Harbans Singh v. State Of Punjab
"#
!$%&%"'(
)* )*
+ ,- '& %'./
0!,&1&
!
"#
1'2 -
(
3 4 *
! " #$ %&
" '''''
*
! % () "
!
! !
*+ ,!(
!)!
)
(!
"! " -***.
! /01232 " "
+) ""! "
(!(
!)!
) " !"1)
)!
(! &+ !
( !
! )!
**14*/)&+ 0+ ( (! (&+ " !
!
!
) ! ( &
1** *5*14*/ (
!
! ) ! ( &
-/*.1**6 !&! ( +
) ) +
&
)! ) ! )
(
"!!
! ") !
!
(!&" (!
"
1733 )!
( (! &
) "#8
"
4 3 ( ")
! /0123 !
( ! + !) ! #!)!
9 :
)!
( ;)! ! !
!) ! ") !
!) &! ( + ;
+
("5<=+
*5*14*/!
>""!
! "" ;
! % + &+ ) "! % + ;)! ! +)
" & > ;)! ! " )!
;)! ,
!
>""!
! ! ! !
!) &
&%
;
!
2
;)! ! !
((" ) ?!
04
)!
;)! , ) ?
#% :4 ;)!
!
@;:4.
!;!
!! ( :/
& ;
+
! ( "
+
<4+ " + +
)
))!
&
+ ") )
&
!
( +! ( ")!+ &
)
*5*14*/ ) &
+
) +!)
"
) )
/ "! ! ( " !&+) ;
+
! !
)&
)
) " !
) &
&
" )
!
**14*/ 2
;)! !
" !
)! ) ! (
) !(
5+ )!
*5*14*/!
!+!
&
(
+ + )
!
!
( ") ! ( )
!
! " !
@; ! !
!"!
+ )!
)
!!
)
!
+ !
;
&
!
! (! (! !))
!!
! "! "
"
&%
! ( )
"
)") &
** )! !( )
!)
)+ ! (+
)" 1**)
")
&
***) 2 ! ( :1 !
!( 6 @;:1.
+ ) !
7
! (! + !
" !
!)
" !)!
!
!
( ! (! (! !))
!!
!
!) 6
) ! " )!!
)) ( "
;)! " !
"
+ ) )
+ ! (&
(
(
+ "
&%
) !(
&" (!
! " A2
& "
( ! ( )&+ & " !
!) #:4
"
!
+
&%
! 3
!
+
"
!;
2 ( +!
"
) " !
!) ) +!
))!
!
!) ) 2
&)!
"
"& !
" ( +" + ! (! ( A2 )!
"
( (!
" &
" !))
!!
! 2 ( " & ") "
)!
!
!)
- ) &
! !?
) "
!! ( ! !
&; )!
!+ +2
( !
!
& -**.-/* !
&
!& !")!+ )2 ( ")!+!! )
& ))!
!
" ")!+))& 2 ( B +)
! % + &+2 ( ")!+ ))&
) ! (! !
" )!
;)! ! "
! B2 ( AB ) ? " !3
! ! (
! !
+ ( ! ( ! 2 !
>""!
!
#8
) "#8
&
!
+!
!
!"!
!
2 !
+) ! (
!( "
( ( !
) &+ !) ( " )!
"!
% () " ! 3
! !
+
"
!;!
""!
!
!"!
" &
! ( !&
1 !
" ;
""
!) + " !
!) !
!
)! (
!
)
!
! ( " & ! "
3 "! !""!
+
!) + " !
!) &
""!
!
&
! ! ! ( ! 3 " )
"
"+!
% !
!
!
!
!
!
)" (&+ &
!
C !) !
& ! &
! 2
6 ,&;3 ! "! ( " !
)+&
)) "
!
"#
$ %!
$
0
&
'
$
(
) !
$
* +
, ,
-+
$
.
!
!
6 ,& )3 ! 21 '6 " /!,& 0&* !
"# 6/7 , 6!&/5
+ ))
)
&
(!
!&!!
+"" !)!
! 2 & "
" ( " ! "
!; )
& ;)! " ! % !
&&&
&
)
!
;
! & (
2
5 D/ $
$
!
&
$
2 8!!9166%'
:% & 881 0&* !
"#
!:/%5
; !
& ( ! "
!;)
&(! )! ! ! &
! &
!"
+!
!)&& &! (!
&! ( ! +!
! !
( ! ! "! !
!)! )
2 & " ,-
=
1
&;)!
"
!;!
! ( &! E:
! (
!
&!& !
! ! *5*14*/ !
!) 0+ "(
!)"
)!
(! "
+
! ( )! &! (&
&+ " "
)&"+
"!!
&
") ! ( &! (!
!")!+
" )!
!
&
(! &+
! ;)! " !
2
+ ) !
+ (
! " ! ! ! " !
!
! (
)! ;
+
&
-/*.1**!
) ! ( !")!+ )2 ! !)
"!
!( +!)&& !
8 + !
+! (! ( A2 !
)!
! !
&
8 ) ? " ! % +!
;
&+"
!; !
>""!
((
#8
)
* &
!
! (+ #8
" +
!
! (
!&! (
!;
! ) +"&+ "
!) & " )!
)!
+) "
&+
!
(
" !
!
(! A ( & &+ (
&
(
+!
!)&& &! (!
!3 &+
! ( &
"
!; !
" 2
( & ! ") ! !3
! ! ! !
!
+!
!!
+
!
)
&
"
! !
" !
!)!
! (
+
" &+ !
!)&& &! (!
! & & !
+ !
% () "
! !
+6& " !
!" !
+!
C !! + )* )*
+
! : ! (. F .8 : & F .8