M/S Prem Singh Jagtar Singh Thr. Its Partner Prem Singh v. Nirvail Singh
!"## $% !& '( (!")*#+# ,-
.("/0$/%$ ("/0%0 !1/0(% $ %"
.("/0 #########22 33$"% 4 ( $(3("/0 ##########
2!"
"% ,) 56, # 4 # 7
4 # 78# !"
"
" # #
" $ %& '( # )" * ( (" !"
!"
"+ ,
# ( "( ,- ./ ,..& #*
0" ( #* !"
( " ( " $ %& '( # )" &&
%
(
# (
" ' 1- %.
./ ,..1 " $ %&
$ 1, '( # )" && ( (
((
#" ( 2
)
( " " # ( ( *
)
( 3
( ( "
" " 4
5....3 # " *# #* "
!" ' .&%56.1 ,.
.6 ,..1
" #* "
( # * " 4
5....3 $
!"
" #* # " " "7 ,, .6 ,..1
'
$ %& '( # )" &&
" 8 * *
9
!"
"
"
"
:
(" #*
" !"
" (
( 3
#*
" ;
< #
( # # # * " (
!"
"
(*
"
;
< = "( ( ( ( # (
" #
"
;
< = "( " #* 4 ,....3 !"
# "( #
$ ,-/ $$ )
8
;
< ' " # " #* #
"
* ( #"
;< "
* "
" 8"
"
; < > ( # "
( " # #*
" " #
? " ( # (" ( #*
"
# #
9 8 *
" (" !" "
"
# # "
# ( " $ &
$ %/ '( # )"
9 " "# "
# *
!"
!" # ( *
-
? " ( # "( 97# $"
"
"
!0(%90$(( $"3$3 $% 34 #%$% !&1:$ $% $" "
#8 .% ,. /
(.("$322 $3!#*!&
+ 8
"
!
!
" #$%& %'( )* !
+
, -#.
+
!
/ !
- !
)
+
0 !
!
1 "
+
2
+
!
" #(
3)
+
4
2
2
2222 ' 2
!
!
1
! !
!
0
0
2
!
2
" ( #'
3) 3
2
5
2
!
1
0
+1
+
(
"
6778$$$$9 +
6#$$$$$9
68$$$$9
+
:
+2
; +
"
6 778$$$$9
0
7$#7$;
@"
!
;
('
%#6% #4 # 0$<%("%
"$%(!"$3 $ 0(!"6("<
$"
# ., ,.,.
(.("$322 $3!#=!&8 97# $"
" " <;
0
+
+
+ +
+
" #'
3)
2 4
=
+
)
!
+
+ +
+ !
2 " #'
3) )
= !
" #'3) " #'
2
+
+
2
> &
*
" ( # " (" "(
(" # "
# ( " # "
" #
"
9 "# " " $ &
$ %/
* *
* #"
( #* ( # * " ( "* " " *
#
* " " ( # # ( (* # # * #* (" !" ( #
#"
" " " * * #" ( #*
9 " "# 3 *
8 ( "" " "( (* " "(( ( # " ( # " # ( !"
#
* " (
(
9
( "(
) 2
!
0
!
0 +0
0 +
+
+
?
*"
8 "
@9## *
!
!
0
* "
0
0 0
+
!
+ *"
/
)
" ("
" # # ( ( ( # #
( *
9 "# 8 8 # * ( ( " #*
9 # #* "# 8 8 ( # * (* # # #
66
,
6
,) .
" " $ %/ '( # )"
#"
#"# "
"
" # ( " " # "
" 8" !"
)
"# " " "# ( 8 " # " (" #" " # #
!"
"* !"
B " "
#* " #"
" " !" # 8"
( 8 ( # *3(* # #
=8 (* # #
!"
" !"
)
" " $ %/ '( # )"
"
("
" " "
#"# " !" *
"( 97# $"
"
> (
"
$ %/ '( # )" 97# $"
" # " /7!
/
+
/
/
& 0 " #'
3 )
!
-
+
+
" #(
-!
+
& 0
77&
" #( #'+
- -
+
+ "
: ?
))6'8("
.
! "! # $ %& $
& & ! "!
-)
2
- "
- -
*
!
$$ $ #$ %
!
& '($ & ! "& $ 7#)
+
2
-
2 2
2 - )& *
# $ $ #
$ #$ "
$ & !!
&&$ " #&$ ( $ ($
!
* &
& +! "
+ 7%A
+
+ ) B =6
C * & )6 '. "
#.
" ( 3 )
" %
C !
!
+
&
&
D "
:
)6 '.% "
8;8
"
: ?
) "
0
+
)
2 -
-
4
-
% ! "! , &-#$.$ $ $ " && $ (!
&& $$
!
/" & % (!
)% + $ ! #+ %$ $$ ! # "
0$ ! "! +!
&+
(!
%$" !
.& $ ! #%($$
% !
"
& & ($ !
"
%
$ !!
(1 *& * (!
!!
!
&*! "! $ ! # $ - ;= " < ,
)
" # ( " * # (
"
" " "
( # # * 8
"
"
!"
# "
8
" #"
"* " #" " (
"
#" (
( *
#" # " * # #" " " # "
"
" " # 8
8 # #* ##C # * # ( 7" 7
%
4
* # "( 97# $"
"
2 "
-(!
"
!345
8
" /# )
" (
!
"
!
0
!
" (
% " #'
+
+
+
" #(
8*
@
)
- -
7 - -
# - -
!
E /
2
- -
*
- 0
2 - ." %
C
E/ E , - E/5
E /5
- )
)
;" (
" #'
+
+
(
E /
" #
C
" ( #'
" #(
2
2
2
" ( #'
!
2
+ 0 2 '!
-
-
" (
-
- " #'
-- - -
" %
C 0
5
7$) $$
$ 56 &.$ % ! $ % $
( !
$
$$ " $ & $ '($ & $ !
! "
!!
$ () ! "! $$ (!$ ! #&$
(!$ &$ "!
$"
) $$ "
$$#$ ! # 7 % !!
$ %
$ " %#*$ # $ $$
! # '($ & $
$ #$ $ ($ &
# #$!
$ "!
2
" %$ !
$ &
&!
&& $ "!
) ! # ! "! * $$
$ $& $ $$ " $* !
$ & %$* $ "
# $ ( '
($% !
! "
%
$$ " $ &$ * $ !
!
(
=
+
0
!
" %
C
" ( #'
7!
2
2
4
0
" ( #'
// ;= " <
"
#" "* " "
8 #* # "#
8
" * "
!"
" #*
# # * # ( #*
"
* " " 8 # #* ( #" 8 (
* #
# ( 8 #
" " "
" " " # ( " " "
" * # # 8 8
## "
" " " " * 8
)
!!
9 ,,* 97# $"
" # "
" $ %/ '( # )" " /7.)
2
" #'
2 !
2
B A &
2
7;" #'
2
5 " #(
+
" #'
" #(
+
)
9
2
7()
B
" #'
E / !
2
9 / -
) :
2.
" "
.
". . ,5* 97# $"
" #
" " $ &
$ %/ '( # )" #"
;
< !"
" ( " *3
!" " ;
<
" !" #* "
"
* *
" ;
< "
#" * # (
"
( !"
"
(
"# "
#* " " " "
" ( " ( * " "( ( "
#* ( #
"( 8 " /. 5 2
A :
"
A : , )
!
;'!
$$ $#"
""
% " &8*4*<'% !
"
68$$$$9
68$$$$9
)
!
&
% %
!
! $ $ " !!
& *% $ "%!
$
&
%
)
2
+
68$$$$9
+
2
+
!
!
+
2222 ' / % ! "! $ 6
% 53 &=
/ ".$* % # !
$ "!
# % 7 & & # # $ "
$$ > $ & $7 !!
& !
" # $ % $$ %
"
0 !
"
% $7 & # &$ "!
$B
+
2
A
68$$$$9
+
2 2
0
+
*5
2
+
2
0
5
;
"
0
" #(
A 2
)
A
/ ;= " <
)
!!
9
!!
34 ,6*
(
" " '( # )" 97# $"
" # " /%A "&"
:"3 :
: ?"
B
7$$. ."
#'
" ( #( #'
(()
" ( #'
C2
2 < > < >
37(, <7(5
2 < >F > < >
@ ) *G 7$$8 7"
,
"
#$#87 <)
F H F H " %7
* = 6
G
I
F H !
2 FH F H 2
" %
C (;7
)
2 F H
F H> 8)
2 < >
6
< > < > " #
C
3#$,
+ <#$
< > < >
" (
# $ ( $ '($ & $ !
! "
* $$ " $ &!
$
$ * $ !
!!
$ ( J
C
> . ) %
!
&$*& %$ $ &
$$ ! #($ &$ %
& $ #$ # #$ $
& &$ "!
$ !
D
3#7, <#7!
)
> ;) B A & ?D
G
7$$( %"
8%
2
J
* 3#7, <#7. $$ & $ &!
& !
$ !
" ( " " &"
$
&"
$ .
$$ $
"
$ & !
& !
&
$$ &! $ $"
$ &&> (!
< >) 3#%
, <#%J
< > )
> 785
" ( #'
,
4
2 +
" #'
+
)! "! $ 53
! "! $$ !
&$) &!
&&
! "! & !!
$ & !
) ! "! * !& $$ #$ " $$ $
"
" $ "!
!
&$/&$ &!!
$
& !
$ % & " "
$ !
&$ $$ " $ !
%$
!
2 " #'
7.
+
" #'
+
!
+ 0
) 2
*5
+
+
678$$$9 0
*5
*5
'';
6(0
)
7$$
6%8$$$$9 & G *
6%8$$$$9
7$$
68$$$$9
3' 7$7
C2D7
)
7$$7$
6( 0 D
= 2 6.0
+
!
/ ;= " < &
" " * * " ( #
" #" * *
" # 8
" !"
(
#
"
* *
!" 97# $"
" "( " *
" # #
)
# " ## * # #* " !"
"
66
6> 6 /
#*
"
( ( !"
97# $"
"
9?.
%
# &9 *./835 *
8 " . " %7#
+
!
*
+
/
+
+ +
!
+ !
+
+
)
1
+
!
+
"
K
+
2
&
+
*
"
" !
B
C 3 : C )6'%8* 8
; "
K
+
+
-
-, ""
?!
"
" "
? "
*
+
-
/ )
+
-
--
-)
2
+
!
" %7#
+
=
6
"
"
-
0
+
- !
2 -
-
!
" "
"
6
"
!
"
* 1
+
!
+ 0
0
)
+
& #.
/ ,.
@" 97# $"
"
=
# &2 *4* " A@ &
+
" #;( *
+
+ @ )
& "
B 7$$ '"
('
+
"
#;( * ) 7 '
, 7!
+
!
+
+
!
0
9
0
"
? &06 "
@* ';8 #"
7'"
:
"
& ''$ %"
;"
* "
@* 7$$# "
;. 3 "
"
:* 7$$% $"
.''& "
"
@* 7$$. '"
;# "
@* 6?"
7$$; #"
$7"6 "6 6 7$$( 8"
8#8 "
7$$' $ "
7$. * "0 6 "
* 7$$' ."
'( 6"
"
* 7$$ 7"
%%8
#) "
" B
C)6'#%*
77;
* , ) %$% <L
A
1 7
0
+
1 #
1 %
A
> %!
"! B "
)6 '8%"
& "
"
* )6'8;"
7.:G "
:
)6'.#"
7$$B :
"
& ';$ 7"
%8$" "
B ''( 8"
%7& "
"
:* 7$$7 %"
(8 "
G " !
0 7$$; #"
;88 8)
"
B 0 7$$; % "
%8
, "
%#7%7 <
+
7 !
*';# 2
+
# ? 2 F
H F
HF
HF H F
0H
2
+
"
F
H
+
%
+
J
"
+
8 )
+
> .) G = "
@* 7$$( $"
%8$
+
H+
!
+
;) "
6
3 7$$' '"
#.(
2
, "
#;%7$ <7$L +
> () "
@* &
7$$' %"
7;
+
!
, "
7(. 7( < !
H
!
H
1
!
1
!
H
1
!
!
2
"
+
>
D "
7$$' $"
%$ '!
2
+
!
H+
)
>
@
7$
, A7$!
2
0
!
<
>
? 6 BB D '(% % "
.#8 C2 !2 4
G 3
M " ''7 " 7 "
#7!
6M*
C''%" # "
..8GD * 7$$ "
8$ "
7$$' $ "
7$. G &B 6 "
* 7$$'
$"
.#. > @5 )
B "
* ''' 7 "
$
&
@5 )
? : "
"
B 0 7$' 8"
%#.
" #;( *
+
!
'87 ) #
, A#
+
@ A ';( "
77()
+
+
+
$ , "
7## <$
+
4
=
" A
!
" A
> #) " "
B ''( 8 "
%7
+
+
+
+
5
( , "
%. < (5
5
6 & D "
G ''. '"
778 K
+
*
+
&
N 5
0 )
+
1
)
H
&
+
1
+
2
> #7) B60 @
"
B
''' #"
#$'
A
+
" A
+
" A !
" A
9 +
!
!
+
" A ##) "
@*)6'88"
($; 8
, )6($' $ A8)
+
A )
" %; *
+
+
)
+
0
0
+
)
+
+
)
0
"
& ""
"
)6'87"
8715 B "
@*)6'8#"
77 )
#%) BG6 "
* ';'
+ "
#88
0
> ,
"
( "
#* 97# $"
" "(
"(
( ( !"
# " D " < (
"
(
!"*
( !"
#< ) (
( !"
(
" #
"
(
<
" (
"
(*
"# ( ( #*
" "*
(
# #"
" (
( "
(
<
(
"
( !"
" # " *
E* "# ( F
< " " * "( !"
# "(
" * # ##
+ < G " 8 " H"# ( I H( " ("I H* ( "I H " I H( ( I
" 8 "
( !"
$" (
" H" ("(I " "
!"
" "
"
(< ( #* " # #
( # #*
( ( 8" ( #* (
3 #
( * # #
A(
( F
( "("* ( "
*
B'
?:$)B'
,,
)
"
C 8
1 #
&C "( 97# $"
"
(
" " " $ %/ '( # )"
#"# "
B " ##
* #
"(( " " ( " 8
" (
#8 #"
" " # "
"
+
8"
( 8 ( # * (* # #
" 8 (" !"
" ( #" # 8 ( # * (* # #
,%
' " # 8 # ( #*
* (
" " #"
" #
"
) "( "(
" " " " ( " 8 " * #"
"
9 # #* 3 # 8 ( # * (* # #
" " * ( ( "# # #*
# * ( " # # " # ("
* * #" ("
"
(
"
( #" #
* "
" ("
#*
"
" " #
"*
" "# "
"
) #*
"
# "
" * # "# " #*
"
)
( *
++
* * ( #*
"
(*
?4 # 7@ *#+# $"(3
0
9 , O93
O93