← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/155/2023dismissed

State Of Punjab v. Adarsh Rathour

2024-09-12Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh10 pages



    

    

    !"#$ %%&& '" ( ("

%              )"  ( +%, -, !"#$

....

   % %%& ( $   )  #")0      % 1"), %

", 2) 3(& 5($* %( (" 6"



&

78 29     )   2!

 !&

 (:&  $  

% "     , 2 $

)( 3!;  5 

0 0 (% (0 3!;4 (")( $& <#

)(, & %

   % 5 

0 

2<!=  " %: &)   $"  ! (% (0 3!;4  %   $( 

 ;(

& 6"

 0 %  %:

(, & 5* $" %%(



6"

* & 0 ( (",   0& >

0 2 $

)(  ( % &

 *

0 5 &)& )(  (

% -?

  

(5 && )  (

% -?



 )&*,  @A!;B %% 2 $

)(

&&  !

"% #

)( 3!;94,  ( %

%



 @A!;BC 

  2 $

)( "%  !

"% #

)( > $) 

 !

"#!$%  $  &#& '

 ( )!'

 (&*#  +

, *-!(&*#  5 )( 0& $ 2D/ =, 0" "  2  A% *     

%"

*

  % % )

")( *"%

")( *"%





 !

"% #

)( 2 $

)( %  &

0% E 2 F % &* % &

0% %% 2 $

)( (  &  8 (0%& 3!;4 

& :

 %

@A!;B

) 2 $

)(  8 (0%&   !

"% #

)( "6 , $

78 B ) 

!&

 (:&

%&*  ?

@A!;B 

0%& 0&   %,

&) 

%"

$ <>B 8

"0  3!;4,   * 

,  A &

0% E F % &

0% %%

%  < 0 +"0 3!;=4 &



& :"% > A *

 =   ,

&)

%"

$ 8&&6 



% "

")( *"% %



 5 &,

% 8&&6  5 & 0 $"&:

 &

0% - 70 2 %% 8&&6  %  B1 % %  2!

 >

%

% 8&&6   

 &* &) 70 2 BD 7 D, 2) (& >

0%&

 )

(&& % ) 

"

" 0

()  2!

) 

",

 %& )"

&*  8 "%%



, % " A0  !;

2 $

)( %    , 

0 0 (% (0 3!;4 (  ( & %, 5(

" % &)

2 <!=  < %% 

&)& )(  ( >

  (

&

"



%   -?

  , % @A!;B %%  !

"% #

)(

0,  ( %



%



-?

 @A!;BC > 

,   !(%(  )

%"

* % % 

  0



  !

"% #

)( %% &  %% &

0% E2 F, & % &

0% %% 

& :

 % @A!;B

 ? @A!;B < % "6 B, 78 B ")(  %& %& B < "(  "



%"

$ !; <>B 8 "0  %% &

0% E F

( 0 % 

0&:( > A *,

%"

$ 8&&6  % 7"

")( *"%



 5 % &,

8&&6  &

0% E-F 0 $"&:



 %

8&&6  & E-F 70 2 BD %&* %% < %

* % B2  % 8&&6   2!

B1 < % %()%(

* %  ) @A! @A! % 7 D B 

!; (% (0 %    , %%(

  

2<! = 

 % 

& <





0 @A!;B

) 2 $

)( 3!; (")( $& <#

)( >

0

 ( % < "(

$ 0 !;

= !;  8 (0%& 00$

%* ( !;

2 $

)(

$ 0 % 00 @A!;B @A!;B,

)" 9 !;9  !

"% #

)( %   , %  !

!C8B2!

0  ( %

%



@A!;BC <

$ 0 !;

2 $

)( % @A!;B,

$    !; "0  %    , % <> !&

 (:& > *,

&)  &

0% E2 F E F

2 <!=   %"

$ 2 $

)(   * 

, %% &

0% E F &

0% & % /(, 

% 

0&:( > 9   0&:( 0"(

%"

 &

0% -,

"(





%% &

0% E F  A  

  ( 0 ( $ :

0&:( 0"(



 %

7 D

!; <# 

)( % 9   $& (00

< %"

 A " 6"

 2 !9 

=

% 0

7 D

  !;= 88 0 +"0 % <

!&

 (:&

   @A!;=B ) %

0  !; < (00

<    @A!;B

 % :

   8 0 

!, 

  %"

$" 0 %&

  &

0%&

  <5,

(  A0  * 

   (

"&  % 

  , " 6"

 %%&& #")0     , $ &&5   

       

 

        !"

#  $

 %

#'  # 

"

# ))*+  ,$+&)- (   )!./  0) *,, )  

 "

#     

  "

    1

  

  !"

#  $

 #   #   "

 " ( "  "

# ###   

  ( 2(

 3      

# $ 

   %  &

#  '  #  

 ,$  4522  $(

   

  -$ 4(    

   #       $  

   %  &

# '  # 

,$45226$(

7( 

# 

  # #(# 8       9           

   $ #  ./   ./1:'

;./1:*<    =,$4522+5 &      



 ###   

("   #  *

      $ #./  &

       #  "#



"   

#  $ #./      ###       "

   " ( "



 (#"



  " ( "  /       

./1:';./1:*<> "  ( "

          

"#      #(   $ #, 

#    #

###   .    ##  

$  

   %  &

#  '  #  

 ,$45226 $>5?'

 

 6  +5   

 # 

 @,$4522+5 @ 

  6 !      $(

    #  

 ( 

 "   "  (  ' "  ("

(  A(

 

 

 ' (        "#"

  , B) ))):   #8 (  8   # 

 (

 

    31;<  $ #   (   $   "  (

8    

  "     '@"#'$(

     

# #"  



"  

 '@"#'$(

$ 



"

   ( (# 

/  

"  #

#

      "(       /

 #

#2#"         

"& &  #")0 6"

& % ", ( )"

(



%%( &)

2 <!=  !;,

&& !;

 %

%%  &)& )(  (

%   -?

 %   (

&

% -?



  0 @A!;B ( !;9  ( %  )

0 

%



 @A!;BC 8

"( "$0   (

&,  $)

 

 !

"#!$%  $

&#& '

 ( )!'

 (&*#  +

, *-!  (&*#  5 )( 0& $ 2D/ =, 0" "  2  A% *    ,  

&





!;

!;9 %  & (  ? @A!;B 

"& ( "( "$0  $ "0$,  0" " A% *  %



&&* 0 

@A!;B

"&&* 

00 >





 !; <> &

0% E F 0 :%



"* 

"& ( "( "$0  A *,

&)

%"

$ 8&&6 

 5( %  )  2!

 " " $"&:, 5 0%&  (,

 5

")( *"%, %

&  & E-F 0 $"&:

&  & 

"& "( "$0  (

")( :

 %   &* , 0 

 &&

 (

7 D  % % 7 D B, "

  0)B 0&   !(%( 

0

00

6" *

$, % % 2!

 

"& ( "( )"

) 

"0 , " 5)&*

0

&" % " ( $& ( %

(0

A0  B

& 

& 0 

@A!;B 

"& ( "(

 %%&    &&5  ; (

 "$0  0 

"& = &&5

"  

 $ "    

 (  "# 

  

 2 +./1:*

#  

#    ./:0C 9 

@A!;B, %



 !

"#!$%  $  &#& '

 ( )!'

 (&*#  +

, *-!(&*#  5 )( 0&, $ 2D/ =, 0" "  2  A% *    ,     0

" <5,

* %  ) B1

"

  2!

, (

 0 $ "0$, 0" "  A% *  

& @ 70 2 BD,

%%

% 8&&6 

)",

& ) $ "0$,  0" " A% *  &&)  

& 7"(0, % 7 D B

0%&&* & $" $ "0$,  0" " A% *  

& 8 $ $ "0$  0 

7 D,

 5

")( *"%,



 " %  0 $"&: /(", (

& :

6"

  & : $ "0$,  0" " A% * 

% 7 D B

* % B1 70 2 BD, % " ( $& (  "0 &

")( *"%

 

@A!;B 7"(0, % @A!;B, 

 !

"#!$%  $  &#& '

( )!'

(&*# +

, *-!(&*#  5 )( 0& $ "0$,  0" " A% *    %, 5( % 7 D

) 5  &$& +

 F  5 )( 0& 8 , " )(&* (& 

")( *"%

&$&  G  5 !DH , 5(

% 7 D,

5  +

 F

%&  G, 5 !DH

( /(", % " % % 7 D B & &&) 0

A

  $

@A!;B

 )&*,

" 0 $

 )  %%&&   8 )( $ " 

"& ( %  " *

&&)& *  % *

0%") #")0 5($*

6"

 & ) $ "$  6"&*, % %%&

($* 0   0 

.  /  01231214 . / D   5!

%!

&"# $6 -7& $"

+ "7

5!

%!

&& # &%$8'

+ "7