Rakesh Kumar v. State Of Haryana
!"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2 #,
!
00#..3+$ 34#," '*3% "3, 5"3..#+)#( $"# &'()*#+$ -6 5-+715$1-+3+(,#+$#+5#%#5-%(#(/8$"#$%13. -'%$6-%$"#-66#+5#'+(#% #5$1-+ 9 3+( :;<;(< %#3( =1$" #5$1-+ :;< -6 $"# %#7#+$1-+ -6
-%%'0$1-+5$>??;6-%,"-%$@$"#5$A< $1,$"#53,#-6$"#0%-,#5'$1-+$"3$-+
?$"#355',#( 71,1$#($"#"-',#-6$"#5-*0.31+3+$1+5-++#5$1-+=1$"$"#*-/1.#0"-+# 0%-71(#($-"1*/8$"#5-*03+8="#+"#=3,,#%71+)3+(-+$"#3,41+)-6 $"#0-.15#*3+"#71,1$#($"#0-.15#.1+#,-6615#="#%#355',#( 34#,"
'*3%*#$"1*3+(1+6-%*#($"#5-*0.31+3+$$"3$$"#*-/1.#0"-+#=3,1+ "1,0-,,#,,1-+3,$-.#+0%-0#%$83+($"3$"#"3(%#5#17#(35-*0.31+$=1$" %#,0#5$$"#%#$-#(#*3+(#(3,'*-6
B3,/%1/#3+(3,,'%#($"# 5-*0.31+3+$$"3$"#=-'.(#C-+#%3$#"1*6%-*$"#5%1*1+3.53,# !
#C0%#,,#("1,1+3/1.1$8$-038$"#/%1/#-6
B55',#(3)%##($-$34#3 ,'*-6
B 5-*0.31+$ =3, .-()#( =1$" $3$# 1)1.3+5# '%#3' */3.33,"#"3(5"-,#++-$$-)17#/%1/#$- -+,$3/.# 34#," '*3% !'("71%1+)"="-=3,$"#5-*0.31+3+$!:3%43," "3+(="- =3, $"#,"3(-==1$+#,,(#0'$#( $- 355-*03+8!"37#5-*0.#$#.8 $'%+#("-,$1.#$-$"#53,#-6$"#0%-,#5'$1-+"#$%13. -'%$5"-,#$-%#5-%( 5-+715$1-+(%3=1+)0%#,'*0$1-+'+(#%#5$1-+ ;<-6$"#%#7#+$1-+-6
-%%'0$1-+5$>??
:
#3%+#(,#+1-%5-'+,#.300#3%1+)6-%$"#300#..3+$7#"#*#+$.8 ,'/*1$$#($"3$1+$"#.1)"$-6$"#%3$1-.31((-=+/8$"#-+A/.#'0%#*#
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
: ,'00-%$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+53,# $1,$%'#$"3$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+#,$3/.1,"#($"%-')"$"##71(#+5# -6!D$"#-661513.=1$+#,,,"=3% "3+(="-=3,,#%71+)3,#",1.(3%
3.43$"3$%#5-7#%8-6$"#$31+$#(5'%%#+58+-$#,=#%#%#5-7#%#(6%-*$"# 0-,,#,,1-+-6$"#355',#("#E'#,$1-+$"3$3%1,#,6-%5-+,1(#%3$1-+1, ="#$"#%30%#,'*0$1-+'+(#%#5$1-+ ;<-6$"#5$53+/#(%3=+/8$"#
-'%$1+$"#3/-7#,0#513.635$,3+(51%5'*,$3+5#,-6$"#53,#$-%#5-%( 5-+715$1-+3,3)31+,$$"#355',#(
+353%#6'.%#3(1+)-6#5$1-+ ;<-6$"#5$61+($"3$$"# 0%#,'*0$1-+5-'.(/#(%3=+-+.8="#+3+355',#(355#0$#(-%3)%##($- 355#0$ -% 3$$#*0$#( $- -/$31+ 6-% "1*,#.6 -% 3+8 -$"#% 0#%,-+ 3+8 )%3$16153$1-+-%3+873.'3/.#$"1+) ?
$1,3=#..,#$$.#(0%-0-,1$1-+-6.3=$"3$*#%#355#0$3+5#-6 $31+$#(*-+#8-%%#5-7#%8-6$31+$#(*-+#8(-#,+-$ #,$3/.1,"$"# 5"3%)#,'+(#%#5$1-+9-6:;<;(<-6$"#5$"#0%-,#5'$1-+1,/-'+($- #,$3/.1," $"3$ $"#%#"3( /##+ 3(#*3+( ="15" 0%#5#(#( 355#0$3+5#-6 )%3$16153$1-+3,-$"#%=1,#$"#3/-7#5"3%)#,(-+-$,$3+(.#)3.,5%'$1+8 > +
1$"3,/##+"#.(/8$"#-+A/.#'0%#*# -'%$3,6-..-=,
!"##$% & !
# !"## ' (
) * + * #,#$$$$
F
"# 3/-7# %3$1- "3, /##+ 7#%/3$1* 6-..-=#( 1+ $"# .3$#% (#51,1-+1+ ! "
# $%
& '( )%( %*%) '') + , (% , ="15"
%#3(,3,6-..-=,
-.
( "/ * +#, 0 1 23$/ * +#,#$$$4$ 0
* +#, 0 5* -.
0 * + * #,#$$$4 $ 0 *
6 0 * -. 0
D $"3,/##+53$#)-%153..8"#.(1+$"#3/-7#(#51,1-+,$"3$$"#%# ,"3.. /# 3 0%--6 6-% (#*3+( 3+( 355#0$3+5# -6 )%3$16153$1-+ $- (%3= 0%#,'*0$1-+$"3$$"#355',#("3(355#0$#(/%1/#3,0#%#5$1-+ ;<-6$"# 5$ +$"#1+,$3+$53,#$"-')"$"#%#1,0%--6$-,"-=$"3$$31+$#( *-+#8=3,%#5-7#%#(6%-*$"#0-,,#,,1-+-6$"#355',#($"#%#1,71%$'3..8 +-#71(#+5#$"3$$"#355',#((1((#*3+(3+(355#0$#()%3$16153$1-+$-(- -661513.637-'% :
+71#=-6$"#3/-7#3*-6$"#5-+,1(#%#(71#=$"3$$"#$%13.
-'%$"3,*1,5-+,$%'#($"#300.153$1-+-6#5$1-+ ;<-6$"#5$3+((%3= 0%#,'*0$1-+-6355#0$3+5#-6/%1/#/8$"#355',#(="#+$"#%#=3,+- #71(#+5#$-(%3=,'5"0%#,'*0$1-+"#%#6-%#$"#355',#(1,#+$1$.#($- 35E'1$$3.-+$"#3/-7#)%-'+( #3%+#(,#+1-%5-'+,#.6-%$"#300#..3+$(%#=$"#3$$#+$1-+-6 $"# -'%$$-$"#5-*0.31+$.-()#(/8!3+(,'/*1$$#($"3$*3$#%13. 5-%%#5$1-+,"3(/##+*3(#$"#%#1+ $1,"1,6'%$"#%,'/*1,,1-+$"3$$"# 0.35#="#%#$"#1..#)3.)%3$16153$1-+=3,355#0$#("3,/##+5-+$%3(15$-%1.8 0%-$#(/8$"#0%-,#5'$1-+
!?="-1+7#,$1)3$#($"#53,#3(*1$$#($"3$$"#%#"3(/##+ ,'5"-7#%=%1$1+)6-'+(1+$"#5-*0.31+$'$"#53$#)-%153..8(#0-,#($"3$ "#"3(+-$*3(#,'5"3.$#%3$1-+ +-$"#%=-%(,1$1,6-'+($"3$,'5" 3.$#%3$1-+"3(/##+1+$%-('5#(-+.8/85-*0.31+3+$/#6-%#$"#5-*0.31+$ =3,61.#(+$"#,1$#0.3+1$=3,*#+$1-+#($"3$$"#/%1/#=3,"3+(#(-7#% $-$"#355',#(-'$,1(#$"#-6615#-6$"#355',#('$$"#0%-,#5'$1-+"3,
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
'.3$1 !"