High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4063/2020dismissed

Mahender Singh Chawla v. Yash Pal Singhal Ips Retd State Chief Information Commissioner Of Haryana And Others

2022-07-07Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu5 pages

!""#$%$&'((

' )*

+ ++ !"# $%&' ( )

****

++ ,

+ # & " , # # -& '&

./0/12 + #

##

3

' -& $ "

& 3 # " 4

!

0,0/102 ! #' 5 "

!" # $%%#&' $#( # )#&* ((&*

( &&

(

* +

++#+# &&

, #

# + #,&& -((& -1-

. )#&* ((&*

( &&

(

) /

$ & % # %#&' $#( + !! !0 &&

((&* # + #1

"

& + -& " " # " 6

&

"&'

.70/ 12 +& '

# 8 ' # " /70/1.2+# 90

# 3 # ''

)

/ ++ #' "

## ./0/12

# +!

#

,/0/142+# ''

$ #

" +& " !

- #

7/0/1,2+# ) :+ ! #)

# '

0000/17; <2# #

#" +& & ' ' ) "

3 " + & # ''

## ./0/

##

& #

&

"+ "& " & + & ! +

+& ! & ' + $ # & # &+'

'

& !

# " " + &

&+'

&'+ #=3 &

&+'

+ #" ! -2-

# "+ & 5 "

" & ",#

( )

& # & +$

. +$ !

&+'

' . & "$

"

'

"

## " #)

# +$ '

/ = & & '&

" #& # &#'

''

## !

"#'

" !=

! "

/#&

0470/# #" " & " ! '3

"

+#

70/+&

=''

# &# "

##' 70/ + !

+ #&

3> ' "' & #

+# ''

'

"' + #&

+ 3> -& ./0/

"

&## "

94 ; , # ' & .

/ ++ #&&*

&-+ #

( ## %$2#(

#

&& #,

##

# #

((&# + #

-*

((&&# ## -*

( ## %$2,3+# # &# #.

/ ++ ##

((&&#

&+# # + #.

/ ++ #'(+' -

(+-& # + # #

- &-&

(-&

* -##

((&&# -3-

-*

( ## %$2 4 ,' #

# 5 '

#(#* # ##'

/ ++ # # (( # *

((&&# #(

&# ##* , )#*,

# #*

(

,

, * ( #

( ## %$2 #

.

( ## %$2

&#

((&&# #( # # ( ((&&# ,

# 6 ## (

(+-& +# # -*

((&&# ( 7! (' ' -6# #( # #8(+-& +* - -* # % # !

. #

&& #* (#*#

# # + #'

((&&# &- *

&(5 #,

( ## %$2,

(*

/ ++ #' ,

# # *

( # + # +# ##&#.

( ## %$2

((&&# ( 5 #' ,

# # * ( # + #' # # ( # + #

((&&# #

- &-& ',

# #* ( (5 ### + #

/ ++ # .

/ ++ #

#

((&&# # )

3( #& & & # &- *

. #

# + #,

#9 $&

.((& # 9!

!" # -&

# + # &

& &- *1

((&&# ## #8# # # + #&)&* #

&

((&&#

( % #0

.

# (

3 # (& + # & #

((&# .

((&&# #

3 # (&+ # ( , ,#

# #

( % #0

: &

3( # & ; &- *1 # # + # # ( # # % # !

#

( ## %$2# +&

-# -& # ( .

((&&# # (# +)-+ ##

# ,

- ##'

((& ( #&*1 -4-

0 = +! " "& "

+

! # "+ &

"

!

& ",#

00 +$ ! ,/0/ # +# ''

+&##' $

0 3 !

# +! & #

"''

&# "#& ' !+

'

")! $ !

'

'

9

'

#

+ # '& & ,/0/ " +

+# ''

12 #

## 123(!4, ++

<

()# # = <

( -& = -5-