Buta Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"#$!%&'&"()**
+ &(,- ***..!// ( 0'* !"#+(1 2 ***!'."($!( ) 3 4 * 0 5
!"
####### 0 56*
"
! $% $& '$()
''
+
,
" (&-% . /+
01 ($ , , 2 ( 3 ,
* 2 3 ,
4
, " ') $& '$() !
$% $& '$() , '5 ($ '$(5
, $) , $6
, 4 $5 $6 '$(6
"
! "
+ 4:
(';:$))$
< =
* , > , ? =
"
, 4
*
"
? " @ 2?
* =
?
,
, "
@, ? " 2? "
9 " @ . 1
8 =
*
."1
"
= :
* 9
,
! , *
* > , * ,
, "
? " *
"
" * ,
4
, "
? * 9 " " " ''5$$ '$ " *
,
"
2? )) " )) " "
"
* , 3
9 /
,
* ,
,
, * * ;
(5) ./ 0 1 " 9 "
'$5
''
+
, ? , * >(
* (6 $6 '$($
=
B? , "
3 :?
(6 $6 '$($
, 8
*
"
>'
;32 3 '$ " *
" ''6-$ " *
,
7 * 2? " * * , * * 3
9
/
*
, , B? 4
2 C%$7:
* B?
B?
7 * 3 :? *
* , *
*
3
9 & )$ * !"
# $!%%&!' (!)* # * ##+ #+,- .
, #!
>) 3
"
;32
* * * "
*
/
B? (
,
8 B? 4 * 2
B? , B? 8 @ B? = * *
* B?
2 C%$7:
* B? 3 $- $6 '$($
, " = , B? 8 @ B? = B? 8 "
!
9 (6 $6 '$($
;
;
(5 $6 '$($
B? B?
* "
9( 3 :? *
, /% (.&,0 +# ## # #+ 3
* ? "
" " , B? 4 * +
1 + +
!
' (!
# !
*
;32 , *
+ +
, 23
!
#
, 2 3
8
9 ,
* ; + '&
,
"
" () $% '$()
*
" @
)()
? 3 ?
>( 2!
>'
*
<
* 4
, " , 4
"
!
2!
"
?
89 =
"
@
<
*
4
?
, 4
3 :? " * ,
,
>) !
+ 5$(7
= "
, + '( (6 $6 '$($
*
, "
* ;
;32 + %& ;32 + 6$ , B?
( , + '- (- $6 '$($ "
B?
'
>C " 2
"
!
2 = * , B?
>C7
! @, B?
>C74 , B?
>C7 @, , B?
>C7
, @, B?
>C7B :
'5 $- '$()
;32 B?
! $% $& '$()
,
''
+
$% $& '$() * ($ , 2 3 2 (
" , ;32 , B?
>C7 " "
!
89 = >) @, "
>(
>'
>) 3
"
%:6 , ;32
4
3 " @,
@, B?
>C7
@, B?
>C7B >)
"
3 " * >) 3
"
, ,
@, *
: * ,
9 " ;32 * * >'
* >) 3
"
,
%$ +
: " " F 9 , * ,
, , *
,
* * ,
, B? 4 2
2 C%$7:
* " , +
,
%$ * ,
0&1 ;'&(,- - ($+2- $!1 0'* ! "# +1 < 6
9 6*
"
:
4 # # 5 # 5 , /% (.&,0
, 6#' 7# 8 & , .+7# 8
9 7:8 , /%
;
, < 7# 8! ( # # , /%
!
# + + ! 3 "
"
80"
!"# 1 ' - (0'* <= ( ($ ($ (" -!<6
7
<&=&( / 7 "
%$ +
*
! "* :
" + + # + # , /% (.&,0 ## !; + # , /% (.&,0
## ! #(!:&
= !'
# !-# !& #(!),
!" 2 >
# # # , /% (.&,0 ## !
+
, /% (.&,0
!"# # +
&49/6!,!( ,#!
"+ !0 +> ; ;
, +
# , /%7:8 (.&,0 !
- +
!;
!0
+#(!)?,
# (!: ? &
!
#(!:&
! 3 ? " " *
, '$ " * , ''5$$ " *
9 + (7-& () $6 (&-& 3
*
" *
'>&($!<&(,- ($ (" -!<0'* !"#+(1 26
<&=&( / 86*
:
"
9 ## #, (!:@A* :B 6 :*A* +
+ ' 7.# 8
+
#
+# ! # +
# + / ###+!, , (!:@A* CD , & ,
# , !
)!:,
# ! !
0 ##+ +
# # !
)!).
#!0#
@ + #
# !,
# #+ # # + # # & # #
+
#
#!
)!BE +
# !D" +
# /
# #+ # #
2 7 8
+ )1
!"
#
# !" #
@
#
#7# 8 !
)!1 C7 8, @#
!9
#
@
## ! (
+
# 7 # 8
#
@ #
@ !
)!/78 ; #
@ !D - #
@
#
+
+ #
# #
@
+ + :%#
@ # 2 8
+ 1% #
@ !'
#
@
#7# 8
+ !
)!$; 78- 2 !D4
2
)% #
@
/ #
@
+
# !
)!F78 . !D
/
)% 2
#7# 8
+
#
@ !
)!A. #
#!D4
# 7 # 8 # #
# +
#
@
#
# !
)!*,
#9# !D"
## #= #
!" # # # ##
+ ##+!, #
+
# !;# ,!
(! #
78@ 78
# !"# #
#
!" !" # # #
9
#@"
= + !
B!%.#
# 9" !D"
> .# !
> > G > ; ( ( >; . ! #
# H
> >H +
# # +
!"> 0 ;,'
>; > &
+
#. > ' H +
(.!0, G 0
+
#
. @.#+. @0 .
# , ' , H +!
B!:&# +!D0
# +
#
@ ##
7 #
! ## # +##!
0 +
#
#
#!
*
"
4 !"#+(1 20'*- < =&(,-6
<&=&( / 76*
"
:
0#+ :A/% !"
#
)/ # !
## )/ + #!0## + . #
/
!" )/ + . #
:)/ ! H +#9
# #!E
/ . #
! # !!
:A/% / !
. #
# # + . #
# + . #
+ . #
*)!/% !
9
! H ,
# . #
/
#
#! 3 " " *
* 3
9 " *
8 ? "
*
3 , , '$ " * "
3 ?
>) 3
"
, " = B?
*
, "
$5 $6 '$($ (6 $6 '$($ $& ,
3 "
*
/
*
$C ,
" $6 ,
;
" >) 3
"
, ",
"
*
" ,
"
"
*
>)
*
*
! " >) " " * 3
9
! <1&($!<&(,- 0'* !"#+(1 26
9 <&=&( / 6*
:
" +
::!%A!)%%)
## ',HH +):!%A!)%%)!" + :% +
#!0+.; >
!" #$
( >;
## #F)> G
!- # + #
# ! 3 " " * :
C'.1 +
! 80"
!"# 1 ' - (0'* , 1&(,-? (' 6
9 <&=&( / 8 6*
"
:
G0> ; > %&'
$ (
)!!! *
"**+ )!!!
),
# (.&,0 2 >!">; 2 $ '
- ## + 6 ; . / 0 1%&2 7# 8
+6 ;
)!!
,"! + )!!
*, " ; ## > $ '
=
, /% # #
! + >; , /%
+ +
#
!4 9 # , /% 9 # , 1) 0 !
" " " )) " 2? , * , 3
+( !<$>&(@&<%-!<0'* !"#" 6 7896 * 80"
:
" # ## # # !( , + ## # # #!0 # ##
!4 # #
: #
!
#
, B:B >!&!>!+ #
+ #
#!2
## )B!B!*% # / ! :)
! ## + ## !"# # 7 ##8
!"
+ ## ##
+ # #!
"
!" ##
## #
#! 4
#+ # + # , )F
+ ##
# #
!" ## # #, )F 0 !
' ## ## 2 +
+
# , )F+ !4 +2
! ## , )%7878 0 :%+ !!
! ! , )F 0 $ < !! # + !:
# + $ < !!
,2 ## # ! 3 * " , " , " * ! , " 3 ,
" :? *
! *
*
* >
:
C'.1 +
"
C'
.1 +
,
, "
3 " "
, !
=
3 " B?
>C7
>) 3
"
" :
*
:
.1
,
!
89
=
?
B?
>C7 @,
B?
>C7
B?
>C7B 4 *
>(
>'
>) 3
"
89 =
%:6 , " ;32
, ;32 3
? , >) 3
"
* * .1 >) 3
"
, ,
%$ +
* * *
,
%$ +
*
*
/
*
8* $C , "
$6 ,
"
* , * *
, $5 $6 '$($ ;
(5 $6 '$($
,
= B? " " >) 3
"
*
(( , !
*
: , B? 2 C%$7:
*
+
:
%$ +
, " , *
*
>(
>'
" *
;32
>) 3
"
89 =
! ? .1 A
? , * >(
*
;
8* ?
, , *
"
(6 $6 '$($
, (6 $6 '$($
;
(5 $6 '$($
.1 B 3
9 >'
*
"
* /
*
%$ +
* , 3
9
" " F 9 * :
%$ +
*
,
>) 3
"
? = B? , * !
.1 3
" "
" 2? , "
*
3 * ! <1&($!< &(,- .1 "
" "
, .1 3 * ! 80"
0&1 ;'&(,- - ($+2- $!1 .1 <= ( ($.1 , *
"
%$ .(1 +
: .1 4 *
/
*
? :? * *
" ,
>) , " >) ?
* .1 B * *
9 + (7-& 3 , " *
"
*
* 3 * ! '>&($!<&(,- .1 - < =&(,-.1 '$ " * "
"
"
.?1 3 " ; + '&
>( >'
" $5 $6 '$($ >) * (6 $6 '$($ ;
" ; + '&
7 "
"
"
.?1 B? = $- $6 '$($ *
; + '&
, "* :
> ##+ I +#
## +#I # >
#J.,=!"
+ !> ##+# 2
I
##
! .?1 3
" * >( >'
,
;32 " * " @ . 1 ;32 :
%$ +
.?1 A
* ,
%$ +
* 3
9
!
3
, "
8 (( ,
%$ +
;32 B?
'C $C '$()
! ;32 +
; " * ! $% $& '$() : @
''
+
"
, A0 5B (( (( '$(5 > 7 H7+ > " H7+