High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/610/2003allowed

Bhupinder Kumar & ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2024-08-14Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma21 pages

!"# $ % & '('

) *$ &)'+'

)

"& ,- ./"'0123 /21/24351 ,- ./"2'0123 /21//32"

!"#$ %

& ' %

& '

"#$

& '

"% %*"

& ' , '%* - .

(

!""$ /$ )

% 0$

& ' #%

21/2435160'

, % %' *% %#* &%'$

,.2.334$ % ' (%* 56

,776$

%% % 8*$

#($ 0"" *"

'"* 0 *% -

++' %"( '% 429$ 43.$ .3,:49

!$ " % 8* '$ '

+%%*

&%'% *% ;'

&%'

++' %"( '% 43.

.3, '%

! 0&$

" ;'' #) <"

# % " '-% + '"* 0 *% "#

&$ " *"

'%*

& $ % 8* '$ " ' ( "

&%' "%+ =' #

! "

# $ % &

' #

( ) ! ")

# $ % &

' * . "

'';'

&%' ('

# **%& + & 0 &%'

&%'% (% $ ('

# **%& + - "

'>?

%#% #$ $

+% ('# %# $ "#$ &%'%* '$ $ "' "& '"

%% "*% "% '%& '%#% $ (+ 4 %' .

#) ")# @$ % %* ')

$ "+ $ '%* - "%# ' ( " *"

,535.3.9

!""

9 *%

'% ' ('

# #( %

0"%'"

=:, %* % '% =:, $

.,,,779 ,,33 # #% "# 0%+

# &%% %' *& " #

%'$

0"%'"$ 2$ .,,,77A %* " #$ % "#

4,,3,77A$ ,3 33 #$ "$ " "( "

#$ " *"

$ * ) "

" '"% "

' " +

%$ 0" " "( "

0 " +" "% %*"(

B % "%

@ !"$ 0"

*%&%* '$ "% C"D " " *"

" ' "# @

%* /% ") " B 0) " "( "

"# &% )$ " #% () +%%*;

0"(

" "( " ( ";%;

0 "

-% "

# * "% %&$ ")

(

+% )"%* "%#

+ "%* & #$ # "#( #B "#

+ "$

# #% & #

%;%;0 "#

( ' #

@ "

%* 5 "+$

2,,,77A 435 # # *%&

%' $ %' %

$ 0"% " > < ?

&%*

<$ '% -%)

2$ .,,,77A

%* " B%*

% ""( "&%* " ( " "

) * ( "

+ "$ " "&%* 0

" ( " 0"

) *

" ( " #% %%* "% "

( .3 ) ('B$ 0" "

,5:,2 )

$ - " B ' (0 "#

' >?

" "$ *%*

# %%

'''$ %<) ++ @ !"$ +"

" + "

"$ @

!" " =% '

'''$ +#%)

@ !" "&%* #%) "# &%*

4,,3,77A$ "% ' "# @

" " ' B 0) "

"% C%"BD @%- & "#

633 #$ ( " #"

# "# " ( *" "

"% "

,3 33 # "%

@ !" "# @

%" " *% B 0) " "#

$ 0"

( 0%+ *"$ '%&)

"$ " %

& "

# + ''

#)%* "#$ % ") " B 0) "

0 "% C%"BD F" "

" '" "

= %*$ "# 0"

)

"# '% * "# %'

3.,,,77A

++' "

#%%*

)

%'$ ") +%%*

0"(

# * "% %& "%

B ' "# " B "

+ "

# "%# &*%* "

@ !"

"# @ "$ 0"

(

# '

"% "# "

(' & #%

# "%#

& #

5.A$ 2;,,;,77A '% '%

% %' %

%* %&%*%

'$ "%$ ")# @$ <"

# % "

$ #%

#%%

%&%*% ") '" '% 429$ 43.

.3, '%

% %%" & "

++' %"( '% 43.

!$ ='%&) %(

% "$ ##% '$ " *"

##%

,A9,776$ "' '

##%

+' % (+

% '" & "

A % 8* '$ + '%&%* ' %$

(<'%& )%

%'%#% ) #%$ ' (+ "%# )$ " '

0 '"* *% ''$ ##%%

++' %"( '% 429$ 43.$ .3,

! + 0 '"*

''$

0"%'"

") *%)$ $ '%# % 6

% '$ '% =#% 0%$ $ "+ (%'

' '$ ' '% &%'

+ '

'% &%'$ % 8* '$ 0 '%*$ '% 4,4

!!$ "%$ % ''$ $ '%# + %#%'% 0&$ ") % ) &%' ()%"!!" * +

! * + ,, !

7 **%& &%'; " * (+ $ ( "

%#* &%'

&%'% $ - "

'$ " -% %+' & (#%%

* $ % (

* #%'%% $ ;'%%

&%' *#

'"*

()%"!!" * +

( ! ,3

" "$ " * (+ $ &%'

&%'% $ - "

'>?

>?$ ('

# %# &%';$ 0 #%$ $

-% ) %+'$ (%* ='%

% <%%'% "+ $ " " * $ + &%';$ ( %#% +" (#% " '"* &%'

'-% *%

" ;'' #) <"

# % "$ %" (+

(+ D(

= $ '"$ &%'

'-% - "# " '-% (%%* '%& ++' 7 $

,, % ' &% %'%#% ) %B '"%

'%'#' %#) %'%#% ) %B ('# ' '% ('

# #% )

%* *"

' '' ) * F;9 F;A

&$ %

( # '% ,29 !! '%&) # "#$

#$ #"

@ ('# & F:4 ,.

" %# %B '"%

%'%#% ) '%'#'$ #% %&

B% '$ "$

* +"

# % B% ' "

# ( "

@ '

##%%

- ' "

# ( "

@$ "

@ ('# &%' % '$ &%'

&%'% ('# & ,4 %*%+%') ( )

' % ('

# & ) ) ('# '

( )

' ) %'%#% ) %' #

('# %&%*%*

++%' '$ ) - "

&% ('# ++' %'

,9 )$ % ' '

0"() "%+ %+'

% >%?

( )

' #%%* '

& %'

''$ >%%?

' '$ " ('

#%* %(

' ++'

# %<%$ )

( )

'$ >%%%?

#%) ('

#%* %(

' 0"" # %<%$ #%+%* "#&

( )

'$ " ('

#%* %+%' " "

%'%#% ) 0

++'$ ('#

& %'

%&%*%*

++%' '$ " '

% "

%' # )$ "() ++'

&$ "()$ )

%* *"

'$ * F;9 F;A$ #) ('

# 0"#$ (% ++'$ %+ )

%& >?$ %*

#) ('

# 0"# 8 $ 4) ,5 F;9 >0%+

%* " =#%% ;%;'"%+ " ) ('B

)

%0%$ ,3 33 #$

B % "% "# @ '#

" "

B " "( "

# >'?

#) "#

"% (%"B "( 0 * "#$ $ B%* %- "% (%"B$ % " %%* " "(

#) "# " +" " "( % % %* "+ $ " %+ # " ( ";%;0 +' ( ";%;0 '" " "( " *"

) ' "%# (- %*$ " * " ( ";%;0 0$

%' % * " "( #%%* %' %*"

%0% + ,3 33 # " +" '"

" %# ) "&%* #%) " "($ @ !" >+"

B% " "( .3 ) %

%'% % % (0 " "( +#%)

# % 0&$ " ) ") " B%*

" "( '-% # ' *% *% "%# ,2 %* " ' ;=#%% " %#

@ !"$ "%

# 4;9 )

" +" % ' " "( &%'

% 0&$ " '-% D( %*"

' (0 " "( +#%) ##(

# + '-%

" "( % %'% "(

B %- 4;9 ) " +" #% "%

# " *

/#) " #% " %= )

% ) ,775 " +" %$ 0"

( "

/ "%

% &%* "

0 "

#$ % # 0"%'"

%#) B'" "

&%* >/ "?

" +# "

0"%'"

&%* " +" #% &%* # %*" + "% +%

"% '

" &"%' "

"% +% %*" "% &"%'

'' "%

"&%* < ")

"% +% %*" # %#

# %*" + "% +% #

' % %*"$ 0" " ' -%) &%* #

@$ #"$ "# $

# " 0%+

' % %*" " +" " " "+ ' B%* %- (%"B

"# @

%# ' B%* %- * $ $

" "

# " & " )"%* +'

# " & " %$ 8**

%% <(% % # * "

" +" "

< % " "

'' "# @ %*

$ 0"$ "%

# " # %%

# " " "+ "# @ %*

% "

" +" " ) +' " =' " + " +#%) ##( " ' B%* %- '' 8 $ 4( ,A F;A >*"

" =#%% ;%;'"%+

B "# @ " #

' " +" ") B " +"

#) "# 0" " "

(<'

%$ ") ")

B + # %# "+$ " +" + "

"% #) % ,6 " (<'

' ;=#%% %* " ' ;

=#%% "

= ) %'

++%'% " #

" "

" -%% + " " " "%# & +' "+$

++%'% & ) -%) + " % " #B ) #

) %'

++%'% " +" ) ('B " )%* .

" &%* "

# +" '

B "# @ 2 33 #$ &%* " %*" ,, 33 # "

" " " #

" 0"

" " " %' 0" " " %

" +" + * %*

%$ " ") "%# ('B &)

> %

0% 0

# = 0" % 0" " " %

" +" + * %*

%$ " " +" 0% ( &)

0&$ % #% " " B " +"

* " ' ;=#%% " " ) B%* 0"() %+%'% " " =#%% ;%;'"%+ " ( '

( '%0 ") 8 $ 2 9 2* )

,7 #

# '% ,29 !! # " "

>'?

= "

# 4,,3,77A %*" 6 43 #$ " * %*

B%* (''

" (%"B

#$ " 0 "%

#$ ")# @$ "$ <$ %$ 8**

%%$ <(% % "

>'?

( %%* " %*" 0" " %* (%"B$ " " %'

* 'B '?

$ '

% %'% " " +$ 0"%'"

' %

* (B )$ & %

#%#$ "%

# '# 0%+) +

% + %

( *"

'' "% .;4

" < "%

# 0

% &%* 0 " % %&%* < 0%+) %)

"% ' % 0 % %*$ " '#

B "

" * "% ' " # ('B 29 %$ * .3 %&%*%*

++%'

' "

!" ' $ %

0% ( = F;7 %* =#%% ;%;'"%+ " '"

%&%*%

"%# <

$ %' %* %&%*% " %

' '' # ) # !" %

8( ' (+ "%# "% %*"$ "# @$ <"

") +" '"

(- )$ " % * '' ") %' #$

&) ++' ' " + .5,,,77A "" " '

/)) (%* *%% !;3,;.627 0"%'"

B %

% &% ##

=$ $ # !

(% %*"

( !"" %*" +"

32,.,77A$ " *

F "#$

#$ #"

@ '% ,29 !! (+ !

#( %* %&%*% " #

F '% ,2, !! ,.3.,776$ " *%

(% %' #

'' "+$ %&%*%

' +

! ++

+ #%

%&%*% " '% ,A4 !!$ 0"%'"

( %* ., 0%

' ;=#%% %* ' ;=#%% " ='

#$ " " #

8**

%%$ <(% %$ $ %$ 0"

"& B %B ' "$ $ ''$ "

%*"

%'% +" " " #

) 0%

%*"(

"#$ ' "

' "

" (%"B

# +" '"

" &%* " &%

"#$ '"$ " % "% # '% ,2, !! 0&$ " " < % & %&%*% " -% "# "% +' #% <%#%

%' +% '"

" " ) ( B / " 0"%'"

# *

* 'B

/ " "

"%# )

&%* 3 $$ 8

$* $9 88:76 ;* /<'=$$$ '

$* 8

% * 9

:> :$ $ *$** $ .. # #%

#%* *% 0&$ % "

"#$ &%&%* 0%

' "

# " 2

3.,,,77A (+ %' *')

.4 '% '$ %%

F;9 F;A "

"% '%&) # " B%*$ -

# "# @$ &%%%* "% "

-%* '

#) "#

"% (%"B$ 0" 0

(%"B

''$ 0" # %- %' "( % % %*$ "()

('# *% -)$ "() ( "

0% >?

* %'%#% ) %B

( "

%* *" ' .9

0% ('# (<'

'"%* ' ;=#%% ) "% '%& ' ;=#%% ") % #B ) %'% 0"() #) ('

# =

0 %+'$ "% '%& *% $ '% "% '%& =#%% ;%;'"%+$ " ('

#%* '%0 ") .5 % #)$

%' ) # 0% >?$

#%( %' ) '% ' ( 0

.2 %#) %* $ ('

# *

& +'#$ - + & '%

" 0%

"% '%& # '% ,29 !!$ (+

*% '

#$ #"

@ "% '%&) # &(%# =' "%+ ( % * ( % !

* ( + %+

. ) ) )//0 1 2

# 1 31 4

# ' ' '

- ' , '

-1% ,

# # 31 4 3 47 #

# 1

# #

1 - # - # ( # 1 ( - :

# # , #

( % * % !+ 0% !1 (+"

) ) )//0( 1 2 ' 1, # 31 4 # ' '

; % ' 1'

, <

# 1

;

, : #

# #

, : 1 1 31 14714#8

<= (

- 1 , 1

: :#

;

> .#

# 47# 8 :31 4# 1 <

3 4 ' =

: #(1

> # ( 1 ' '

- ( ,

1 1 #

$ ? ( % *

2 !

* %+

" 1

1# & #

1 1

1 , , 1 ,

;

1 (# .

) ) )/00( 2 , # = #

' '

131 4 7 4 18 7 4 18

= 1, 1

; % # :

) @ '

1 1 , 4 #

@ #

# # (* :#, 1 # 1

; % , 9 :1

; %

( ,

1 # '' ' ) )) )//0# #

( # #

: "

)) )//0 : )) )//0

% %'

< ( 1

( ,

1 1 # * .A

**%* &'%)

%+%'%

$ 0"

'$ $

"#$ 0"

&%&%*

'$ ( "

0% ( = F;9 F;A$ 0"%$ ") '% &% ' (%* *" "

' (%"B

''$ % ')

%+%'% >?

'% ,29 !!$ (+

*% ' # &

*% '$ 0"

0% ( = F;4 .6

# # (+

*% '$ & +' (%"B

''$ %*"%* "# @$ "$ <$ %$ 8**

%%$ <(% % 0&$ #

& $

# + "# >F;9?$ "() % # 0% >?

# (% & & #>?

#$ " (+

*% ' .7 ++'

B%* >?$

'' #

"# >F;9?

" (%*

#$ %#'"

$ %' %* "% #

%$ 8**

%%$

<(% %$

(

&%( (%"B

''$ 0" F;9 %' %* "% #$ "$ "() %+%'%

F;9

=$ '$ " #( (%"B

#%* %- " (% (%* *"$ " ('

# +%+% 43 % 8* '$ " +%

<'%&) ) #

F;9 F;A$ " # '% ,29 !!$

# ' " <'%& )%

#$ "() & %

- %'% "& #*

"# $ & % %'% %+

' '% ' "

( "()

'$ )

%* *"

'$ " ('

#%* +) * F;9 F;A

&$ %' % %+%'% '%&) &%&%* 0% *"

'$ ('

# & %# '% &%'$ "() # '% ,29 !!$

# " % #% % &% &%;;&% '%# & )$ 0" &% >?

#$ #) %%' + &% * F;9 F;A$ "() % %'%

%) (% '% ' %' )

& %+ #%*$ #

#$ (+

*% '$ %'%&

+'$ % %' # '%&) F;9 F;A$ "

( %* '' - ) ( %* )

%* *"

' 4, "$ ) (+ %*%* ) '%

+' % ('# & F;4 >0"

*% '?$ 0"(+ 0"

# #$ % ('# %'#($ '%

# "

0% ( = %*

# %

0% ( = "& +' ' ;=#% "%#$ " %#'"%* '%0 "%$

&% # '% ,29 !!$ 0"% " =$ %* *" ' & %+ (%'

. ' '$ % $ %* %

0% ( =

#$ ) % 8* '$ -%

# (%* %

0% ( =$

"$ + '%

=#%% ;%;'"%+$ " ('

# ' ;=#% +' $

"() ++%'')$ %+ )$

)

%' ) '"

%* "%#$ ('

# #

( " 4.

#%% >?

% 8* '$ " ' & ')

+'$ %#'"

$ +' (%* %(

' ;=#% "%# " ()%* B%*

'' # >?

&$ +" ') 0"%'"

#*$ + %* %

0% ( =

#$ "$ +'

#%* %''%

+ "%#$ " %+%'% '%&) F;9 F;A$ '%) 0"

# ('

#%* + #$ "() +' #) "& &$ %" '%&) #

F;9 F;A + :

& - #

#$ " 'B%* &'%)

44 +#"$ ++'

+$ '%%*

# 0%$ (% %* "%# %

0% ( =$ "()$ '% " # " #*'

- *%

''' )$ (+%

( "

( ( 0

'' 49

&$ %' %&%*%*

++%' '$ %*

%&%*% +%

<$ %$ 8**

%%$

<(% %$ 0"

( *" ' (%"B

''$

/ %+'$ % ('

#%* ) *"$ ' ) %" "% '%# & (%* %&%* "% (%* '% 0% ''

#%% %&%*%*

++%' '$ "

%+' "() %&%*%*

++%' '$ " ' %"

B'") %&%*% %' %) #

' " #% *" % %+%'% $ "()

% %#%& %&%*%*

++%' '$

& $ 0"$

#%%

%" "% #

%&%* "% '%# &

'%&) '% "# '% 0%

''$ " " #) % %&%*% $ ('

#%* '$ 0"() '

#% +%

<%' " 7:

$* 8

%9 %

* 99$$ * 9% 45 #%*

)

%& '"%* #%

%#% ' %& '"%* #%

%#% '$ 0" ('

# 0% +%) * )

' ''$ "() '

#%) %& '"%* #%

%#% '$

# '% '

( 0&$ #%* " %&$ '"

%#% '$ ) 0" " ' ;=#%%

"#$ " '%) " #%

0% +%% # * '

" #%* *

" " #( (%"B

# %- $ "()

( ;#%

+%% # * '$ "() "

%& '"

'" #%

'' )$ %& #

** 7:

$* *

$*:

** $

* $ 8

* % $ * 9

;8 $ *'

$* * % *$66$$

6$* ** $ * 9$9 * 42 %&%*

++%' '$ %% " % #

&$ " % "

' % % *% ) " +%

"% '%& %* %' # ' " $ " &%

) %'%#% ) #%

%' 4A

#%% >?

>?$ %# ) *&

#%%

' &)

( )

'$ "$ "() " # %(#

' '$

' #

( )

'$ (% '

#%)

(&% % $ %#

) # %<%

( )

&$ %

( "%#

#B )

%% # %<%$

( )

' " -

& 0

++' %% %' & '%# % #% #'

#B$ %'

''$ % %&%*%*

++%' '$ "

' % % *% "

'$ "& ( +) %#%' ' 46 +#"$ %'%#% ) %B '"%

%'%#% ) '%'#' ' '% #% & 47 -$ '%%

&%'$

% 8* '$ ++ + * &%)

#%;'%% '%%

&%' *#

'"* 7: 93

& %'% "$ +% #% $ $ %

% -)$ 0 %#* <*# &%'%*$ $ '%* $ $ ('

# % 8* '$ -"$ $ % '-%

'"* +# *% "#

+% # $ %+ )$ % "#$ ($ ''

' 0$ +

"# $ $ ) (

" "0%"

''$ $ %'"* ' ) ( 0%"$ ''

' 0$ + =%)

%#%% +%%*

$ %+ ' )$ $ %+ -% )

" '$ ( "0%"

%() 0 ( ''

%*) 9, '

(

0 "0%" 9. #%' %'% >?$ %+ )$ %:$

+ 21/24351# 01?/ 21//32"# 01?/

$)6 ) :$ 4 $8> = $ & @$=,

4 8

: & @$=,