Lal Bahadur v. U.T. Chandigarh







      
      

  !"#"

$%&&'

()* +, &&&-- ))$

.

,#+#

&&/*$ "0,* &&&

#- $ $

 1%  2(1 &


 .

 3

 

 !"

#$% !
& ()) *"+* !!   ,- 
(!

(  .

 3/&  
    -())(./)(#

0 '( # 1(#(! !01(#(##!# !0!( )). )!.0 !# 

0    (  ))    '

    !  (  *!

  "# !!2 )!.0(!!  3!

# 3!

)#
 
(!

( "!1(#( ())1(! 0 #  ''#)(.!# 45 !1(# 6 '(7! 
!$'

( 87
8&!# !1(  # '
(!' 9:''## 





 

1( ! '#!!

1(())1#! !



 ) '

 ) ! ' 50! )0' ' 6 ;!!' )0 ''  '(!

)) '

 4 ( '

  ''#!# 45 $ &!1(# 67


1'( ."!((  ((# "#(.(! 0! 45 $ &;67
1# !1(# '(

:
:# .) "!!!#  :
:# ( )(1!! 0!# 45 $ &;67
1(#(  !  # !1(# :
:#!( ! 1!)()0!( :
:# 4

'  '#  '  (  #    )  )     (

) 
(!     (  '  (  ) #9  "   ) () #((11 / 

/= > 65  
(!

(!   6 6 .

5 (1(  !((.!(!

10'

1 /!( ! " 0% (!$))& #(= !(((  .)( 1 -(' ('(#(!  $) #9&  !.

50!.

0 !.

601(% (!!

(1 /((   1((# 

 ('

!( % (!10 /! (.!!(!!() #9 (  !  (  1  0      (  )    (    '  ( ! (;) #91(( 1)0 .0(: ( (!!!#0 !( ( 1 '( (  0* ( #( ( 1" '!  )) 0 % (!1 (# (!10' () -('
(! "# )?9  () #'

/  #  (##!  (. '1(#( '

@7?9  ! 45 67
!#   :
:#1 ! -(##!1! (!0!1

!#  0

4 9!-() ## !!( '(##!!# 
 
A "    )
(!'!

 () #9!#  09!!(' () # .!() !# 54
 
  -(
'!(#( !# 45 !1( 67
!!#  ! :
:#  1(#( ##!)!!  0!#! 6 7() "!# () #9))! < !)) !() " !!((##!'

#.0 ! (( !

/ ''(# (-(##!  "!

(# (!!(  ()")!! ( ) ()")-(' ( (#(!('!

()' (##!!

/( ()!!1) !

(' ('(#(!('(! (((!( ##!!(10' (

7  # 9     )#'#  B   1  )    ( ) #9(1((##!!!1(( (!0 '#!C7 )0 (!(##!! (( !!(  (!( "!(# (!0!

1/! (.!!! (  ()")!! () ()" ) 5

)
(! !) ! ( !!(1((! 

 (1##!% (! 0  /!    (  .!  !  0    #   1  #  1(  ( ) #9.(10!(' (#!() #! "

 (# )?9 ('(!(#(##!(! 0 )!    #   )  1(  (  ! (  (  '!     ( ! (;) #9!#  09! 

<4A ( !



!( 4 6 6 7!



#09!() #9'

! '(.

  !) !0 (!



#  #91 0$D; 0&=( !((((# ) !

.!) !.0(!AA"! A E=  
(!

(!() ?9 4.  )   1!.0 <6 AA"! A    E= #  
(!

((## !  ( ) .! (9 #9 (! 1  0 !((  !() ?9 4 1( <4 <=
.((() "! # !?9 6 ! AA> 4  2

A0-0  ?: E= #  
(!

( ) "! # !(!#)  '())?9

!) ()  (1 (  

())1#). )'

 9#   

<5  7;7:  .*    7#(  

# 

  %/
(!

(  ) "!    # !    (  "  !

#    

!# '"  ?9 5 ?9  1(#((

) #  '

@7 !

!.0(=:  (##!1() '()# ### <=

( ) "!(#!)?9   -('    '  (  ##!  1  # !!  !

6 44
 
!(# "!# 1(#((!#  # ! 1) ##!7B .

()# (# (!(( #!('0.)#!(1 '#!).1( ( #9!('0!

1((/!(# ).

( (/!( ( 

!'

 /!( (# )#!

() # ( 1"  !'#"!#1! '( .

(()!))# ( # ! (
# "#!())'

#  ''# )(.!# 45 !1(# 67
!# !

1( # :
:#!#!( #!.

" =# ())) 4 %! #  )) '

,- 
(!

( ( '!

# !0#'# ## !  1(#( ())(!

# # ' 40   (!

!0  !0! #

' 60   (!6!0#!    %!# '

())( !((.#

'0!#"!# (
(1 0(!())

0 '#  ''#)(.!# 45 $ &!1( 67
 6 %!# '

())('( !() (" ) (! !* ((!# 

!!((!#!() # ( 1" (1( . 9!  .0  (  ) #  1(#(    )#   .

  (  ) " 

%!# '

())('( !(( !#)#( #91( ); ( #97( #9  (  #   (  (  ##!  '

#.0  !    (  (   1(

)(!(##!1!" . (

'

$1' '(!. ( '# )8(.!&(! ( (#(!!(1 '

1 /%!#  '(!(( # (# 9 '(1 (())1/ 1 (# )'

('"0!

(1   ('0 5 %!# '

())('(.!(( ) #9( !(('( (.! '(# ) /1.

()# '()) !(

 1(

!.0  %!  #   '

  (  ))  (  ) !     ( !# ( <;) #9!) !(( (!'( ((!()) 1( ; ( #9(!

( ( (!#0 (! !# !!! ##(( ##!;)) ( 1" (#)!!10' (%!

'

())'(.!('#(1   0!).1(# )!('0! (##  (1#!# )8( !  (# )#!( ) #!)#!('# 2 7)0 !#  )) '

(,- 
(!

( (.!(' ( '(1 !

#   <4A

5  ( !



! <6AA"! A    ) "!((  #91)) 90 0!( (!0)) !() " !(!1#( 9 #('1# 9  1( B ) !.0(!'# (( !(##!) ''(# ( !! /)"9

%!# '

,-
(!

(('(.!( ())(! !'#"!# ) "()/.0( ((10 0!).1 )!('0  !'#119!

 '( !# '

() 7'!  !

'   (  '!   # !!  .0 (  
  '

  ( '

 1

  ( 1" .*# '

 1  !'#  $&

(  <;) #9! ) #   (    (  (  ));##!  !    (  ( F  "!(# (!0!

1/! (.!!( "!( # ( #9!! # ) () #9 -('

  '   (    '  (  ) #9    1    (  (;# ) ) "!(())(# ! ''# 

"!9 !'!# 2!1(# ( :
:# $.& -() ( ) "! <4A  ( !



! <6AA"! A  ((   #91)) 90 0   " ()) ! !0"!#(() #91  '(  ' 

 0 $#& = 1"  (  )   (  '!    !  0  !# "!# ) "(1(# '

"!)"9   !!0    (  '  (  ) #9  !!       ( !#  09!  " (! !* ( 1(  )@7 "! ()# ### 1 "9! 1-()# ###"

1(((  '

!* (!) ((!'(##!1(( /!("

!1!((  !

(!

#1 / 1(#(( 1((1)() '(( 1(( )# ###"

!!(1  ! !!0 (##!# " !)!'# ).0()) ('0(!  0!)1( 

(!!(##!. ( '(3($1' '(!. (

'# )8(.!& ( 1" ()#1 ) )0!1( .0(
 $!&

   (  9 #('    1     # 9  (!((##!! # ) (  ! (!(# 9 ((!(  

   



 

       

 

    ! "  # $ 

 

 

#% -( #9 1( ((!((##!)! # () $& 7  "1  '  (  .

"  1(  )( !  (  *!

  "#  )!.0(
 7'!((#( !#

2 7
!1(# :
:#. . !'!!

())(! 0 ''#)(.!#  !1( :
:# $'& A" #( '=#( !(= (

 

     





  !!( (!((#1!!!# :
:##. !#!  ### $ & )# !0#'#!! 2 ())( ' ''!!(0  !( #.#/  !-( ))(!

 # ' 60!6!0   1(#( ((!

## ' 40  2 (! 6 !0  2

7"1 '(.

"!#  ()))0!!

!1()( ! (*!

 '# "#  (#1!!

())!#! # ' 60) "!!!   :
:#-(  '' !#!

 6 ;!# ' )0 '' ())1!

)) '

6!0

4 -()).!'

(1(' B!0 ( #

 # )0 '( !.  ()!;A)0 )!  !3 
(!

('

# )# -,")/'

4 .

 35








  &



'( 

) (* &

   + ) (*