;!&%&&)#2""1#!44#55!'"A45!%'"%&!'2#?#'"1#/;%&#+"1# 0!""#/;!&5%&"#2/1#!/%'*' ,+1;#?#/+"1#"1#'22%"%'!5 %/#$"/4/#4'#2"1#1#!/%'*"1#0!""#/">-,;%"1)"%&&)%'* !'9'"%$#""1#!44#55!'"A45!%'"%&!'22#$%2#2"1#!445%$!"%'!*!%'&" "1#01##'"%/#/2#/1!&:##'#B"/!$"#2%'"1#<)2*0#'""1#3;#/ 44#55!"#)/"1#4#/!"%?#4!/""1#&!0#/#!2&"1)&(A

! "

'$0%'*"7';"1#!/#0#'"%'#2/2#/+"1#!44#55!'"A 45!%'"%&!&&!%5#2"1#/2#/:90?%'*!'!445%$!"%':#/#"1#%/#$"/ '&5%2!"%'/&#""%'*A!&%2#"1#/2#/+:)""1#&!0#;!&!5&2%&0%&&#2%' !0&"&7#"$190!''#/!'2;%"1)"!&&%*'%'*!'9/#!&'?%2#/2#/2!"#2 ,> B %'$# "1# !/#0#'"%'#2 /2#/& ;#/# ;%"1)" <)/%&2%$"%'+"1#!44#55!'"A45!%'"%&1!25#";%"1'"1#/4"%'+:)""%5# !&)%":9%'?7%'*"1#<)/%&2%$"%')'2#/#$"%'"1#%?%5 /$#2)/# 2#'"1#4/#0%&#"1!"2#1/&"1#:!/)'2#/#$"%'"1#$"+"1# &)%" ;!&F%& 0!%'"!%'!:5#+ ;1#' "1# /2#/& !&&!%5#2 !/# 4!&&#2 ;%"1)" <)/%&2%$"%'#)/"1#/&):0%"&"1!""1#"/%!5)/"1!2/#'2#/#2"1#%'2%'*& '!55"1#%&&)#&+%'$5)2%'*%&&)#!2?

#/&#4&&#&&%'+:)"2%&0%&&#2"1# &)%"'"1#*/)'2"1!""1#%?%5)/"2%2'"1!?#"1#<)/%&2%$"%'%'?%#; #$"%'"1#$" **/%#?#2!*!%'&""1#!/#0#'"%'#2%'2%'*&+!'!44#!5;!& %5#21#3;#/44#55!"#)/"+%'&"#!24'2#/%'*)4'"1#*/)'2& !44#!5;1%$1;#/#$'%'#2"%'2%'*&/#'2#/#2'%&&)#+)4&#""1# %'2%'*&'"1#/%&&)#&;%"1)""1#/#:#%'*!'9$/&&:<#$"%'&F$/&& !44#!5!" "1#%'&"!'$# "1#/#&4'2#'"A2##'2!'"& !'2+"1#/#/#+ "1# 4/#&#'" !44#!5+ !$$/2%'* " 0#+ %'?5?#& "1# 55;%'* &):&"!'"%!5 G)#&"%'&5!

81#"1#//%04)*'#2/2#/&+;1%$11!?#:##'4!&&#2!" "1#:!$7"1#!#$"#24!/"9+"1#%?%5)/";)521!?#"1# <)/%&2%$"%'

"1#:!/)'2#/#$"%'"1#$"= :

81#"1#/"1#3;#/44#55!"#)/"$)52/#?#/&#"1# %'2%'*&'"1#/%&&)#&%'"1#!:&#'$#$/&&A:<#$"%'&F $/&&A!44#!5!'2!$"%'/#'2#/%'*"1#%'2%'*&%&4#/?#/&#= '&)44/""1#!/#0#'"%'#2$'"#'"%'+5#!/'#2$)'&#5 /"1#!44#55!'"A45!%'"%&1!&/#5%#2)4'"1#<)2*0#'""1# )55#'$1 "1%&)/"%''1 2 3455

-2 ,

2 12

5,6 78,0"$'"#'2"1!"/!445%$!"%')'2#/ #$"%',"1#$"+"1#5%0%"!"%')'2#/ )5#"1# )5#&%&&%B 0'"1& 9 /#59%'* )4' "1# /!"% 2#$%2#'2% $)55#2 )" %' "1# !/#0#'"%'#2<)2*0#'"+1#&):0%"&"1!""1#/#&4'2#'"A2##'2!'"&1!2!' $$!&%'"0?#!'!445%$!"%'!"#/"1#/2#/2!"#2,CC B ;!& 4!&&#2+:)""1#4#"%"%';!&%5#2%'"1#9#!/,;1%$1$)52'"1!?# :##'%5#2#!5&/#5%#&)4'"1#<)2*0#'"/#'2#/#2%' 11 +$ 455*

2 *

1 %1 ,*9 /"$'"#'2 "1!";1#/#"1#/2#/&4!&&#2!/#;%"1)"<)/%&2%$"%'2#1/&"1#!$""1!" "1#/#%&!'!5"#/'!"%?#/#0#29+"1#:!/"!?!%5"1#/#0#29:9%'?7%'*"1# <)/%&2%$"%'"1#%?%5)/")'2#/#$"%'"1# $)52'"$0#%'

%"&;!9 /)'%5!/*+5#!/'#2$)'&#5!44#!/%'*':#1!5"1# /#&4'2#'"A2##'2!'"&&):0%"&"1!":"1"1#)/"&:#5;1!?#/#'2#/#2! %'2%'* !$" !'2 5!;+ :!&#2 )4' "1# !44/#$%!"%' /!5 !'2 2$)0#'"!/9 #?%2#'$#+ "1!" "1# <)/%&2%$"%' "1# %?%5 )/" )'2#/

#$"%'"1#$";!&:!//#2!'2+"1#/#/#+"1#/#0#29+%!'9+ ;!&"%5#!'!445%$!"%'/"!?!%5"1#//#0#29)'2#/"1#$"#)/"1#/ &):0%"&"1!""1#3;#/44#55!"#)/"1!&/#?#/&#2"1#%'2%'*&'"1#/ %&&)#&;1%5##B#/$%&%'*4;#/&)'2#/ /2#/ )5#>> +;1%$1$!'

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

/0"1#4#/)&!5"1#/2#/2!"#2,>+%"%&#?%2#'""1!" "1# 22%"%'!5 %/#$"/ 1!2 4/#4'#2 "1# 1#!/%'* "1# 0!""#/ /0 , " >-, ;%"1)" %&&)%'* !'9 '"%$# " "1# !44#55!'"A 45!%'"%&!'24!&&#2"1#%04)*'#2/2#/:94/$##2%'*"1#/#&4'2#'"& "1#/#%'!'2!44#55!'"&1#/#%'!&

"%&!0!""#//#$/2"1!""1#!445%$!"%'%5#2:9.)'21! %'*1+4/#2#$#&&/&A%'A%'"#/#&""1#/#&4'2#'"&+/$//#$"%'*1%&'!0# %'"1#/#?#')#/#$/2!&#;!&2%&0%&&#2',CC!'2"1# &!%2/2#/1!2!""!%'#2%'!5%"91#4#"%"%'%5#2)'2#/#$"%',"1# $"%'"1#9#!/,;!&'"'59:#5!"#2+:)";!&'"0!%'"!%'!:5#?#' "1#/;%&#+"1#/2#/!55;%'*"1#!445%$!"%')'2#/#$"%'"1#$"+!&

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

"1#%'&"!'$#.)'21!%'*1;!&:#5!"#2'# '?%#;;1!"1!&:##':&#/?#2!:?#+:"1"1#)/"& :#5;1!?#$00%""#2!'%55#*!5%"9!'24#/?#/&%"9%'2%&0%&&%'*"1#&)%"' "1#*/)'20!%'"!%'!:%5%"9!'2!&;#55!&&#""%'*A!&%2#"1#%'2%'*&' "1#%&&)#& &/#*!/2&+"1#%'2%'*&'%&&)#>+"1#/#;!&'$$!&%' / "1# !44#55!'"A45!%'"%&" 4/#&& / "1#&!0#'$# "1#91!?# :##' !55""#25!'21#9$)52'"1!?#$5!%0#2"1#!2?#/&#4&&#&&%' 1# %'2%'*&'%&&)#>+;1%$11!?#!5/#!29:##'/#?#/&#2:9"1#3;#/ 44#55!"#)/"+!/#1#/#:9)41#521#%'2%'*&'%&&)#&!'2,!/# /#&"/#2!'2"1#%'2%'*&/#'2#/#2'%&&)#!/#&#"A!&%2#!'2%"%&1#52 "1!""1#%?%5)/"1!2"1#<)/%&2%$"%'1#G)#&"%'&5!;+'"%$#2 !:?#+!/#+"1)&+!'&;#/#2%'!?)/"1#!44#55!'"A45!%'"%&!'2!*!

"1#/#&4'2#'"A2##'2!'"& $$/2%'*59+"1#!44#!5%&!55;#21#&)%"&"!'2&2#$/##2 #$/##A&1##":#4/#4!/#2 51,/9 *)+%

;53 '(-.&