High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2180/1987allowed

(O&M) Jaswant Singh Etc. v. Kesho Dass

2015-10-08Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages

!"#$#%&'&()* !'+!("&(,- $#%#!'#$ "-./,-0 '!($"-#.'

11#22!("'

3#.'/'

-4#'-!''

$#%#!'#$ "-./,-0 ' #'1($#("

) 50 4 0

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

-#.#&( -!$&2#$!'/&".$#%2!.!"&(""-###%""-!""-#;-!8# <#%9# +(#.' "-# '/&" 2!($7 /22; $#"!&2#$ &( "-# 12!&("7 ( !%%/(""-#&.-!8&(,<##(&(%("&(//'1''#''&(!'"#(!("'. 9.#"-!(-/($.#$;#!.'/($#."-##C1.#''!($&912&#$%(".!%"/!2

66 %($&"&('(#8#."#=#%" -#1#.9!(#("&(=/(%"&(+!'!2' '/,-"..#'".!&(&(,"-#$##($!(" .#'1($#("-#.#&( .9$&'6 1''#''&(,"-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'.9"-#'/&"2!($79#!'/.&(,? B!(!2' 9!.2!'7<;.%#!($+&"-/"$/#%/.'#2!+-#2!($ &'$#'%.&<#$!'B-!'.!'@*7@ A9&(/"-!($@

7!'1#."-# !9!<!($& . "-# ;#!. A6

8&22!,# !/2!"1/.7 #-'&2

!"-!(B" %%.$&(,""-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'7"-#12!&("&'!($ <#.#"-#97"-#&.1.#$#%#''.'6&(6&("#.#'"-!8#<##(&(%("&(//' 1''#''&("-#'/&"2!($!'"#(!(".9.#"-!(-/($.#$;#!.' -#.# &' !( #C1.#'' !($ &912&#$ 1.9&'# ( "-# 1!." "-# $##($!("

.#'1($#("!($-&'1.#$#%#''.6&(6&("#.#'"(""#=#%" "-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'.9"-#'/&"2!($-#12!&("&' !11#22!("'

-!8#9!$#%('&$#.!<2#&91.8#9#("'/1("-#'/&"2!($<#.# <.&(&(,(,&"/($#.%/2"&8!"&( -#;-!8#!2'%('"./%"#$%!""2# '-#$'!($.9'."-#&..#'&$#(%#'9#"-#2!($+!'!2' !%D/&.#$<;"-#0!($%D/&'&"&(#1!."9#("-#!..!(,#9#(". $.&(B&(,+!"#.-!'!2'<##(9!$#"-./,-/(&%&1!299&""## !($ ./&" <#!.&(, ".##' -!8# !2' <##( 12!("#$ <; "-# 12!&("&'

!11#22!("' !($ "-#&. .#!"-#.' -#; -!8# <#%9# %%/1!(%;"#(!("'"-#'/&"2!($+&"-&("-#9#!(&(,#%"&( "-# /(=!< #(!(%;%" A ' '/%-7 .&,-" +(#.'-&1!2'8#'"#$&("-#9("-#%99#(%#9#("1.1.&#"!.;

6?6 .&,-"'&("-# %%/1!(%;#(!("'%"*? -# $##($!("

.#'1($#("

$#(&#$ "-!"

"-# 12!&("&'

!11#22!("' . "-#&. 1.#$#%#''.'6&(6&("#.#'" !.# &( %("&(//'1''#''&(.-!8&(,<##(%/2"&8!"&(,"-#'/&"2!($. 9.#"-!(-/($.#$;#!.'"+!''"!"#$"-!""-#;-!8#(#8#.<##( "-#"#(!("'&("-#'/&"2!($ -##C1.#''.&912&#$1.9&'#+!' !2'$#(&#$ " +!'%2!&9#$"-!" $##($!(" .#'1($#("+!'"-# +(#.&(1''#''&("-#'/&"2!($ -#.#.#7"-#D/#'"&( 12!&("&'

!11#22!("'<#%9&(,%%/1!(%;"#(!("'/($#.#%"&( "-# /(=!< #(!(%; %"7 7 $#' (" !.&'# -# 12!&("&'

!11#22!("'!2'-!8#("!%D/&.#$"-#1.1.&#"!.;.&,-"'&( "-# %%/1!(%;#(!("%"7*?

.9"-#12#!$&(,'722+&(,&''/#'+#.#.!9#$)6 :-#"-#."-#12!&("&'-!8#<#%9#+(#.'"-#'/&"2!($<; "-# < %%/1!(%; #(!("' 3#'"&(, .1.&#"!.;

&,-"' %"7*A>

:-#"-#."-#12!&("&'!.##("&"2#$""-#&(=/(%"&(1.!;#$.> ?

#2&# -#2+#./."7!"#.$&'%/''&(,"-#.#8#(/#.#%.$!($ "-#'"!"#9#(""-#1!."&#'-#2$"-!""-#12!&("&' !11#22!("'-!8# (+-#.#.#%.$#$!'%%/1!(%;"#(!("'+#8#.7&"+!'-#2$"-!" "-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'!.#.#%.$#$!'"#(!("&("-#'/&"2!($

6@6 <!..&(,AB!(!2'A9!.2!'B-!'.!@*&(7?B!(!2'7<#!.&(, B-!'.!@

9&(!($?B!(!2'B-!'.!@

9&(-#.#.#7 &(=/(%"&(+!',.!("#$.#,!.$&(,'!&$B-!'.!(/9<#.'<;.#'".!&(&(, "-# $##($!("

.#'1($#(" .9 &("#.#.&(, &( "-# 1#!%#/2 1''#''&("-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'8#."-#'!&$2!($ ("-&'

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

!11#22!("'-#%1&#' .$#.'"-#.#8#(/#!/"-.&"&#'&("-&'.#,!.$-!8#<##(12!%#$( &2# !9"-#8&#+"-!""-#%(".8#.';!'"+-#"-#."-# 2!($-!'<#%9#'/.12/'!($+!'.&,-"2;.+.(,2;!22""#$""-#

6*6 12!&("&'

!11#22!("'&'(""-#'/<=#%"9!""#."-#1.#'#("$&'1/"# !($&'"<#$#%&$#$<;"-#%91#"#("!/"-.&"; -&'/."(2; %(&(#'""-#!%"!'"+-#"-#."-#12!&("&' !11#22!("'!.#&( 1#!%#/21''#''&("-#'/&"2!($7!'$#"#.9&(#$<;"-#2+#. /.".+-#"-#."-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'-!8#!&2#$"1.8#"-#&.

1''#''&(>"!2'%9#'/""-!""++.&"'!.#!2.#!$;1#($&(, <#"+##("-#1!."&#'.#,!.$&(,"-#2!($<#&(,$#%2!.#$'/.12/'!($ !22""#$""-#12!&("&'

!11#22!("'-#.#.#7"-&'/."+&22.#.!&( .99!B&(,!(;%99#("'("-#'!&$%(".8#.';&(828#$&("-# '!&$+.&"'."-#9!""#.'1#($&(,<#.#"-#.#8#(/#!/"-.&"&#' -# 1#./'!2 "-# .#8#(/# .#%.$ '-+' "-!" "-# =/$,9#("!($$#%.##1!''#$<;"-#2+#./."&'<!'#$(&($&(,' .#%.$#$!"#.,&(,"-./,-"-#.#8#(/#.#%.$ -#!11#22!"# /."-!'/1'#""-#&($&(,'("-#<!'&''9##(".&#'&(B-!'.! ,&.$!+!.&&("-#!9!<!($&'1.$/%#$<;"-#$##($!(" .#'1($#("

C7C!($C: !9"-#8&#+"-!""-#&.'"!11#22!"#/."#..#$&( &("#.#.&(, &( "-# &($&(,' !%"' .#%.$#$ <; "-# 2+#. /."

2!&("&'"?!.#"-#'(':!$-!+! !9!($12!&("& @&'"-#'(!(,/ !9"-#.#8#(/#.#%.$&'1#./'#$7&"+&22 9!B#/""-!""-#&($&(,'.#%.$#$<;"-#2+#./."!.#%..#%" ("-#%1;=!9!<!($&."-#;#!. A6

C 7!.$!.&0!2 +!'.#%.$#$&(1''#''&(""-##C"#("G'-!.#!($!'+!("

6A6 &(,-7 -!.!9 !2 !($ !"1!27 '(' :!$-!+! !9 +#.# .#%.$#$&(1''#''&(!' &("-#2!($<#!.&(,B-!'.! @*&(!'" ?6 7@ A&(/"- 6A !($@

6 &9&2!.2;7 &( "-# =!9!<!($& . "-# ;#!. AA6A C: 7 :!$-!+! !9!($!(,/ !9'('/22+#.#.#%.$#$!'

-#.#8#(/#.#%.$'.9"-#;#!.*6A(+!.$' -!8# <##(1.$/%#$ " %2!&9 "-!" "-# '!&$ :!$-!+! !9 !($ !(,/ !9+#.#&(1''#''&(!'"#(!("8#(&("-#%1;"-# B-!'.!,&.$!+!.&."-#;#!.'A6A?" ?6 @ C: 7&"

%9#'/""-!"'!9##(".&#'!.#.#2#%"#$+&"-'9#%-!(,#("-# B-!'.!,&.$!+!.&. 7"-#!.#!9#!'/.&(,AB!(!2'A9!.2!'&'

.#1."#$"-!8#<##($#2&8#.#$"2(&H!"&(#1!."9#("78&$# .!1!" $!"#$ /"B-!'.!@* &9&2!.

#(".&#'!.#/($&("-#'/<'#D/#("B-!'.!,&.$!+!.&."-#;#!.' @6 *"6 C: -#.#.#7&!(;%-!(,#&(B-!'.!

,&.$!+!.&-!'<##(9!$#.9;#!. @6 *.#,!.$&(,B-!'.!' @

!($@

9&(7 !' .#2#%"#$ &( B-!'.! ,&.$!+!.&' C !($ C? 7"-#'!9#&'("<&($&(,("-#12!&("&' !11#22!("' -# B-!'.! ,&.$!+!.& %!((" <# %-!(,#$ +&"-/" "-# %('#(" "-# 1#.'(.#%.$#$&(1''#''&("&'!2'("'-+(!'"-+"-# $##($!("

.#'1($#(".#,!&(#$"-#1''#''&( -#.#.#7"-#'# +#.#.&,-"2;&,(.#$<;"-#2+#./." #,!.$&(,B-!'.!@

"-#1''#''&(!.$!.&0!2#"%!' &''-+(

!9"-#8&#+"-!""-#&($&(,'.#%.$#$<;"-#&.'" !11#22!"#/."!.#1#.8#.'#!($!,!&('""-#.#%.$0#!.(#$'#(&. %/('#2..#'1($#("-!'.#2&#$/1("-#!/"-.&"&#'"-#1#C /." &(

*/1.#9#/."7* I ? */1.#9#/."7?!'+#22!'"-# !/"-.&";"-&'/."&(

! " #8#(/#0!+ #1."#.

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

!"-!(B"7&'.#'".#$ -#!11#!2&'!%%.$&(,2;!22+#$

0 * '=B'