Major Singh v. Gurcharan Singh & ANR
!" #$ %%&& '"( )("$" #$$"(#$* $"
%
+$$""%"" && ,%%"-./&&, !(#- 0 1/" """%""" 0 +$$"$!(#- $(&/"%" $#0 2"
"3" #$'"456 "$%%&& "6$7 &56 ""%
1$%%&& #(&" %%&# $!(#- " /$$:("/&, ;,(&/%#6 , / "6" #$"6& (/- $%"$&)("$" 2"% #$ 1&4 #$5 ((/" # <
&- &" $$."=&(6, "
-"&-%" 4$"
$" "/" ""& >> ( ,$ $ "6 ( '&&# -#"$ &
=&(6, " -%" 4$" ?
5?
<9 5 ?
95 ?<9 5
?
<9 5
?
-(" -"&$" "/ " ""& >7> ,&& "%"- !( "" "-&- #%" $/6& $-% :("1&4 #$,""&/"$" ,"
(% % ( "$& &"7&, #$ #$ $."
& /$ $,, $$" 1&4 #$ $."
< 1$%&
$"$& /.$" $" @(& $" 6$ $"$ #$$,, #$=(+&& %&
"$$ 1&4 #$5$",&# - .:("1$%&
$6(#$ &" $%"-$A"! #$ 7&, #$9& &" $&$&
-"&6&
"#"
1$%&
&4$"&- $/ (% ."#$ -"&( 4 & -"&/ #$& $"1$"&:(""$ ( ##"6# $ !(#- "5$ &$%%&1$*,"%%&&:("%"&. %$%%&,$&$& #$%&
"&"=&(6 , " %
=&(6, " % -"&; , ("$"$&$!" #$, &#$&
4 & -"&%" /, )("$" 2"% #$
$= $& $" !" #$,(& / &#$ $& $" $&
$""
,"$&/&&#& (&&6 "3" #$'"45&"
&%%" /$&
(/-5$$:("6""
$(#$ $"%" "-&,"%%&&:("6996 # ( <1$&,"%%&&:("6"%"
#6$
## $%%&& $&$A"! #$, $/#& , " $&=(/.A"! #$
#$/" #4$"
%"" & ,6& &,5 51&4 #$$%$ " ,$"% $& $" "/( $%" #$ #$$& % /
6""- $ % A ("$"(/-$&,"%%&&:("$-- &&#&. %"6". #" # $ "& 6996 %"%".
-("
-"&, #$ $ #$/ #$/"$"," (% % $ & " (-/" ." $( $. $ @(" $ , "$%$= $& $"A ("$"(/-$ &&, (/ &@( &,"
!
" # $
# $
$
%
&
% '( "6$7 &5&"
&%%" /$&
"% (/-$ 6 $/ %& ""
/$& !" #$%"6$ "/( ,-/.$ %""9 9 " #$6996$%("$ $& -("
-"&5$-( ". "6 (""
"&1$%%&& $&& #$ & &-&" 6996$, "$% $#"(
(% ."#$1$"% 9%&
," ##"6# $
#" "/.$"&:(",$"#"#" #$"$ ,&& #6 #$"#$4$%" (/-$ (/ &@(
&," ""- /.$:(" A ("$"(/-$&- $%&
/.%" # "6 %"6 $2%(1 . #"(&("& * 5
,(& /- /& "$ " ;,(&/%"%"( $
)* "$ + ,%
"
-
%
)
. .* "$ + ) * /+
-
"
" %
% 0& ) *
1 )"*
" -1 )*
" "( ;$6$"&"
& "%" %%"$%%"
/4 %"(& %"6 56 $ $&&/ &@(" "-$& , " -%" #$ .$"#$5&5 "/.-6 # %%& $ "
($";
$ 5 ($%%& &&# $6/ (/-5$/ %"6 ""1$%%&& $ $&& #$&/. & # .( "&-5-($&5 &- .&" ,$"#" $, "$%/.6"( " 1$&,"%%&&:("%"$"%"
#6 #$A"! #$, /#& , "
5$" "5 (& /%" "6 " 3" #$ '"45 6 $ "& $ !(#- " "/.A >/&(%"-:(" 2
2 3 4 , % 56 ,78 )9* 5:
$%"# ,$-$"%"$/ (#$ "( "%"6 "" (&
/%"&("%&# $"%"5 5
("$"/! "- - --" (- %%&"@("
" ". $"6 ("",(& $,"%"6$ %""9 9 "A"! #$,/ #& &" &$$- ( /#& &" ;
$/ $$&& #$&5 -($&5(/- .%%& $#"" ($".5,$& &- #"#$ & $%"%".$&/.$& &"5$%%&& 9
4$&-6996$&
-"&B6 $",5$&/ %"6 ""$ "& " "%("$ & , "/(/.
/. #$5$$& $% /
;
6, ,$$/ /"6/65;
",$$ #" "/.$:("/&,5-($&5"%"
C( &, /65$( ,"# $ "% 9%&
1$" -" $%%& 2" %%&" #&.- ! "#" $