Sonia And ANR v. Ranbir Singh And ORS




   
  








 

!!""

#$
%&
'

 

(%! 
     

   ) 


*+
,-+ .
 /.


 0/
0 .
 /.


!!"" 
&+1-
2 .
 /.


! 
3  4- 
5+!1 666

   

 7

!!"

&
!  
&1

"+.
8
 

8.
+


+

+
,-+ .
9'
+

+!
8

+
&1


 
5"+
7 &-".

!

 
:
57;
/ 
8 


<




"+
!
-
- 






#"
.
=<<

 
:
#
;

-




+
,-+ .
8
>! 


+
/-"
 
8
9
!"



2.

7



"+
8




.

+
,-+
"'
8
+!"
-9
,-+
 -0"
8 
''
8 
/""'
? 


+ 1"
& '
' 
3 *%  , = <=.
8
8
&'
/
&1
+
,-+
@
1


,8"
 .


& '
' 
3 *% AA 

 
 



: '
/";.
&'
/
&1
! 
3 
%&
'




'"'
+



'
! .
+
 +

!!

 

 -9
'

+ 1".


-"

8.
+
,-+
 -0"
""
8

-
0- 
%! 
3 
"

 +

!


 
@

"!

! &1.

+!"


0-  .
+"1
-0"

+
,-+ .


!".
 +
8 
+
,-+
8
 

)B4 .
%9

*8/ .
&
-0"

+
,-+
--+&


0- 
-


 
 4%
3 AA.




- 

A=.
A
 
4)5
8
' 

)"

 
!
'
! 
3 


+!"

-9
,-+ 4.

It was averred that the accident had taken place on account of negligent driving of the offending vehicle by its driver (respondent No.1). It was averred that Amit Kumar was 32 years old and was working as an Inspector in G4S Secure Solutions India Pvt. Ltd., and was getting monthly salary of Rs.13,745/-. Besides this, he also used to run a milk dairy, earning Rs.2 lakhs per annum. It was averred that he was earning Rs.35,000/- per month. However, due to his untimely death caused by the accident, the claimants had suffered irreparable loss of financial support, love, and affection. Accordingly, compensation of Rs.75 lakhs was claimed.

%! 
3 


/

8


 '
/"
"

8 
+
 

-+


 

%! 
3 
- 
+!1


--"



8 
+
 

-+


   +

!" '


! .
""8'
" 
-
8 
 + 


     

           

 

 

 

 



 

 

!"



 #$%  

&     

   '

  

 (

) * )

 &   + ,& 

-!    &( 

*

 

  ./00 1    

 





./0


2   *  *  

!3 4+"

  

! *     *  *

!           ./0 5    "

    *   *

      

 

 

&  

 )./0   6 < ) 
"

!/
/  7
57
"



 

9
!"

-




'"'
/'


 '
/"
&1
! 
3 
' 

C--+

+!.

'



8



1 .


+"1
+
8


% A $
!
+
4
 +


"8
" 8




3

7 &   ) * 0  )       1 95: 8 98 * :   

  * ;<8 1= 9>: 88 1

9!'

/8

'



.
-- 
! !
D
 E



+
8 
"




+



+-"!"

F G
8
!!"
&1

57 

8
"



/


 '
/"
8
"

'

/"
 /
/'
".

/ .
8

- 
+!1
""
8 
"

0"1

/ ""1
"&"

!1

+!


"+ 7
57


' 

""8'
+!

3 * 

5"+
'



1 

4+


A $
!
+

-'
$ 8 
! "
>!
A $
-"
4+

$

-- 
! !
D
 E

$

H
7"
+
% .

$
!
+
 .

.

$
-"
+


!!"1'
-"!"

F G

.

.

$

>



















H%

.=.

$
- "
>!




















% .

$
< I

J




















% .

$
5 -+




















% .

$

 !"#$%&'! (&  ')* +, )--./


4 
D
=E
!
-+
 +



"'


"+
!
""
-"
"K
8
"
8

4
/

" 
-"


!   I 
-"


!!""
-&+


57
 

'

+




% .A $
!
+
8 .

!

+

)@ 
 
2-.

+"1
" 1



8
%

.< $


4

- 
&
 '-


57
8
 -+

% .

$

"1

"+
8 .

-"

/
&
8

""
 
"+

 +




"8
"

8
&1

*G&"
-! +
5- 

4 




0!&!1% 2(
-! 

?!@  7 &  8 )A *3 &  8& & )-34 3435-

I 
-"
- 
-&+


57
"
 


-'
$
>!



 +

+"1

+

% .A $

4

&
-&+


57
8 '"1
   
-"
+

%

$
8 .

-"
+
-"

/
&
= $

-'
$
>!
8 
! "
>! 
  .
" 
-"


- 
+!1

-&+


57


++
1
 

'

+




% .A $

% 

&
+ 


" 1
+
J> )

J> )



&
-&+


'- 

%

.< $
!! '

J> ) 


-





-+

%

$

&




+

 /""'
""8.
8

&
9

&

! 


" 1


@"
 '


-+
J> ).
J> )

J> ).


&
/ 


+"1
" 1




&
+

% .A $



 /""'
""8

&
+
! "1

4

&
 '-



 /""'
""8

&

! 


" 1.
 .
1
8-"
&
!1&"
"1



 /""'

8-"

&

>!
- 

 /""'

*8/ .
" 
-"
-"


 / 

-&+
&-

 -+





-'
$
>!
8 
! "
>!


.

+"1
+


-"

/
&
% = $
!
+  4
/
  

-&+
+ 
&1
" 
-"


! 

7
 '-+
 /
&1
" 
-"


!!""


" 1



8
%

.< $
!
+

""-


! -"


!1
"!
J> )

J> )
8


+"1
" 1



8
% .A $

%

$

J> ) .
%

<

J> ).
% < <

J> )

% A=


J> )
8 
 /""'
>!


L 

 -+.

" 1
8-"

&
9

&
.A $
!
+

 /""'
>!
8-"


&
"-

J/
J> )
8


 /""'
""8


+
8
"1
A=

$


L 

 -+.

 

-


+

" 1

% .A $
!
+


' 
"-"

$
>!.


&
-"1
&"


+9'

-

 
8 

! "

"/'
>!


.

-"
+"1
"

+



! 
+

% =. $
!! >+"1


4




 -+

  .

57
 

8 '

+
"1


"+.
8 .

 +



" 8
&1

-! +
5- 

4 




0  )  -!  ?!@  7 &   ) A  -! .
 -+.
D
% 

$


! 
8
C- 

&
' 

A */'
  

-&+
+ 
&1
" 
-"


! .

+!



-  .
9!'

+

! !"
-
&1

*G&"
-! +
5- 

4 

3 * 

5"+
8
&1

57
J 5+!
'



1 
3
'

4+


.A $
!
+
3
'
 -

$ 8 
! "
>!
A $
< $
-"
4+

$

= $

-- 
! !
D
 E

%

$

H
7"
+
.

$
!
+
 .

.

$
-"
+

$
7"
4+
.< <$
!
+
 .

.==$
-"
+

!!"1'
-"!"

F G

.

.

$

>



















H%

.=.

$
.

.==
>


.

.

$
- "
>!




















.

$
.

$

'
<

I

J




















.

$
.

$

'

5 -+




















.

$

. .

$ % 

$
>


 !"#$%&'! (& 

')* +, )--./

.

<.


A 7
"
+!.
  .
+

%

.

<.

$

-'

-+

%

.= .

$


&1

57.


&"
+!
+

% ..< $
7
+-
8-"

&
!1&"






+-

&1

" 
57
"'
8
 
D
A

E

-""1
7
&- "

"&"1

!1

+
8-"

&

!

8

< 7
! 
!!"

 '"1
!


A
) '
!!".

1.
""
"
 !



    
!062)7 )-), /' '

@
!9'$  
M$3
@
! &"
M$3