Yudhvir Singh v. State Of Haryana









   

  

  







 !

"#$"$

  % &

 !

"'"$"$ 




  


 
 


 
(!

 )* ( + 
+ + 

,

 )* ( + 

,*



   
!
"#$ 
$%
&$$'
 ()$
*
!


"#$#$'
 ()$
*
#


!
+
!$%'


%


'
$$$
&#
!
$$ #
!$ '
 '
$$$

!
,$-$%
#$-$'
 ()$
$ !
$.$
#$-$'
 ()$ *
 / + + 

,

- 

# #
#
$
'
#

)#$%% 
# ($% 
*
$
*)$'
$
)$-

 
)
2
*
#
3$

)4
)'
1562
7#$*
*
#
)$%%
$
#
8)
*
156289

!('
#

$%
-$+
$
)#$%% 

#
($% 
* $)
*
$
*)$
 
)
:
*
#
8)
*
15628
  )#$%% 
#

7;
/<9'
$
-$ 

)-%$)
&#
#

)
*
$
(
=)#
*
#
" >

#
$ (
*)$79
)$-
)(%

 >?

@5 165?
7;
/19
$

>A @5 1655
7;
/>9 <

#
&

$%

"B
<1::C1656



*
#
"'
&#'
$
)#$%% 
&$
-$ 

#
*)$79 7$9
#
$
&

&$

*
# #
$
 
-$ #

>5 @6
#
 
$
-$ 

#
$
&


)-
;$)
#$*


            



 

    ! 

"

   #!   $ %     &  

'      & (  &

       (    $ '& (   ) 

     $   

     &

   $   (  *  (                   



 

    !  "

   #!    

 +    & '   & 

,  $ -. /010      /2

%      $

       %  ( $     &    $ '&         ! &!

(   '& &    $      (  &

    '&

  !

(  &

  !



  $ & 

 & 

 (      ! $      

  

      (   & &  *  '&  (    

&    &%    &  (    , 

    &  (   &

  



 

4

#
$)$%
"--
$
)$

(
* $$$'
(
$-
 -
#

7;
/>9'

$ '
#'
#


)--
#
-$+ 
*
$ ;-79
(/$/(
#
$)4
%$ 
&('
#
$

(


)) '
$#
-$ /$*
&#
#

*
# $)$%
"--
)) '
$
)

)#$%% 
#



$)4
*)$79'
# #
#

#
$
& 
*
#
"

#

&
)#$%% 
#
$)
* *)$79
*
$)4
7$9'
#
# #
(+
# -$ $
*
)
>2
7>9
*
#
 #

$
"-$
$

$$)

3$
)4'
#$ %$
$
%- )'
>@1<
7#$*
*
#
*

$
#
8)
*
>@1<89'
&# '

#

%$
*
#
$%
%$)#
$)4
) 
  #
8)
*
15628

:



$

-
#
#$
-
*
#
&
'


$

(
*-
#
*)$
7$9'
#)
*%
"B

<2@2
*
1656
$
#
))
&
'
*
#
"'
 # #
$
 
$
#

#
"

>6 @:

>@1@'
# "B 
7$9
)$-
-

#
$

(
#*-
*

'
*
#
8 %
;
"'
&#'
#
))
$ *)

#
$%
 
-$ 
#
"

>5 @6 1656'
  &#*'
#$
$%$ 
;$)
$ ('
&#'
#
)%
* #
% $
)) '
()
#
$
 -

#
$-
* !  =$.'
$)$%
"--
7(9
$
)$


(
$$$'
*
#
-$+ 
*

)
*
#
 )) '
$


&##
#

$
$
/
# ;-
%
$ % '
#
&#
#

#)
* # 
#


$%
$ 
#
*
*
;-

 %
#'
#
%($
))79
$#
)$-
)




$-$ %
*

%$
*-
$)4

?

)
#
$ (
3 )$-
- 
#
8 % ;
"'
# 
$%
#
$ (
;$)
 '
$
)$-

  
#
"

"B
<1::C1656
$

"B /<2@2/1656'

$ '
#
))
&
'
#
$)4
))%(

#-'
$%
#
$
 -
$-
*
!

=$.'

$)$%
"--
7(9
$
)$

(
$$$'
 (
#
%($

$

-$+
)-- $79
4$
$-$ % 
#&
*
#
$)4
%$ 
*-

%$

'
# 
$%
$)4

$
))%(
**)

/-%
&#
#
$
)-- $79
$ -$ 
#
$)$%
"--
)) '
)$-
#
$(

(

#
8 %
;
"
#*'
#
)-- $79 *$($ %

#
$
#% 
$
&%%
$
*$($ %

#
$ #% 
$


))%

)-
$**- 
#
8 %
;

"
#
*#
$
)%%$
#*'

#$'
#

)$ -$+
$
)#$%% 

#
)-- $79
$ ($$%

#-
$ -$ 
#
$
$)$%
"--
#

#


!('
# #
#
$ (
-$ 
( )79
*
-$%'

$
-$ '

#
(
&
79'
#
$)4
))%(
$

**)
$
# 
)-%%
'
#

*-
/ )$ '
#
-%$
#
)$
*
$)'
$ '
$%-
-%$ #79
%*79'
$#

#
$

*
#
" 1@

#%'
#

)%$-79'
#$
)
# -%$%
$
%$ 
)$-
%$
*-
$)4'
#
 )%
*
$'
#'
#


$%
%

+
$ ($%
)%$-
*
#
%$
*
#
&
79

(
#
$ (
$ 

-/%'

(
# $ (
%*
$
)%$-

#
$%
&
79'
#

.)

#
%$+'
#$'
#
$
$ ($$%
)-- $79

$
)$-
-$ 

#
$)$%
"--
)) '
#

($% $ 
#
8 %
;
"'
# 
/(%$ *
#
$
%*

#
$
'

#
'
&#
#&( $%


$))
#
8 %
;
"'

$%
$ '
#
 #
%$+
*
( )$'
$#

  
#
8 %
;

"
4$
#
$
$ ($$%
)-- $79'
$'
-$ 
4$
# $
#% 

#
$)$%
"--
))

#*'

(
#
($% $
*
#
$ ($$%
)-- $79'
$'
-$

#
$)$%
"--
#)
-$ 
$ $
#
&
 $#

#
'
# 
$%
#
$
$ ($$%
)-- $79

(

)$)


#
" 1>

"4%'
#
"



(
#
$ ($$% )-- $79
-$ 
#
$)$%
"--
))
 #

#*'
#
&

)$
$ 
#$
#

%


$
$
)%$-
*
#

;-
*-
$)4

1< #
%$
)%
*
#

 -'
#$  4

#
$)
*
*)$79
7$9'
#
 
 .)
 
)
A
*
#
8)
*
15628

#
$

.)
#

)
#$

#
$)4
%$ 
#
#$

-$ 

"%$
))
"4%'


)
#$
#  
-$ 
#
 
)) '
.)
#
$
 .)'

&#$*'
#
#$

$
)%$$
 
)
:
*
#
8)
* 15628
7;
/>9'
#

$

!('


$%
)

#$
#
 
#$(
)

$ 
#
$))
*
( 

)-$'
$-)#
$'
#
 
%$
#
$)4

%$ 
(/$/(
#
$
#% '
&#$'
#
 
 )

 .)
#

%$ 

$)4'
# #
-$+



#
- 
*)$79

&('
*
#
$


$ 
#$*'
# $ (
-$ 



%
$

.)

#
-$
$ *
.)
#
$ (


* '
'
#
 
 #
%/$** $('
$
&%%
$

#
$ -'
*-%
)

#$
#
&
%$ 79'
&$
$)4
*
*#
#
4
 %) '

%

$))
*
 
*
-
 
$ $
# 
/
*-
#
$
%$ '
#$
# ;)
*
#
 %)
&+'
#'
)$-
*$%%

)  -$)



$ 

#
 %)

#$

 ( $% 
*
#
$
#% 
))

#*'


'
# "
*$

$%%&
#
8
)%$-
*
#
$)4
%$ 

%$
*-
$)4 1A #-'
#
$
)%$-
)%
#$(

&%%
*

%

-
*
)
25
*
#
8)
*
15628

(
&#*
$ ;$)
#$*

     

      !"#  $

 $ % !&&%' & 5 / 6'

&    &

 (    

7.  "

    $  $!   (    ) 

(  !   (   & 



 $ % 

- 8    "

    (   ! 

  ) 

          

 (

& 

  (     (( $!   

)   ( 

   (  ! &

  

    &! 

 

   &

     

 

$! 

 $!    & 



(  &

 

      

   

7<9
;;;;;

1:

&('
)
#
$ 
*
%$
*
#
$)4
%$ 

)$

-
*
#
$
(
7$9'
#
)%


%
*
#
$-
*

#*
$ C
* #
)-
*
$&$ '
$ '

 4
#79
#*'

&#
#
 '
*
$'
#
-
#
 .)
$#
&$ 4


$$%
-%'
#



-$ '
&#$'


-$
-


)#$%% '
# 
#





$))
*
$
&$(
$
$ $ -'

-$+
$
)#$%% 
#
-$%
 '
*
$'
$
)$-
-$ 

#
 .)'
$'

)$
 
)
A
*
#
8)
*
15628 1?

#
*#
)4)
#*'

$%'
#$
)
#

)


;)
&#
#
$- 
*
)
25
7$9
$ ))

#
8)
*
15628'



;)


#
$-
* 



#
-$+
*
#
$&$
*
#
$)4
%$ '

&#$'
#
$&$

#
$
)$

)
 1:

@< 1656'

&#
$
-

)$-
*% *
#
"'

)#$%%
#
 '
*
$'
.)
#
 .)
$
$
  )
A
*
#
8)
*
15628
"4%'
#
)%$-
*
%$

#
&
%$ 
*-
$)4'
)$%%
&#
#
$-
)- $)4
*
 /(
#
4
 %)
'

#
-/ *
$
$
-/
%*'
$ '

%$ %


.)

&'
$- %
#
&$
-
$
*
)#$%% 79


#


#
-$%
 
-$ 

#
 .)'
 &#
$$
*-
#
"
 
*
$
#
/
* #

*-
#

%$ '
#

-$+
$
 

$
#
 
*-
-$+
$
$&$

%$%
# **)
*
#

$
*
#
 
7 $9'

#$'
#
-$%  '
*
$'
$
)$-
-$ 

#
%($
 .)79'
- 
 #
$&$
$
-$ 
4$
#
$)4
%$ '
# 
#
)#$%% 

#  '
*
$'
.)
#
 .)
*%
 
)
A
*
#
8) *
15628'
#
)-
*)

"4%'
#
$ (

*
)-$
 $

$
 

#
&

4$
-%$% $
%$ 
*
$
#% 
)) '

#'
$
)-%% 

%
$ -
$

.)

>@

#
*#
$
*
.)
#
$ (
 -

)-
*

#
*$)-
#$
#
$
'
$#


#

$

($(
()
*
%$
$
%$)#
#
$
* -$+
#
$ (
))%
)-
$+
*-
#
*$)-'
#$ #
)#$%% 

#
$*'
#$

-$ 
$*
$%-
#
*(
$ %$ '
)
#
%$)#
*
$)4
) 
 
#
8) *
15628
%$%'
#
;$


#

#
$ (
()
$ )#'
#

(

.)

21.

Even the Hon'ble Apex Court in a judgment rendered in case titled "M/s Star Wire (India) Ltd. V/s State of Haryana and others", reported in (1996) 11 SCC 698, has in the relevant paragraph of its verdict, paragraph whereof becomes extracted hereinafter, thus declared that any belated challenge, as made to the relevant lawful fully terminated acquisition proceedings, thus is hit by the vices of delay and laches, and thereby too, the said belated motion as existing in the instant petition, is but required to be declared as misconstituted.

(

"         

 (   &



    &

 

%

 (   ) 

&

 9  

    %

(   ) 

     

!

(   ) 

&

    (   (  

  (  

  &

 # ( 

     &



 $ 

 

 (   $   )   $



 8 ( 

(    

 

  ! 

$   $!    (    ( & $ 

( 

( 

  

:

/  

 $    (  & 

(    ! %

 (     $ & ;   

     ( (   

$ 

  

/. * "

 %   < ,

 ;  ( #!  =+> /00?

1  -21>  

      $)   &   

   

   !

(   ) 

&

 

 

 (  % ( & $ 

( 

( 

 * @A "   (  =/00.

/  -1:>    $   ( B =/00.

C 7-?>  

     

 $!    (    ( & $ 

( 

( 

  

:

/ 

 $     "

     $ ( ! (    $ (      )  ; &    

  )   !

  6  

 (   $!  &   

 ; $ ( !

      $  & 

( (  

$  * B + A D

%

 

   <    E F  &  D D

%

 < , G /00. /  /-:>  

  (     &   (  & &! ( 

( 

  

:

/  & $  

 (  

   !

( 

( 

  !  %  & 

(    $(  & $ 

(   

  

.      &&     

  

  $

 ! %      (   ( !  <      < , =* /0.:  /22.>   

 

      

  $

 '&   !     (

  && 

$  



$ !     &

   

!

'  ! !

(        !

 ( ;     

  (  

 H

$     < ,  ; B 

( *  < , = /0C2 /  1:>9  ( !  < ,  A  A% =* /0C?

 -/02>9 (

<    D "



 ( I = /0C? :  -1?>9 E ; %       < ,  # 

  

 (  ;'  $! <   =* /0C2  101>9  ( ; A < ,   J D F  < ,   =+; /00?

1  />9 *&

  ;  %  < ,  +   < , =/01C &&  .21>9  ( 

$ < ,  # , 

&  #

   

! D  =/01C &&  .1C>9 %   #   F   < , =+; /00?

1  :0:>    ( #!   I   = /00.

C  70:>   

     # 

 

  (   (     ) 

&

  ; 

        

 &  & 

( "  $!

 ; *   I  &  < *

      D < , =+; /00.

1  /.>             &

 &&    

 $!  $     

   (  

 (    ) 

 !

( 

( 

  

:

/  

  

.     (     

  

// "

. /0



23.
% 2



>> 
$*-$#'
#
"
* 

-

#
&
'

#
$-

)-%%
*(%'
#

4

-

&#
)
#*'
#
$-

-
&#
)
*

A@'@@@C/ 

*#&#
 
#

&#
#
8

'

 !

& '  )  &  *

'

  + ' 
 ,
*
- $
#
$$%

$

#
$
))

><

#
- 
*)$79
$
#
)4
# $&$
$
-$$
$
$**-

>2

)
#
-$
)$
%*
#$

) '
#'
$%%
# 
$%)$79'
*
$'
$%
$ 79

*

4+ + 

,5


4,*



5 "'"$"$  +$(
 #


323

6/7. 89 / 

!

9 323

6 2/:0 !

9