High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM/30907/2004allowed

M.S.Bhullar v. State Of Haryana

2017-08-18Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

!"#$%$&'($)$(*$"&+, , -'$ $./)/&+,00 , 12!33-( $'/'/&$( 4$()!) 1'-'$($5($)$&'$"'2(!#26-7!( & (.$%$&'

/.$(89-(&-3 $)5&"$&'

($)$&'+ (99!5'-8"*.-'$ ('2$5$'/'/&$( (1-'/)21-/&/88-(:-&- ((!&)-/&8$&'(-3*'!&)$3 ;;;

2$/&)'-&'5$'/'/&2-)7$$& /3$"!&"$(1$.'/& ( )$$</&#=!-)2/&# -.%53-/&' /3$"7:'2$6-7!(& (.$%$&'

/.$( $&'(-3 8 9-(&-3 !&"$( )$.'/&) -&"

'2$ &'(-.' 6-7!(

$#!3-'/&-&"73/'/& .'8,2$($/&- '$('7$($ $(($"-)'2$, .' 2$/%5!#&$".%53-/&')'-&")-55$&"$"-)&&$>!($ -3&#?/'2'2$5$'/'/&-&"-5$(!)-3'2$($ ?!3"($*$-3'2-'&'2$7-)/) -&/&)5$.'/&.&"!.'$"&

, 8/'/)-33$#$"'2-' .&'(-.'

3-7!($()?$($ !&"$&#-#$"7:'2$ "(5(-'/& &"/--' -/3 $-"8 -(-(/ '2(!#2 @) !(#- (-&)5(' %5-&: &'(-.'( /& 7($-.2 *' -(:-&- '/ /.-'/& , 0 6-7 -'$"

,,,0A4/3-'/& )$.'/&,, '2$,.'8-))!.28/)-33$#$" 1/&.$'2$/%5!#&$".%53-/&'/) !&"$"&-7($-.2 '2$ -(:-&-*''/ ,,,0A8/'?!3"7$-55)/'$'-"*$('

''2$)-%$-'&&$>!($ , 2$-(:-&-*''/ ,,,0A/))!$"7:'2$ 6-7!(%53:%$&'$5-('%$&'($-")/&'2$ 33?/&#'$(%)+

"#$% $ &'

()*+,- ./0 1*-+ (.**&2 -3& -+, ( # % . -+, ( 4 . / (*+ & 3* #536, ((& 6,, (%+7 84#(*6+"8 . 84%7 / 9*( * .*2(.*+ (-36, (1,//: 9,- *2 (*+& 3* */*&20* /,&,-;06 2;( . + (*+ 6& 3* ,( / . 66 1,(5 . - *5 0 - ,(+63,(5 *,6 /- . / *0 *, ( . (, #*2( 5, (% .* ; / . 03&6,+, ( . /,- ( ,.,+, (,(/ ..,+,65<'

;&6 !

=5/*, "!

>3*3?-/* $!

/ 1 /36/,? @!

>,/6 8!

>*(6

=3(6 !

(,0

(*,

** *,

,--,(5

: (0

=,(

:., (

*1(

!"448

.44$# A %

/,1(, 4!

,--* :,*- !

*,& >361(:,(5/ ,((+,6 ;;,--, (*(:+**2!B 2$ -(:-&- *' '/ /.-'/& "-'$" ,,,0A 5(2/7/') $%53:%$&' .&'(-.'3-7!(/&.$('-/& "1'(-#$$5')/&.3!"/&#

-/3$-") '2$ -(:-&- $#/& (%'2$"-'$ 5!73/.-'/& '2$ &'/ /.-'/&3/)'

"1'(-#$$5')-&" -/3$-") '2$ -(:-&- $#/& )'-&"$&!%$(-'$"'2$($/&/&.3!"/&#-(-(/-'1(,, -*/&# 2$-(" .!&)$3 ( '2$ 5-('/$) -' 3$&#'2 -&" 2-*/&# 5$(!)$"'2$53$-"/&#)&($.("8'2/)!('/) '2$.&)/"$($"*/$?'2-'

'2$/%5!#&$".%53-/&'.-&&')!)'-/& 1$.'/&) -&"

'2$,.'($-"/&'2$ 33?/&# '$(%)+ "! (*9(, ( . 0* 9,-, (- *5*,(5 ;06 2;( . + (*+ 6& 3*!

C/ 9* + (*9(- (2 0* 9,-, ( . /,- + * . (2 *36- ; /*3(* 0* /,&,,(57 *-*,+,(5 * *536,(5 / ;06 2;( . + (*+6& 3*7 *+ (*9(-(2+ (,, ( .6,+(+ 5*(3(*/,-+7-/66&03(,-/&61,/,;0*,- (;( . **;1/,+/;2)( /*; (/-7 *1,/.,( 1/,+/;2)( (/ 3-(*30-7 *1,/& /7(,( /+- .+ (,(3,(5+ (*9(, (1,/(,, (6.,( 1/,+/;2)( (/3(**30-. *9*223*,(5 1/,+/-3+/+ (*9(, (+ (,(3-.*+ (9,+, (. */ .,*--3+/+ (*9(, (!

$! /* ..(+-!

.(20*- (+ (*9(-(2 ./0* 9,-, (- ./,-+ *(2*36-;/*3(*. * 1/,+/( /*0(62,-6-1/*0* 9,7/-/66 & 03(,-/&61,/,;0*,- (;(. **;1/,+/;2)(

!"448

.44$# A %

/*; (/-7 *1,/.,(1/,+/;2)( (/ 3-( *30-7 *1,/& /! .(20*- (+ (*9(-(2 ./ 0* 9,-, (- ./,-+ *(2*36-;/*3(*. *1/,+/ ( /*0(62,-6-1/*0* 9,7/-/66&03(,-/&6 1,/ ,;0*,- (;( . * *; 1/,+/ ;2 )( /* ; (/-7 *1,/.,(1/,+/;2)( (/ 3-(*30-7 *1,/& /!B .-'$#(/.-))$('/&2-)7$$&%-"$&7$2-3 '2$5$'/'/&$( '2-''2$($/)& -/3$-"?&$"7: -'-(-(/89-(&-3'/))!7%/''$"

'2-' ?&)- "1'(-#$$5'-'-(-(/ $3/-&.$2-)7$$&53-.$"

!5&-.$('/ /.-'$/))!$"7:'2$1'-'/&1!5$(/&'$&"$&'8-(-(/('2$(&

-/3?-:) 1'-'/&"-'$", 53-.$"&($.("-'&&$>!($ A-&"

?2/.2/)''2$ 33?/&#$

$.'+ C :

/,-,- +*,.2/ * *,,612:, ( - ( /9 (2 ,6 1( ( + (* 66 &2 !!7

* *,!,-( 0*-+*,&,612:, (7 : *5 0 -0* 9! .*2( ,.,+, (!

1 *? .6 ,(5(*(-0 *,-&,(5+**, 3,6 : *50 &2+ (*+ *00 ,(&2!!!B 2$.&'$&') )!.2.$('/ /.-'$-($&'"/)5!'$"7:.!&)$3 ($5($)$&'/&#'2$($)5&"$&' '/)-3)'2$5)/'/*$)'-&"'-<$&&7$2-3 '2$5$'/'/&$('2-'

'2$))/)'-&'6-7!(%%/))/&$($&'(-3 8/&/)'(: 6-7!(2-)7$$& /))!/&#3/.$&)$-)5(*/"$"!&"$(1$.'/&, '2$,.' (%'/%$' '/%$-&"/'/)/&5!()!-&.$')!.23/.$&)$#(-&'$"'2-''2$?(< 3-"/&#8 !&3-"/&# -&" '(-&)5('-'/& /) 7$/&# .-((/$" !' '2(!#2 '2$ 3/.$&)$" .&'(-.'(-'-(-(/*$&)!.2-))$('/&2-)&'%$'?/'2-&:($7!''-3& 7$2-3 '2$($)5&"$&'

A 2$($/)-&'2$(($3$*-&'-)5$.' '2$%-''$(2$1'-'$*' 2-) 53-.$" & ($.(" - )2(' ($53: '2$ /&-&./-3 %%/))/&$(

(/&./5-31$.($'-(:'*'86-7!($5-('%$&'8-(:-&--&"?2$($/&/' 2-)7$$&)'-'$"'2-'-)5$(-%$&"%$&'.-((/$"!'7:'2$$&'(-3*' ?$ 0,,0B!&"$('2$,.'8'2$-55(5(/-'$*'/&'2$.-)$

/)'2$$&'(-3*' 2$-%$&"$""$ /&/'/& '2$C55(5(/-'$ *$(&%$&'D/) !(&/)2$"7$3?+ !.,(,, (- # %(/,-+3(6--/+ () /*1,-*D3,*-7 #% 00* 0*, 9*(;(B;(-

#,% ,(*6, ( (-&6,-/;(,(*-0+ .1/,+// 00* 0*, 9*(;(3(* /(3-*,6,-03-+7

$8# $ . $8%,-/(*6 9*(;(7/(*6 9*(;(E #,,% ,(*6, ( (2 /*-&6,-/;(7/ 9*(;( . /:,(1/,+// /*-&6,-/;(,--,3!B E2-'$%$(#$)'2$($ (%/)'2-'7:*/('!$ '2$-%$&"%$&'

.-((/$"!'7:'2$*' &"/-/&'2$"$ /&/'/& '2$C55(5(/-'$ *$(&%$&'D?$ 0,,0B'2$55(5(/-'$*$(&%$&'/&'2$.-)$

/) '2$ $&'(-3 *' &"$( )!.2 ./(.!%)'-&.$)8 '2$ /%5!#&$" .%53-/&'-&"5()$.!'/&$&)!/&#&'2$)'($&#'2 -5($*/!)-(:-&- *''/ ,,,0A8.-&&')!)'-/& & '2$ ($53: 53-.$" & ($.(" 7: '2$ 6-7!( & (.$%$&'

/.$(89-(&-3($3/-&.$2-)7$$&53-.$"!5&-"$./)/&"-'$",

'2$/*/3!"#$1(/*& 89-(&-3/&/*/31!/'

@ '.&'$&"

'2-''2$.%5$'$&'.!('2-)-3($-":)$''3$"'2$%-''$(-'($)'-&"-(-(/

-/3$-"?!3"7$.&)/"$($"-)- -/3$-"?&$"7: )-)' -''(-.''2$5(2/7/'/&$&*/)-#$"!&"$('2$-(:-&-*''/ /.-'/&"-'$"

,,,0A *$& )!.2 )!7%/))/& /) ?233: %/).&.$/*$" /*/3 1!/'

@ ?-)-)!/' ("$.3-(-'/&-&"5$(%-&$&'/&F!&.'/& /3$"7:

.$('-/& 5$()&) /& - ($5($)$&'-'/*$ .-5-./': 2-*/&# 7$$& $&#-#$" -) .&'(-.'!-33-7!(-&"?$($.3-/%/&#'2$7$&$ /' ($#!3-(/G-'/&2$)!/'

?-)"/)%/))$"7:'2$/*/3!"#$1(/*& 89-(&-32$/))!$) (-%$"

?$($-)!&"$(+

% C//*/06,(,..(6,-0*- (-* (,6. **536*,<, (,(-*9,+,( (/&-,- . -(, *,27,.- 1/..+F % C//* / + (*+ 6& 3* -2-; ,- & 6,-/ ,(

* *, ,6 ,( 9,1 . / ( ,.,+, ( !

F "!

C//*/06,(,..(6,-0*- (-*(,6 0*;((,(G3(+, (-665F $!

C//*/06,(,..-/9( +3- .+, ( .,6( ;,(,(/0*-(-3,F C//*/06,(,..-*- 00 .,6/0*-( -3,&+3- ./,*+(+ (3+F @!

C//*/06,(,..--/ 36/9.,6/-3,3(* ** 36 !!7,.- 1/..+F 8!

6,.!B &) -(-)))!$ -)'?2$'2$(.&'(-.'3-7!():)'$%/) -73/)2$"/&-(-(/ -/3$-"/&*/$? '2$&'/ ,,,0A '2$ 7)$(*-'/& %-"$ 7: '2$ .!(' ?-) '2-' -) 5$( *' -(:-&- '/ /.-'/& "-'$" 0,,,0A > , '2$ .(($.' 5)/'/& /) '2-' '2$ .&'(-.'3-7!():)'$%-'-(-(/ -/3$-"2-)7$$&-73/)2$" 1!.2

/&"/&#-&"7)$(*-'/&/)&3:-($ 3$.'/& '2$.&'$&') '2$*'

-(:-&-'/ ,,,0A /&"/&#2-)7$$&($'!(&$"-)' ?2$'2$('2$($-.'!-33:$>/)')- -/3$-"-'-(-(/?&$"-&".&'(33$"

7:'2$

!('2$(%($8/'%-:7$)$$&'2-''2$($)5&"$&'?2/.2/)-?/&# '2$$&'(-3*'2-) /3$"-.%53-/&'-#-/&)''2$ ?2/.2/)-3)- 7":.(5(-'$ '2$$&'(-3*'&-)2('-

/"-*/' '2$$5!':2/$

6-7!(%%/))/&$($&'(-3 89$&"(/:-1-"-&82-&"/#-(253-.$"& ($.("8/'2-)7$$&"$5)$"'2-'/&("$(')$''3$'2$"/)5!'$($#-("/&#'2$ -553/.-'/& &'/ ,,,0A/))!$"7:'2$1'-'$ -(:-&-8 -1!7%%/''$$?-).&)'/'!'$"'$>-%/&$'2$/))!$ "1'(-#$ $5')/&.3!"/&# -/3$-") 2$1!7%%/''$$)!7%/''$"/') ($5(' - '$( 2$-(/&# '2$ 5-('/$) -&" )!##$)'$" ' '2$ $&'(-3 "*/)(: &'(-.'6-7!(-("'5(*/"$ !('2$(.3-(/ /.-'/&-7!''2$.*$(-#$

'2$ )-/" &'/ /.-'/& !('2$( )!##$)'/& ?-) %-"$ '2-' -55(5(/-'$ -%$&"%$&'%-:7$%-"$/&'2$5(2/7/'(:("$()%-</&#)5$./ /.%$&'/& -7!''2$-($- 5$(-'/&/& /& -/3$-")-'(-/3?-:5($%/)$)?&$"

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

0 )!)'-/&-73$/&/')5($)$&' (% 1!

/.$/''&'/.$'2-''2$/&)'-&'5$'/'/&2-".%$!5 ( 5($3/%/&-(:2$-(/&#& 7$ ($'2/)!('-&"?2/3$/))!/&#&'/.$ %'/&5(.$$"/&#)7$ ($'2$(/-3!('2-"7$$&)'-:$" 2$5($)$&'5$'/'/&/)-33?$"2$/%5!#&$".%53-/&'"-'$" ,, &&$>!($ -&"-335(.$$"/&#)$%-&-'/&#'2$($ (%8-($)$'

-)/"$

3!.<:

E2$'2$()5$-</&#@($-)&$"+ $)@ E2$'2$( $5('-73$+ $)@