Ved Parkash Goel v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"# "
$
"%&"
"
'
%
"
"
$'"% (
$ ) $**+ ,( -( .(
!" #$ % % " # #&'(& /
)%*+ # ## %#
!" #$ % % " # #&'(&
#* ", -
!" #$ % % " # #&'(&
.0
# .*+ #,$ -
!" #$ % % " # #&'(& %"+
1#2 %( ! 3 4
$ 3( # "%$"!( % 3
/ 012&234 (562478 &89&8*29&8:4 (5624 ;8'
*22182(72<4 (5624 2('*9024 (5624 )&8224 (5624 02=2(894 (56242( ,34 (5624 ;8'&CWP-3132-2020, CWP-3473-2020 and CWP-5932-2020 with Petitioner-in-person in CWP-3473-2020.
Mr. Rahul Dev, Addl. A.G. Haryana.
4
$ 3( # "%$"!5 !
%"2
)535> (623 &&9&4 8 '& ?268 ; 7 '&2?>(6((?@2600<9(>0 96663@48 ;26& 2 ?>A26(;0 *6 74 8 '6 4( 3 )
9
B
:>(6&;A8083@?2&6'& ; 8 ' 7; CC 2 '2 78 8& 8 '& CC '& 6332>9&4 ?@ 233@ ;A> 8& '2@ 2& ' 9'72( 5&( 0(;( '2@ &623& ; D >&E 8 9?36:&'20;82;"2@2248&27 '82&?;3(
8;26&;862&2828'<(8 &'( )>2 '20 2& 2 &&&2 > 8 @2 CFG ?> &36( ?@ 8 "2@22 9?36 56 00&&;&8H" B"72&'0(8'&; A695 >2(8&9'292(2&&968 CCC "72&7:>8'2@&623;#& G 7;GC C 786872&5&(#& G7;CC (&'8 6&'(>'2@&6238&623;#& G ?>8'2@ &623;#& GFG68'2@;8'72& 6&'(> 78 8 ?2&6 '2@ 7868 72& ?> (27 ?@ 8 '486 % F;72&;3(?@8' ; >2 ; 8 6&'(> '2@ &623 8 '2@ 23 ?> (27?
@80 8'&966((8&20789'8 ?;;'2@&623;#& GFG72&32&(80)& 23&9(&'9(828<9(>0'2&&( F;72& 68233>( 9' 8 "B?
G ) & &9?0( 82 7; CC4 8 2 ; "2@22 ;98 5&( 8 '2@ &623& ; >& ; 9?36 :& '20 5( !26 '20 %;62 (2( C C 02( ;;65 ;0 CC & ' 8 5&( 6&'(>'2@&62348'72&3(8'2@&623 ; #& F4 F4I ,2( 2@ ) & 89& 6(( 82 8 '?6203(;A2;8&'&8'2@&623 7868 72& A(( 8 >& ?@ 8 &'(2 ; "2@22CC8'2@&623;#& F2( 2&'#93 ;8#5&( ]&4C402(2&82 '&&893(?3&&82GJ;0090;8'2@;8 '2@&62389>?2(2(>2('2@2268(85&( '2@&6236&'(>8'2@&623;0786880'3@ (
29& &0323@ '326( '&& 2''268( 8& 92(2?968;7'&72337(?@8&95(
!"#
$ "
!"B F -& 2 ''23- %CGG;3(2& 2;"2@222(28 &2@2'23$2(252(28B72& (&0&&(?@25&168;8&95(<9(>0(2(
G
-2( 69&3 6(& 82 8 &2( (& 825 232(@22(;23@2(6#93 ;8#5&( & #93&4C46323@6'2&82'&62?3&&82 GJ;0090;8'2@;8'2@&62389>?2( 2(>2('2@2268(85&('2@&6236&'(>8 '2@&623;0786820'3@(48648&2(?; 9>8825?A((8' C -2(69&3;8&'(2488 82(4&9?0&82589>8&(&'9(828'2@&623 ; 8 ' 72& '326( 8 '2@ ?2( ; #&
FI , #&C,2('2@48754&&9?0(828 ' ( ;0 8 '& ; A695 > CCC 2( 8 72& >2( 8 '2@ &623 ; #& GFG 7; CC 2& ' 8 (& '2&&( ?@ 8& 9 CF % F; )&&9?0(828'&'2@>'& 8 '2@ ?2( 7868 & 02 ; 8 '& ; 9'(> >2(&68'(2&2 A695 >4 864 8& '& 62 ? ;A( 8 '2@ ?2( ; 9'(> > ) 825 82( 8 32( 69&3 2''2> ; 8 &'65 '2& 2& 733 2& ( 2:2&8 ,34 '
2''2> '& 2( 825 23& > 89>8 8 (690& 2''((23>788'&' 838 ;26923 2&'6&2(&'9 2( & 23&(&'9828'72&(27>'2@8'2@ &623 ; #& GFG 7; CC 7868 &968 '2@ ?2( 72&5&(#& F48648?<62:?@8 &'(& 82 &2( '2@ ?2( ?> 2''362?3 8 9'(> > 2( 8 ' 825> ( 2& 2 A695 >4 (@ 8 ?; & &9&22?3 8 '&&?>(0(8?2&&;832&'2@8272& ?>(27?@20'3@2(&('(8'&?> 83(?@8068'2@&623&(&'948&'(& 62&9?
082589>880'3@72&(27>&232@ 8>8 '2@ &623 2( & 3( '2@ 8 6&'(> '2@ ?2(487542&872&&5>237'&482&'6;8 32&'2@&623793(?>(2(8'&793(?;A( 8'2@?2(2&793(?2''362?
8 &'(2 & (&'9> 8 6&'(> '2@ &623 ; 8 ' 2( 8 &232@ ?> (27?@80 893&('&6?828'&82&? 6236932(8?2&&;'2@?2(2''362?382:83(?@ 2(5(9234284893&60'32828'&82&
F ?0090GJ;8'2@&6232786820'3@&(27> 8&&232@
8 ' ( ' CC 8 '2@ &623 ; #& GFG 7868 72& 5&( 1
F 8'&&?>&>3632&&2(825>?& 83( ?@ 8 "B?3 9'0 9 8 29825 '960802;%2:22 &+;)(24 '( 2& C
G4 8 ' 62 ? (;;2( ;0 8 0'3@& 78 ( 2; CC 968 ?; 72& A(( &0323@ '326( 0'3@& 8 02;
$ "
!"#
!" %"
"64 8 &'(& 2 32?3 (&?9& '& 8 '4 ?@ 6236932> 8 &2( ?;& 8 6&'(>'2@&6232(0&;#93 ;8"2@22 5356&( ]&4C G - 8 (;93 ? ( ?@ 8 &'(& 78 2 '(; 08&;86';6;(6'@;8&( 2( 8 5&( '&2@ ?;& ? 32&( 8 ' 782;98'(;08&
8?;&?32&(23>78&KGJ' 290)62&8&2('&2@?;&232&(78 8 '( 2& 2;&2(4 8 ' &8233 ?60 3( & K FGJ ' 290 ;0 8 (2 ; &9 ; 8
'&7'47868&9682((23;262332?3@02@ ? 65( ?@ 8 2 ;0 8 > ;;623 ;;623& &'&?3;(32@(6&02:> F
8'&7'&&2((&'&(;2?5 0& (>0&62''362&4;2@4&823323&&2(& (&'&(;266(>3@ C '86'@ ; 8 ( ? '326( 8 66( ;3& ":;: ,5 .(
4
$ 3( # "%$"!
<
! $'