M/S Dlf Projects Limited v. State Of Haryana And Others

 

     !
"##
# $#
# # #
 #  

 (- .

 /    



 

  





 

#+ 
01 +2 "2  #  
01 + 2 "2 +#
2## # !

"
# $  
!% 
& '


!( 
)

 
!%
!)*'
!( 
  
 
&*'
!( '

 

"*
+*) '
!,'


 --- +#
2## #3"

 . &
*"
 
) '
 


% %

 



/ 


*"





..


# 

 
1



*
! +2
!'

34 !+
!56
) #


#
%



)
 "
 







 7.8


* **"
 
( 

 
.81
36
36




,



 (
+2
!'
.8
3




4 ,+
!56  + 


*

# 
 9/  


#







3!:6
..9.
#


;.;

#
<2

+2 
= 99!"

!

'
, "


3<6
)


2"
 
#

%

 




# '

 

 *




7'>8'1'1>?9
 !+
!

.?'?'>?9
 
/ * *
+2
!'
.>;?
3




4/+
!56
+ **"
 # (


;.;
#
*"
 *
#


@ 
<2 
+2 
/ 
3! *6'
 #
+ 

 *
) 

7>.?
3 ( 
(



0 1.
 .86
) # 



;.;
)

 
 

)

 
"


)
  
 



 

( 

*)


("



 
#"

 
+ 

)
 
* #


"


 


"
(


7.8
) *
"("



 
 
2
*#* 
 


!+  "

;'.'>?'>.>9

/+

.?'?'>;9
!
"


2
 
* 
 '
 
2
 

2

 

)

%
  '
 
*#* 
 

)
2
A ;'?>'1.'>?;9  B
)

#
 

..'



)
 



 


)

#



 
1
!+
!

 
>
36
/+
!
**""




**"*



 


7.8


# 
+
#"
""

(
# 
 "
 

..
 



C "
 


"


 




( %"

 

 
1
!+
!

#



(



0 

 
)

**"*












7.8
B

**"
 
#
"
  "
 '
 

%"
 92
 
#

%
 


( *

( 

 
>
36
36

!+
!
B

#
 

 


" ) 



!:
..9.

 
  
"





2  
.



"



) 
"
"



..
) 
 
 "
 
)
'



'
 
 



 *
 
#


#
#*
#"


#


B

*
#
**"
 ) 
 *
 
# 2 
# 
"
 
"





# "


(



 
"


) 

D *


**""
 
 "
 

#

#  #
*)**
( %"
 ) 

 
1
!+
!


( 

#9 
36

36

 
.81
,+
! ) 
* 
( 
 
/  
B'
  


* "




  1 + 

(
*
 
) 

"

*

# 

 

 
 
) 
 
)
 #*


*
"


#
 "'



"



#



%
C "

( 

#  
36

36

 
.81
,+
!

 
  
"

)
 *
(*
=
 '

)
# 
 
 "
 

..

#

#




*

%
 
*"*



 


7.8'
 

)
  **
(* 



)
) 
 
 




) 
 
2 

) 


D *
 

( "


"
*'
 
*

) 
#
 


 ; +
*
  

( "
 
*

%
 
) 

*
# 

9 "



)  ? B
) *
 
#


*

 
*   *



)  

 "
 
2
 **"

 
 "




..

 
 
"


 **""
 
( 

 
.81
36

36

,+
!'
.8

  *
 "
 
 "


)
 
)
*#*

#
C 


)


( *  *
 *


)
)


 

#
 
#
"


 "
 '
 
)
%"
 92
 #

%

 

 "
 
!:
..9.
) )
 
  

%




 
>
36
36
!+
! +
)
#*


 ("

 
#

%
*


  
"


 
* 

#

%
* 

 
  
"





2  


.'
 

'

*
 
#
  **



 
#

%

  )

)
 


* C 



.

 "
 

**"*





 



7.8
)







 
 " 
'
 

'
 
 *
 
( %
 
 
1

!+
!
 (
 



D *  "

)
) 

"



*
 
 


( 

!

*
?

/  
B'

 "


4


)
#*
(


"

* (
 
 
# (*
#
'
 

'
 "
 
 "


)
 
)
*#*

#
C 

 
) 
 (

#
** ) +


 
 "'
* 
 *


*
* 





+5.

672116 % 8 9- . 9

 (( --:#....

;#8  < 6 8.'
!B

/ 87.E
 (# % 2;

  6 8.'
3.>>>6
.
//
.E

6.

 : = 

16 %  >82

;83!B
.1
/
87E21 :

6%  ::

..

3 ::- 9. 6 8.'
.;
// = 

>7E ?

@ -8%  ::

..

 ( ::- 9.3 +<.

3 3.>?86

+/
?8
F
< #;  6. . = 

:

6  %  2  (  <    6  8.'
3.6
B 

#




'
? 8

 '

)
 "
#


"*
+*) '
*   
!( 
, *'



 
) 

*
"



)
 

 
#*

**
 
# 
#
) 
*"
 * 

""
 

 
)
(


(*#*
) 
+ 
*

%




*%

 





 
 "
 




( *

 *

 *

G

(
 
1
3.6

!+
!'
 *


)
*
 (


 # 
"


) 

  
2




 

 * 








 
 "
 
)

)
 (
 
..
)
) 
* 
 #


( 

 
>
36
36
!+
!
) 
 


A

**
 

 


 


"

 

) * 

7.8
#
 
"


) 
 
 


#





 
>
36
36

!+
!'
 
 
#

%
) 
* C 

#
 (
**
   *

"
"
 !+
!

 *

) 

  
"





 
* 



 
#
 
(
)
 


 

 *  *
(



* 

#

%

 
) %


# 




) C 



("




D 
#

  "'

)
#
 
) 
)
 
#*
 )
*#*

#

+



 "'
* 
 

!( 
, *
*
*
 






::

..



(   9- .36 % +5.@ .8 &9),16 '

3.6
// ;8E
8> .B% =: #8  <%  ::

..

 (  

9- .3 . :. 62% -9 6 8.3
.;
3>6
+
;;
F

  .. 6 8.%    9= .

%.16 '
!B
7
/
.?. 7 D
(

* 
 *


#
 
 
   #*
*"

(
"(

*#  
 
  



#
# 
 > + 
 **"
(* 
 "


)
 

..


# 
) # 
*  "


#
"
 
7.8
C 



!:
..9.
!* '
 
 **" 
(* 
 
 "


)

 
)


(*"
 (

* (
 
*"
 * 





/


""
 


 

*
)


(*"




*
 *
"
 


#
 
* 

#








+ 
*


 
 )
**
*

( %
 
 
D 
/ 

 
*
#

)
(


#*

 
 "
 
) 

( *  *

 


)


 ) 


"
 '
 
)
 
#*
 
 
 
* (
 

+ 
)**
*

 
*)
) " 

2 

 

!

*
?


/  

 


) 
 
!

*
 #*

*
 )
#

H#*
! 2
/ 
#
) 
( *



#
# *

#

"
 
B
 )**
#* 
 
) *
2 "

 

!

*
?

/  '
 
/ 


# 
   $9 6  
) 
( *(
  *2

 
C 



) 


# 

* *(E #6 (*
**
 *
E 6 

* (

(



* 
 E 6
( %"
 
 

"* 2 *
*

* E 6 2

#


#

*)

* E 6 "


*

"
#*
*

#


#


(*
*)'






 .  

#

 %  = 16 '
3.>7;6
.

'

//
?'
) 


H#*
! 2
/ 
2 

()
  !

*
?
)
 





 

 (


 
B
)
* 



) 
 *
**

 
 


2 



 '




) 
(

( 


)

C

(

#*
)

"
)
2 #*
2


 
( 

#*



 ( 
#*

C 
'
 
 

#


!

* ?

/  
B
)
*
 
(
 
 
/ 

(
"

 


# 
 
* (


(
# 

 
 
( *("
 (
) 


 ) 
(*#*
) 
 

  ..  


#


7@:28 %8% -  (

( -: '
3.6
1
//
88'
) 


H#* ! 2
/ 
) *
*"
) 

)  
* (



(*#*


"
<2 "
"
!'
.>>>
 * #
# 

 

!

*
?

/  
 *
# ( %'
# (

 ** )$9 4D 







 
#
*)


 *
"

(





*
'

) 


* 
#
 
"

"
 


  
B
  '
 
"

/ 








 *

 C 
*)
+ 


*
 
#
#

"(

"

#
#

*"


( %"
 




*
()
"

/ 
 
 
. B
) 
"


8
2 (+8.8  6 8.%  .8 =
) ,1 :

63 !B 
/
117

8



2 (+68<6.8 6

8% +5. ::- 

;

.

 6 6< 6

; := <1 :

6'

3.16
*
>'


H#*  
/ 
)
*"
)

) 
 



 #
 **"
# 

 *
#
*"
) 
#

"

/ 
B
)
*
 


(


"


 *
" 



# 
"


"



# 
 **


'

"



*
 * 
#

+ #*
B
)
*
 

()

 '
 "

/ "


 


(
 
 
) 
 

!

*
?
 **""
 


()

(*#* 



 
! / C* '
 

)
*"

(*
 


  *


(*#*
 
!+
!'
/+
!

  *
*
# (

#
** ) . D " 
 
C 
#* 
)  
 **""


'
 

#


+6

;. 68:1 :

6% 

 ( '
1
3.??6
< +
.; 3/6'
) 


H#*
 
/ 
 
 
()
%
#

"

/ 
 
 **


*
 

**
 # 
#





)



 





'


( 



"
 
 **'
 
*#

#
"


 

 "

/ 
 


#


+8 ; =8


;:1 :

6%  8 : 3   6 -9.

 6

8'
1
 
36
/
;>'
) 
 

 *
) 2 
#

H#*
! 2
/ 
#

*"
 

*" 
"





*
 
#
 "
 

#
 ::

..

 (
  9- .36 .C.-.3 6'
) 




H#*
 
/ # (
 

) 


*


**
 
#  
"
 




)

 
+ 
 **

*
 * 
**
 # 
#











'

( 



"
  **'
 
*#

#
"





 "

/ 

*
   9= .

%.16 C. 
3 6'
) 


H#*
 
/ # (
 
) 
/ 


*
 
 
 ) 
)





(*#*

*
 *

"



#
 



  
"



#
** )
 
  * 


 "

/ 


 
) *


 
 





 .1 B
)**
*
#
*(
 
+5.

672116 C.


3 6'
)


(





H#*
  / 


#
(* *
 
# 
* 
 *


# 

 "
 

) 
)
#* (
)


(*"
 
* (
 
B
 
# (

'
 

 **"
 



# * 


2 


 
*
)
#
*"
) #


"

/ 
+ 
) 
#


 
"

/ 

*
  

 
"



(*#* 
 * (
 
 *
 
 **

 

!+ !
+

H#*
 
/ *
 


 *

)


# 


 
) 
C "
 
(

 

*


2 

 
) '
 

#"
 
C 
*)'
 
) "


 
 (
#


)



*



.; B
()

 
*)

*
 )
#

H#* ! 2
/ 

 
# (



'


(


2 *


"

/ 

 

) 
(


"


* (



 
#
(*

 

 
C 
*)

 


# 
)


"

"

 
C 

'



" 
# 
"


 (


 
)

 

'

 

( *  *

 *



 )
%





*
"


+ 






 "

#


*"
 
 "


)
 

 

)
**"*

)


 

)
*#*

# C 


)


( * 
 
>
36
36
!+
! # 
)

*
C 




 

#

%


 
 "
 
!:
..9.
) *
 "

"


 


"

 

)
 C 




 (

 

#

%

 
#



  
"





* 
*(


+ 
 "
 
#
  

#
 (
#


 *
 *


'
)  
  
 

*%

 
0
 #'


 
>
36
36
!+
!'

" 
*

C 


 (

 
#

%



  
"


 
* 


#

%
*

 
#


 
#

 
(

( '

*

* C 
  (

 

#

%
** 
  *

"
)
 
"


( 

!+
!
+ 
 

%




 
 "


'
 
) *
#

C "




#

%

 



!:
..9.
)

)




*#*
  (
B

 

 *(
#

%

 

 
*"
 


 




) 



 '


  


 
 

0 
) *
C 


 
#

%

 
  

#
#

  
  
B
 
 "
 '
 


 *(  
#

%

 
) *
#
C 
# 
0 (
 

  
'
 
(
"

**

#
 
**"*




) (
#




 
 "
 
 
#




'
)

)
(*#*
#


"



 )


(

 *

C 
B
)**
 
#


*




(
*

 *


 * 
.?
#"


 

)
 
) *
#
C 
# 



("
 




) *
#
 

#

 
(*#*



 "
 


"* 
B

 
) 
 

0 

  "
 

 
 "

 
 
#

%


*(



) 
 
(

* 
 
) *
 
#
"

 

 


 
"
 "
 
 "


'

 
 '
  "
 
 *
 
#


#
**"*

)


  *
#

)


2 


  
"





 * "

!:
..9. .? B

*
#
*(

 

 
 
 

)


 



7.8
G

(  
1
3.6
!+
!'
 

* (






2




 


 * 






+ 

'
 
)
)**
) 


  "



%"





7.8

 
 
 
#


#
 #


+

"
 
!+
!
 *
 
#

 ( #
  *
**

*
2




 


"

'
 

'
(
)
 

)

# 


 (

 
#

%

C 

 
>
36
36
!+ !
**
 
!
 '

**"*

#

 (
#
 
#


#
"
 
 "




..


 

 
 
#


#
 
#*

"

 .8 + 
 **"
 
 "



 #

# 
"


 

**"*
 



 



7.8


#



 

 *
 
2 


) 
 *
#


 
"


) 
"

 



# 
"



B
 
" '
* 
 *



*
*
 
(# C.

3 6



6.

 : = 

16 C.

3 6
) 


H#*
! 2 / 
) *
*"
)
 *
*
"



# "

/ 
3
*


6

( 


# (
  
)
*



)
 
 "

/ 
 #
 
"
)
/ 
)

)
"
) * 2 "
 
*
  (

 



*  
 *
 
#
C
)
 *
) 

**

  


* *
 
< 
#;  6. . = 

16 C.




3 6
) 

/


& 
/ 
*


*



 
*
 


)

**


# 


)
#


 
* )




 
%
    


 *
)


"


 
#
 
2"




 



+8>

>  #

+ 8::6$D>*2

.% 2 (@ D33.>>6
>
+/
8?

3I 6'
) 
"

/ 
I %

# (
 * 

)
 ) 

**



2
 






"



#

#


= *




 "
*

 
*"*

 



 "*

"



)


*


)


 "



#
(
)
**"*



"

#


=
) 


"*
)
* 
 
( .7 
 *


 
 
#
 



 *
2 
*
)

 
1

!+
!
*







 "
*

 
*"*




"
 
) *
"




7.8

 


*"
) 
C ** )
) "

*
"(
# 
"


 '
#







# %
 

C '
 

'

 

 
 "
 
B
 
" '
* 
 *


*
 
?

@ -8C.

3 6
) 
 "

/ 
I %


# (
 


 *
#


 
* 

 )
 
#

(

)
( 







(

) "

'

 *
#

 
 
)
 


4



*
 
 *

)







+ 
#

 
# 
 

 ) *


**



2
 

"
 !+
!'

 (

 




#

  


 ) 
 
2'

 

# *
)
2 #*

 
) 




 
*



 )

  #
#
 *"* 
#  #"
 
  '
(J'








*
 
 


(
+ 
 


)  $9
* '







*
 
 

(
+ 

2  
4*"* 5

4

 5
) *
%
)  
 *
**
 

**"*




)
"

(
  


"
"
#


"


"

( 
 
*
 
 
1
!+
!
)
 ) 
/ 
2 
*
) 
 
 
  *




  
)

(
#
 

 
B
 
'
 



 (
 

# "




**"*

 

+ 
 
2 *
**


 

 
*
#  &
"
 
 "


'

 '
) 
)  
# (
)
* 

()'

#

)


 


+ 
  
 
) *
#( *   






#


 
  
 
+

 * 

()


 

)**
*
#
  
 

 


) 
 
) *
#


(

+ '

)( '
*
 
) 
(
#


*"
  * 
B

*


A

)
 
)

*%

 
  ) *
"
 
 
+

"



#
#
   *
 *


#
( *'

)( '

 *
 
#



 ) 
 *

 *


#
( *
) *
"
  "
 


)K
+ 
)
  


  "
 
) 
2




 


 * 






7.8
 



  

#

) 

'
 

'
# 
*

 
 
 
 
!


+6 ;. 68: :

6C.
3 6'


(

)**

**
 #  #


)



 
 "


 


'


( 



"
'
 
*#

# "







 
/ 
B
+5.

672116 C. 3 6
) 
#
*
 
#
* 
 *


'


H#*
! 2
/ 
*
 
) 

!

*
?
 * #
 
(


* (

)
(*#*
*

 ) 
 

(
)

 *
*"*



 
( *(
  C 


#
*
C 

*)

 *


#


+

 

*
 )

 

 
#


#  *#*
 
*


 







*"*
C 
*)

#

#


 "



( *(
*
C 
*)
 
 ( *(
C 


"

**"*











#


(*#*






+ 
 
 
"


#


 



B
  

 '

"
# 
/ 

 
"

*%*
#

/

*
 
 

 
 
 
 
+ 




 



 C 

#
 
#




 
 

+ 
 

#
 

 *"


# 
 

#
(
#

)**
 (

 


  
+ 
C 

  


*#*

#
(



#
 
#

*



B

 '
 
) 
 
 
  (

#
** )
/ C* '
)


2 "
   




 
 

 "'
)

  
#
** )
 '


  

 



  *
 * 
 "





  



"
+
)**'

)( '
#

*# 
**


  

 
/ 
 **
*
) 

 *
 


)
*)
)


#"
*



#


# ( 

# (




 
 * 
#




*"*

 .> !**
** 
 * 36'

 '
*

 
 ) # , )+#
2## #,  "

"








 /   
 %"   :0 

#* :0