← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5223/2019dismissed

Balkar Singh v. Avtar Singh Since Deceased And ORS

2026-04-07Mr. Justice Parmod Goyal6 pages

1- 

        

! "# $%&'(()  "%&%*&+ $%&',(-() 

 



   

  

     

      ' ./

(  

 /



   !"# $%&"'%

  " !"# $%&" '%"(())"

***



 /0(

+,)"&% "((") "-(' -."(())"/ ()"'''%+"  0, 23 5267("

-.)" 

%")$)!, +%$%# "8% "" 0, +1 67 5269(" -.)" 

%")&!, +# !")" "

(())"/()"'' ,'% &)""% "

&)"1  "  %:(%%%')" 1",+538"")241")"-+6;<  "%'%")"+&,),"))" 1",+52=8"")" 2>1")"#',)).

&- ()"#," ""%'$))"+8-"(,# ) " 8%# &  !")" "  (())"/()"''  "

 ")%  %,+   &)""%   " 0, 639>(" -.%,%')" ,-/ !, +?)"# "8% ", % 57>%'639>) " ,0 +

  $"+ " 0,  57 6337 (" -.

)" ,-/!, +&% )"# "8% "$), % 74>%'6334

,0 + "   !%+ ",":))" ,"%-"+ 6264" 6624"))+")#$% #" %- +,(% +  %' "(())"/()"''

(())"/()"'' "

")%%,+  &)""%%    ''&   "  ")     6< 5223  "  52 5223#  "))+ ).

@&, -. 6'"$%,%' " % <#9#" 3" : %,&% "%" )+")&."  '%#"))+")#,)":',)# ,))#$% " " 1,"% % 6696" 6695#"&% %  -"%'"-%$") ")"-)%&"&)) " " (())"/ ()"''', %,+ )'%'(1"0,&%"+ " 5" <%3'%1")"+,(%(." &)"1 0%(%%

:" &"%'"(())"/()"'' ",)" :"(% -. %)"

+ " "'  " # "-"+ +%6;>  "" +%1"+5;>  "% -"%'%")A))" % -"%' " A))1,"% % 3=4:""&%

:"', "  " 6/'"   %'  "(())"/()"''#  "'     "    '"$%,  %'

5$ 0, 639>(" $) , % 57>%'639>#: -.=68"")2=1")":""' "

1,"% % 6264:":%+). '"$%,%' :" ', &)"1  ",)" :"0%#&%/("&".#0% ,'"1).

(%(." "(())"/()"''#-+&%/("&# ")+")+ %$  (%(.-.$,%' - :"")%"  "$ ")

1"

'"$%%' " % <%3" 1,"% % 6696" 6695 ("+%"

"):))+")""1:1"

: %, -+

 ".)+")&.

' 6 "%+ %)))"   "

-+ %'&%/("&".(%(.

(())"/()"''"&&% +).%,+ 

&)""% "0, 639>B57 6337#")

 6< 5223B52 > 5223" &%C,1,"%-"+ 6264#6624#6696" 6695"%- +% +  >

' " % 6%>#4" =%3 "

&%  ,-.

')+  :  "1#  :    .  "  ()1".  %-0&% +" +1"""-).%',#&",%'"&%" )%&,"

:" "   "  (%(.  :" %  "&")#  &%/("&".  "  0%  , ?"1). %(." :"@&),$(%(.%' 6#: %:" :"  :     +   %  ,''  &  "  :))  "  @&,  ")  

:"', "  ""(())"/()"'' "+%%+ %$ , (%(.  "         %:  %    (%%  %'     (%(.

' 3&)"1  1)'%-  

 (,& "%' )"

1",+248"")#-"+8 "" % 72;;52;6'%"$") &% "% : %,  %&  -.  $,  %'  ")   5> 5223  @&,  -.

:""  ",)" :"%"&")(%(.   " %' %)"+ " "1 "%- $%)$ ,(% 6-.","),&&%#" # 6+%,)" -.:".%'

A))   :" ")% "   " "    1 %' ("+ %' 

639>#"(())"/()"'':"%$-% ' ""&&% +).

 -%     0, +1  " &   55 639>  "

6337("  '"$%,":))"")  6< 5223"

5223" &%C,1,"%

-

 1()&"%'"(())"/()"'' ",(%(.    %'  "  % 6  :"  &%/("&".  (%(.  "  -+  #

6 "

%+ %"'%)) "1 -.:".%' ,''+0, 639>" 57 6337" ")

 6< 5223" 52 % %(%$ ",(%(.

"&")(%(.  " %' 6#"(())"/()"'' " ) ,(% %:%")1%.: )"(("+" A6"  "%'  1% " )"$#: %"((" " A5" A> ))   A "$ " ,(%(.%-"&")&%/("&".(%(. A5" A>#

%%"+ ",(%(.:""&")#")%&)"1  " A5/ 1% %'"(())"/()"'':"1" % (())"/ ()"'':"-%%,%' : )%&8 )"%%' A5" 6-&"1%," %6= 6334#"&%1(%1:"''& +" + 1""&%'"(())"/()"''" 6 "

"+ %"' )" 1",+6=8"")" +1,"%'"$%,%'"(())"/()"''

%%%'25"&%')" :" ,)."' %"(())"/()"''

 1",("(("):  "(())"/()"'' "  ,&&    (%$+   "  ,  (%(.  :"  0%  ,  '"1).

(%(.;&%/("&".(%(." 6 "

%+ %"'  "1-.:".%'0, &%-.:".%'+ ")

%% ?"&%'(&""% (,1,&  %+")%:%'

 ,(%(.:" %)"+ #+" '" %'"(())"/()"''#: %  %#"1). "-"+ #$"+ " " %%)+ #: % +%,(%(.-.:".%',/+ A))@&, -. %)"+

 %-,")% '"&"% "-%$ % % %:"(%(.

 %-&%/("&".(%(.#&,1-,(%(%&)"1+(%(. %  -  &%/("&".  (%(.  %   %:   "    "  $   %,+  '%, +"%  %'  1")  )"+  "     ,&&%    -.  :".  %'  ",") ,&&%: %, -+".-"8 "1

=

&% "%#'  " %$ &"%"'.

-%  &% %: & "C, % &)""(%(.%-&%/ ("&".  (%(.

   (  &"#     ,  (%(.       "   %'

6:"%-.$,%'","),&&%#-, &$   "1-.$,%',/+ A))@&, -. '" #: %:"  %:%'(%(.

 %$ &%&%&),  ",(%(.  %' %)"+ :""&")%&%/("&".", ?%1  1"")%&% # %).&%&),%: & &"- ": ", (%(.  " %' %)"+ :" )'/"&C, (%(.: &

$%)$ -.:".%'A))'"$%,%'  % &# +%,(%(.-.:".%'A))# "1&"%-" %&% 

%-&%/("&".(%(.  "

  %' :%#%

"-%$#&%,) -"-)  -."(())"/()"''

%  )" %, -)%: "$+ ). )  ""(())"/()"'' "'") %(%$",%'

,  (%(.  %  -  &%/("&".  (%(.       "   %'    '" #

6C,""(())"/()"''

 0,

5267" 67 5269(" -.-%  %,-)%:# '%#" "&&% "&: )":

"(())"/()"'': % "

'") %(%$  ",(%(.:"&%/("&".(%(.  " %' 6#  '%# 6:"'%")" "1" %& "))+&" -1"

%,& "'-."(())"/()"''

) <

$:%'"-%$#("((") 1 -+: %,".

1

 +"(()&"%#'".#" (% %'



 /    ,(-()