High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5899/1993allowed

Ramesh Goyal. v. State Bank Of Patiala.& ORS

2017-11-28Mr Justice Jaswant Singh6 pages

! "

#$%

&#'

()(%*(% +#%,-%%# &#'(.#(%,/0(*(%+#%,#$-%1(2

%,$%(%)#%-%%%,-%%#-#(3%,(% 45 )#%+#%#(#.((./$#(3%,#)#%## ##%($%,$678/#%.$+%(-#-#%, +(%$(#/.$%($+%,($.(32837$$/ 4(5 9/($,:%,$8%8$%;/# 1<7:88:(8 +#%,#($$.%%,-%%((3 ($9/($,:%,$8%+#$-%$$ % ),/8%,(*78/%,8$%+ ((%$%7(88+#%,%#*)7:*# ( (7* +/# %.$ %, /.7# + *(($ -#$#7/#%,#/8+#.#/-66+#.8#(8 %&'1= 9/($,:%,$8%8$%;/# 1<73,8:

%,(%%,>.(#2$+#%,%#*)(#(:($%%,8() 8( ) 73 %, 678 '/-#. /#% ( $ (#7%#(#3($#.(%#3($%(8(%-2( ,$ .%, 7: (-% 73 %, ++(8 #$-%$= 45 #%,(8%#(%*8(#:%,(%%,-%%#),

$,:,839/(8+)88;-#($#/8 %7:#(,$.%7$8% , #$-%$ ,(* *8* -#.% -83 )%, #+#%(:#.%7%)%,$$(%(2$4;8/:'%(% 7(2+'(/#($,%#(5+'%(%(2+((%,'%(%'%#(2 .-83$6 $$(% 4;/# 1 5 ,# $ ( -#*$ +# -#.%%%,-$%+/#&((:.%#(1 (.::#/- (,-#$%-%%$#8(%:%-#.%/##/- 4%(8 #.%5),,#($($/# ?#/-664%(8 #.%5

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

*(($+#./%+%,$),,(*:*$%8%%#$ )887(88+#%#*)(+#.(.:$%%,$(88 (88++#%$)887.(%+88/-%,%+*(($, ,($+#-#.%$/#%,$:#/-)887#$%#%% %)%.$@

/#%,#%,$(.)($#%#(% "

AA 4;/# ;%#(%+-83#($($/# ? B%,(*)%+88:/-%,*(($%,(%.(37 $%.(%7($#*)#%,#)$.-83$+/#%.$ %,/.7#+*(($/%+%,$),)88:*$% 8%%#)887(88%(--(#%,%#*)##+ %,#$#%3,../.$#*8.%+ "3(#$.(3 7#/73%,(2%%,;%%#9/#7/%%8$$ %,( 3(#$($%,.-83$)%, "3(#$6$#* 9/(8%+/#%.$%,/.7#+*(($(#%(*(8(78 ,8%%#$+$%+#..-83$)%, 3(#$$#* .(3(8$%,#+#7+#)(#%/$%,($+'C' .-83$),#(9/(%/.7#+%,$.-83$)%, "3(#$+ 3(#$+$#*$%(*(8(78#8(%% %,*(($#$#*+#%,.%,$#*#.$%,# ($.

(37#8(;73 3(#$$$/,$%8%%#$ #$-%+'C'.-83$)%, 3(#$+$#*.(3 (8$7+#)(#%/$@ ,#$-%$-#%+88/- *(($+&'1 $-#-#.%-83+/#%.$)#%7(88+#%#*)+# %,-/#-$++8:/- *(($+&'1,-%%#6$(. )($%$#($,)($8:78,/$,,($-#$%%,$)#% -%%,(88::%,$8%+%,#$-%$ % D(#/$8+#%,-%%#$/7.%%%,(%#$-%$ )#7/73;/#$ -#.

-83#$-%$)##9/#%*%+/#%.$%,/.7#+ *(($ -#$$$,/8,(*7(88%+88/-+ -#$$ 73&'1 %,%,#,(%,3,(**%E -#$$73%, +/#%.$(%#(#3%-#.%-83 $-%$ % (# 7%) %E ,#+#$#(%+%,#(.+#-#.%% %,-$%+&'1$%#(#3%%,-#.%-834;/# ( 5$8%(-#.%+%,#$-%$ % (#8(78%7$%($

# %#( 8(# /$8 +# %, #$-%$ ),8 #$$%:%,8(.+%,-%%#$/7.%%%,(%%,-%%#)($% 8:78*($$/.:%,(%+#$-%$ % $8%( -#.%(#$%($*%,#)$-%%#/8%7+%%%, -#.%%%,-$%+&'1,(*:#:(#%,.#%($#%3 %,#)#$%)($$/7.%%%,(%%,3)#%,#-#$$),)# $#%%,-%%#)%,%,F+$#(%),,(*% 7-#.%,#+#%#+#$(88+#%)($+/#%,# $/7.%%%,(%$+(#($', (0G/.(#(#:$#%,-%%# ,($ .( (88:(% %,(% ', (0 G/.(# (#: )($ % (88 +# %#*))*#,,($7-#.% %,$$$/#$-%$ ,(*$%(%%,(%(#8#', (0G/.(#(#:(.)($*#82( 8(%#,,($7(88+#%#*),#+#%,#$+#.%3 -#.%:', (0G/.(#(#:

,(*,(#8(#/$8+#%,-(#%$ #/;+%,.(%%#%,-#$%-%%$),%,#%, $8%(-#.%+#$-%$ % %%,-$%+ &'1

$(#()%,%,-#.%-834;/#$ 5# %(+/#%,#', (0G/.(#(#:-#.%%%,-$%+&'1$ ###%

$-/%83%,#$-%$,(**8(%%,-83($ %,3*%.#%,(+/#%.$((%$+#%#*))%,#+# *(($%+ *(($)#%++#),, -#$$ $,/8,(*7(88+#%#*)4+/#%.$5),#($E -#$$ ,(*7(88+#,$(.$$-/%%%,;%%%,(%EE+%,. ,(*7(88+# $-%$ % )/8+(887%)

%EE,#+#*%:%#*)+((%$73 -#$$$ %#(#3 % -#.% -83 4;/# 1 ( 5 ,#+# $8%(-#.%+#$-%$ % (#8(78%7$% ($#:83$%($ $+(# ($ %, $8% ( (--%.%+', (0G/.(#(#:$#%$/$-/%%,(%, )($%(88+#%#*),#(+%#%$.$%,(%,,($7(88 +#%#*)(,$(.,($7$#%(%$#(8<E #/$(8+ %,#:(8$%(%.%+%,$-#$$),,(*(--(#+#%#*) (%,#.(#2$#()%,$#(8<E),,$.%7%) $#(8$<E(<"((+%#$#(8E(%7%,%,-8($%,$(. ,($ % 7 (/%,%(% 73 %, .

-%% (/%,#%3 73 -/%%: $:(%/#((%,#+#%$*%%,(%%,#$%.-#+## %*.%%,(%78)%,$:(%/#.(73(,+%, %#*) ..%% ..7#$ ),#($ 8(# /$8 +# %, #$-%17(2$/7.%%%,(%./%$+%,.%:+%,%#*) ..%%,8(% (%(8(AC !

%,(%%)($,8AC ! AA #/$(8+%,$/.%$%,#$ .%%,(%73*#$:,%(.+', (0G/.(#(#:)($%(88+# %#*)(,)($(88+#%#*)(%*(% *)+%,$+(%$(#/.$%($%,-%%$%($ (88)(%,#7(2$,#73#%%#$#%, -%%#6$8(.#$%#%:%,%#*)+/#%.$($-#%,-83 4;/# 5%%,;%%(88: -#$$+#%#*)+# %, *(($+&'1+%,-%%#$%,#)$8:78,7 -#.%+#.%,(%+-#.%+%,#$%%,-$%+&'1

/#%,#$9/%(8.%(#37+%$7;%%%,-%%# ' .(%%# $ + %, 3(# AA 7%, -%%# ( %$%: #$-%$./$%,(*#%#+#.$#*+-%%#$-#.%( ;% .%(#3 7+%$ %,(% *% %$%: #$-%$ -#.%7(0/$%+#+/%/#(%$+%$-#.$$78 ,(7*$(;#$$,(887.-8%)%,+/# .%,$+#.%,(%+#-%+%,## !"#"$%&'() *+,-

! "

$ B,%,#$-(2:C#($ $C B,%,# -#%(78 $C