High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2115/1987dismissed

Daya Kishan v. Kanwal Lal Andors

2015-04-08Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj19 pages

!""#$%&'( )* +% ,-, ."

,/'0#/$

11- 2

- 333333 #

!""4''%&&& )*

11- 2

- *.5 61*

## $% &

(

) * +,))-+)./0

! #* 1

(

- * +2//)+)...

3333333

0 4 1 # ## 1*

,))- ")./0 1*

2//) ")...&

" " * +,))-+)./0 #

)+# "" " $! *

+,+

))55 ")./-% 1" "

+ 67 # "

# "" # #

,$% #

))80 85 ), )./-& "* *& 1 )

"" # 1 # "" # #

,$% # &

& 9 & # "!

# ""1 " : 4 " #

)+# "" &" ## + "

) " " #

)+# ""

, ; ' * 1 "

1 # !1 '1 4 < & = " # # + $ % 4

),5>,82 );>>5>) )5$)2%>>0>, / . )8 )) ), ); ,8>; ,0>>/ .>) ), ); -;>>)>, /)>>)0>, )/>, ,2>) /0>>5>) 0 );>, )2 //>>,>, ;>; />, . ), );>) 1)2)9 )5? $'%4 @ & 1

),5>,82 " ,.5$)+- % ;88$)+.

% 1 , 9 )2 ? 1 &

4 "!* ",22A ? $%

' #

# A 1 "

B < @ = A " "

& & & " !1'1 4 < &

>( " 1 ? C 4 1"? ( = " ? * = " 1

+;+ "

,2 8- )./2 # # "

+ 6%

' * 1 "

, "

+ $%

1 #

)$ %

# & 1

),5>,82 );>>5>) )5$)2%>>0>, / . )8 -;>>)>, /0>>5>) 0 );>, //>>),

E ")>, 4 9

! "!1 @ # " 9 = # # " 9 9

# # " 9 +

120 9 . $% @ 9 @ & 1 9

;88 1) 9 . "

),5>,829 @

)$'% #

" # " 9

1 "

# 1 " "

= ( F

)$% #

; * "

+ $%

),5>,82 ,0>>/ .>) ), ); //>>. ;>; ,>, />, //>>);>) ),

E ")>, 1259 5 9 !1# " *

# "

@ #

& 1

,.5 1 ) 9 - 1

),5>,82 " #

)$'% #

G*4 1 "

& " "

G+

+2+ ) +) *+) 4+) " "

)$% #

# """

+ $% 1

),5>,82 )2$)5%>>)) ), ); ,8>;$,8>)% /0>>)2 /)>>)0>, )/>, ,2>) 12/9 ; #

)$ % # 9 # "

, #

,$%$% # " 9 # " 9 = # #1 $% @ & "!1'1

" 4 " ! * & 1 ,22 A & & + B 4 1"? C = "7 & = ? ( "4 "!*? * = " *

&= $% 4#

D 1 "

B < H I " "

9 & 1

)$% #

;

4 9 $, %9# # 4 1 &

# "" "

, ; 1! )J 9 $ % # !

) # & !

* 4 K 1 "

) - 4 ,2 - )./2"

& ! # "" "

+-+ ' * 1 E 1

1 "

# "" " "

# "" # # 4D 1 "

= B< # "

, : "

, ; '* 1 &

)+# ""#! # " # 1

" 85 ), )./-

#! # "" # 1!

& # ,2 8- )./2 4 " #

)+# ""

! # 4# "" 1

1 85 ), )./- # & &9 "

) "

" & ! # & 1 = " # # "

, ;

4 # !

))80 & 1 1 "

,2 8- )./2? ! # " # &

& " E# 1 1

)+# "" 9 ## + "

, $ %

A # #,$% # & ! 1 " 1

" & '* 1 # = " # # # "+A #

" 4# "" " 1

! 1 7 "

,2 8- )./2 & # !

+5+ # = ! # # "

& # "" &

1 #

A " E 1 " # & # "" ' * 1 #

, " ## ! 1 " 4 85 ), )./- # !

))80 ), )./- " 1 !

)+# ""

# & "

# "M! 1N

# &" # & 1 1"

& # A #

# =! 1 # ;88 1 " 1 & 1 1

) )8 888 & 1 1

+##

, ""+ # # 1

" 1 ""

1+ $)% C & "

& # ,2 - /21

"" OF $,% C # "

)J9"

)1 "

OF $;% C "

& E 1 "# ,2 - /2& # ""

,1 OF $2% C 5 ), /-

))801 ! &

& 1 OF $-% C # ""

" OF $5% C # "" " OF $0% C

# "

OF $/% C

! # #"

## " OF $.% C # ""

## " " 1 #

+0+ &

A OF $)8% C # ""

1 #

; # & O7"

"" OF $))% "

*& 1 ) ! 1 )) ), )./5 # ""+#

(

)

# # "

,2 8- )./2 & # ,$% #

85 ), )./-# !

))80

& 1

1 " #

) # ! #

# (

" " " ## &

1 < &

$ % "

;!" 1

##1

" 1 & 1 # 1 ##"

+ $)% 4 "

BE ; & 1 # A 1

)+# ""

+ # 1 " "

$,% #

)+# """

# ! # # = " # # $;%

E& "

# #

# !

$2% B! ! 1

)+# ""

# ! # " " E &

, ; " 1 ! 1 # 1 A

+/+ * +2//)+)... ## +# "" " $! *

00; ,0 8- )./.% 1 1 " 1,59 ),& ' * 1 #

+ "

; "

& "

,2 8- )./2 85 ), )./-# !

))80 " 85 ), )./- 4 & " 1

&'* 1 ! " & 1 1

85 ), )./- & "*& 1) ##1 &

1 < & 1 1*

,))- ")./0 # 1 4 ##

# " 1 # # = ! 1 # 1

## '* 1 #

+ "

; # ",5 9 ), " & 1 9 >9

),5>,82 9 );>)>5>)$)+-% )2>,>0>,$)+0% /$/+8% .$/+8% )8$/+8%" ; ;8 888 "!

" #

+ "

) , " "' ## +# "" 1 !

& ""

+ "

) ," "!

+ "

2 -&E 1 8;

8) ).., 82 8, )..,"

.. "!

## +# ""1 1

589 ), " " "*

" 1"

)8 8- )./- 4 E! & =&

# ## +# "" & "C ,, 8) ).// 7 # &'

+.+ * 1"

1 #

#! 19 # "

;'* 1 9# #

) , E " # 1

1 " "" &

+ "

) , #

+ "

2 - # &

"## +# ""

7 # #

+ "

) ,& " # "

4 # & "

"'* 1 #

+ "

; "

,2 8- )./2 "" !*

))55 ")./- )) ), )./5 7

85 ), )./-# !*

))80 "85 ), )./- ' * 1

# & #

+ "

) ,

+ "

; ' * 1 !

4 # 1 *

###

))55 ")./0 " "

,2 8- )./2

1 #

'* 1

! ##

! +# 1 ## +# "" " " 9 1 #

P "

2 -! ! "

# 1

! " 1 ! 1 1

## +# "" # # 1 #

" 1 ""

+ $)% C " " # "" $ % "

; ' * 1 $ %

$ % # OF

+)8+ $,% C "

" # ""

; # OF $;% C

;8 /. E & "

; #

& #

2 - #

1 ,5 ), # "" 1 !

OF $2% C # "" +

" # OF $-% C "

) ,& " # & #

2 -

OF $5% "

! 1$ ! %

(

" ## +# """ ## & 1 < & ! 1 ,0 8/ )...

7 ! "

# # & * +,))-+)./0 4"

# 1 )22 9 )8 4 & ! # 1 ! "

,2 8.

)./2 4#

,2 8- )./2$BE ;% # # "

4# & "

## #0 1 "

+ 60 4 "

## 1

BE ; ,2 - /2 # # " "

7 !

& BE ; "

BE 2 E 1 ,2 - /2 & 1 ## #

+))+

1 =L ## C2 ,2 - /2" &

+ + =L !

& # & &

" BE ;

& 1 1

# !&

# 1

E 1 " # " ' 1 1 1 BE 2

1 & " ## + "

) ## C+) E

,2 - /2 #!

& E 9

9&9)J9 " "

E "

BE ; 2 1 9 1 ! # &

& ,2 - /2

=L #

< C;

BE ; 2

" C2 =L + + " ## + "

)

BE ;

# !

# 1 # 1 + E &

&! 4"

! # # !

+),+ 1 !

BE ; ,2 - /2 E 1BE 21 & #

& 1 1 # # : 4 "

9 # 1 " "

1!#

' * 1 # > &

F & " !

# 1 "

4 !=L !# !

" & " E 1

9 # & ' * 1 ! 1BE 2 & 1 "

1 ! " "

& & 1 '* 1 4"

& #

9"" # " 7 " "

A 1

= N&*# 1 & ! "" ""

&! #. 1 "

+ 6.

1 # !

# "

& # 9

"" ! " " 1

& # !

! 1 #

+);+

' ! " "

1 & " " 1 "

"" #

! " 1 # "

" & 1& # 1

" 4 " 1 1 ! & #A #

! & "

" 7 !&

< Q # ;52 9

1# &! 1 1 " 1 &E ? Q4 # # ##

# & 1

A ##

" # "" 1 < 1 1 ! & # A #

! & "

" 1 !

& # & ! # " " #

1 1 9 1 ""

1 #

Q 4 & 1

"" 1 1 ## " " & &

& ! & " 4

! 1

& # 1 1"

# "

# 1 " " "

# %7,8

7 + 98 :;, ; +; "

" +8 ,- <,+98 !,=,!! 9+: +; = ,-

+ ! - - - + ;,= < !,-+ ,9+, % :+;, -+!%

+ +, +;-7, +;; !-%

+)2+ %:,- !9+!87,-+ , +;!7, ,-+ +, % - , >-+, ;+ ,- :;8 +; + 7 ?%7,8? ;- + 9 ! -+! , :,! - - - - + , ! :,+;, ,+- %! + 8 - +, - ;, -9+= +;- " - -:;78;=-7- +% + ! ++,+0 -79 % ,7 = ,% +;8 ;= -"- -

--, - - +;+ %+ !,-"+- -! % = ! +; %7,8 , -+! % %,;+, ,7- , + - ! :-+, +,707 8 ! 8 - ;% ,+-- %+,,+,+, ,-9+!=+,+-++ +, +7

-+ +,=:

@, +; , + -+%+; + 8 4 ! "

"# 1 " 1 & 1

!1 C " " 1 """ 1 "

" "

###

! ##

# # & 1#

" 1 9

9 " 1 " & " 4 B 1

# C 1 1 # 1

1 "

& #E #)8 "

+ )8 67

# & 1 "" ""

1 # # $)%4"

&& "

!" # !& " A & !

" # & ! & " $,% 4

& & " " $;% 4 " 1 &! 1

+)-+ $2%7

1 & " " 1

1 = & &

1 " " 1

## "

" 1 & "

## "

9 1

7 "

E 1 1 !&# "

" " " * )0$,%$% * )0$)%$&%$O% 1 "

# 1 &?$-%4& & #

" 1 ! ! # & # 9 1 & #

B! " #

& 1

# A "!

" # 9 1

& " 1 & # " "" 1! 1

? $5% B! " & " # # # &

& & " " 1 " A & " 1 " & 1 #

Q 4 1 # # & #E

1 "" 1

A 1 ## "

" 1 & ""

A 1 "

E 1 1 !&#

+)5+

" " "* )0$)%$&% "1

F E

BE ; 7"

# 1 &

! # & 7 ## "

" 1 &

& # 1

4 "

# & # " &

BE 2! '* 1E 1

# "

"# BE ;

$BE 2%1 & '* 1 4"

9 # 1" " 1 "

# & "+A # 7 ! # 1 B! "

! & 1! 1 # "

BE ;

4 # 1

7 "

# 1!

& "

BE ; "+A # "

BE ;& ,2 8- )./2 '* 1 " $! *

))80 ), )./-%9 1 '* 1 & " 12/9 )2 #

!& " 20 9 )5

+)0+ # " 4 " 1!

12/9 & 7 $! *

))80 " 85 ), )./-% "

BE ; #

+# "" # "

1 # &

"" "# &

BE ;

!1 # 1 # # "

BE ;

A "" & CE & 1

"" 1

# "

BE ; F # " 1 & 7"

1 " " 1"

" ( & A "A 1

* +2//)+)... ## +# "" " ! 1 1 " & ' * 1 &

" #

) , "

1 1#1# ' * 1 & " 2/ 9 ; " "

= "

E &

& " " & # "1! ##

,))- " )./0 C 1 1 ! ##

,))- " )./0 "

,2 8- )./2&

4 & ' * 1 #

& " "

+)/+

## +# "" & $! * (

))55 ")./-% & " ! 9

1 &'* 1 "

! 4 " & "# "

& !

" " 1 1"

" ( & A "A 1

## 9

A " & ! &

## $* + ,))-+)./0 * +2//)+)...%

,/'0#/$

+).+