Harbans Kaur Etc. v. Ajit Singh Etc.

  

       
 



   



   "

#$ %&' & (





         *#  +# ,$! .)/

# +# , .)/

#

 +#

0  .)/

+# /) ### .)/

##  

 !"#

!$ ',  #

!  ,   1

  #  ## )  12   !

33# / )12 4$ $--

)12 + ) 6!

-'#1$ !.+3 7,  

##  ## 8'#1$ !9:/)

- $3 #))

) ;   $ )

,($# # 3, 7,  

# #  ##  8)

)9:   - # / ,!

)  5,, $## )          $    # ,  )   3!3  )#/3  12 5,!

)#/3 #$<1

#3# 3

*%
; 

 $- )  ) $

.  . #) - $3 #) )12 '#1$ !  1 3

)/

# < 1# / 2  ', '#1$ ! !!53 -

 + ,!2&- .;= #- , # #2 

:

.;= - ,7 #2 

:

&- 

#) )$ . =

+$!

 !  

!>

2 . ? ;. =
$ !@?

. = .A. =

6-

4.

Learned counsel for the claimants-appellants has not challenged the income as assessed, however, the deduction towards personal expenses, the addition to be made towards the future prospects, multiplier applied and the amounts awarded under the conventional heads i.e. funeral expenses and loss of estate, loss of consortium are stated to be not in accordance with the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the cases of National Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. [(2017) 16 SCC 680], Magma General Insurance Company Limited vs. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram & Ors. [(2018) 18 SCC 130] and N. Jayasree & Ors. vs. Cholamandalam M.S General Insurance Company Ltd. [2021(4) RCR (Civil) 642].

 * #    >

# )  $ !  #  #   &$# 6- 2, / !2 #3$

$ -$ !#

)21

-

     ; & . , 3 1

- 12

# )$ !# 

- 

5,5 #-2 )12 '#1$ !.   #)3!2 $ , !)

)5 1$ 2

#

 )

  -#

-# .-$!

 ! #8A95$!)1 

89 !

5!

))51291!

 

#!

"

7$ # :', '#1$ !,  - 2 )) 5 #)!

$ $#  # 

5 2

# .

 01 )5 3

3?

)# 3$!

# #2., .

))  B5$!)1 5 #)$ $#  # !

))51291!

 *# 2

,7$ # :

3  / 5

 )

) 5  $- ## ).  -

 ,  1

$3, 12 . $-1 #)

5. )$  1 =&

,

!1  -

C. = 5 #)$ ! ?

.

C. =!

). =

,

5 #)! !# $- C #)3!2. # 5#< )-

5,, D

  $) # &- .;= #- # #2 

:

.;= #-
$ $# *#  B C.;= 7.;EA:

)$ = 7C.;C:

C +$!

 ! A A C?A? A. .;A=

! 

2 >@

C. =
$ !@?

C. =  ?  . = >  ! # $-

 !

F A..;A=

!  6-

!  6-

)  12  '#1$ .A. = @, )  -$   -

A..;A= ;.;;.;;A=

!: .A. = )12'#1$ !:

A 6!

, !! !1  

#

CB $-#-

!3

 !!#

!G



, )-

 # - )! 1! 2# -

, !!1 #)  &/ 5  )  12  91!

 

%&'

%&()*+ &'  !,

+ &  6C. 

!$!

 , -$  1  ## )12#

&$# 6- 2 1 < $ 7:

5 , #)  ?  5

< #-  ) 2 ', $!

#     1 <

$ 7:  !3  5 ,  # 4$

 )$-     $ #   , !!  1 $#, )  12   !

    #   D  &$# - 25 , #) 55

<#- ) 2 )

)$!, !!1 ) 12# D&$# 6- 2 

#/ #

5 ,

#)$#5

<



!35 ,$  )



   & / 5   1/  )$.  #) ) 12 '#1$ !-)

!

) !!5 #)3!2 * )3

. 2. !

))  ) #   $      ,# 0

/ H,

<3=

  I H,

#

 I