High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5738/1993dismissed

M/S Wattson Paper Board v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-02-19Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul8 pages

!"#$%!& '() *&+,-!"",

.

/0.

* 1.

/0.

* 1 02 .

! " # $ % ! "

$ & ' ! " (

'

) ! "

) * +

'$ ' ! " # )$ ! ! "

) , .

#* -''

& #

./011*2

456 7 &8 ' ' ) 0 " 40 (&

' " 7 3

# '' 5*11.2

406

' 9 7 " -

7

# '' 8 ' ' ) 0 " 40 (& 7 &150/: *"

37 ' ! +/01;* 2

46 &

* <7 " & 7 7'' 9 = %9 >9 ? 2@

&' 6 " 15+ %9>9 2'

6 '

15, -' */ '' 7 '

"

'

# " 7 # # '' 7 -' A*/B ''!

" 7 '' 7 C

"'' 7 '

' # '!

*0/,1;.!

4*9 : '

"

" /*1;12

4.6 ! @

- A,

''!

" 7 # 7 "' "" # ! '

&' 7 '7 79 " D"

" ' " 7 9' &9 ' # 9 '

C 8' " 7 " ! ;2.6 ;2+6 >9 @ " 1;; /1/011/ /;/011*

"!

' ./011*

'&

E '

"' # E " 9 '' 9 #'' # & '' 7"

" # " 7 " 77 10*8' "' "' " # ''7 ' " 3"

' :

.

# %' #F 10; 8 ' ' ""

9 %' #F

497

% "

"& "

!

" '' &

'

' : 9 % 9

9 9 & (&

7 & # 7 >@ " & - 7 7

' ,+11. 7 >@

'

' ' ! 'EG F ) #@ ' /110+

7 & D"

>@ (& .10+9% " "

9 " "

# '''

7 # " ''

*./*10;

&

' ' ! %' #F *//10;

#E

'

&# "7 9

497 "7

'" #'

? D"

>@ (& #"

' # 7

'' # & & AH ? D"

>@ (&

4"

#'''

'' ./011* @ " &

'

'' 97 & "

'

9

9

7 ? D"

>@ (& 97 **/11. " .*=45C 3+= *=I5C35= " # '7"

' 3 #" # E & 8 ! # " 9 !

' 7

#

'' 1;*

'' '

*/

''

+ " 9 " "

7 ' 7 77 % 8 !

&!

"

& # '

7 D"

>@ (& !

7"'

&'

'

8 7

'C # '

'97 '' 9"7 #

7 "

'

" 7 '# '' 7 #"'

& " 7 ' &#

"

' '# %

'

" 77 " /+/;*/*2

416 " "

# &!

'EG ' ) , " 40 (& /,/,11/ "

# &!

%' # F7 ' ) 14/4 *0/,118 "

" ' '"E

& 879

) ,I %' #F

''#

*/10; "

' ) 0 " 40 (& 7 +'" '

#

"

'

""

7 #" #7 /*/*//0

' 9

) ,& %&7 "

'' # '@"& ,/**/.

'9 - 9# ) 1* */. " #

" &'

' 7 # 9 '

&# #

,

" '

!

'&

"

" 77 "' & 9

" 7 " 8 "

" ' "'"

9 " 77 " 77 "' 9 & ' " !

#''

! & "

" 77 "' ' " ' !

9

8 ' '"E "

# '

"!"7 #" ! 7

41 " #&!

11/ " " !"

9

' " ' 9 ! & '

" ' '

& # 7 #

8 7 '

@

-

"

9 !

# " 7 7 '' 7

"

7

''

9 - 7 E '

"'# E""

9 ''9 #'' # & '' 7"

"# " 7 " 77 10*

7 "

9 # 97 G "' - 9' 7

' '

!

"

# E " ' 9 " 7 9' ' # E &" ' "

"#

9

E7

& " #

7 "

9 9 '

#"# 9 ' 9 >@ & !

'

&9

5 'D E & '' # "'

"

&! & !

9' 98

" '' ?

! @

7 9

"' "' " # ''7 ' "

3"

' : G # '

# %' #F 10;

7 #&!

>@ & C 8 7 " & ' "' 7E '

" : 9 9 "9 #E '

@

- <" 7 = 7 '

" 7 #'

' " 7 "

"'"

' 9 ') '

''# 'E G F 10+ 9 ' ' &

#

) , I %' # F */10;

#''

# " "

9' #" #''

# '' ' # &"

& &7 '

" '

"' 11/ 9#

"

9

7 " &7 ' #'' 1;* #" # E 1;. & " 77 " D"

& "& #

"

9 !''& 9 " 7 '"E # & &"

'

" =9'

- **345 346 4

; 3 '*6 715343 $%%"89:1;;% ''"E 7 & 9 #" ''

"

E 7 ''7 "8# ' '' # " A+ 9'"" # &

""

"'7

"!

" '

" " ! &

37 & 9 " 7 E

& ! # 3 & 8 '' 7 !'9'

# ' & 7 8 7 7 ! & # ' '

7 7 " " D #

" " "

9 # ' 9'

"

77 ' ' & & 7 "

! & & 7 9'"" 3 & 2"

7 < 7 =6 " '

"

#

< = < !"

= & ! ' 7 & #" " 7 ' " 9 '

& ! 9 " '

#'' &!

" 7 ' "#'' !

%"

" " 7 ' 9 " " '

& #

' & " C &

"

9 " 7 "'"

# 7 & " 77 " '"E " "

9

7 9

' #

!

9 '"E & "

'& ' '7 *" &7 # 7 9 -!'- &"

*;/111/ " "7 9 !" /0/11* & %

4 & "

"

9

0

7 "

'

9' # 9 " # # '!

1;. 9' &" '9 " '' 1;, >9 @ & &

' 3 7 7 7 .*10;

! & " 3 7 9 9' & ' !

9

" 9 .*10;G 7 10;''11/ '' #

7 9' &# "

" 3

9 & % 9 -!'- 8 7 7

'' # %' #F */10; # 9

& "

""

7 ! " "

"

!

7

9

#''

# # 9' 9 # 7

9 '' ' & !

'' 7 ' '+* ! # 9 !

" # 7

#

7 7 8.

:

!"#$%!& 8 02 .: 26(