Hukam Chand v. State Of Haryana
!"# $%$
!"!&"'
!"# $($ $
!" )# *+ ) ,
,,
-
*+ ) ,
-+
# "$%& '' !()"*+( , '! -
(.)"".)( %((/' (
($'(#) )( %(( (0(.'( 0()"*+((" (1('( 0()"*+( , !"2 ,,
-
.
4 '
#''(!)'! +'(..#' *(."%,(,+()($+(0 " " +5,'("
+6 +)4785 ' , ' +(.."('9+,47859 * )'! (.0(-(+'(..#'*(."%, (+,(,+( " +:,'9+,47859)$" +'(..#' ! ;
2:)(0("+0!.(+' " +!("$%( *<+','
= '($*,+( $+(0 !+*.% " =>?7487> ;
24("=@?74877 ;
2A
A '/ ! ( . " B A478C4878 $, '
)/' )(+'(..#/(0("',+(
('("/ !/("!",'
#'( " 0(" ' =7?84878' " (0("'("/ ! $+0; (+"'
!
"
#! $ % &
' & ( &
( $ '& ( )
$
&
$ ( * (
! "
#!
+ & ' &
, $ -. /010 /2
% $
% ( $ & $ '& ! &!
( '& & $ ( &
'&
( &
!
$ &
&
( ! $
( & & * '& (
& &% & ( ,
& ( &
4 5 ' (+(. 00 ("+ ( %*, ( %(()* !( 0 $0"' ! ;
2=) (") ' ) ' "" +00" ' 0(-# , (!! ;0! *2(2* ' (+6 " .(" /* ) ' (## *"
! ++ ") (' 0(""2(,"/'' ! ,
' (+(. 00 ++ ")("!
+""+'(..#' (+6 ,+( )'
#'' #'(/ !$, '
'
#'("+0("?54==??>)' / ! (/("!",/'+ (" + '
.*(! ,'(0; (+"' ''''' &
$
)
( ) ( & $ & & 5
( 6-2
78+& 9#81 &&
(
( ! 9 /:220 ( -22; ! & ( ) % ! &
'
/ $!
*
(
( ! & ( ) ( & $ & &
&
) ( ! & $
& & $ & ( & ( ) ( & $ & & !
$
! < &
! & (
( &
!
&
'
/ ) & ( ) $ ( )
< &
! & (
&
( ) &
( $( && & ( @ .# (## *" , 0 ' " () ' ,
" ==@A2=?44$, '
'
#'( "
"
(/' 48?4=?4>)'.( " *<+',' " ", (,'/ ! ( #(. 0$
'
, ("+0 $#0("' ' .*(! ,'* "+ (; (+"' ''''' (
( & ( &
+ (
&& (
&
) )
)
$! *
!
&! ! &&
&
& % &
( ( & ( !
% ( &
& (
< ( &&
! !
&
) !
& & && (! ( + !
$ && $ 5 ( & $ & & $ (
&
$ (
<( &
$
66:2 66:- 66::
( /00/ /2.-1 /22.1 ( /001
$ & !
$
)
! $ (
-:
- ( (( (
$ (
!
= $
-->.
( -2//
&
3 /1/2-2/. = =
!4 : ' ! / +'(..# ' (+ , ,+( , (+6 () '
'
#' *-# ' 0("(,+=5 =, '#' ( 0!(("
(!( +% (" +6 ) '($.( (" .0
+)=?4A ' , ' , ('9+,=?4A9)/' $%) ' .(!#,'( . .( +'"(+6 !
+"# "
'9+,47859 > (!0' '(0,'/ ! ) $#(## *", 0',+( ()'+,." B A5?5,4878("' ++"/ !)$, '
)$ '
#'( " !("' $%'
=8?:=?4?)' B ($+(0"0"'(## *"' , 0!
,
"
) $, ' 9$. !;
) /' ) ' ++
(
, +'( . " 0("$%'
=7?84878) "
/' ,)'((.
("%$; (+"($*)/' )'+ .,
'.#(++ ")*+"' (""0'(!!0, <( 1) (+(. 00 * ("+ ( % * ( %(() , ' 0(-# , ! !+ , ' ++ ")(" ! /'' ' (%!( % 2' ;0!" !. (" $ ."#) '
/' ' ! '+ ,
' $%'! $#(.(#"'$,,;0!
$.%' )' .*(+
+ (' $+(0!
+"
$(0($., $+0# .(", 0(+6 7 +'($*$+(0"0"$%'9$. !;
) ' $% (. ' ($* ; (+" " ) ( $+(0
" "$%'
B A478C4878(" B2A5?524878) (") ' ++" / !) '
(+6 ++.
*%
' 0 ) (. ' (" "0 (!!0 , <( 1) (+(. 00 * ("+ ( %*( %(() *' .*(("0(- +00"( 6 ((0($.% ' /,'(+6 ".(", 0$+0# .(" )"
' $%(.(+6 $"#("++.
*,,+ 8 20.% /' ' (!! +00"( ( 0("$%' (+(. 00 ++ ")$+(0'
(!!
*"
*$%'9$.!;
' , )' +00"( ,(*
($.'('." (/..( ,(*
($.'( '." ( $++.
""$+0(,, 0"$%'9$.!;
',
' (!+ ..( %' ,)'()'! +( 0(-(%+'(..#' +00"( ("* ( (.'0( 0("$%'(" (+(. 00 '
' ! 4? * )' #''($*0("* "+ ,"0(.) (0(")'!
* / ! )'
(+6 ++.
*("
$"#,,+("' $%+0!..%!)'! , 0 2 +(#) '
0.( ' +( , (+) (") (.0 0.(
' ., ) (' '(!$, '
44
'.) ' ! +.(0 ) '( + '
0.( .% (" .(" $+(0 .(" , 0 (+6 ) '
+!.,!( %)' !)'! ( (.."-( *(."+.(0, ' .(,'/ !
! % 4=
*'($* ("# "0 2.) #*' ($* .,(+.(0"'( . / ! )'
$+0#
1+"'!.(-)'()'(!!("* ( (. +00"( ( $+(0 0(" $% ' (+(. 00 ++ ") '
$+0#*(."("$%'9$.!;
)' $% 2*.( ,'(" .,'(!)$%'! )/''/*
( . ""(++'9$.!;
)(.$(
"'
' !.(-,*"+() (' $+0# " "$%'9$.!;
6 ('(!!("* ( (. +00"( )()0("6 ('
('." $%' (+(. 00 ++ "' , ) #*'*(."(,'("* ( (. +00"( )()0("$% ' (+(. 00 '+0("(#('/ !
(' ' ! )' $%(.'("("* ( (. +00"( " *$+0#+ (+"$%'
4A 6 .%)'
$ " * '("* ( (.
+00"( 0("$%' (+(. 00 ++ " ' ! ' , )'/ ! +(( # '('%( ." ((+.(0, ' $+0#;0!", 0(+6 45 ' .( " + . , ' ! $0) '( $6 ' (+,,+( ()'! "$1+ " +@,'9+,47859'(" $1+'! +""'('(+6 ".("'%'("
0(" .(+
+ ,(+ %("( "(.' $" (.+""'(' ,',(' '(+6 ".(" 6 .%)+""'(' " 0("$%' !" ++ ") 1+#'("$1+)/' (, )'%'(" "( "+.( ( " +:,'9+,47859 ;
2A)'
(" * ) (. +"" '( ' !" '(* +""("!'!
(++,*" "+ 0()(0 +'
()' !" .(#'(+6 ".("*2(2*' ( '." )/' ()' !"%!
+"# $1+'! .("(+6 )'
#'0(-#'0!
#",+( 4@ /* ), ' ($(#"' )' ($*0("# "
"" .(" 1+"'!
0( % ( , 1+#'($*# ", "") !)' !" ' !.%2(,,"(*)(/..(' ( # 0), 0.%+"#
'('/ .("
)/((+6 ", ,
' #' 6 !
$.+
!)$ .%(++ , ", 0 " (#(' ! $+0# "2!" , 0 ' (" .(") '( ' ;+ , ' !
$.+ / -) '
) $+(0 , (.." + "0(+$(#"'!
$.+!
!'("*"
(.
,'('." ++ "' , )"#)'
, ((../'! +.(0, '(+6 ".(" $+0# .(", 0(+6 4:
' 0 )'("+.(0+ ."'(*$/.., ""
.% 0,+57,'9+,47859!
*/' ,( ; (+"'
!"# $
$ % !&&%' & 8 / ?'
& &
(
6. "
$ $! ( )
( ! ( &
$ %
- @ "
( !
)
(
&
( (( $!
) (
( ! &
&!
&
$!
$! &
( &
A;;;;;
4> /* )+'(#, .(,'(+6 ".(" $+0#+( " 0,'( %!
* ()'
+ ."
$".%$, '( 0!,!' ,("C $, '!
+0,(/( ")(") $6 ' ' , )
(
/' ' " ) , (%) '
"0# ' $1+ (' /(
6 "$((."!
0!.%)'
$+0#0(")/' () 0(# 0" $ +'(..#") ' $% ' ! ( !!"(++ ,(!!/(* ("($("0)0(-( +'(..#'"0(. " ),(%)($+(00("'
$1+)()+( " +@,'9+,47859 47 ',
' +6 +' ,)(.)'(+' "+ $; +"/''(0$,+57 (( ++
'9+,47859)$; +"!
'( 0!, ! !
'0(-#,'(/( ",'(+6 ".(") /' () ' (/( " ' ( +( $+0# !
+" 4:?A4878) /'(!
0!!$+(0,."$, '
) +'(..##' " ),(%) 1+#'$1+( (" "
+@,'9+,47859 6 .%)'+.(0, .(# '/ .(", 0(+6 )!+(..%/''(0$+0 (+6 ", $2 *#' 6 !
$.+!
!)$'02 , ""("(02! " .,)(").($.$ 1+" 48
/)( 0#.%' /(!
0! (#,+'(..# $%'! '"0(. " 0("' $1+)% /'(!( , 0'
" #, (%#'"2!, '! , 0'"!
".(")'
0(-#(% "
(#' !", 00(-#((/( " .(.%' ,,+,'!(#,' " ()'()'"0(.
" ),(%)($+(00("' .*($1+ )0 # '(/( "(0("6 ('(+6 ".(")' $%'+'(..#' " ),(%) 1+#'$1+,." " +@,'9+ ,47859)'
$+0,
+
=? 6 .%) ' ($* # " , "+ 0( $
(" !( %$#"" ' / ! 6 (0.( .% (" .(" , ( '." ++ ") '
) ( +0!..%
"" .( # 0(" 1+" =4 ' ,
' ( , 1+# ' ($* $0 $+0, "" !',(+ 0'('(!) (' $# '$%(# ! *(**+,".(%(".(+'' (,
0(-#'($*++.
$+0!( -", 0',(+ 0)'( '+'(..#'(, )'($0("(, (.0' %,*%( .(!#)+'.( +'#,(+6 !
+"# " '9+ ,47859 .(.%)';(!$#'$%'($**+( +')'!" *$+0# 1+" 22.
Even the Hon'ble Apex Court in a judgment rendered in case titled "M/s Star Wire (India) Ltd. V/s State of Haryana and others", reported in (1996) 11 SCC 698, has in the relevant paragraph of its verdict, paragraph whereof becomes extracted hereinafter, thus declared that any belated challenge, as made to the relevant lawful fully terminated acquisition proceedings, thus is hit by the vices of delay and laches, and thereby too, the said belated motion as existing in the instant petition, is but required to be declared as misconstituted. "
( &
&
%
( )
&
A
%
( )
!
( )
&
( (
(
&
# (
&
$
( $ ) $
@ (
(
!
$ $! ( ( & $
(
(
:
/
$ ( &
( ! %
( $ & <
( (
$
/. * "
% B ,
< ( #! C+D /00> 1 -21D
$) &
!
( )
&
( % ( & $
(
(
* E9 " ( C/00.
/ -1:D $ ( F C/00.
; 6->D
$! ( ( & $
(
(
:
/
$ "
$ ( ! ( $ ( ) < &
) ?
( $! &
< $ ( !
$ &
( (
$ * F + 9 =
%
B G H & = =
%
B , I /00. / /-:D
( & ( & &! (
(
:
/ & $
(
!
(
(
! % &
( $( & $
(
. &&
$
! % ( ( ! B B , C* /0.: /22.D
$
'& ! (
&&
$
$ ! &
!
' ! !
( ( <
(
5
$ B , < F
( * B , C /0;2 / 1:DA ( ! B , 9 9% C* /0;> -/02DA (
B = "
( 7 C /0;> : -1>DA G < % B , #
( <' $! B C* /0;2 101DA ( < 9 B , J = H B , C+< /00>
1 /DA *&
< % B , + B , C/01;
&& .21DA (
$ B , # ,
& #
! = C/01;
&& .1;DA % # H B , C+< /00>
1 :0:D ( #! 7 C /00.
; 60:D
#
( ( )
&
<
& &
( " $!
< * 7 & B *
= B , C+< /00.
1 /.D &
&&
$! $
(
( )
!
(
(
:
/
. (
// "
/"01
!2 34/
!& 3 =A (, 0(')'
,"0 '/ !) '(0$#+0!..%, *. )'
6 "$"0"
/'+' , )'(0"0"/'+,@?)???C2 $ , '/' "!" $% ' ! /' ' 9
'
!
& ' ) & *
'
+ ' , , 0#(# ' (
(.
"( '(++ "
=5 '0!
#",+( ("'+6 ' (/( "( 0(("("(,, 0" =@ +'0(+(.,'($"+"")' )(..' !"#(!!.+( ),(%)(.("
"!",
5,,
-6
5-+
$($ $ -(*#' 4
08/"9:
!"
#
:
4
7!
30;1
#
: