← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/24/2016allowed

Suraj Bhan v. State Of Haryana

2018-05-24Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri11 pages



      

   !    "#$

%$&'('

)* "+ , 

-

   

   





    

  

   



 * ./ 0  00   ./ 0  00 1/ 2$($)#* !

 "# $  % &  '()  * +,- !

   "(%$( )

(   '()  .*/ +,- !

(& ((%01  00  , ( $$

%2&  ( 2   2 (3

( 

 (3  33 &

 2    

3$ 4



+5+++/4+++/

2 



((

( 

'67 (& )

-%  %() 8*'

9-++4+/%2"(  %$     % 8

%"

&(

 $$( ( ( 2

(

8 (0

3    (

2  %+5/'   :80

:-

(*; ( )

%+,'   <; )=-

"





3 (3  ;$ ( $  +   ( ( $ +%%4 >(

 $ ( % 

3  ($  ;$ ( $        %    

   & 2

(

2  (( )



  

%  ( ( ,++% ;   ? 

  # $ (&

  ( $(    

  "

(3(   22 (3(3

$ $8  ( 9 ( $(" 9

$"(





(& 2 8%"( 3(  (8 +,)+ "(     $2

   2 (3  3(  (  8 //),5,  " (7

 ("(  (  2 " 2 (32  3" $

 $0 (9 ( $("  

2 (3(&(3

$2   

        

   

       $  

(3%



(3 8+ 

,++'67(2( - "(0 %

3 % $(

( 2

(

 8(  (3"+%  9( (  

%  

3    (  !

( "

$  9

$ 2 (3 3(  ( 8 //),5, $

 $  (

0 ("

9( (

? (3%("  

 ?

"  ((32

(&

 

"  ((3(

$(

 & ( 9

" 3 23



(&

%"

 % 

"

 "

 (3  3 23 (     % & (  

%

 



"3"(3 23 "

&

% "

?

@ %

(&

( 

( $   89

 ((3

(&

 ( 

( $      

( $(

 ( 

( $  



(3%(

(/ 80 '67(2( 6%67(2( A 67(2( 1-"

&

 $9 "

 (32 

 !3(    1B 

?(

9 

(

(2



21B 

?(

 

(3%"( $ 3 "  

!2( (3%0 %

3 %"&

((

   $    

 

    

    "    

    ;  

# $    3 23 (     

 9 3 23    "  

"((

%(C

  ( (  %"



("(



     "

(3

   #3 9  "  @ (    

 2 "  (B

$ $9 (& (3(" $ 





% " (

(  ()

   ( )

%    (  7$(

 ((  "(

  $2

(3  +  9

 $ 

(+)

) ($( 

%+5.



 "  

9  ()

 %



%&(

$  

2&  %

  

 ;           %  !

   "(%  $(  

( %

    '()  .*/ +,-% & $ 



" &((

(/ 80  

   "  

 

&(3 $ 

$ $  67(2( 6%67(2( A   67(2( 1 

(3($% (3

 $   "

 "

 

 "

 2  (3%2 "

$

3(& (

 %

" &((

(/ 80

 % 2$(

  

(* 80  "   2 (

 "(

"  (( $

(( (

 







" $( 

(/ 80  ( $   $(3"  

 !3(   !

 "( (

 "(3

( ( D E 



                

 

          

       

!



    

 "   #  $   %  "     & '

 '

 ( '  

    F  %

 % 

 @ (    

%  

     2$(

   

 2 "  &

 

  %2 " 

( 23 %"( "



(3"( $

 %

( /   80 (   



3

(3  



&((

( * / 80 % 2$(



  &( (  &    ((  (    

      

&( (   (

 %

 % 

 ( $(     & 



  (& ( ;"

 (   7  &  &(

2 



(3

 G+%;    

# $ % ?%  (%    

&( (

(/ 80 



 % 

%((  7$(((( D E  !  "#      

"  #   # $  

"%

 &'%(

)!)   #

) ! *$ +)  ,-

 .// 0

)!

123454

"%& 4567

%"8945, #$

  

  "  %

    &'%  (

    

" #   ) 

 ) !     *$  ,-

 .// 127%"89)"#

#%& 

"//5/ "* #       #$  0  #$  /  12     45: /

"%& 4517 /

"%"8 945 #

!$3 3

 *$% 1; 7% %)F 

 

 

D E      /  

"  #   3

"

F 9  $ $ 67(2( 6%67(2( A 67(2( 1%(



( 

   "  "

$

( $

 (  (3%( ( ;( (

2&  23  %  "

 (        

    (

 2  

&(  &

2

$ )

: 

( ((  #"#$

"5"(#6") 7$2(8( "29")")%%+*'- ) ') ($(-* "

@     "(3  &   3    $    (  

3$ %  

D E.) )# $ $ 

"3$*"

$  3  

##  4<"$  3    3   *

  #   # / # 3 *$% ="0#  )! #  &

 3

 ")"$*) /" / % ="

 #    

2

 0$3

* "

# !  /



/ &'%(

0$3

  "



/

&'%(

 $)

) ! 

# /$ +)  $)-

 // 

 # /%"#  1%&) / ) # $.3



 //

3)!

.



## %"8)!

 3 ) :/ // ##   

 $$

) ! *$% ="  # /%"#  1%&): #"



"*  #  0/   *)  /  #   &

3 *$% ="  *) # $   *)     * 2     3  / "  0 #  

   3 #" $* ")

/  !)03) /  #"3;) )



 +   - (   

"  /    %   / 8   "*

     :)   "  3  3 )  

)



"  3

# 3  

  / &'%(

 ""*

  >?

% ="    $        #    3

"  ) "



/ &'%

(3



3 )!

 $/ 

$

 

* *$>?

% =" #   /  >?  1%  &)    %"#       / #   /*) /#  &

3

"

 ""*

  :)  " 3 3 )*!)# #  3  "")  #") #! !

*     

!

 $* 

!$

/ #"/  *) /#  &

?&

#"3/ " #  )  *  

   '+,,,-./ -  /0102-+,,,/3

401  "   /#  $)*)   

 3 

")

! /   

*   3/ "/ #  /  

 $

2 ///       #   /    )-

  //       +)    

#   /  

    /    &'%  (

   

   ( &          $   )  '  4550  -4/    -  /6442-4550/.

705' ?1")9  /   "   # 3 ""*)3  ## #

!) 

) /

3(*) */  $"

  



"

-

 "    *         * $  /    "  *) 0/  

# *

 "  3  * / 3 @# A

")

  / &'%(

 0<"  / 3 %

 "*## *

 * " #"3

!

$/  *) *$#  &

? 8

 

  '4551-+/  -  /03624551-+/& 9 #

- /4702-4551/+

.05' * //     / # / 

"3

"

&

) 3/ " # 9"

  / 

 $ 3) #"

# *)3

! 0 "   # !  /%

 ) 

! *<"

*

#3  /   / 



 *"

2#)!3 /

 # / 

"3   3 *)

$

# /  // 

#$3  # !  3 3

 0 "

/  <"

 /

"            ' 455,  -7/   -  /+032455,-7/& 9 # - / 6,02-455,/+6

6..' 3/ 

!/  *)   *$   #     0/    #  3 2*"



)3

!/

#  3")   #  



$

!$ 3 

#$3  # !  /

  / &'%(

6  3)'#

3   # !  /

  / &'%

3

#3  :) " 3)  <"

) #    ) "

0"/$*) *$#  

:

3  "

*)$  /# 

  / &'%(

3! ## 9"

/ *) *$  #   

  /

&'%(

3!##    # 

&

B*)3 /  *) #" 3

!:#  3  "

      /  #   &   %"8  3  

"

  0/     ) / 8")   /     "

  # )#)#

  / &'%(

3!## F ;(  

(  (

( (

) ( (       

$  )

  (       ;'5"+(')6 6")%8<6" "%$5" 7$2(8( #"#$

85"2"#%+'*- ) ') ($(- 5++%"

@  "(3 3   $  ( 

3$ D E !3 / / ) ) " 3 / /

#   *8

3 3  ) "%



/ &

'")$ 

 # %"*  (

*$ 3$ //)"*

/ "#

!-

2 " /# 3

!





 #  

 )  /# ) /  ) //

*$ 3/   )  3 "*# !

# / # 3 // 

## #  

*  /)

* */  )-

 //  +)  >!    )   /  *) / "

  //  ""*?

/%

  / &

'") $ 

 # %"*  (



 

$ <"   

#   6" 

#$  3   # !   3 "      

!$  /        "#

!  

!

/ 

 $

* / 

!$ /   /  # / 

"")"

 0/  "#

$ $





5  ) # !

" # ! F 9  (

( (      ) ( (     "   % "

2  7)

(   '29"= ')>6 $6=?") @ '99" 7$2(8( )(A$&# 2, 8(# 9(, 8(# 9(  8($, 8)5"<%++'-

) ') ($(-+%("(%((  

D E

 / ##  # <" 

3  */       "

  9   3   

 3   

 

"*

*/ 

!$



"

) "%

  / (

0   "

9  $   

 

"

*

*"

/   # !  /%

  / (

3

$ 

# 3

  /     $  !   /   3 "  !    #  "

 3/"    3

 $ 

  /     "  *      3

  /   *"

/  

*

!$ /   3   3 "  #      /

  /      >  !

)$)   ") ! />%) :

"

)3 

3 / 

## /) $

2 # 

3     3 "  2 

 *     */     ,-

 .//  +)  

45(  ) / 8") C8)B  "# 3/   *

#  ?

# 3  # !  /%

  / (

( $ 2& &(

(

  %



 ( &

2  (

( ("( 

   3   $ 

3$  %"

@ 

2& 

( "

&  

 ( &

2

( ( (

@ $( 

(/ 80 %     "  2 (

   @ (%  "

    (  (  (  "

 

2$( ( $

2!

 "(;

%"

$ "(3

D  '(-

 ")% 

(

2   "

> '((- 9 ($ 3



3$ 4



+5+++/4+++/ 

2 



((

( 

'67 (&

)

-%  %() 8*'

9-++4+/%(    (

> '(((- 9  @ (

  $

3(  $> '(&- A( %(( %2 

 $ 00  

 00 1/

 "+ , 

- $&( G

  (34  

48 G

 2 48