High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1134/2010dismissed

Union Territory Of Chandigarh v. Arun Kumar Pandey

2015-01-09Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!"#"$%&%'() *

'%'"++%!+,- '#%. +- //"00 '!

1"+&2& +2'324 + '#", "&/'#"'!

( 56 73 6 7

+"&"'!( + 8""97- +4 :##%!%' 0 +!-" //"00 '! ++' 97#:#9$ !" 4%$2&2+% ": ++"&/'#"'! ;-"!-"+!-" "/+!"+&0$ 0'"<&/ /"+4 ,=" 00<"#!&"" !-"82#.4"'!> ="+""++"#!!-" "/+!"++'! ;-"!-"+!-"82#.4"'!&-20#="+"/+!"#%'!-"#%."&!> 6 7:

6 4/2.'"#%'!-"/+"&"'! //" 0%&!-"82#.4"'!# !"# ?

): / &&"# =, !-" 0" +'"# ##%!%' 0 7"&&%'& 2#.": - '#%. +-: 9%#" <-%$- //" 0 %0"# =, +2' 324 + '#",

+"&/'#"'!

$$2&"# . %'&! !-" 82#.4"'! '# +#"+ # !"# *

*: / &&"# =, !-" 0" +'"# -%" 2#%$% 0 .%&!+ !": - '#%. +-: < & 00<"# '# !-" $'9%$!%' !-" $$2&"# //"00 '! 2'#"+ 7"$!%' ?

% !-" +"9"'!%'

##20!"+ !%'$!:)* %'&-+!5!-"$!5< &&"! &%#" '#!-"

$$2&"# //"00 '!< & $@2%!!"#!-"$- +."&+ 4"# . %'&!-%4

-"&-+! $!&:<-%$-'""#!="+"/+#2$"#+!-" /2+/&"#%&/& 0/+"&"'! //" 0: +"!- !'*))A:!-"

#'&/"$!+9%&%!"#!-"02+4%00!-" $$2&"#:' 4"0,: & 00"+ 02+%00&::'#2&!+% 0+" :- '#%. +--"+": B.<-" !02+< &2'#+/2=0%$& 0"-" #'&/"$!+ /2+$- &"#

.+ 4&!-"02+'/ ,4"'! '"C 4%' !%':!-"

2=0%$' 0,&!+"/+!"#!- !!-"& 4/0"$'! %'&%9"0%9%'. '#2+ #" #%'&"$!& '#%!.%9"& &-%'&02=0"%'#%02!"$0 ?D . %'&!

!-"4 C%424/+"&$+%="#&! '# +# *D '#.+%! D '#%!& ! &!"%& 0&.+%!!, '#:!-"+"+":%!%&2'%!+-24 '$'&24/!%' $$+#%'.0,:!-"/+&"$2!%'< &0 2'$-"# . %'&!!-" $$2&"# $$2&"#:' //" + '$":/!"#+"C 4%' !%'!-" &"$'#& 4/0"+4!-""'!+ 0 #6 =+ !+, %'&-+!5 65 -" 6&2=4%!!"# #%"+"'!+"/+! 6" +'"# -%" 2#%$% 0 .%&!+ !": - '#%. +-: !"+ .%'. !-+2.- !-" "9%#"'$" !-" /+&"$2!%' '# !-" #""'$" "9%#"'$":$'9%$!"# '#&"'!"'$"#!-" $$2&"#!2'#"+.+%.+2& %4/+%&'4"'!+&%C4'!-& '#!/ , %'" &:

:%'

#" 20!!-"+":!2+!-"+2'#"+.%4/+%&'4"'!+'"4'!--" & %#82#.4"'! '#+#"+< &&"! &%#"%'!-" //" 0:9%#"+#"+ # !"#?

):/ &&"#=,!-"0" +'"###%!%' 07"&&%'&2#.": - '#%. +-

"&/'#"'! '%' "++%!+,: - '#%. +-: ="%'. '! & !%&%"#<%!-82#.4"'!/ &&"#=,!-"0" +'"###%!%' 07"&&%'&

2#.": - '#%. +-: - & $4" 2/ ="+" !-%& 2+! =, < , /+"&"'! //" 0 /"+2& 0 !-" 82#.4"'! !-" 0" +'"# ##%!%' 0 7"&&%'&2#.":- '#%. +-:# !"#?

)&-<&!- ! &/"+!-"

#4%!!"#/&%!%'0 <:2'#"+7"$!%' !-"$!:!-"+"/+! 6<%00&2/"+&"#"!-"+"/+!!-" 2=0%$' 0,&!-"+"+":'0, !-"+"/+!!-""'!+ 0 #6 =+ !+,%&!=""C 4%'"#!- !-" +"/+! <"+" "C 4%'"# %' 0"'.!- =, !-" 0" +'"# ##%!%' 0 7"&&%'&2#.":- '%#. +-: '#%!< &=&"+9"# &2'#"+( E -"& 4/0"!! %'!-%&$ &"$'$"#"#0,:< & ! B"' ' *

A: <-%$- ' ' 0,&%& & /"+ +"/+! 2=0%$' 0,&!< &2'#!$'! %'%9"0%9%'. '#2+#" #%'&"$!&!. 9" &-%'&02=0"#%02!"$0

?D . %'&! !-" 4 C%424 /+"&$+%="# &! '# +#

*D '#.+%! D!&! &!"< & 0&.+%!!,%&!2+"

!!-"!%4" ' 0,&%&< &)A?D ;-"'!-"&"$'# / +!!-"& 4/0"< & ' 0,F"#=,!-"%+"$!+"'!+ 0

#6 =+ !+,: 2'":+"/+!<-%$-%&'%0"C

#%#'!%'# ',%'&"$!& '#& 4/0"< &#"$0 +"#- 9%'.

AD4+"%' 0$-0%$ $%#%!,!- '!-"/+"&$+%="# &! '# +# & /"+ C

!-" & 4" < & '! #"$0 +"# #20!"+ !"#-"+"< &#%"+"'$"%'!-"/"+$"'! ." 4%&!2+"0"9"0!-"& 4/0" ' 0,F"#%+&!0,=,!-" 2=0%$ ' 0,&!'**)A+"/+!<-%$-%&C '#!-"'=, %+"$!+ "'!+ 0 # 6 =+ !+, ' ))A +"/+! <-%$-%&C

-2&:%!%&$0" +!- !!-" 0$-0 $%#%!, %'$+" &"&<%!-!-"/ && ."!%4"6" +'"#$2'&"0+ !-" //"00 '!- &/0 $"# +"0% '$"'

))* GA'!-%&$ &"!-"

%+"$!+: "'!+ 0 # 6 =+ !+, +"$+#"# !- ! !-"+"

<"+"!-+""0%9"%'&"$!& '#&"9"'#" #%'&"$!& 0'. <%!-#" #%'&"$!&0 +9 . %'!-"+"%&%'!-"+"/+! !-" %+"$!+ !- ! !-"&" %'&"$!& <"+" #"!"$!"# !"+ 4%$+&$/%$"C 4%' !%''& + &!-"&! '# +# 0$-0%$ $%#%!,< &$'$"+'"#:!-"%+"$!+- &9"+, &/"$%%$ 00, 4"'!%'"# %' -%& +"/+! !- ! !-%& 0$-0%$ $%#%!,< &&2=8"$!!%'$+" &"+4!-"# !"#+ <0 & 4/0" '# %!& 20!%4 !" ' 0,&%& %' !-" 0 =+ !+,: 4" '%'.!-"+"=,:!- !%'$+" &":% ',%' 0$-0%$ $%#%!, $20#=" !!+%=2!"#!!-"0 /&"!%4"<-%$-!B/0 $" ="!<""'! B%'.!-"& 4/0" '#!-" ' 0,&%&=,!-" %+"$!+-%& &/"$!!-"/%'%' //" +&!="$++"$! '":%' &42$- &'+## ,2'":)G:<-"'!-"

2=0%$' 0,&! ' 0,F"#!-"& 4/0":!-" 0$-0%$ $%#%!, < &2'#!=" GD<%!-%'!-"/+"&$+%="#0%4%! '#!-"

%+"$!+ ' 0,F"#!-"& 4/0"'!- $!="+:)G: & , !"+ /"+%# =2!%9"4'!-& !"+!-"! B%'. !-"& 4/0" '#!-"0%B"0%-# 0$-0%$ $%#%!,- 9" =""'%'$+" &"#'!-"= &%&!-"/%'%'.%9"'=,!-" %+"$!+-%4&"0$20#'!="+20"#2!H 7 + &!-"+" &'%'..%9"'=,!-"0" +'"###%!%' 0 7"&&%'&2#."%&$'$"+'"#:!-"+"%&'.+2'#!#%"+<%!-!-" & 4"'!-"+"/+!!-" 6

:'0%9%'.+#" #%'&"$!& <"+"2'#-" 0$-0%$ $%#%!,< &2'#4+"%'!-"+"/+! !-" "'!+ 0 # 6 =+ !+, -" 0" +'"# ##%!%' 0 7"&&%'& 2#.":- '#%. +-:- &! B"'!-"9%"<!- !!-%& 0$-0%$ $%#%!,< & #2"!/ && ."!%4""- & 0&! B"''!"!-" $!!- !!-" +"/+!!-" 2=0%$' 0,&!< &# !"#**))A '#!- !!-"+"/+!

* !-"%+"$!+:"'!+ 0 #6 =+ !+,< &# !"#)))A&/"+ !-"+"/+!!-""'!+ 0 #6 =+ !+,

:!-"& 4/0"< & '!#"$0 +"# & #20!"+ !"# '$":!-"+"/+!!-""'!+ 0 # 6 =+ !+, &2/"+&"#"& !-" +"/+! !-" 2=0%$ ' 0,&! '# !-"

& 4/0"%&'!2'# #20!"+ !"# '#!-"%'$+" &"%'!-" 0$-0%$ $%#%!,%& !!+%=2!"##2"!/ && ."!%4"%'"C 4%'%'.!-"&"$'# & 4/0":!-"+"+":!-"+"%&'.+2'#!#%"+<%!-!-"9%"<! B"'=, !-" 0" +'"# ##%!%' 0 7"&&%'& 2#.": - '#%. +- ! %& ' "&! =0%&-"#0 <!- !%!-"2+!="0<! B"&'"!-"!</&&%=0" 9%"<&:!-" //"00 !"2+!%&'!!%'!"+"+"<%!-!-"82#.4"'! $@2%!! 0 -"+"+":#'!%'# ',%00". 0%!,+%'%+4%!,%'!-" 82#.4"'! # !"# ?

): / &&"# =, !-" 0" +'"# ##%!%' 0 7"&&%'&2#.":- '#%. +- -"+#"+# !"#)? :/ &&"#=,!-"0" +'"#-%" 2#%$% 0 .%&!+ !":- '#%. +-:#"$0 +%'.!-"+"&/'#"'! $$2&"# & /+$0 %4"#"'#"++'' //" + '$"="+"!-%&2+!:%& 0&&"! &%#" -"/+"&"'! //" 0%& $$+#%'.0,#%&4%&&"#

6 7 ) * &8B&