Tabsum And Others v. Usman And Others
!"#$%& !
'
%&
!
(
%& ) * *%
+, &
* -% %%./ * *
0 1*
23
+, %* ,
2
1 #&
* * * # *
1 & # *
# )
#
*
*
#
&
4 ) 5
%
6
& * %./ % * %
& * -%./
& *
*7
#
6 %**
%
# 8%./ ** & * %--%./ 9 8-% 6 : 7
%
;3
*7
1 %
* * #< = + 4
!
"
##$ "% #&! !&! %! !
"
'(() * +'+% %! #, - !
& . % %
# / .
"% !
"
# '(+0+**1(% 2 3
#, - !
& . % %
# , %#",", !
"
# '(+1+1+4( 8 5
)% % ;
#
4% & *
*
1
1
* #;#
1 % %
1 #%
& ; #
1 &
7
1 1
1 # 6
& 1
* 1
3
; * 1
1 #
)
* /
!
"""
# $%&! #'' ()*%
, *-* ##
((
/
0 ((
# $%&& #'' ()*%
, -
*&%
1
2
*&%
0
/
2 0
0 *&%
2
2
#
0
*&%
3 *&$- ()*%
1
2
2 .
.
!
!
)& ** ()(-
+ 0
.
32 (% ()(-4
5
&
%*
* / / *&$- 3/ ()*%
*8(
611 96:6'
;
' <:65
;
' ,<:
#6 #3 ;
3= 6:
;
5:'6:
#9 116 6 96:6' #
+2 >
?
;
< > 3
?:
+6 3/
##'56 + (( )* ()*8
+<:6 3/ # ,6 +9 ;
' <:7;
6 +3 69'#16 @ 5
6 3/ 56#6 ,65;
' <:65 (A
5:'' 1'#6 #6 ;
:3<+6 6:
'+ ;
' ,<:
#6 3
' #
56+ '1 3/ :61'6/ :
+65
;#1 '
56+ '1
B6/3:6
+96
+:'B<
# 2
.
'
*))))
*())))
*))))
*())))
5
(-C D: !))))E
(-C D: !))))E
/
$)C D: !&)))E
$)C D: !&)))E
*8
*8
1
*-)))
*A)))
/
F
*-)))
*A)))
1
$))));
,
$A))) & G(AA)))
+
: ((*()));
: ($&&)));
'
-C
I !C
: ($&&)))
((*()))
(-$)))
'
&& &8-
: !()&8-; 7.
4
,
&
* * - < = +4
8 5#-# 9+: &
=
D$E +2 2 D 2
, +
J # #
E
*A D .
. *- () (* (- E 2
6+07!'* !4(.
#
*& !*
!-
*- !& $)
*$ $* $-
*!
$& -) 2 0
** -* --
% -& &)
&* &-
- && 8)
&* *1-# %
2
; < = + 4
/ .
"%5# -# 9+:% "-% ' 0 0
-% * 0 . B
,
5
2
0
. B
0
J 0
2
,
. 2 B
'
2
B
.
J
0
2
2 B
-% (
:
J
:
K
0
:
-% !
=
-)C
0
2 0
0 . $)
!)C
. 0 20 $) -)
' 0 20 . -) &)
*-C
F
-% $ -# "
- # 8# # 76
&!.
! ! 7%9 #. % %! !7:(;!7 "
# <%#"
% -!
#"!, < "
8 8"
"
- # 8#< !8 "
2 !7:( .
# (-C 0 20
. $) -) *)C 0
20 . -) &) .
2
F
-% - /
F 2
. 2 . !) !( ,
0
2
=)*"
# - %! !7 , %&% #"< #% %-
% "
< % 8% " &2&" :' !7 " >, 2
=)0"
2 !7 "
- # #"!, < "
<#%#7!&&.% 2
"
, %&% =)1 #! < 7%2, #! -! ?
%! "
#
.!## !7 #
!##!7-! #! %, 7, 9& # ##"!, < #+=(((@6#:((((@6 #+=(((@6 #& - %?
."
7! #% !, ##"!, < " - "
!7+(;%
?
. "
.
# &)
0
2 B
& "1 * * * &#< = +4 1
#
* *
0 ,
1 *
#
*
**&
1 ".* / # 6 # < = + 4
2 3
#, - !
& . % %
5#-# ,& &
%
% *
%
* *%
1 & & "1
* "(*
# B
#
,
0
3
1
#
'
.
4
L
M L
M L
M
.
0
.
=
0
F
(* * ,
.
.
2
0
.
(* (
.
.
(* !
.
. J
.
.
.
#
((
#
.
2 0
0
. N
M F
0
0
0
(!
2
.
.
'
.
0
#
#
0
0 .
#
0
-
90 0
0
#
($
0
. 2 0
L1 # M
0
,
DE
' 0
0
: $))))
#
& "1 % * *
%
* * .
1 & 11.
The revised chart produced by the learned counsel for the appellants in so far as the amounts on accounts of loss of estate, funeral expenses and loss of consortium has been mentioned is in accordance with law and deserves to be granted to the appellants. There are six claimants who were dependent upon the deceased and thus, the present appellants are entitled to Rs.2,88,000/- under the account of loss of consortium, whereas they were granted only Rs.40,000/- on the said account. Thus, the present appellants are held to be entitled for additional compensation of Rs.2,54,000/-. '
%
4
# *
1
23
%*
12.
>
1
& * & %
#
* *-
)
#
%8%./
1*
23
1
1 ; # % *
6 *, # !
"# $%
&'()*(+
,
- 5 K ' ,
1. ? .@ ' ? .@