High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1317/2017dismissed

Tinku Ram v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-02Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!" # $ #" &"" '( "

& ") * "+'( '

", &"* , '*'# $ % ----

' ./ 012 1

' "

0 " "

+ #)," % '213," """" 4 5'# &

'6 "%)7 +' "' +"

"', + , 1

% 81 6, ",%),

"),

%,6 '&

',6 8 ( 9)"

' 9 "

+'6, ) ""

',"%)

+ "

" ) ' , ' "," ")

", 1

' ")" # &

, %) / & $ +, 3," " """ , /(+ + :";/:56 "

%,6 '&

"( (, , (+ ""< % 81 ',

+" &

"")+ % +,"+,, "<+ , ")' , + " 9 " " % < , 6

",,% <,

," "

" 6"= " % '6,,, <,/(+ +:"+ ( ," , "

+, , , , ," 9 % ,% + ""%), 6 ," ", ",,% + , , ,

+ "+,+, ", " + >"

" <, ,6("" ,,/(+ + :"<, , "+ "6 ""<," ",% + , , 6 8

( 9)"

<, " ) "

,( 9)"

<,/(+ +:"

6( , +

9)"

("+, " <,"

+2( 6"("

" < ," " 6" , 6, , /(+ +:", (+"4&4<,

<, " 6 , ("/ +,<

"", ""

6"" " ,/(+ +:""

= , ' ,% 6,,"

./6 "",/(+ +"

"" +, , "(") "" 6 8 : " " , ' , /(+ + :"

" , ', "") 6%"/"

"6"+,'?:, '6,(",

9,6 , (+"4?4, "

",," "',"

', "")6 6,,&? ",@

" +,

1 :,9 )A

',/(+ +:"

6,"6, "")" &? " ,

%" 7&'&

'6, "+ ++, " "")

' "" , ,

% 7

, ' +"

" / 6 "+ ) ( ") "

011:

" +6,

",6"

"+,

,.B'# $ %'&, , 6"6,&? ",@

" A :2

'&? ",@

" ,.B'# $ %'&, ," +, % & "+, ""C9#D;6 "(,"" , ),

6 % ,, =A2 +;1 , ","

A2 +;1 " (+ ,"

+ , " " , " :" ,,

',"6" , "' ( + "

"# 2 ,%"(+, "

, "+" "

,6 + , ',6 , "+

, "+ )'6,,', + ) "

"+, "('," 9

#D/"?

"6"+,'#D ?* "%,$+,'#D? ",@

"'#D8/& $+,'#D1/ +, #DA % & "+, ," " ("

, (6 , "" " "#'6,, ," +"

"+, " ( + , 6" , % , , + +, ,6 , % ) ( (, ?, ","

, ,6 *(" )"(+( ?

#, , ""6,,6 )

"+,(', 9

D 0"

$ ' "

'( ? '

#, '6,, %" +,,

"" "+" +

0( %"

')6,,%+C9 ? , ,"+",

6 " 0A ,6

" %"

" ) ,6 /! ) ,", /,"9

', , 8

6 , ) 1

6 ) " , "+ "+

' " " " 7 +'

"' +"

" ( $

( ,

, ", "

, (

"" , (") ',6 "+ "+" " ") " ) '

;

," "+ ",""+" " " "

) " , $ ( "" , ++"( ,, ," ' 6,,6

6,6 ""+

", "+ "(")6 """

) "+,),

: "2"#, (+% %) , ;

" , " "+ , ) ' ,

6 6 21

%"(+, , ;

, ) "+ ) "' , )'6,( "

) "' , 2 ) ) " " ,"

+, 6 "+,), ,6 ""%" ' %$ , ",+ , % %; ") % , 7&;

)& ;/ = 8 06, , " , "+ 1 /, (, " " "+", E

(' "*", # $ %%++ ," +,,"" A ?" %, , 6 "(")

) #D ? * "%,$+, #D8//& $+,',/(+ +:"

, ( ) "," ")6,"+ " , (+

% ,"

,)6"" 9

+,%, , % ,) ,"+

%, " )

" 0"( ) %6, , E(, % +""( " %)6,,,) +,, (( (, , 6"+ ) + , ) ",(,

+(%),#D %6",)" , ") ( , % " %) , " %)9

+#D? ",@

"' "

6'6, , (C9#D;6,"+ " ), "") + "

, #DA % & "+,'6 , """,

" +6,

",.B'# $ %'&, " + " &? ",@

"/, (C9#DA;', , , , + " ,# +"

" , ,

" 6,, & ?, .B'# $ %'&,

,, ("," &? ",@

"?, , "")"

6,6 ,,""#D;" .B'# $ %'

&, +,6, , " 6,6 , ? &6""(,"

, " 6" 6,, " 2 ,(+ , , % "

",/(+ +:", " ( ( , , 6"+ )',

, )" +

, ",( , "

+ ( ""%"

( "+,"

" )

B " ", , ,6(" ,

+$ +, "" ( " ," +

<," , % % "(, "+ + , ( ) "

( )% ," "+"+ , "

, " , 6"+ ) ( , ?, ," ( " +"

%), , "+ "6 , 6 6 $ 6, , ") )

( % )' 6,, =

(" "

, , " ")

?6("'/ ) ", %(',6"(")'6, " ,6, ( )"( )6,, " %) 6,,,) +,, (( (, , 6"+ )"

+ , ) ",(,), , "9

6 ," "%

"6, 6 + 7 + , " $

# $#%$ , %"( , , 6 "") ,

( ")(

, ),"6 ," % " ) ," +

," "6 "%) " ",

6 ,

")"(1 ,6 6,

, + > " " & 6

, ,/(+ +:"6 , "") , ",,

8 , (, 6 , 1 , " ",, )% +" ) "%+ ""%), ,9 " $

'(%)*

# $ #+$ , %"(, 1 , "

",, 6,"+ ", ",% +,

1 /, ',"("), %" ,% +'

6,,, "")+ + ",, ",""'

"(1 6" % 0(", "

" " ,( %)," ',/(+ +:"

, "

, , + "+,+, ", " + >"" '6, %

,',6("', , ", , , "+ ", %"",""' % , ,"6 ) 1 ,

A B " ", , """$ ,-+

'(%)"

.,.*#$

'6,, 6, 6," ",, , % % "(") , % ' ,

/ "

' , % %"( , "= " "+ % ",%" " * >"' =

?6("' / , $ , ,

;

)

"?",",+"",6 , " ", , , % , /(+ +:" , % "")+"

, "

" '," 6," , "

",, , % 6,," "")+ "

,%)","6 , ,"6,%) ," ) ,(

2 B " ", + , $

, +, " ",, , % "" , ', +,"(")6 ,

( , $

, , , % , , "" ""(")"

" , '

6,, , 6 "")+ , % + + " , , " , $

, " )%=

6,," ", "" 6,,", "")+ )"

, ",$ """%) " ", "

","

1 ,, , % "" ,

"+ ",,"$ ""(%) " ",

))

$0 ', 6 6,"+ " " " 6 , (

, %+( "+ ",""

+, ", %" " + >"?","6 ) , ,""',= "($6

+, ,""+,+," ", " + > " " & " , $ , , ;

)

" ,

%), % (+,"("), ,

6,, %) D0"

$ %+ )6 , ) C(

, ) ( ? '

#, '%+ , )' % , % " , "(") )

)

%, D , , )

" ," , "(, "+ + , ( ) "

( ) , "" ) % "

% 9 ", + "

, ","

6, ) "

,"%) ,6+ , , 6 , "

"+ ", "',

"+ "+" " ") "'6,,,

""% "

" =

) ,

C(,"6', ;

" ")% )6, ( , , , %)

+,"

+ ", ( )"), %" ") ) ,,6"+ , ,) "% 6,"

) " ) )

,) %,6, , , "(% "" ( " " "

+,""', ",

;

%("),+,

" )" ,

+$ ( ""

%)," " "6 " '% ""

" ( """" 6 ," + )""

),", $ (

"" " , 6," , % 6, ) " ,

"+ ) 8

%% +"

%), "?% ,7 ' +"

" " ""6 ""

+, ""

"+,"

+ 0 ")

%+(,=

"""

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.