Karnail Singh v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. And ORS.
!"
# $ $%& '
(
) "
*( + *$( $ ,-.
,
"(
" .
/ " %$
" $ &0
! " ( '
( $ - 1
" $
2, /! '
" $
3$"!"
4
5-6$ 7'" &0" 8
!
(
8 8(
0
!$ ..'
$
44 "& % 9$ " '
"& $!" !
"&
(
8 " ( , .'
$
44 5-6$ 7
5-6$ 7 :
,".&8
8"( , " " ( % ) ' . / 5)7
4 " '" ; 0:
5 ' )7 ' !
8& $(
44 0
!$ . 2 " & .
" " ( '
" (
8
44
! " !
$( $
8 " (
<(( . /5<7 8!"(
8 8(
0 . 8
$
44 5-6$ 7 2" $ " &( "( ""( !'" " " =
> ") " .
$%& '
(
) " ,'"""'( =
?"'
( ' (
.
!'"&$"
( 8
$=
4> ". !" .
$%& '
(
)8 " ?" $!(
$
!
" ! "
#
$ % & '(%) *
+ "
)$ , -
#
$ . $ #$
% &
'( )(* *(+ ,
*-./0/
?"
" ( ' &0 "
(
(
" & % .
4
8($!" '""
'!
0 1 '(2'((( ')(,'((( '* 3 % -2 2 #
2
2 '
-2 2 %+ '* * -2 2 4
4
( 1 %
2$ " - '* 5
6((2%(((( !
%(6((!*)((7% ( 89
4 :;+((2,'
(
,, !
+((!'('((!*'(( 89
< = * 0 '(2'((( ')!,!'((( "" > 0 %,2'(%) '%()'(%)
$
4 '* 2? 2 '*
%+%'%66' %,(*'(%( @ '*
'(!6!%66+ 9
0 %,2'(%) '%()'(%) 0'(2'((( 3
!
1 !
% 43! 3
% &$$
5 67# 8& %
2$
""" > 0 '(2'(%) (%%('(%)
4
(%!%(!'(%) @ '* '(!6!%66+
*%()'((+(%%('(%)
9 # 8: '* 0 '(2'(%) (%%('(%) < A $ '*
# ;
% !
% '
,
!
%!
%;
< 2! ? ?
136+%%2% 88<< 9 /
?"
' 8($! &0 " ( =
4
> !".
$%& '
(
) " >'""'8'" '.
'" & 0
" ( " 8 $
'" & ( $ " ( '
( " & 8($!! "
4
5-6$ 7 '" &0" 8
!
(
8 8(
0 ."& % $
" (
$ 8& .'
$ "
'" "
" ( " 0 & &0 "
( $"
" " & "
!
(
8 8(
0 . " ( " 0 & '! "!"
* 4
1
5( .7*
@ A5 .7,'"""!" " "
"6"!" (
( ,'""<"
*
1 '"
*
5( .7 *
A5 .7,"
,( $ "
$
,'"" "
" "8( 0"&( '"""!" ""
"1" 6 "!" ( " "1"
(
8 8(
0
. - "
!.'" %!" 8
"( " $
"&8(( & (
(. 0
8"
$
'" ( 8( 0
.
44
, "
,"
!
0 .(
8 . $ $ =
1
;. " ', " ( " 0
8 .
" " $ (
0 '" "' .,"$' . &0"(
B" "(
8 ." 8 8
8( 0,"( !" $ $" ! 8 2 " 8
" (
.(0 '!$," $ ".!"8'" "' . ?". :"
" $ <4 /!!
- + =
!"", " " " 8( 0 8" .(0 8 " "& .!"(0 !
&0"8( 0
" 4 0 ?" .(
8"%$!8, $
% - B+ ((!%( (( <"& ','(('0 '6)'(%% $ 6
/ 2 %$!8&0". :"
" $ <" )
4 =
# #!
, '" %!" 8
"(
$!
""
.,
" ($ (
01( !$ C . 8(
0 ( ( 0," ""(
&0"8$
8!
,
$6( 0 ((
"!"!" $ 2"%$!8,"&" $
%( @ C C (%(%66, .
@
D '(''1
"
< .!
%!
%!
> ?
&'@,
&: 3
% @ 9 %, %,$
<"
" %6)'
! .
@9
" #
4 ; 4 A #
</ B )
"
( ?
C' 6, 6&D
- *!
> ( * ( (
C 7 '8 , (0 6&D ) E
>
. % ( ) B
( C' 7, D/ %% < * !
> ?
4 > ?
'8@@&, F: < 3
. ''+ *' "
< $ $
> 9 .# < E FF !
2 %6, %6)( #
F/ %' " $ $
#
D
4
/ ?"
:"
" $ <
=
$ $", '"
%! " 8
8
3$
"!" 3$ "" $
*" %6('%6,6 2A A %6('%6,6
$ 9 # 8 $ $ #9 G . < "
('(,'(%*
5 :: 8@:@
!
" )
-
A
9 . 4 9!% . 4 9!%
%66 '(%' & *' ''
%( $ + #
@
4
,
$ 4 #
. ''+ "
- = < - *!
* ' 7,88 676"
) +( < 9
#
$ ?
- #
#
- .4 #
" .
-
+
'8@:@, F7G <* !
4
'8@@&,7 F:
/ 5
A !
B ) "
' 6,8 6&
< 9 + %+#
4
3!
<
5
$ #
4 ) 0
) E
' F, 8 @
H
A $ !
A
H + A 4 4
.''+ @ A
) .
6 1 *(+'(( *%,'((
'((% '((' '((* '(( '(( $ '(( '((+ @
H 444444 %+
1 1 = A & / I?
J )
B !
8 ',"
86 " 9
$ ! *%(*'(( '*
;
0
')(''(( #
@ !
3!
%%" #
#
#
$ <
.
# %6+ '((
'*
#
%' *%*'((
-
%*
/
6 .
$ 0 5
)
8@@:', B 776
<# K =
4
*)
%(
#
<#K = <# K = #
<
"
/
- +
8@@F'6, "*
F " G 8 =
/
" 4
/ %% + %
% %! !
% +
%
H
E
E
%
%
%
! !
! %' :9D1=
!
!
!
!
!% %*& / ?" D& $( 8 $ - %!
A
#
%, '" ! " $ ! ! 0 "
! " %$!8 " $, ( " (
( 8' /("$ . -
$1($ &!
... $" ( " " & &0 " $"
0
!
&0 !!
8" $ "$ ! ! 0 " & '"
! $
'"
0$"
( 0 " "(
!
. 8 . 80 ( . "8
" & '"" " & !. " -
" $
2,$
"$ ,' & ' / '" '
.
$
"
'"
.! ;. 3$ 0 " & 8" !"%$$ 6( 0
& 8 ;. " ( ( &
!"'
( $ -
" $
2, 0 "
$ & '"
& 8 -
( 8! %$
"
$
8 0 & " !'"(
68 "
"8 0
$"(
?"
$!" $ , " $ '0
. $&3$ " , &$ ( , '"
' "! "(("((
"" $ ($
'
8 0 $ 8 , 0 & $ $
0 " -0 '"
( . " !" & $ $
-8( 0'"
( /*(#/ !
$(
8 $8& " ' $ , . &" $
0 " * . ( !
("
8 "
%$!8 6 & '
%*@ #
4 # 4 $
" $
$ $ '((*"
# % %%%6)* " *% . % /!
' :, 8 88F !D
5
# " 4 4
3!
? 8 #
4 "
;
; ; $
/
2- +
) E
&%," D& $( 8 $ ,
! E &5$( 7 " $ "'"& ( ! F G
FG$1($ , 8( '" &0" $ 1 &$ ,"
$" & $ "!
" $
..! " FG $
8&
($ ?" $
8
0 ""
$ & '" "
! $
'" " '""
( 8( '" $ H =" $ H ( $ '"
$ 68! " 8 ,
!. 8( '" $" , ' 6 " 8 ,
" 0 "
8 "
$"
, 0 " . " $
&$
(
! 8
!
. !.
" $
?"$
/("
6 8 0, 8 $&8
( " 8( $"
0
8 2 ) E
>
. % ) B
!#," $
/
" $ (
' " '" 0
'
"
( 1'
/8 " " 8 8 8/!
( $ %$ 0& ((
"
2 ?
%"" # #% ,"& ("8/!
( (
0 6(
0 ?
" 8
" %$!8 ?
( ) E %"
# &"% 2A % / .
' ,
!#"!,"
E$!:"
" D& $( 8 $ "( ( * !
4
%"" &#$ (
& . " "
( " (
( . " !"((
" " &$ 44,"0'
$ !"&
"
44
2
%!
"
#"," D& $( 8 $ ,!"3$ 0 $ "&
/
0 "( ! !
.& ," $ "$
; A ; 2 .% "
$ /
4
2 .!
%!
%!
" %"$," $ " (""
$!"" (
8 (
.
!'
( $ -
" $
2, 0
0 '
( "
$ & '" & 8 2"" ( " " '
( .0 " $ , ,
/
" 0 " .
"
( &0 " !" $ '"" " 6 " 0 %$ 2<- + > (
0% = ! && , " D& $( 8 $ , " " $
%+ "
# L
$L < $
.1 %,'(%, ;9 '(%' - / ?
"8
"%$!8
" $ <
!
B 4 =
& # ,'" "( ' 8!"&
- , 8(
0
!$ ., .( " & , 0 0 , " 8 " 8 '
% "!
$
0 " 2.'
"& .$"
.$
'&0 D& " $( 8 $ " $ , "
$
"( '
( &0"( & $ 0
" 8 & ' &!,"! 3$ 0,"( ( & &8 " !
$
0 " 4
" " & ., " ( '
( 8 8
*
"" (/!1 I1= "" *(
& I1=