← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/7350/2021allowed

Paramraj Singh Umranangal v. State Of Punjab

2021-03-01Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh36 pages

     !" !  

 !#$%!%&''() 

 

#*#+*#,-'(./+*#(#(.#0

%$'$'(%* 1 -$#$% 2(,#3 %4(5%($    -2+%5/-'(./-#'('

%$'$'(%* 1 -$#$% 2(,#3 %4(5%($ )



     







      



  !  



   !

"



"  #$

 "# "%

#



"  #$

&&&&

  

'()     *+ , -./0

1(2/

202( 

% 



   

  34  

5

6 

 

% 

'2) 4 





5 %

 6

 #

 7.1 *  * 

%34 , (.0  2( (0 20(/ % #



 .02 .0- .7( 20( 2(1 (88+  (20+9 .7 (:7 (:/ (0:

4*

 2/ ;

2-



 

 9$5

 35 '.)  

 #

<# % 4 * 35

0( 0. 202(



.

6  #

 (-.1 *  *    

%

 4% =

 >

4=>

'7)

 



%

 35   9  ?@9%

+$

A%

 *

 #  5

 

   ?5 # 9  ? = 

% 5

 % 9% 34 , (21 % (2 (0 20(/ #

 2:/ (20+9 4* 

 9$5

 35 '/)

#   ##   

  



 #% 9% ?5 # B (2 (0 20(/  

  ?5 #   #

 B (. (0 20(/   % ?5 #

  % #      %

(7 (0 20(/

#     %  %  # #%

%  = #



 

 

 %





  $#

 %

  B (7 (0 20(/  



# +

 % ?5 #

#

%  %  

#

   % 4   #

%     

 

6  



 

   C *

 #



 

 5 3C #

 #5

  3C5  %    C % 



    #

 "

 *% #  



 4  (7 (0 20(/ % 



  $# ?5 # 

 ?5 #



 #    







6 

 *$



 %

 9  ? 4   

  9  ?

 # $#



 9$5 =

4= #

" #$

 %

 4D  

 4  



* 4

 

? 4

D#%  

%

% 9  ? (7 (0 20(/ =

4= 

%

 34   34 , (.0  2( (0 20(/

 '8) 4  

 ?5 # 9  ?

# 34  % 



 

 '-) 4   ?5 # 9  ?  % 

 B  20(/ B  20(1 #% " 

 !>   <# <

 D#6  D#  %

 "## "



<

 35

%  ?5 # 9  ? (7 (0 20(/ '1) = 

4D#6 *  2: 08 20(8

#

# =   20(-  * 

!>   <# $



 = * %   .0 08 20(1 = 

 D#6    #$





#%# 20(1  

 =5  

=

':) = 

 4D#6 *   

" 21 01 20(1 = 





% (-:

  #+

               

              

 

   !   

         "     

   !  #                                           

 !           $  % &'()*+      "                   '()*                             !

                     ,       !                           "     

            "    

    !                  "                !# "!- ./#                                 

 !  ! !    # "

0!      !1 '(0) #

  #  *   %

  %



  

 

  #

%  #

%  

 = * 

   %

 % ?5 # 



    % 

6  

#   

  

 

'(()

%

%  88 8- 81 11 1: :7 :- (-:



 4D#6 * 

+$

A% 

 9  ? 95$

%

  3C5  9  ? (0 .0

 *$

%

  %  9  ?  

  3C5

%  

 6   

$

#

* # =$

%

*=

 4  ! 

%

!B 

  4 

 ?#

!B  = # 4 



E

!B

 , 2 #

#5 ?#

 * 

!B  A 4   9 #

  4% = " #   F= =

 # % 

9# 

%

!B 

 3% $ = 4  



 % %   %#  95$

%

 3C5 $ G

4D#6 * *E+8/  *$



 % $ G *E+1.

'(2)



%  

4D#6 *

% , 11

+

"                   #                 "     !"    !'(23  !   #4   #  '(23   !        !           !

              '(23                 !   5  !   !   #  &'(*)+#  &'(63+ 

'(23  !    "      '(*)    # !#

 #  &'(63+        .       )7)8*8)7         9   .               ##   &'(63+                  #    #                    '(63            '(231 '(.)

 

% :7

  *   

9

*E+(-- 

% +

  #    &'()66+      # :               0 !          &'()66+    ;:              #   #  :         !

      )<)8*8)7& #        +    !   .

:    "           # :     )<)8*8)70   #      ##4/  #     #       ! 

 #       ;:  "   # #  # &'(23+ 4 #  &'(28+   #   &'(*)+#4  #  &'(=7+  !

             4   ! #  #  # !##  &'( 63+   '(23

##        !                   1 '(7)

 

%  :-

  *  

% +

                     #     #    #  &'(23+

4 #  &'(28+ #    #  &'( *)+ ##4  #  &'(=7+ > /,)384 #     !       / #  #  # &'(23+  !    #  #    &'(63+

0#  &'()73+ . #  &'()7<+4 #  &'( )77+ 0#  #09?         !        !   !   "                                   



              

@                  A '(/) B



  

*  

 # 

*   

6 

% 9  ? = 

4D#6 *   

 #$

#%# 20(1  

 =5  

= *#  (0

 =5   

*

4D#6 

!>   <# $

  #+ 

 



 ! "

 ! #

(  !     $%&  '& B  "       !

   !

# "    !    .  ;   .    "# "

!   !  1&/  4  ,C74 +            

  #   #    #  &'(23+  4   #    &'(28+  #    #  &'(*)+ ##4  #   &'(=7+           > /  ,)38  4   #      !

         /        #    #    #  &'(23+ !    #  #   &'(63+

"                !.  > /,)38*))8)7 @38*@386@3< 4*7 *6  !    4#       -   > >!                !

     B )#  # 44# *#   #   44# 3 4 #   <#   #  

 

 



 ! "

 ! #

0#  &'()73+

.#  &'()7<+     4   #   &'()77+         0#  #09?     !        !

!      "                                

  1 &/4 ,C64 +

                 !       '(*7=!

       > /  ,)38   *))8*8)71  &/  4   ,C2   4 +    #    #    #  44# !    # #   0#  

  .  #     4 #    0#     #09  ?      !        !

!          - !     ! 4     !        "                      !      !            !

     .

/ - :

(0 (  &!

!    (   %  )&!

 !*!&!

!&( '         !    !

     

"         @        !                            !                      @   @/

 

 



 ! "

 ! #

!*!&!

"+ "  #! 

"                         !                             "             !

                     C8!

     1 &/4 ,)6C4 + )&!

!

"+

"    "#.   #    ,              )<       B              

    "         !

)+# #  #

##4@;               *+# #    - .@>D/    1  &/  4   ,)6C   4 + 3+#/ !

 -.4@? E <+ #/  #    ##4@; 7+0 #  ;  ##4@>D =+###; ##4@ 6+#;#  2+###    -.4 C+   # 4##  0# "

)8+  #F F  

.4@ 

 

 



 ! "

 ! #

))+ # 4

#   : 

  4@?  )*+   #     #    #    -#4@ )3+#F     -#4 )<+#  #  &#4+ -.4    =8<6@3   )<82*8)2                        F   &/+  /   #       !

+-G !          @          > /,)38 *))8*8)7  @  38*@386@3<  4  *7     4#        > &   +B ) # #  #(-G !  

*#  #   #  4  3 4#   <#   #   +  G5           ,(.D 4       !        !      !    

  5                        !         !

  B(

 







 ! "

 ! #

)+   #09  4#    &       + *+   #09  4#    &            #  . .  #   F       

F #   + 3+    ;   #   &#      + <+    #  .   #    #09  4# &>   + 7+     #  -   #    &  5    4  #           + =+    # .#  &  

 ;+ 6+#09. #  &  

 ;+ 2+    #   #  &  5   4  #           + C+       .#   #09

 &+ )8+ # 4 #     4   4     &#       + -.4  ? ,6@*)3@*8)3(30<@<)38   *<82*8)2                      C8!

+                              ,(.D4 9     !

                        !       '(8) #



 =5   #  



4D#6 *

% (-:



 "  #  #  (7



 #%

=

 

 (7





  # , (0

 =5   B







 %  6

 # 

 6  #

+$

A%

2. 01 20(1 *%  #

 27 0: 2020 

 # #   

28 0: 2020    20 (( 2020 # # ..

 4



 

 # (:8:

'(-)

    # 

  6  D#

%

%

*   # 

 6  



#6 #  % #  @  %

@

 # '(1) +$

A%

 %   6

% *E , (7:02

*E , 22-0.

!% *# B (1 02 20(:

+$

A%  34 , (2:

 0- 01 20(1 % #

 .0- .2. .7( 20( 2(1 (20+9 4*

 2-



 

 *6 ?5 #

%

  ?5 #  

 #6 

 (( 0. 20(:

*#

 35

         

**=

%

6 *#   # 7/



  5

 

  #

  





#6

 #

 

+$

A% ?5 #  ##C    %



6 =

 6 4  

% 95 <

$

?





% *+ , 88:7

20(:

 > 4#   #4 > *+ , -(.-

20(:

 > F #   #4 > *+ , -8./

20(:

 H  #   #4 >  6

 !% *# 4  6

  % 



!% *# 

  

%

'(:)



+$

A%

  



 

    34 , (2:

 0- 01 20(1   

 *+ , (0802

20(:

!% *#

#

   

 %     = 

  

!% *#    0- 0. 20(:

   %  6

  

  D#

% 

'20)

 



 34 (2 07 20(:

6 % *$

 

 %

%

%

4=

   4 

$

% 95$

%

 4  

    



$% #

 # 

 #

 (88+

 

 (20+9 4* +$

A%   6  4   #% #

% #

4=

  % /   

*6 ?5 #

 *$

% 4  

$

%

! B 

9$5



 34 , (2:@20(/ % 

9$5   

       

% %%

# 6 5% ? 9%

% "#$

$#% 9

 = 

 *$

%

 95$



% 4  

4 

$

%

!B 

9$5 #  6  

#

9 D# (2

 %#

"# *$

 % 



 

 "6 6 , 92:++:8(2  %

    



#  = G





 %

%  

6  #

 %  =  

 G

6  #

 %   =  %

% %



   (2 07 20(:

4  



 # #

%%

  !  

0. 0: 2020 

 6

#   "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 



  #



 34 '2()

 

6 



4= 0: (0 2020 %

# 

 6

$

? 95$

%

 

#

9 5$ 9 ,

6   %



  %

"

, (8  2- 0: 2020 %

> 

0. 0: 2020

'22)



 +$

A%

 *E , 22-0.

%%   #  "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 = !% *# # 





#$

(2 0( 202(



%



@      #5%

  

 %



#% 6  #  G 

%   (1 0( 202( =#%  #5%   

#  #%   

 

'2.)

 

6  

4= (/ 0( 202( 

 4  

H   

$



4  

 

 *#

#   4 #%





%  

 +

"##  #            *7(*(*8)C   !

4 #  :          )*(*(*8)C      



     !  0H  4     0!  0  1 '27)

 

#

 

6  # 

6   % #  

   D#

"#

B



6  <# % 4 * 35 # 

   (/ 0( 202( D#% 

 *# 0: 02 202( +$

A%

 * , (78-+*E

202( *E , 22-0.

#%

 

% 

6 #   *#  

%

##

  (/ 0( 202( = !% *# 5 %C

 0: 02 202( 



 0: 02 202(     ! *#    





  *#  

 6 G  

 * 

6 

 

+  =  

 5 % 







%

 6





% 

G

(( 02 202( =  <# % 4

 * 35

    0: 02 202(6 % 

  

# %

+ $

A%  G 

% 9   

6 #   =  $#

0( 0. 202(

'2/)

 4  

  #   6

 

% !% *# ! 

 

 

0. 0: 2020



   "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 =   

 



   

 4D#6 *

6

 5 $ % (2 02 20(:

2/ 02 20(:

   



    #

 6  H "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 

 

0. 0: 2020 #

  0- 02 20(:

D#%

+$

A%





 4% = (2 02 20(:









$%

 %



6 

6   20 02 20(:

#

+

#

 D#% 







 4% = #

 (80 *  * ,   #



   #  "

, (8  2- 0: 2020

#6  

%

  *# # %

  D# 6  4%%

%6 

    

%



6  %

%

%   %

"#



#   2/ 0: 2020



!% *# *E , (7-08

% 

6  #

 (-.1 *  * 



4=  % 6 % $



'28)

6% # ,!-.!*"

"$&!/(

0#  $ "1234516



5!!

&6378I ,!

%$!!%$! &*! "

*"

  -    1212536



5!!

&63I "$!& ..9&  $ "*"

  5( &$!6   $ 512126 :3

*!

;

*"   -" $ 1232536  <=> 

#5%

% #

*#  D# =#%       D# #

 (-.1 *  * #

%



6   

 *#

# %% %   6 #

#     %

 5



# #

%



6   

# = D#

5%

 

# #

% @



6   

   6  



 (-.1 *  * = 

5  

#6  

#      #  

%  #

 



 #

 



 

 4 



#

 6

  5



# #

%



6 %

6  6

     

%



 6

 

% 6   % #  

 

'2-)

 *+ , 7/272

20(1

+ #

 #% #

   % 6  % %  * 9##

4% 6    %6 #



#$

= *#    (( (0 20(1



    G 

% 

  #%

 ?5 # %   %



5

% 6 

%  

 

 

 % ! 4  "

 4% #$

 "

 #$    5>   







%        #     = 

  

% 

G

28 0. 202( '21)

 #  

0. (2 2020



!> 

G *# *

 , 12-

% #

 * , 7..8

 %%  6

 34 , --  08 0/ 2020 % 

 *6 #



,% 

 #

 .02 4* = !> 

G *#  

   6 20(1





 "

 #$

= 34 %  

#

6 (::( 46   % 

 .02 4* = %  6

 #

 .87 20( .77 ..0 2(: (20+9 4*



  6



# D#6



 #

 .02 4*  

 6 <%

?#

= !% *# $  6

    01 0: 2020

 *+ , 28.07

!> 

G *# %  6

   

0. (2 2020 '2:)   

#6 





%



 @ 



 %# 

%  11 :/ :- (-:



 4D#6 *





  %  ./ 7( 77 7/ 78 71 7: /0 /2 /7 // 8.

  G

 ?5 # E 

%  (-:

 

 

4D#6 *  

 #% 



#

'.0)







+$

A%   # ?5 # 9  ? !   



" 

#



 *+ , 1(2/

202(

# = 

%6 %  $#   , 

 %

#

@ %  B6 



#



  4   ##C

% 

 

 

  * 6 %   %  /     

   !*

# ?#  $#6 



#   %   $# 9  ?  = # ?5 # 5





 8 00

 = 8 .0

   # 9  ? 5



 : 00

 : .0

 = 

 

  # (/ 5 =  34 



 



"

#



 *+ , 1(2/

202(

'.()







 %   *$

 ! 

5 

%   $# 9  ? , 

 6







 

 

+ #

 

" #$

9  ?

 # $#



 9$5  

 35   # 4"

%

+$

A%6

 # $#

 %

'.2)







 

!* ?

#D

    

=

 

  



 9

  $

%

6

 4D#6 * = 

4D#6 * 6 



   

#  

  

"  21 01 20(1 '..)





   G+  

#

+$

A%

%    ?5 # 9  ?



  *#6

"   G

 

  #     

 D#   

 ##C 



"

# (10

   ##C6



   *#6

"  D# #





  6 



 35  

 



#   D#  

 6 

#  

#

  *$

%

 %  %

  #6  9  ? %



% 6 5% 



 '.7)





  



#



   #    = 

  



 

%



  

 G

% 



  0- (0 2020

#

, ?#

 =

 ##C6 % 

# 



 =  



   6

%   './)





  *# #6 

 #5%

%

 



  #

 (-.1 *  * 0: (0 2020 %

$

? 95$

%

 

#

9 5$ 9

%   +

                       #  )63&2+4@ 1 4  

 #6 

 (/ 0: 2020

*#

 35 '.8)



   

+ #



   #  

#

    

  

#  '.-)





 #

%

 *# *94 ,

 

+ #

 



% 

  6  

# 

 ?#   



 6

'.1)







+ #

  

  

 34 =  # %

 #  D#  #

 

 =  6



6 # 

 6

 6    

 ,  (2 02 20(:

2/ 02 20(:

#

 



'.:)

% 



 D# #   6  *# #

% 

 

%

  0: (0 2020   

   % % %



% #

6  #

 (-.

*  * 

 '70)

 % %

 



 

%



  # ## $#%  



  % #

*#  #5%

%  6



 6

  

 

'7()





6% #

0 ! $ *"

$  #$ $  51228680   "

"47>?

) ,!- *"

   '

&   $ 51232610   "

"47=?

-- '*"



&  * " !. ! 5123267 0   "

"4<=?

&! '!*"

*  



) "$  $ "5123>610   "

"3I '!

.@0 *"

'$9-A!$ 37>:)3=I   !$   $ *"



  & $  $ "

 

) !

.$*"



  &$   $ "537=263 0   "

"::>?

%$!

   $  $ "*"

(!

"$ !"$  0 $ &   $ *"

   !$   $ 537<864 <<=?

"$!&..9&

 $ "  *"

    5    ( &$!6       $   512126  :

 0   "

"3?

'! ( *!*"

   -" $

   $ 37=850060   "

":>7?

 

        $ "  *"

 $-  &      $ " 3771 005360   "

"44:?

 $"" ! "

 $ "  *"

      $"$       $ "  512346  3> 0   "

"42>I $!* $)"*"

      $ "5122<610   "

"8:8   !$   $ *"

) ) $   $  3771005360   "

"111

 % #

 $#  >   > =

     5 G       

 

  

 *

% %

 

  

6 #   G    





'72)



  ) ,!- "

   



"  

5 #

 

 , (-

$#% 



% 6 #%

  -- '"

  #

6

 



&!  '!"

   34 

%   

# %C 

   # B







 %C 



# %

6 

   #  =     #6 %   %C 

  

   

"$!&..9&   $ "    

 6  #



 !



#  %

  %   % 

'7.) !%  

 %







  6 

6 

 *# (/ 0( 202(

#% #

% #

 4%% =

4= 

 

 $ %

4= = 6  

+$

A% G

$% %   0- 02 20(:6 D#%  $ % (2 02 20(:

4 

+ #

   # 20 0: 20(:

D#%  $ % 2/ 02 20(:

6

  

   #

  "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 

 %

> 

0. 0: 2020 ,

  

  

  #%

$

% '77) 9



      

%  

*# 4    % # 5% 6

  #  

 ##  

   

5  

#6

   

#

 6

  5



# #

% = %% %6

   #



  =    #   %

  



 #

  

   



5  '7/)     

6  #   

%       % % % % #  #

 (-.1 *  * 



 

%

  0: (0 2020

 6

   "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 E   #

  

#6  #  %   6

$# 



 '78) = *#  

 5% 6

   % %   #

%  

*#  # 6

$# 

 = *#   

 5%   %     #%

# %

 



 #  *#





 

  %



6  =       G    0- 02 20(:

#

+$

A%   20 02 20(:

#

+ #

 =   # 

   #  "

, (8  2- 0: 2020 '7-)

 

 %



 4D#6 * #$



6

 =5  

=  

 %

 %

 6 = # #



  *# 46 34 % % *$

%

 % =  

6 6

#  #    6 

6 



 

 '71) H6 

6  



 %

 # %   D# = 



6    7   % % % % #

6  % % # #

 #



 (-.1 *  * 8  6 D#

"#

#  

 *E , (70-8

!% *# 

%

6  D#  6    2/ 0: 2020 4

#      %#  

 

)%$# 9!

*"

  

) C  & 00 & 3:412125!"!

.

 )5& 6 712812376  27 0( 2020 '7:) 4 



 #  

   



 %  6



  



##





 <# % 4 * 35 ,





 <# % 4 * 01 0. 202( !   *# # 

 $    =   *# #

 6

      9

  

 '/0) ,%    



  

  -  0(6 202(

!   E  5%@ "%9 E   "%9