← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3040/2019dismissed

Uma Lal Yadav v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli14 pages



      

!"# #$%&%'( 

)!*!+ !,!- .#"%"%'#/ 0#/&1& 2"!"# !/3!'!!',"4#/& .#&5',#'"&  ( 6 * 2 02 7  8 2 9 * 2  **8    

    

      

  

!

 "

#   

  $ %& '

 ( ##   

!

  

  )* +,  "# # # #

"# -.

 02 7  8 2 * %

       

   

 "!/&+/. # 0 -  ,   1 2

"  /3%4      

%%, 1 2 %56&   37 %66%    

             /3%4  3% 3% /3%&   "    

"

" !   

" 8 9    

"   2#

  /&+/./3%4  



# 

%4 /3%7     # # 2# :"    /

 /&+/./3%4

  #  "" -  ;" ! -  9          

       

 " < -

   ##  #     2# " 

 "  #/&+/. /3%4  ,  #  #   4=4    :#    "   >?

    !"

 # $#$" %    

 !"

"  !"

!  &'   ! "(

  )      !"

! &   "  %  )  %   %% !! *"

(  " )     !  " '  "( 

 "  

 "

 # $#)$! "

! & "

! +

!  )   & , % -.   "

  #$ ) %

"

  )-.-. ,   ! "/  "("

  #$ !  "

 !  & 0

" %   "

 !   !!    "

"  !   "

'   !     ) 0  "

 )  %'"  ) 0'"

  )   

   '!"

 ) '   ) 0    

 , *  1 1      ! "

  #$ !  "

 !  &    "

     ! "

   "  , "/" ! 2   

      "

  #$  "      )    %   "

 3  !   (  

)!"# %$  ! !" ! 

"/ "

 ! "

! +



)   "

   """ %     !  "

 !  &  "  ) (   "

 &  !  4 "/  "

 ! +

    ) ! !

'     "

 &  !   "

 " ) (  52   ! "

  # " $    

     !  "/  "(  " ! 2   %   "



 3  !  ( ! !    ' "

   "

! & )   6 %6

 ! !" ! "/ "

 !  "

! +

 7  "    )

  "

   "

& # $! "

! +

'    "

  "/    "

  #$ 

 2    2  ! "

   "  , ) (     "

  )

(   "

& # $4%% !  ""

 "

   % (  !" ! ( "

 ' "  "

   "/ 

"(  "

 #$! "

! &  ,   "

 #$! "

! &  )    !"

 #$  !"

 # $#)$ 8 ,  ! 0(    "

 !

+

" 

 "

 #$)%(! /    9    :" %  )  

0( "

 ! "

! +

'         (  "

 #$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 

 "

 #$ + ,   ! "

  #$  ( !      ! "(  

")   "      !     "

  0    "

 !!  )! "

! &"    !"'   "( !  "/  ( %  ""    

, !) "!      ) "    ) *"

   "

  !! 

 "

 #$! "

! & (   % " ! "

  /   (  ! ""



"( !  "/  "

   

  

"( (     ! !"   !  "

 !  &' '  

             2) "

        ""

 "(  

%

% /   ( ! ! 0( 

  "( !  !"

  

 !"    "/ .

<  " <- " @   #               "  -   + .

9     2

"  "



" %%   %56&             /3%4  3% 3% /3%&        #            

 

"         /3%4      



%% %56&

"

         /3%4   /3%4 

" #  

#     %56&

"  +".

 >;"  "  # /&+/. /3%4"  -. -.  

  # 2#"  #  "  #  " 

   

"

"      "     !    

 "

" 

"

  " # #!"  

&&#$! 3(  $ +.

             2    ;" ! - 9

  # 

"

<    /&+/.  /3%4     A

  2  "   

    

 

"<  &

#       

     

  "        

  "  

#   "#   

       

      " @  

#   A  #   4%+%. 4%+/. 4&      %56&  #        7% 53 /3%4 ;"<-

 

2   

   4& %56& B

;" !-

     

        

 " 8   4%+%. 

2#     "  @      



           "     ,       ;" !-

   " 

     

      #      

   +.

 # !/& /3%4"     /&+/.      /3%4  ;" ! -

   

         

 "  " "  #   "  : # 

  /3%4

"        2  &      %56& # #    

 "          :# 

   #      

"     1  2 -          -   : # # "        :  # #    " 4& %56& " 2 +.

 #      

#   ;" ! -

   

  #  2 8    

  

"

,   # #

 # "  

 

"

%=  %56&  !   " # # +.

# #  "   

       /3%4    "#"<  

<#   2# '   /&+/. "  +#.

;" -

     

   2 

   " 

#   2   

     #     "

/&+/. /3%4 "    "

  + .

9 447 ;"-

  

 /&+/. /3%4 " " "               &      %56&   "2

C      /&+/. /3%4 &

   "    8  #%332 D

 $ '388%&+5 3.       B   ( #  

: ,    "# *0  "

 ,   #             " 2 "   !  

       3/ %656  3% %663    &  =    1  2  %56&   "

   %66%    "    *  )@      !&'0  "

 9

" #" 



          

 "     2 #   2 #   # "   " <    ! 9  



# 2 "

   %66%      

  " 

 "   !       

   "         - 9    

"

 

#    

            2   2  2#

" 

"   /&+/./3%4 C   # 

   

#    

#    %4 /3%7   "     '

9 " "      1    

  #! 

 



2 "      9 *   +! .   

      9 

     "   

        

#   2 # "# "2

  2  #

"# 

"   %/ %% %663    !& %56&     "# ! 9"   

 

  :# ", :#;"  ;" !-9    ;   !  " 

7&8 '  ;"<-  #    #  "2

  

     &    

 

# 2#     # 2#/&+/.  /3%4

     447    :#    9

* +! .  -"

 :# !

D ;  "

 /&+/./3%4 "  "

   

 :# " -<=   7! +  =>    !? 

    

 "         #   "2 

      2 #    "

"#"2

    # 2#    #  =

 "

 



    2

#          

 " #

 @ 

   ==  37 %66% 

#  

#    2       !     "     #          

           #              "       :    

  " , 



     9    "  

             2   # /&+/./3%4

0   "

2

"     !&'0  "

      

 "   @         "

      

:  ,        

#!# !&' &=0  "

  

 *-  2 

 # "  2 



#     #  "    #   #    

     

    

2 "   " ;"! -  9       9 *   + .    # # 2#  ,  2 #            #   -

    <  : - , 2#  "

#"            &    %56&    



   !&      %56&   

   >"2 

 ;  "     #   "2 

  

#  2 #    

" 

"2



#    2 2#

 :#  " - 

  E  +! .  -  #       :#         

"2



#    2# 9 "   "              & %56& " ! 1         

 "             &%56&    "" <- !

D +! . >  ; #  " 

 "      " ! 

 #   

#  2 #         # 2#/&+/./3%4

B  #           "# "2 

          "    

  "  

 

2#

  !/&+/.   /3%4         #           " ;"!-9

##  

#    

   "              2         "    >  ;#" < -  9 *   +! .   ;" -

 #  

 > %56&

  # 

> 

!/&+/.  /3%4  A    !   2       

#   "#

 @ 

   ==   37 %66% 

  

#                 

   

" #         !  ,                        "   "

        !  " "  2 

"#

 @ 

 == 37 %66%     !  "  #    "#    ": %%

#     # # 

;"< #  > ;#! /&+/.

 >;!/&+/./3%4

  # "  # " " #

  > ;   

" "#        A

      F  

G

"<  /34 

8  

  "  

 " 

# "#  

      9          

           "        

  :   

  " " ,    #  

  

 "

    

    

 

"  

%/

#  

   





    2#

2 # "<         



#"#  2 #            # /5 /6  

  2 <  

2# $  # "!/&+/./3%4 #   #

#            "     " : %4

 #     

 

!  2  ""   @    - ! &'0  "

 , "  " #8 #        22 2     "     2   # # !&'H&=      *-! !&'0  "

    A

  

# "     #         "   #     # 2    "   8    " "@  2 

#"!

%&

 2 "    @   4=4  9 *   + .   

#  

      

 2         2#   

 "#    

# #

2     "

      

           

  

#"# 2 "  ##/&+/.  /3%4    "#           

# %4 /3%7 #  %'

#    #   

   ,   ! 2      + (9!

$DB I .  - 9B0I)!,9-B + )$119. I)*B 3/ /3//

:    

#8  E8$   " E8$