← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/848/2010dismissed

Vishal v. State Of Punjab

2015-09-09Mr Justice Gurdev Singh21 pages

 

       

 !"#"$%&'&' (  

   

   

  )% *+) '  '

'    

  

   !"#

 $      "

# %  !"   &" &!# 

   

 

 

 

   

'

' ,'







  



 

"





$#

 "

  #  

" % #% &

#    





    #    

" '

  # 

# #

 

"









"        

    

      !   "  

 $ # # 

 

 $ " $ $"

&  #$ (





 )  *   #  #

    

+,-  '

  

 )  .')/  

# 

 

(

$

*-0*,12*1134 5

  

6 7  





# 

  #     " 

( $  





#



"  8

 8

9! $ #      #"     # 



$  %

  # "

 

#



#

+:* ;1- ') + <'$ #



  #$

( # 

 ! #. 

   = 5*>/$ " # ,  

     ? # !$   @  *-12*113 5* 

 " #



(    52$

">    

# 

  " <

 !  

$ 

 " 2* @>  &    '

 $ 



 

# 

  " 

52  5* $

 '"! )   (& &

 ? #  ! " $

 

 # 



 

$ #9

" & # 

 



  ! 





  

     

(  #  #

    $" :  



 $ 

 "  # 

 '

 

 A( B5;0  

 *312*113

 

   

    

 # $ "   5*$

 #  $

 9994 B

 $

" 

     ! 

    

% $ B5;   5*

 

 $ <'A(B52*09$ #

 ;

  5

   

 7   .

 / $  

     "     "

 '

 $   "  

  $  ##

  5

  .

 / $



 # (

 B52*0)#

 





$ #$ 

!$

 " B52* ' 8#  ?

# # 

  *312*113 -  

 6 7   .

 /    

 A( B52*0< 

 $    #  

     $  

$    

 $

 

 



      $      #  =8?>$ ""A(B52*0A , # $   )*+) ""&)   $ 



$

 )   A(

   

  A( B52*0  A( B52*04

 $ 



A(''' ''  # $    $ 



 #   A( ' '''   '   #  $   $ 

 



 <C   .

 / $    

 $       $  

 $  D

2-$

  

  

 !

   

  

.?

   #$

 B52 B52:

    

  #   $

   B53 

  # #

     5*      #  $ $        

  B530  " 5*  " ) B521 

  # $ #

 4)   # $       B5210  

/ 3  #     

 +2+ ))

 

 

  

 

 # 

# 4   



 $

 $  +0: 

  "     ! " #$     " ! " $

 " 

 

>

 $#

      ###   #



#

 !

   "

 

 21

 )

#  # 4 $

 ##  

,"

 "

*11105     ## 

+

 

+,-')4 $

 ## 

 ( 

    

 +:*   ;1- ') 

$ 



" 22 

 "





   

 " 



 





  2;12*12; "     



$ 

, 2* '

 

 

 

     #

#  

 

" $   

2+

 

>   

#



) &"& #  5 ./ #  " # <'E ./

  

  "  

 

 #   #   

  " "



E ./ 

  



"E . /

 





 @      

 

   



#

)



 2:  '

   





 ##

 

 " 

(  5*     $

  

    # 

   

 2-: ))  $

" 





 

A( 52 

(  ! 

 $ 

  " 

# 

221**113 2;

( 

"       *-12*113 



  "

">  1311  !  

 $ 

 "   2* @>  & @  $"     

 6 7   .

 / 

    &- ."

&  4  

   $ 

 "  # 

  

67 

# 

(

/ 



 # 

 

7 

# +: "  "



&   "    * & . /

 &- ."

& !   $

" 

$

$"  #  

6 7     

  

 #  @ # #   # 

 

 # $

 

 "$ #

$ #9 

#     $ 

 

! "$&  2111

(  # 2211  $

 !

4   #$    

67   ! #$ 

$  %



   "

 "   #

     # 

& 

$  ! "  

  #   

 5  " 5*     

 A( 5*

  "  # 

 '

 

5*   $ 

 $

    #



    #  $     $

   "B

" #     #   $   

    !

        

67  

 



 #

 # 2- B52:6  ##$8 # 





 

2-:))! # 

B52:

#$ " 

   1+1**113 

 # $

  " 



 

# $  

 221**113  



0

 

 !  # $ 

      221**113 $

 

 # 

 

  

 !

 # 

$

#   "  "   

  

$ 

  2, < %  



 #  #  

!



# 5*2+ "

 





(.

52/ 2:"

! $ 



#

$  #

 #    # B5+

( 

   #   2: "

 

B5:   2D B5,   6 C

 

 

 

"   ? # $

( .

52/   #     #

     

 



($

  1,1:*11D#

"     3,*D !  

      # 

 

  1-12233;) "

A(B5,0 '

5 B5,

#    

-   < 

  

 "  " 

#

( $   2: "

   + $

&   



23   



 #   

 " 

(   

  B5+



" #.

5*/.B521/ *1 ? %

B5+

$

"$  # &(&&

6 #)

$"  "E

 

67 

  

 6 7    

#   

 6 7

        

     

$  '

 

  +0: 

  "    # !

     

 6 7   " & # 

 ! # 

 



  ( 

  $

( *2 B521  5* $ 

  #

  

 6 7   .

 /  



  (

 





"B521

  

 6 7    

  

  "

 



      

67  



B521B521

  

67  

 $ 

(  # 

$ 

%

 

      "

 



**

(





5   #    #  



 "   # #    "  ## #    

*+ '

$ 

 

      #  5  $  &

 "     $ "  

 B5+ 

 &- ."

& 

*1  





 B521 

"  ;0, B5+

 &

  " #

 "

1 *:   

   

  #    # $  



    

&



 !

 #  &9 &<'

%

     

   $ 



   #

  #   $        #   !  #   # 

 " 

5 



 (



 "$  #  

 #

 *; B5+ 5

&-."

& 



= >  # &=9> 

 ##   

 & )  & < 

 #  





*-

 

 B530    $$

&  #  * &

  #  A(B530  B530) *, ?$   %

  #

5

B5+

(   "   B5+

" 1*11  1+11  B

" 

 #    $ &     



 

# #  !  

   #  

"

$ 

 $##

+  : 

  " $  ##

    

  ("  #B5+$ 

$

   # 

  #

" ## '  $  "+5:

 " # #$

$ 



  $    "

#

 #

"  &  "



  



  9 

" 

$

$ 

"

   

 B521   

   

" 



"

#  "

   !  #  $  $

  "

 # 

&    

 

 

# #  "  $

 

   "

 #  

  



 ! 

 $ 

 #$

      $  

"'

$##

B5+

 

67   .

/ #

 

  " $   $  #$ +5:" 



 #" "

 5

 "



 

 "  '

$" $ %  

"

*D B521  5  

 

  $   +1 :;





   

 ! "$ $

 #

 # 

 $   *3 B5+ 

  5 " $&  

(  # 1-11   

67     "  

 

"

 

##

 

67   #

  # 

  # $    

 "  +5: 



      

 

7  

 #





  

 #   

 "" 

 

(  2211

 

67 #

 

  5&

    < &   21 

  #   +1

  

   





  



 

 #  5

B5+ B521 " & 

#  '  $ 



$$" $

$

  

 

# " 5  +2 

 

B521 

##  

    

5* &  

  

 

    $"

" #

    B5+ %   $

  

       

 5 2$"  "

       &-     "

 & 

 "& "& &  "&" "

  &&"!  

  .

  .   "

  

3& !

 "! " &"! & "

 "    "

  

 3&    "

    "

"   & & "

"

 &  "" 4 &     "

3&" " "

5& " "

"

! 

&"! "

)&"  &"4&  " !

 &" "

"    "  "

 &"! ! " 



"6 *"

 " &"  " &  !&"  "& &" "&"!7 +*  '  $ $

$

  

 

# " 5   % $  ##



"& " 



 ! 

"  #

 

 "    B5+   B521 





# 

   # 



"

++ <   "

 "B5+ B5 21

   "

($ &   $ # $ $  "

   "  

$ 



  

  $         " 

#  "

(!

$



  #  $        #

  

# 

 +:    

  

  "

#" 

(

" 





#

   

 



 '

 $ 

 

( "    #$  

" 

$ 



 $   &

 $   

 B5:   

( 

  5 #

 #

  "$ # 

     #   

  

 B5: $

   )    *31D*113    , 

 



 < 



    

   

%

 " #

 " 

$ "



 



+; B  #  



 

   $

  4 >    )      

         

   !

 

 % $

$

  

#

"   $  8#  $





   &

#

   8#  "     "  $  $

   " 

#

$     #       !  

    " $

   " # ) $ 

 

       

  $ 

 !

  

" 

  $

    



 #  



$&   !# 

 

 $

   # $

   "       

" &       

   

  "  

 )  



         $"

  $

'

 " 

   " 

 "    

# " 

5  +- '

   "

    # $ %%!     &'

)4 F  )   5 8$  ) &- &"!-& ")&" &-  &"

)"

 &"!



"

  

   &"        *   &&&"! " !&"   "

    & &"- -  &"   && "

  "  4"  &"- -&"! 9   & ")      "& & "

& - "

 & 

 "  -&

    & " -" &"&&""

   &9   "

) "  &"&    &

" ) 

  

"

 & &    & "  $ &""

 "

   "

  "

"    "

!

9 !!& "   &    "

 -

* $ & "

  -&& &"    & -& "

 "    &"!  "

& "& 

*&"!

  

& "

  ")  &"

"

&

&   " & "

-&&

9   "  "-&"     & " &"&  "

& " "

 &

"

   &  *&"!  

& "

  " 

&"!  ") )&"   " 

&"!&"  &"   -& "

!&  

"  &"

  9   & ")  -&  &

) & &   && "#$  &&&"!-& "

   &9

*

  "

"   &  & &&  "&") &"  &  &"

&&" &"  

!-  )   & "

 : &"

     &"&  "  

& "

  "    "-&& "

 "

,    $ -& "

  -&&

 9    "

   "   &  -& "

 " &" 

&""

 "9"&-" & ; 

&"  &"  &" &"  ")

&&"



"

  &"

& )& "&     !

&" &"  "   &  &*  &  &)-& "

-&&

9 

" & "&  !

&!)  "

 

& " "

 &"

&"!  

&- -& " & "

"&&-  ""

&& "&"- 

   

& "    "

&& "

 && &" "  & "

    &9 & "

  : &"

    ! & "

  " "

 !&-" & " 4   "

  -

*   

"   !&      9    & "

 "  & & &-&&

"

 "<   "

 & & &  "

 "

&      -& " &&" "

 && ")&"!  &    "  & 4"

" -  

 "    !&-" 

 "

 & " & && &-&"

"

   "&

&

&!& &&"

 

 &&"

  ! "



 & "& "" *&"!  &    ""

&"! 

&

 "

&"&  "  

& " -" & ) *"   )    *"

  -&&

 9 & &*  && &"



 8

/ +, '

  

 #

 "    # $

# " 

   

   

 6 7   .

 /  



 

   

    (



5

+D

 " # 









"

B5: 

(    

   #

  #

 

# 

  " 

  #     

 1*11 B



#   "&

 # # $



         # #

 '

(  # 2211 #

$

"

 

   

67  #$

 $

$ 

" #  +3 B5;      5* $ 

   

A( B5;0    

   *312*113 !  

B53  5* # %

 :1 9  # $   "

   *312*113 "B5* 8 6! $ & "# 



   ##  !  $   

 



 #$$  "

#





 $  $  $  $  

 

 )

# $2-"

# 

"

 $- A(  

+,;')" 5 -.('

/G    H

I$ (

  

(

   (

0

  $   $    

  #  " ($ # 

5

& 

&  99 99 99 99 &9 B $  

$

  (

"

#  :2 



# 

# ( # %

"4"

$

 # $$ &



 @  

   "   (



    $  #

5* :* '

$

"

"

 

    

  " 

 C   $  " 

   $  " &

  

 " "$#



 #

 

  "

  "

 " 

$  

#  # $   

"< B5+  &$   B521  :+

 



# 

( 

 " # <'$& " 

 



       ' 

  " 

  "  

  

" " 

 # "   #  

"

 

  

 $  $

  

 

 #      2211 

( "

 :: B52* ' 8#  ? 

# # 

 

5

"  



 

   *,12*113  *D12*113 '

  %

 #

B5;$

     *312*113   1+21  



   $ 

#$  "

" 

B5+ 5

 #



(  "   



 

 



:; B5:   

( 

 $

(      " $

 )  9 $ #



  

! 

 "$



 $ 

 

 @

(  " $

  #

 

" #  $



        $  





$  

 $

 $  

 

$  

  # 

     *-0*,12*113 $ 

!



 



$ %

# 

'

 5 B5 :

    &  2111  *-12*113!

"$



! 

  

 

 

 

 

 # &

( 

$  #

( " "$ 

 

(  # 



 2211 *,12*113! " 

$ 

 +

1 :-

B5;   5*

( "  *,12*113  



1D+1 #   # #  

       #   "

! 



       B



   $  :15;1

 

 :,

 B53     5* 

 

  #

   

       $

   $    $$& #  1+111:11  *-12*113

     $   %

  $





 $       # # 4 #

  



   2211  

(  " !



  22+1   2* @>  &     *,12*113 

 

&  

$ " 



13112111  :D B521

( "  #      $  



     !

" $







 $"$

$ 



:3  

  

   



  # 

     !

  B52* ' 8#  ? "      



 *312*113

     $  #

#'

(  "





 

   #  



  

 

;1

"$   "         

   "  + "

  

  " $ 

 4 >  )    # $() *  ) 

& 

(

 " # #<'   

"     "   

(   "   # 

  

$



(   "'

 "

# #   #   

(

#

"# 4 >  )  

   

 

   $

( $   

  $  

    

" $  #  "

  

  E  #  

 

$

(F   $ $   ,0D "

   



 $  

(

  

#

  #"

  ) 8 # 

    (   "

  





   

 $

     

 

 

(     

   )   A(

 

 $

 $ 

 %

  

   " "   

   ( 

  # $ "

'

 B5* 8$ 6$ 5 #"

(

 #  & 

   2; "  

( $ "



 ;2 '

$        '    

"    $

 "

 )

     !

   " #

$   $ 

   

    

  # 

      

  



   %

 

$    / 012&, (  3 '

' 4 *