Haryana State Co-Op Supply & Marketing Fed. Ltd. v. Rakesh C. Jain
!
"#$
$%&'& ( ) *)
!
"
!
+ , )
- )-)-./ # $ # %& '
( # )'
# '
)-)-./
) *
+,-./0 #
( (
% 131*1 4
( 5'
"' !)' )4' % *- 1/ 311, ( *6 1/ 311, 4
( 47 " '
8
(
*+-9*/3 &
4:
*--* . ( (
1#2$ %#30 9
( 47 " .
7"05 ( ' % *- 1/ 311,' 7" 5 9
(
(( 4
*+-
*6 1/ 311,')
( )
(!
/
%
4
' 9
( 4( " !) % 12 131*1'
% *- 1/ 311, ( *6 1/ 311, 4
8
(
)')
(!
+ )
)
( ') ) 4
+
(
31 1, *66-'
'
(
*+-9*/3
9 !% ;)
9
4 (
!
,6'*2'*/6 329 ( *662
*66-
(( %
) ' (!
/2'-/'<,,9 )
) *, 1, *66-
) 4
9
(
4
=
84 &
,,+*/< 1, 1/ *6--( (!
3
4 8 *+ *66-' 8) ) ( 8 8
>?
@ A 3< *66-'
'4 ( (
1* 1< *66-) ) 4 4 12 1< *66-)
)
B '
(
4(
/
4 4 '
*+-
( (
(!
/
)'
4(
'
( ) %
(
' 9
)
(
(!
3 '4
( (
'
)
4
)
9
4 )
(( )'
8 ' )
'
(( )
4%
(!
+ ' !
3
8 !
*
4 9
( 4 )
( 4 '
(
)
4 ) 4
: ) ( ' % *- 1/ 311, *6 1/ 311, 4
) )
4 8
)
(!
+ )
)
') ) 4 4
:
) 4 ( ' % 4
)
(
% 4
4 4
((
4
4
)
)
'
) )
( (( % ) ) ) %
(
(
((
*+-
4 )
)
* 4
) ) 8 (!
3
3< *66- ) ( *3 <
C
'
4(
( 9
4
((
*+-
8
(4
D )' 4
'
? (
4 8
'
4
4 E '(
4 ' 4 )
((
8
4
( 4
( *3 311/.;0 ((
( )
'4 ( )
4
(
4 8 4
4
' ) 4 (
% (
( ) ) 4 F4
"5 6"7 -) 7"829 :') -";$6 "8<"< ) 7&5&("< ==$"<'
)
> ') 4
6$%&6$6
";
0 * -0
$#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 :') ."(%2"( $2#"
@ 0 -0 *
,
:
(
(
) 4 - 8 ') (
4
'
)
) % ( ) 9
(
((
*+-
' )
((
*+-
4
4 F4
% (
F4
)
8
(
(
% (
')
((
( "5 6"7 -) 7"829 '9=7" ( ) $
!
!
!
!
" !
#$ %& # % &'
!
(
)
)
%&
)
*
"
+,
-
(
!
%&(
( .
!
/,
%&0
(
+,
-
-
(
!
) 0
*
1 2 -
(
! -)
@
. ( -
(
!
(
3 -
(
! 4 *1
4
((
*+-
(4
' 4
4
')
4 F4
( $#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7" ) ) ) 4 F4
')
8
)
( ((
*+-
4 ')
)
8 4
8 $ 5 0 !
#
6
( 75
! 8
!
( 79 :
:'
!
; !
<= '
/5
;
!
'
"
!
!
"
"
'
"
;
<=
'
*
! ( >7
?
"
( 7/@%7&
;
( A> ;
!
( >7
;
( !
!
! "
! !
?
)1
! *
! ( !
!
!
'
?
! !
( A>
; '
?
?
!( >7
7/@%7&
!
**
) 4 (
*+-
((
' F4
? (
) >E?
B
*+- & :
*--*@ -9
#9 /7&# $#&#& 7<) )
6$%&6$6
) 4) 4
; ( ) $ 9 *
%
& ( >7
*
6
'
"
( >7 ?
B /5
'
+( >7
!
:
:
( 75( /5
*
"
/5
'
( /5
( 75 '
"
*
%
&
'
( ) :
: ( >7 '
:
:( >7
( AA/
<=
!
"
$
)
!
.
CDE'
F
1
F
1
"
C7DE'
C>DE
! "#$ %&'
(# )## (( (* +,-
'*
+( #. ,(/ 12 )++30 / 2 ,**#,. *, #)44"+ 00
''/ 2 55 "
;
%
& (
(
%
&
'
'
!
!
?
( 75 ( /5 '
.
'
)
*
7
!
"
'
)"
( 75
F *
*
! " 7'
++7+
( 75
.
.
.
!
( 75
'
"
( 75
)
>'
!
# & '
.
*
!
( 75
&
( 75
!
"
7&0
( +
!
) ! *
?
?
>&
!
( 75
( 9
/& '
.
'
!
( 75
!
A&F
;
%
& (
(
%
&
'
!
4
'
'
( 7
!
1 )" @& ( /5
( 75
*
%
&
'!
'
( 75
++7+5&
"
?
( 75
4 *3 4 '
; G4
(AB=$6&#& 9'
7&"<
"'$'
(6$7 -$%#& @
#2$ )) %# @@C % ( G4
( $#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7" (
( )
)
)
( ' G4
4
32-
#
)
4
*+-
?
' % ($#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7" )
G4
) A"'
"7 "'
5";
8$C
*
*/+
)
( 4
3<3
3<2 ( #
'
H :: #
)
4( )(
*+-
)' G4
) ( $#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7"
((
8
(4
( ' 4 (
'
' % ' 4 (
4
'
*+
E % ):) -$'2"&"2 :') 2$ -#"#$
$<"(D"("
"(6 "( #2$7
7&5&("< @0
) )
( E'
$#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 :') ."(%2"( $2#"
@ - * ) */ & )
(
'
) 4 G4
' 4 (
% 4
4
44
:
(
) ) )
( 4 ' 4 E
32 ** 311+. 0 =
(
((
8 ( *3 311/.;0)
(( ) 4(
11, 31*1') 9
((
(!
3
' 4 ( ' 9
) )
)
*2 &
4:
*--*) 4 &
4 :
.
# 0
3113
((
4'
*/,
)
E ' ( (
4%
') )
(3113 $ :;
3 $(
6"
B
$ '
3
55
8 ) ; 0
- %
&955
<=
'
!
!
'
?
! 3
55
( 75>
<=
3
! !
'
?
!
: %
&
*<
( '
())
8 ) (
4
: '
4
4
*/,
') $ -$%#& 4 6! 7 ( * 8 7*9'* #8+ $ 3
;
9@7%9@>&
4 *,
*/, ) $ '
(( &
4:
4
4
*/,
+31 #
)
4 4
: (
'
+31 #
(( ') : #
*-<1 (
*/,
') 4 ')
(( ) 4 ?
)'
+31.60 #
E
) '
*/, &
4:
) ( ') ) ) ( )'
+31 #
@ *- E (
*/,
' (
4 ) 4
)
)
((
: 4 (
'
) 44
4 G4
(
' )
' G4
) 9
8
(
'
:
( "5 6"7 -) 7"829 '9=7"0
G4
( (
')
(( ) (
( ( (
59<#&=<$ %
4
'
'
)
' G4
( $#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7"
' (% ' 4 (
4
)
'
4
(
')
) ( % 4
; G4
(:
( -9
#9 /7&# $#&#& 7<) )
6$%&6$6
) 4)
.E? B
*+- & :
*--*0
E % ' %
($#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7" ) ') (
32- #
4
! ( ')
' 4 (
4 8
')
8 E ' '
( ):) -$'2"&"2 :') 2$ -#"#$
$<"(D"("
"(6 "( #2$7 '9=7"
G4
) )
($#$7'
"(6 ('#795$(#'
7&?"#$ ,&5&#$6 "(6 "( #2$7 -9=7") *6
E
) ') )
33<
(:
/-3 #
' G4
( E'
$$2"7&F"
( 7"'#79%#97$ ?#) ,#6) :') -#"#$
"2"7"'#7"0 -9=7$5$ 97#
- ( ) $ :/H?
( >5
? '
.
!
"
?
#%& !
%&
%&
"
? !
?
" 3
!
!
?
!
'
?
.
!
?
!
"
?
%
!
!
?& ?
!
"
?
?
" ?
? "
"
? ?
!
"
"
"
"
?
"
"
?
)
4
(
'
8 8 ) 4
1, 1/ *66-
8) 4 )
7
'
32 ** 311+. 0'
=
' 9
((
8 ( *3 311/ . ;0 (( :
11, 31*1' 9
((
)' )
4
(
*3 '4( )
4 4
4
(( 4%
(!
+ ' !
3 8 !
*
4 4 9
) 4 4
(
)4
) )
8 ' 9
( !
/
(!
+ 4
4%
*+-
( ( 4
:
4
*+-
'
4
8 '
% 12 131*1 4
"'!)' (
?
( !
+
!
/ (!
* 44 9
)
(
' ( ) ' % *- 1/ 3131, ( *6 1/ 311, 4
(
4
3* : ) 4 ' ) 4
8
(
'
' ((
' ( ' (('
3+
!
4 )4 4
) *)
)-)-./
A 9 $ I 9& A 4 $I 9&